I will revise and correct a paragraph from the post you didn't like to make you like it even less.
But that would get us back to just how improbable random chance assembling even the first organism so as it came to life, a persisting, containing membrane structure just happening to contain the right chemicals and structures [each of those structures certainly requiring an equally improbable random-chance assemblage, as well] so as to begin metabolism and maintenance of the organism before we get to the more incredible unlikelihood of random chance allowing its reproduction on the first and only try it would get to do that successfully, ending up with at least two of itself - if it reproduced to three, that first time or more, the chances against that happening rise incredibly fast.
If its unlikelihood happening once is measured as one times ten to some very large exponent of times. if the first act or reproduction resulted in more than one organism as a result, I would guess the first term in that equation would go up by the numbers of reproductions which would, of course, increase the resultant improbability on a very, very steep curve.
And that doesn't bring up the improbabilities involved with such things as the original organism internally reproducing things like those complex molecules and structures in the numbers allowing it to split into two or more viable organisms.
The internal mechanisms for allowing that internal reproduction of components - and to what random-chance, undetermined end? - is among the most improbable of the many improbabilities of the first organism arising by mere random chance. So far we've only imagined the organism reproducing beneficial internal structures and molecules, organisms, as well, generate those that endanger its continued life, but that's only an observation to show that there are random chances against it working, as well.
And, since we are supposed to detest teleology in biology as well as physics, why would it do that? Why would it split in a totally unprecedented way (there would be no such thing as precedent for that first organism)? What are the chances of those thing happening by random chance? If you imagine the scenario I described here - and I don't see how even the most daffy of abiogenetic ideologues could not believe that had to have happened - how could you maintain that all of the events preceding AND ALLOWING FOR SUCCESSFUL reproduction would have just happened without that result being anticipated?
No, it's totally implausible that that happened by mere random chance. God making it happen any number of times is far more plausible, the chance of it happening if God chose it to happen is one in one, not some integer times ten to an incredibly huge and ever underestimated exponent of times.
Atheists are always playing the plausibility game based on the chance of something happening. Well, you want to play that game, game on. I'm more than willing to look at their claims for just how much they are claiming happened by chance.
"It seems to me that to organize on the basis of feeding people or righting social injustice and all that is very valuable. But to rally people around the idea of modernism, modernity, or something is simply silly. I mean, I don't know what kind of a cause that is, to be up to date. I think it ultimately leads to fashion and snobbery and I'm against it." Jack Levine: January 3, 1915 – November 8, 2010 LEVEL BILLIONAIRES OUT OF EXISTENCE - MARBURY DELENDA EST
Wednesday, July 1, 2020
Here We Are Where We've Been Before, Where We Will Be
By heritage and personal experience of human folly, I expected this pandemic to be terrible, it's been terrible and it is getting worse and I now think it will be worse than I can now imagine. Especially as it will have new strains of viral disease helping it kill in the coming flu season. And they're talking about finding another meat-industry enhanced virus that has pandemic potential.* In such times the worst of human character plays a controlling part, it really shows up the strong link between what people mistake as "freedom," "liberty" if they want to get all Founding Fathers, and selfishness. Virtually every awful thing conservatives, Republicans, the secular play-left advocate or claim as a "right" is done through a claim of "freedom" especially when they say "liberty".
The language of rights and liberty is wide open to be a cover for selfishness, those words are as capable of enabling the most stupid selfishness as well as being used to describe the right for people to do and advocate for the most unselfish, generous and rational behavior. Unselfishness being, so often, ungratifying to the self, as well as harder than what is more gratifying it has the general character of being a tougher sell to a large number of people. That is the secret to the success of American-style conservatism, really of European style libertarianism and conservatism, that 18th century style of "liberalism" that frees the rich to enjoy and enhance their wealth, that is in opposition to the more traditional American liberalism that had the name before then which is based on generous, "liberal" provision to the least among us.
It also plays out in FOX, Sinclair, the right wing media, the Republican-fascist politics which they sponsor appealing to the stupidest, most selfish inclinations of people in order to gull and swindle them. In the case of this pandemic disease, the anti-mask, anti-shut-down, anti-responsibility being peddled to their Republican-fascist viewers, many of them in the age cohort most vulnerable to the disease - that gulling and swindling them is getting them killed or putting them in danger of being seriously, disastrously ill. And if not them their nearest and dearest as well as anyone else they come in contact with.
The "liberty" the "freedom of the press" that is enshrined in the irresponsibly inspecific First Amendment should rationally and rightly be indicted for its major role in permitting the disastrous course the American Covid-19 pandemic. From the racism promoted through it about the pandemic to Trump peddling his adult Chicken Pox party style rallies, to literally everything else about what has made, especially the "red states" most influenced by that kind of criminal irresponsibility shows that the traditional, post-war interpretation of the First Amendment, by "liberal" as well as Republican-fascist courts is extremely dangerous. If you think regulating the press so it doesn't spread homicidal lies is an infringment on personal freedom, getting intubated as last ditch resort to trying to keep you alive IF YOU'RE LUCKY ENOUGH TO HAVE ONE AVAILABLE DUE TO THE REPUBLICANS AND MEDIA SPREADING THE PANDEMIC is somewhat more of an inhibition of your personal style.
I wish I'd copied the doctor's tweet about wearing a mask and taking other precautions or get intubated by a novice doctor in an unrelated field who did their last semester online. It was a good one.
* I've always told people as they promoted promiscuity and things like anal sex as being kew-el and transgressive and fashionable that even though they may have the stupid belief that AIDS ended (it didn't, in anything except the ability of rich people to, as of now, control its severity) that there was absolutely no guarantee that another deadly pandemic couldn't arise through the same means that AIDS developed into one through risky sex, needle exchange and blood donations by infected people in the period before the virus is even noticed. It wasn't a welcomed message among gay men in the 1980s, even as they saw the new disease killing men, even as it was clear that there was a link between promiscuous sex in places like bath houses and sex bars and the disease. So much of what we're seeing about the assertions of "freedom and liberty" so much of the denial of reality among the Republican-fascists and their criminally irresponsible media was seen by those of us observing the early years of the AIDS pandemic. Only differnece is that there is no homophobic content in the irresponsible misinformation about this present pandemic to complicate things. Though that might have had anti-"liberal" anti-North-Eastern, anti-Democratic bigotry as a media and Republican-fascist promoted and exploited stand in.
The potential of the factory farming or even small farming of animals for the meat and egg industry giving rise to novel viruses, involving ever so many more animals kept in ways to insure that they take in each others virus carrying body fluids and breath, is even more obvious a means of that happening. The workers and those they come in contact with take in those viruses too. Unless the entire human population takes up a vegan diet, this is hardly going to be the last one. The next one could come from any meat or egg producing operation anywhere in the world. I would expect there are many that arise that way which don't kill people dramatically so they are never intensively studied or named. I don't anticipate that veganism will rise greatly - the online cooking shows certainly aren't doing a lot to promote a diet that doesn't contribute to the generation of pandemic viruses. Which I have to say, I find enormously frustrating. But there it is. The worst of human follies can be carried in what we assume is the simplest of pleasures.
The language of rights and liberty is wide open to be a cover for selfishness, those words are as capable of enabling the most stupid selfishness as well as being used to describe the right for people to do and advocate for the most unselfish, generous and rational behavior. Unselfishness being, so often, ungratifying to the self, as well as harder than what is more gratifying it has the general character of being a tougher sell to a large number of people. That is the secret to the success of American-style conservatism, really of European style libertarianism and conservatism, that 18th century style of "liberalism" that frees the rich to enjoy and enhance their wealth, that is in opposition to the more traditional American liberalism that had the name before then which is based on generous, "liberal" provision to the least among us.
It also plays out in FOX, Sinclair, the right wing media, the Republican-fascist politics which they sponsor appealing to the stupidest, most selfish inclinations of people in order to gull and swindle them. In the case of this pandemic disease, the anti-mask, anti-shut-down, anti-responsibility being peddled to their Republican-fascist viewers, many of them in the age cohort most vulnerable to the disease - that gulling and swindling them is getting them killed or putting them in danger of being seriously, disastrously ill. And if not them their nearest and dearest as well as anyone else they come in contact with.
The "liberty" the "freedom of the press" that is enshrined in the irresponsibly inspecific First Amendment should rationally and rightly be indicted for its major role in permitting the disastrous course the American Covid-19 pandemic. From the racism promoted through it about the pandemic to Trump peddling his adult Chicken Pox party style rallies, to literally everything else about what has made, especially the "red states" most influenced by that kind of criminal irresponsibility shows that the traditional, post-war interpretation of the First Amendment, by "liberal" as well as Republican-fascist courts is extremely dangerous. If you think regulating the press so it doesn't spread homicidal lies is an infringment on personal freedom, getting intubated as last ditch resort to trying to keep you alive IF YOU'RE LUCKY ENOUGH TO HAVE ONE AVAILABLE DUE TO THE REPUBLICANS AND MEDIA SPREADING THE PANDEMIC is somewhat more of an inhibition of your personal style.
I wish I'd copied the doctor's tweet about wearing a mask and taking other precautions or get intubated by a novice doctor in an unrelated field who did their last semester online. It was a good one.
* I've always told people as they promoted promiscuity and things like anal sex as being kew-el and transgressive and fashionable that even though they may have the stupid belief that AIDS ended (it didn't, in anything except the ability of rich people to, as of now, control its severity) that there was absolutely no guarantee that another deadly pandemic couldn't arise through the same means that AIDS developed into one through risky sex, needle exchange and blood donations by infected people in the period before the virus is even noticed. It wasn't a welcomed message among gay men in the 1980s, even as they saw the new disease killing men, even as it was clear that there was a link between promiscuous sex in places like bath houses and sex bars and the disease. So much of what we're seeing about the assertions of "freedom and liberty" so much of the denial of reality among the Republican-fascists and their criminally irresponsible media was seen by those of us observing the early years of the AIDS pandemic. Only differnece is that there is no homophobic content in the irresponsible misinformation about this present pandemic to complicate things. Though that might have had anti-"liberal" anti-North-Eastern, anti-Democratic bigotry as a media and Republican-fascist promoted and exploited stand in.
The potential of the factory farming or even small farming of animals for the meat and egg industry giving rise to novel viruses, involving ever so many more animals kept in ways to insure that they take in each others virus carrying body fluids and breath, is even more obvious a means of that happening. The workers and those they come in contact with take in those viruses too. Unless the entire human population takes up a vegan diet, this is hardly going to be the last one. The next one could come from any meat or egg producing operation anywhere in the world. I would expect there are many that arise that way which don't kill people dramatically so they are never intensively studied or named. I don't anticipate that veganism will rise greatly - the online cooking shows certainly aren't doing a lot to promote a diet that doesn't contribute to the generation of pandemic viruses. Which I have to say, I find enormously frustrating. But there it is. The worst of human follies can be carried in what we assume is the simplest of pleasures.
Tomorrow is the day that Blogger pulls a change on us, I have no idea how that's going to go. I will continue writing things, I don't know if I'll still do it in this format, if the new Blogger allows me to, I'll probably keep it up. I have heard that it makes posting Youtubes harder, though I'd expect it will be possible to post links the way I post most of the radio dramas so maybe it won't be so bad. We'll see.
Tuesday, June 30, 2020
Sad that the really great Carl Reiner has died at 98. He's one of the few people in the comedy field who maintained the hard work of being funny for more years than I can remember. Unlike almost every other person in the comedy world, he didn't peter out before he died.
I'm sad for us, not him. He gave us all those years, how much more could he have been expected to give? I believe he's in a state of eternal happiness, he having given so much of that to us. I don't have any reason to doubt that for him.
I'm sad for us, not him. He gave us all those years, how much more could he have been expected to give? I believe he's in a state of eternal happiness, he having given so much of that to us. I don't have any reason to doubt that for him.
Elizabeth Warren Responds to Mike Pence's Misleading Coronavirus Press Conference
Another day in the pandemic, another day when I've got a fever and sore throat and am thinking about getting close enough to the guy who delivered some meds for a relative to sign for it last week. He had on a mask and gloves, I didn't, he caught me by surprise and I didn't think to tell him he was going to have to wait till I suited up. It's probably not Covid-19 but who knows.
And the news is that they've found another humanly transmissible virus from in and around the pork industry. Damned carnivores are going to get us all killed.
John Roberts Is A Shifty Operator, Not A Principled Believer In Egalitarian Democracy Or Even Good Government
My take on the Louisiana abortion decision, a quite unexpectedly pro-choice (pro-choiceish, really) decision joined in by John Roberts, an opponent of the rights of women to own their own bodies, is that Roberts is biding his time. He is trying to avoid the even bigger electoral disaster that his Republican-fascists can already anticipate in 2020, losing the entire Congress and the Executive branch, perhaps his fascist majority on the Court as Sheldon Whitehouse has access to the records of Bret Kavanaugh's serial perjuries to the Senate which will certainly result in Kavanaugh being removed from the Court or forced off of it and who knows what else. Personally, I'm looking forward to the operations of Chuck Grassley and the other Repubublicans on the Senate Judiciary Committee, Mitch McConnell to be exposed too. One of my wishes is that Grassley live to realize that his name in history will be as a villain, a dishonest, sleazy, sanctimonious hypocrite who is a real life Henry F. Porter who sounds annoyingly like the annoying James Stewart. And for the people of Iowa to understand that they have put him there as much as I hope for the people of Maine to realize what they did by allowing themselves to be duped by Susan Collins. I hope to see her live to be humiliated and to realize she will never live down her exposure for what she has always been.
I don't trust John Roberts at all, he is a dedicated ideological fascist - as everyone who the fascist Federalist Society* promotes for the judiciary - an opponent of egalitarian democracy, a willing servant of oligarchy and the status quo of unequal power and wealth. The Court decision to allow Trump to destroy the Consumer Protection Bureau's independence from Trump and other Republican-fascists, it is a crack that Roberts and the other fascists made in the wall of separation for agencies designed to act independently something which will certainly, if not stopped, destroy the very concept of independent agencies, one of the backbones of much of the progress made since the Roosevelt administration started those to address the disaster Republican-lassiez faire economics had wrought in the Great Depression.
Roberts is playing a longer game than any one decision will figure in, he is biding his time for a time when his desire is fulfilled in having an intelligent, disciplned version of Trump whose stupidity and flagarant corruption and incompetence is endangering the goal of his entire professional life.
The solution is to reign in the Supreme Court, to have a Democratic president, a Democratic Congress refuse to allow anything short of a unanimous Court to nullify laws duly adopted and enacted by the deliberations of hundreds of legislators and members of the Executive. That the Supreme Court regularly does that now on a 5-4 ruling, often with the most absurd and dishonest of sophistry being their excuse, ignoring everything from the impassioned testimony of people in real life to carefully complied mathematics and scientific fact is a crime against reason and experience. The Court, having given itself that power - it is no where in the Constitution, in Marbury v Madison, it didn't dare use it again for a century except in the execrable Dred Scott decision one of the main contributors to the terrible Civil War. In the 20th century all hell broke loose that way, it's high time to reign in the out of anyone's control court and cut it down to a servant of egalitarian democracy. Roberts should find himself in the fascist minority on an expanded court - one which has members who are not only dedicated to egalitarian democracy but who also know enough math and science so they have a clue about the testimony and record they are supposedly basing their opinions on. And he should have one that knows it cannot destroy legislation except on a unanimous basis. It is a hell of a lot easier to overturn bad legislation after an election, AN HONEST ELECTION, than to wait for the fascists to die from the court. The Supreme Court attack on honest elections is the absolute proof that they cannot be allowed to continue as they have been.
* The endorsement of the Federalist Society, among others, should become poison to a nominee for the courts. They are poisonous to equality and democracy.
I don't trust John Roberts at all, he is a dedicated ideological fascist - as everyone who the fascist Federalist Society* promotes for the judiciary - an opponent of egalitarian democracy, a willing servant of oligarchy and the status quo of unequal power and wealth. The Court decision to allow Trump to destroy the Consumer Protection Bureau's independence from Trump and other Republican-fascists, it is a crack that Roberts and the other fascists made in the wall of separation for agencies designed to act independently something which will certainly, if not stopped, destroy the very concept of independent agencies, one of the backbones of much of the progress made since the Roosevelt administration started those to address the disaster Republican-lassiez faire economics had wrought in the Great Depression.
Roberts is playing a longer game than any one decision will figure in, he is biding his time for a time when his desire is fulfilled in having an intelligent, disciplned version of Trump whose stupidity and flagarant corruption and incompetence is endangering the goal of his entire professional life.
The solution is to reign in the Supreme Court, to have a Democratic president, a Democratic Congress refuse to allow anything short of a unanimous Court to nullify laws duly adopted and enacted by the deliberations of hundreds of legislators and members of the Executive. That the Supreme Court regularly does that now on a 5-4 ruling, often with the most absurd and dishonest of sophistry being their excuse, ignoring everything from the impassioned testimony of people in real life to carefully complied mathematics and scientific fact is a crime against reason and experience. The Court, having given itself that power - it is no where in the Constitution, in Marbury v Madison, it didn't dare use it again for a century except in the execrable Dred Scott decision one of the main contributors to the terrible Civil War. In the 20th century all hell broke loose that way, it's high time to reign in the out of anyone's control court and cut it down to a servant of egalitarian democracy. Roberts should find himself in the fascist minority on an expanded court - one which has members who are not only dedicated to egalitarian democracy but who also know enough math and science so they have a clue about the testimony and record they are supposedly basing their opinions on. And he should have one that knows it cannot destroy legislation except on a unanimous basis. It is a hell of a lot easier to overturn bad legislation after an election, AN HONEST ELECTION, than to wait for the fascists to die from the court. The Supreme Court attack on honest elections is the absolute proof that they cannot be allowed to continue as they have been.
* The endorsement of the Federalist Society, among others, should become poison to a nominee for the courts. They are poisonous to equality and democracy.
Freedom As A Gift From God Is Far More Logically Coherent Than Atheist-Materialist Treatment Of The Problem Of The Mind
I am a little disappointed that though I had to take a day off from writing something important my usual messengers of materialism didn't note something that I'd thought of, that someone could claim that that same problem I noted determinism is for the atheist-materialist-scientistic view of life can be a big problem for a believer who believes in free thought, free will. Determinism is anathema when it comes to physics and cosmology in quantum mechanics (rather hilarious because doing those depends on an inherent determinacy in natural phenomena) but it is an absolute necessity when they want to dispose of human and other minds which cannot be made to fit into their requirements of causal determination as an explanation of the universe of our experience. Minds that escape the determinism they like are an intolerable fact of the very same experience upon which the science they deify depends - there is no place that science is known to exist except in human minds, science cannot be significant, it can't be true independent of the significance of minds and their capacity for knowing truth independent of any physical causation determining the outcome of our thoughts.
The problem for materialism, for the scientism that rests on that materialism and the atheism which is supported by both is that materialism is perhaps the only ideological position which, when treated rigorously, checking it for both logical coherence and consistency, MATERIALISM CAN ONLY BE TRUE IF IT IS FALSE.
But, an atheist, scientistic materialist might then say, for a believer in the signficiance of minds, the capacity for minds to know truth, to be free of the determiancy of physical causality, determinacy is no less of a problem.
How can human minds escape a divine determinacy such as that hated so much by those who use the "fine tuning" that cosmologists - a good number of them atheist materialists, even some of them devotees of scientism - tell us makes our particular life allowing, intelligence sustaining universe is so wildly improbable.*
The answer for a materialist may be insoluble, remembering that materialism is, by fiat of the materialists, a monist system, whatever "material" is, matter-energy, it must be the only constituent of reality. But if you believe God created the universe you have already made the materialists only allowable thing subordinate to Who created it, who made it as it is, who is not bound by whatever determinism that God created the physical universe appears to us to follow.
God would be quite able to create a universe in which those improbabilities which human science and mathematics may well merely impose on reality are not the all powerful thing that materialists elevate them to be in their deification of math, science, material causation. The universe may not be monistic or dualistic or even poly-istic. It may be far different. And I would imagine you could come up with many ways in which such a reality could account for free minds, free thoughts, free observations of reality and conclusions about it, because God is not bound by physical causality or even the logical coherence which is the human sense of an order to things, in so far as we can know them. Freedom of thought may well be explanable as a gift to us from God where it can't ever be explained (or rationally disposed of) by atheist materialism.
Almost a century ago, A. S. Eddington, fresh from his producing confirmation that Einstein was on to something with his new physics and writing what Einstein said was the finest explanation of it, said:
It is one thing for the human mind to extract from the phenomena of nature the laws which it has itself put into them; it may be a far harder thing to extract laws over which it has had no control. It is even possible that laws which have not their origin in the mind may be irrational and we can never succeed in formulating them.**
And that's conceiving such uncalculable "laws" laws that "have not their origin in the mind" in terms congenial to physics, such "laws" would be a totally different thing than the things we call "laws" which are a product of humanly conducted science. If such unimaginable entities are a force in the universe, they would certainly not have the same character as those things which we can conceive of as laws in terms of observation as treated by mathematics and the other methods of that thing which is produced by mutual consent by humans, science.
I think science should have stuck to questions about the understanding and manipulation of the phenomena of nature which it could honestly deal with - though I think exempting the world of science from questions of morality was probably an even worse mistake than allowing it to become the tool of atheist ideological desire. As it is, we have a large number of very eminent and professionally successful scientists who impose their ideology on the cultural view of science and inject it directly into science, itself. The number of scientists who are obsessed with getting rid of God is rather shocking when you think of it. Hawking is supposed to have called cosmology a "religion for atheists," and so it is as practiced by many, abiogenesis is a biological quest to do the same thing, one which is even more obviously so. And those are only two of the areas of science saturated with the desires ideological claims and restrictions of some of the most eminent of scientists, prohibiting finding anything that would violate that atheist desire.
That is certainly why Robert Oppenheimer implored his colleagues that if they couldn't refute David Bohm, they "must agree to ignore him." It should be shocking that such an eminent scientist with such an eminent position in the scientific establishment could make such a demand of his scientific colleagues a and not be dressed down by them for violating the alleged fearless and objective quest for truth no matter where that leads them. But they didn't, violating that value of science will not get you in trouble, violating the anti-scientific imposition of atheist-materialism will, though there seems to be a bit of room for doubting scientism which is one of the most plainly stupid of claims which cannot sustain itself since the ideology of scientism is not open to scientific examination, itself.
* And, I'll add here, from what I've seen of that thinking the enormous improbabilities that they calculate vastly underestimate instead of cover the probability of life as we know it and see it around us. But that would get us back to just how improbable random chance assembling even the first organism so as it came to life, a persisting containing membrane structure just happening to contain the chemicals and structures so as to begin metabolism and maintenance of the organism before we get to the more incredible liklihood of random chance allowing its reproduction on the first and only try it would get to do that successfully, ending up with at least two of itself - if it reproduced to three, that first time or more, the chances against that happening rise incredibly fast. I love thinking about that problem, nothing shows the idiocy of materialist, scientistic atheism for what it is like thinking about that problem they inevitably don't consider or they could not maintain their naive faith. I wonder if it would be possible to come up with a probability of a random chance that could get that random chance to produce such an incredibly improbable thing happening once, as opposed to random chance that would not produce that ever. Live by the math, die by the math.
** I would call your attention to Eddington's phrase for the proper and only legitimate object of science, "the phenomena of nature." I think any scientist, atheist-materialist or not would have to agree that humanly preceived phenomena are what science was invented to look at and analyze so as to understand them. Phenomena only become such as they are seen, perceived, by minds, our human minds in the case of science. That vicissitude of science insures that to pretend that that fact isn't totally determinative of the nature of what science can tell you about anything will lead you astray. Yet the ideological requirements of deveoped atheist-materialist-scientism demands that that absolute requirement of science be denied or, since it can't be refuted, ignored. I doubt that the outcome of that will be true, certainly not in most or even many cases.
To pretend that our experience is irrelevant at any second to science is one of the most insane of the host of delusions of current scientific culture. I cannot think that the insistence that that can be done is not part of the same ideological program that the above descries. It fits in with the rest of it too well for it to have other motives.
The problem for materialism, for the scientism that rests on that materialism and the atheism which is supported by both is that materialism is perhaps the only ideological position which, when treated rigorously, checking it for both logical coherence and consistency, MATERIALISM CAN ONLY BE TRUE IF IT IS FALSE.
But, an atheist, scientistic materialist might then say, for a believer in the signficiance of minds, the capacity for minds to know truth, to be free of the determiancy of physical causality, determinacy is no less of a problem.
How can human minds escape a divine determinacy such as that hated so much by those who use the "fine tuning" that cosmologists - a good number of them atheist materialists, even some of them devotees of scientism - tell us makes our particular life allowing, intelligence sustaining universe is so wildly improbable.*
The answer for a materialist may be insoluble, remembering that materialism is, by fiat of the materialists, a monist system, whatever "material" is, matter-energy, it must be the only constituent of reality. But if you believe God created the universe you have already made the materialists only allowable thing subordinate to Who created it, who made it as it is, who is not bound by whatever determinism that God created the physical universe appears to us to follow.
God would be quite able to create a universe in which those improbabilities which human science and mathematics may well merely impose on reality are not the all powerful thing that materialists elevate them to be in their deification of math, science, material causation. The universe may not be monistic or dualistic or even poly-istic. It may be far different. And I would imagine you could come up with many ways in which such a reality could account for free minds, free thoughts, free observations of reality and conclusions about it, because God is not bound by physical causality or even the logical coherence which is the human sense of an order to things, in so far as we can know them. Freedom of thought may well be explanable as a gift to us from God where it can't ever be explained (or rationally disposed of) by atheist materialism.
Almost a century ago, A. S. Eddington, fresh from his producing confirmation that Einstein was on to something with his new physics and writing what Einstein said was the finest explanation of it, said:
It is one thing for the human mind to extract from the phenomena of nature the laws which it has itself put into them; it may be a far harder thing to extract laws over which it has had no control. It is even possible that laws which have not their origin in the mind may be irrational and we can never succeed in formulating them.**
And that's conceiving such uncalculable "laws" laws that "have not their origin in the mind" in terms congenial to physics, such "laws" would be a totally different thing than the things we call "laws" which are a product of humanly conducted science. If such unimaginable entities are a force in the universe, they would certainly not have the same character as those things which we can conceive of as laws in terms of observation as treated by mathematics and the other methods of that thing which is produced by mutual consent by humans, science.
I think science should have stuck to questions about the understanding and manipulation of the phenomena of nature which it could honestly deal with - though I think exempting the world of science from questions of morality was probably an even worse mistake than allowing it to become the tool of atheist ideological desire. As it is, we have a large number of very eminent and professionally successful scientists who impose their ideology on the cultural view of science and inject it directly into science, itself. The number of scientists who are obsessed with getting rid of God is rather shocking when you think of it. Hawking is supposed to have called cosmology a "religion for atheists," and so it is as practiced by many, abiogenesis is a biological quest to do the same thing, one which is even more obviously so. And those are only two of the areas of science saturated with the desires ideological claims and restrictions of some of the most eminent of scientists, prohibiting finding anything that would violate that atheist desire.
That is certainly why Robert Oppenheimer implored his colleagues that if they couldn't refute David Bohm, they "must agree to ignore him." It should be shocking that such an eminent scientist with such an eminent position in the scientific establishment could make such a demand of his scientific colleagues a and not be dressed down by them for violating the alleged fearless and objective quest for truth no matter where that leads them. But they didn't, violating that value of science will not get you in trouble, violating the anti-scientific imposition of atheist-materialism will, though there seems to be a bit of room for doubting scientism which is one of the most plainly stupid of claims which cannot sustain itself since the ideology of scientism is not open to scientific examination, itself.
* And, I'll add here, from what I've seen of that thinking the enormous improbabilities that they calculate vastly underestimate instead of cover the probability of life as we know it and see it around us. But that would get us back to just how improbable random chance assembling even the first organism so as it came to life, a persisting containing membrane structure just happening to contain the chemicals and structures so as to begin metabolism and maintenance of the organism before we get to the more incredible liklihood of random chance allowing its reproduction on the first and only try it would get to do that successfully, ending up with at least two of itself - if it reproduced to three, that first time or more, the chances against that happening rise incredibly fast. I love thinking about that problem, nothing shows the idiocy of materialist, scientistic atheism for what it is like thinking about that problem they inevitably don't consider or they could not maintain their naive faith. I wonder if it would be possible to come up with a probability of a random chance that could get that random chance to produce such an incredibly improbable thing happening once, as opposed to random chance that would not produce that ever. Live by the math, die by the math.
** I would call your attention to Eddington's phrase for the proper and only legitimate object of science, "the phenomena of nature." I think any scientist, atheist-materialist or not would have to agree that humanly preceived phenomena are what science was invented to look at and analyze so as to understand them. Phenomena only become such as they are seen, perceived, by minds, our human minds in the case of science. That vicissitude of science insures that to pretend that that fact isn't totally determinative of the nature of what science can tell you about anything will lead you astray. Yet the ideological requirements of deveoped atheist-materialist-scientism demands that that absolute requirement of science be denied or, since it can't be refuted, ignored. I doubt that the outcome of that will be true, certainly not in most or even many cases.
To pretend that our experience is irrelevant at any second to science is one of the most insane of the host of delusions of current scientific culture. I cannot think that the insistence that that can be done is not part of the same ideological program that the above descries. It fits in with the rest of it too well for it to have other motives.
Sunday, June 28, 2020
Can't Live With It, Can't Live Without It - The Basic Contradiction of Determinacy In Conventional Science
I must have been extra tired yesterday becaue I could have pointed this out. While re-reading the post about Bohm and his blackballing by the upper reaches of physics because his mathematical quest for truth, which is what theoretical physics is, he came to conclusions that there was something other than random-chance behind things - to put it in one word, "DETERMINACY" which in context implies the will of a mind, the Creator, God, shows an enormous inconsistency in the very ideology that the physicists, Robert Oppenheimer, Wolfgang Pauli, the circle of Neils Bohr, etc. were upholding in blackballing, ignoring him at the command of Oppenheimer, into obscurity to, they were confronting only one side of the double-edged sword that determinacy is for atheist-materialist-scientism.
The irony in that is that the same determinacy which is poison to the atheist-materialist-scientistic ideology of physics IS ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY IN THE BIOLOGICAL AND LIFE SCIENCE FOR ATHEIST-MATERIALIST-SCIENTISIM TO HAVE ANY PLAUSIBILITY BECAUSE IT REDUCES ANIMAL CONSCIOUSNESS WHICH CAN ONLY BE SIGNIFICANT, THE EXTENT TO WHICH IT ESCAPES THE CLOSED, POINTLESS MAZE OF MATERIALISM TO ABSOLUTE DETERMINACY.
The very same ideology that demands indeterminacy rule in physics lest these determined atheists may run into something that implies things are as they are by the will of the Creator, MUST have determinacy to, likewise, not be confronted with "the hard problem" of atheist-materialist-scientism, human and animal consciousness on the other end. In that, the ideology of materialism runs smack into itself as it did in the cosmologists' calculations that led to those enormous, truly enormous numbers requiring multiplying ten to very, very large powers to express concerning the improbability of our universe and its potential to generate intelligent life - the motive for high-end physics to invent jillions of universes either simultaneous in time or in an never ending universe bouncing in and out of existence, to make those numbers go away.
That, as Shedrake and Vernon and others have pointed out, demoting human minds to the condition of the program controlling robots destroys any confidence that our ideas, including those of Oppenheimer, Pauli, Bohr and their colleagues to meaningless artifacts of determinacy, including their insistence on blackballing a colleague for finding determinacy where it is not only inconvienient but poison to their ideology and their pretensions of finding some objective truth (it can only not be a pretense if their minds are free acting observers) may be what drove David Bohm to the radical form of free thinking of J. Krishnamurti, a freedom which, as well, corrodes the world of the atheist-materialist devotees of scientism. I don't know how far in that direction Bohm's engagement with Krishnamurti went or, in fact, how far Krishnamurti was willing to go with him, but it certainly presents the common received basic POV of a post-war physicist with an enormous problem.
No, science went wrong in the 19th century when it adopted an ideology unrelated to the strict observation of nature treated mathematically and confirmed by others performing rigorous observation of nature. That started in the 18th century, as the ideologies mentioned took hold in that most ironic of ideological namings "the enlightenment". That light has led farther astray as much as it led farther to the truth. Maybe if physics hadn't become such a steep hill to climb up and there was a requirement that its priesthood engage with rigorous philosophical discourse some of that might have been avoided. At least in so far as they were open to philosophy which didn't, as well, get so sidetracked. The atheist-materialist-scientistic world view may have started in the repute science gained for its common usefulness but its infuence infected a lot more than science, especially as other disciplines hankered after the repute, fame and resources that science attracted to itself. Lots of philosophy has descended into the same decadence, some theology, even.
The irony in that is that the same determinacy which is poison to the atheist-materialist-scientistic ideology of physics IS ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY IN THE BIOLOGICAL AND LIFE SCIENCE FOR ATHEIST-MATERIALIST-SCIENTISIM TO HAVE ANY PLAUSIBILITY BECAUSE IT REDUCES ANIMAL CONSCIOUSNESS WHICH CAN ONLY BE SIGNIFICANT, THE EXTENT TO WHICH IT ESCAPES THE CLOSED, POINTLESS MAZE OF MATERIALISM TO ABSOLUTE DETERMINACY.
The very same ideology that demands indeterminacy rule in physics lest these determined atheists may run into something that implies things are as they are by the will of the Creator, MUST have determinacy to, likewise, not be confronted with "the hard problem" of atheist-materialist-scientism, human and animal consciousness on the other end. In that, the ideology of materialism runs smack into itself as it did in the cosmologists' calculations that led to those enormous, truly enormous numbers requiring multiplying ten to very, very large powers to express concerning the improbability of our universe and its potential to generate intelligent life - the motive for high-end physics to invent jillions of universes either simultaneous in time or in an never ending universe bouncing in and out of existence, to make those numbers go away.
That, as Shedrake and Vernon and others have pointed out, demoting human minds to the condition of the program controlling robots destroys any confidence that our ideas, including those of Oppenheimer, Pauli, Bohr and their colleagues to meaningless artifacts of determinacy, including their insistence on blackballing a colleague for finding determinacy where it is not only inconvienient but poison to their ideology and their pretensions of finding some objective truth (it can only not be a pretense if their minds are free acting observers) may be what drove David Bohm to the radical form of free thinking of J. Krishnamurti, a freedom which, as well, corrodes the world of the atheist-materialist devotees of scientism. I don't know how far in that direction Bohm's engagement with Krishnamurti went or, in fact, how far Krishnamurti was willing to go with him, but it certainly presents the common received basic POV of a post-war physicist with an enormous problem.
No, science went wrong in the 19th century when it adopted an ideology unrelated to the strict observation of nature treated mathematically and confirmed by others performing rigorous observation of nature. That started in the 18th century, as the ideologies mentioned took hold in that most ironic of ideological namings "the enlightenment". That light has led farther astray as much as it led farther to the truth. Maybe if physics hadn't become such a steep hill to climb up and there was a requirement that its priesthood engage with rigorous philosophical discourse some of that might have been avoided. At least in so far as they were open to philosophy which didn't, as well, get so sidetracked. The atheist-materialist-scientistic world view may have started in the repute science gained for its common usefulness but its infuence infected a lot more than science, especially as other disciplines hankered after the repute, fame and resources that science attracted to itself. Lots of philosophy has descended into the same decadence, some theology, even.
Saturday, June 27, 2020
Saturday Night Radio Drama - Hear Now Festival 2020 Podcast Palooza
In lieu of posting a single drama I'm posting a link to the Hear Now Festival's 2020 Podcast Palooza with a large number of contenders for their prizes. Lots to choose from, lots to enjoy.
Blackballed By The Blacklisted For The Sin Of Finding Determinacy
Quantum physics, like all of modern physics, is written in mathematical language that is way beyond what I can understand so, like just about everyone else, I am left dependent on the descriptions of it and its consequences as doled out by those who do know that language. And it is almost inevitable that anyone who does that has a personal self-interest involved in it.
I listened to this dialogue between the great biologist Rupert Sheldrake and one of his many lucky partners in dialogue, Mark Vernon with some understanding though I certainly have never read David Bohm's theory or much of what it flew in the face of in more conventionally acceptable interpretations of quantum mechanics but there are several issues that are relevant to things I've said here, mostly in regard to the atheist-materialist-scientistic god of random-chance and the insistence on indeterminacy and, if their atheist god were ever to be expressed in a trinitarian theory, the stupidity of nature.
I have read a very, very little about how his former mentor the atheist-secular saint of the play-left, Robert Oppenheimer got freaked out over the work of his student when some of his equations more than arrived at an implication of determinacy behind the workings of nature, so much so that he said, "If we cannot disprove Bohm, we must agree to ignore him." And he was hardly alone among eminent physicists, men of science, those who presented themselves as fearless followers of the truth no matter where the evidence brought them.
I wish I knew enough to be able to look into another famous statement about Bohm's theory and the setting of post-war physics in which it lay like a piece of sand in an oyster (perhaps) that of the iconoclastic critic as well as friend of science, Paul Feyerabend, in a quote that can be found in truncated form all over the internet.
The fact . . . that Bohm’s model was pushed aside while all sorts of weird ideas flourished is very interesting, and I hope that one fine day a historian or sociologist of science takes a close look at the matter.
Paul Feyerabend, 1993; letter to David Peat
I would assume that among the weird ideas that so flourished were the many varieties of multi-verse scenarios which I think are one of the most certain products of the decadence that science came to because of the materialist-atheist-scientistic ideological commitments of its main figures. The motive behind much of it has been, in fact, to prop up that ideological framing which made anything that implied determinacy poison to it. I have often quoted the biologist, one of the few dedicated materailist-atheists though not a devotee of scientism, Richard Lewontin saying that they chose to not let anything in that could be like the camel getting its nose under the tent to protect their ideological commitments.
I especially appreciate that Sheldrake, who seems to have known David Bohm personally and rather well, is critical of his determined avoidance of philosophy, as, in fact, Paul Feyerabend said had become common among eminent scientists of the post-war period. Even a figure who you want to praise will have his flaws. I wonder if the requirements of modern physics have become so stiff, if the learning curve has not become so steep that it is almost a guarantee of not having the time to learn much about such things, though a number of those who express such a disdain for philosophy have no problem with mastering some massively unserious and unimportant features of commercial pop-culture and celebrity. I think it's possible that the hatred of philosophy has similar motives to their hatred of religion, that it might challenge their ideological commitments which are, in turn, a reflection of their own personal preferences and hatreds. Not to mention what is de rigueur in their chosen milieu of academic and cultural life. I wonder if he were around, if Bohm would get on the talk and late-night shows. But I don't wonder hard.
And, considering what Sheldrake and Vernon discuss of Bohm's involvement with him, I will say there was a brief period when I read a bit of J. Krishnamurti's stuff and quickly stopped bothering with it because it just went in circles, not committing itself to anything except the unremarkable idea that you had to think for yourself. I don't know how that was something that escaped anyone's notice though it seems to be considered a remarkable idea, especially to many devotees of "eastern wisdom". I can't understand why anyone would remain committed to Krishnamurti unless they had a deep seated fear of making a commitment, ironically, enough. I was young and I will admit that the guy who tried to interest me in it was good looking. The relationship didn't go anywhere. I have no idea what he's up to now if he's still around.
I listened to this dialogue between the great biologist Rupert Sheldrake and one of his many lucky partners in dialogue, Mark Vernon with some understanding though I certainly have never read David Bohm's theory or much of what it flew in the face of in more conventionally acceptable interpretations of quantum mechanics but there are several issues that are relevant to things I've said here, mostly in regard to the atheist-materialist-scientistic god of random-chance and the insistence on indeterminacy and, if their atheist god were ever to be expressed in a trinitarian theory, the stupidity of nature.
I have read a very, very little about how his former mentor the atheist-secular saint of the play-left, Robert Oppenheimer got freaked out over the work of his student when some of his equations more than arrived at an implication of determinacy behind the workings of nature, so much so that he said, "If we cannot disprove Bohm, we must agree to ignore him." And he was hardly alone among eminent physicists, men of science, those who presented themselves as fearless followers of the truth no matter where the evidence brought them.
I wish I knew enough to be able to look into another famous statement about Bohm's theory and the setting of post-war physics in which it lay like a piece of sand in an oyster (perhaps) that of the iconoclastic critic as well as friend of science, Paul Feyerabend, in a quote that can be found in truncated form all over the internet.
The fact . . . that Bohm’s model was pushed aside while all sorts of weird ideas flourished is very interesting, and I hope that one fine day a historian or sociologist of science takes a close look at the matter.
Paul Feyerabend, 1993; letter to David Peat
I would assume that among the weird ideas that so flourished were the many varieties of multi-verse scenarios which I think are one of the most certain products of the decadence that science came to because of the materialist-atheist-scientistic ideological commitments of its main figures. The motive behind much of it has been, in fact, to prop up that ideological framing which made anything that implied determinacy poison to it. I have often quoted the biologist, one of the few dedicated materailist-atheists though not a devotee of scientism, Richard Lewontin saying that they chose to not let anything in that could be like the camel getting its nose under the tent to protect their ideological commitments.
I especially appreciate that Sheldrake, who seems to have known David Bohm personally and rather well, is critical of his determined avoidance of philosophy, as, in fact, Paul Feyerabend said had become common among eminent scientists of the post-war period. Even a figure who you want to praise will have his flaws. I wonder if the requirements of modern physics have become so stiff, if the learning curve has not become so steep that it is almost a guarantee of not having the time to learn much about such things, though a number of those who express such a disdain for philosophy have no problem with mastering some massively unserious and unimportant features of commercial pop-culture and celebrity. I think it's possible that the hatred of philosophy has similar motives to their hatred of religion, that it might challenge their ideological commitments which are, in turn, a reflection of their own personal preferences and hatreds. Not to mention what is de rigueur in their chosen milieu of academic and cultural life. I wonder if he were around, if Bohm would get on the talk and late-night shows. But I don't wonder hard.
And, considering what Sheldrake and Vernon discuss of Bohm's involvement with him, I will say there was a brief period when I read a bit of J. Krishnamurti's stuff and quickly stopped bothering with it because it just went in circles, not committing itself to anything except the unremarkable idea that you had to think for yourself. I don't know how that was something that escaped anyone's notice though it seems to be considered a remarkable idea, especially to many devotees of "eastern wisdom". I can't understand why anyone would remain committed to Krishnamurti unless they had a deep seated fear of making a commitment, ironically, enough. I was young and I will admit that the guy who tried to interest me in it was good looking. The relationship didn't go anywhere. I have no idea what he's up to now if he's still around.
When You Privilege Lies, People Die
Seeing the early non-response of the "red states" to the Covid 19 and that of the Trump crime regime and how that is, as was predicted, coming back to bite hard and mercilessly, I'm at a loss to how anyone could doubt the danger of lies freely told and transmitted through the mass media and how the judicial system cannot be allowed to aid and abet political and other lies without this being the result. What is happening in Florida, Texas, etc. is a direct result of the law of the United States permitting lies to be told by and through the "free press". Trump is a product of that media spreading lies.
The promotion of irresponsibility and selfishness, the core message of modern American conservatism was a permission granted to the mass media by the courts using the language of the First Amendment. That those lines are vague and don't account for the use of them by those of not only no morals but bad morals who gain power is only one of the hard truths about the defects built into the American Constitution and how in the United States - as probably everywhere - the legal profession benefits by telling the rich and amoral how to rig such language to allow them to do the most unjust and terrible things. Trump's life is the story of a rich creep whose lawyers and judges allowed him to constantly get away with things using the language of the American law held to conform to the Constitution. Whatever depravity that is allowed to stand as law in the United States must be held to be a result of a defect in that sacrosanct document. Even that we are afraid to change it for fear of billionaires and millionaires queering the process of reform through the Free Press in its deregulated mass media electonic form is a result of the Madisonian poetry of the First Amendment.
Democracy is going to depend on a rewrite. Probably Congress taking back the ability the Supreme Court granted itself in Marbury v Madison, too. Ironic isn't it that "Jemmy" Madison was one of the first people who must have regretted some of the language they put into the Constitution. I'll bet that slavery enabler wished they'd been more specific about the role and powers of the Supreme Court the day that ruling came down.
The promotion of irresponsibility and selfishness, the core message of modern American conservatism was a permission granted to the mass media by the courts using the language of the First Amendment. That those lines are vague and don't account for the use of them by those of not only no morals but bad morals who gain power is only one of the hard truths about the defects built into the American Constitution and how in the United States - as probably everywhere - the legal profession benefits by telling the rich and amoral how to rig such language to allow them to do the most unjust and terrible things. Trump's life is the story of a rich creep whose lawyers and judges allowed him to constantly get away with things using the language of the American law held to conform to the Constitution. Whatever depravity that is allowed to stand as law in the United States must be held to be a result of a defect in that sacrosanct document. Even that we are afraid to change it for fear of billionaires and millionaires queering the process of reform through the Free Press in its deregulated mass media electonic form is a result of the Madisonian poetry of the First Amendment.
Democracy is going to depend on a rewrite. Probably Congress taking back the ability the Supreme Court granted itself in Marbury v Madison, too. Ironic isn't it that "Jemmy" Madison was one of the first people who must have regretted some of the language they put into the Constitution. I'll bet that slavery enabler wished they'd been more specific about the role and powers of the Supreme Court the day that ruling came down.
Correction And Mocking Those Who Would Walk In The Footsteps of Bruno
I have gone through yesterday's post and corrected a quote I got wrong, I had to go digging for the video on which I saw it which is the problem of quoting people through transcription - there is no word-search function for audio that I'm aware of. As well as several other points.
Re-reading it for corrections, I left out two of the biggest reasons I think the criticism and debunkery racket is generally considered to be above criticism, other than the inefficiency of fact checking in the ink on paper era. I think one of those is the thing farthest from the truth, that such debunkery presents the best facts out of the diligence of the critic or debunker which is ironic when it is generally the shallowest of intellectual endeavors. It is a rare critic, as such, who is as careful as the constructive quasi or genuine scholar of a subject. I have said that in the period since I started reading theology that it has astonished me how many of them, and not only in the modern era, are among the most careful, the most wide reaching the most even handed and fair minded of academic writers I'm aware of. Hans Kung is only one of many such modern scholars and he is carrying on what is a long tradition of such expansive breath, depth of scope and rigorous and fair consideration of his intellectual opponents.
Related to the misrepresentation of the debunkery of modern criticism as rigorous scholars is the cowardice that is the most common response to a bully, which is the general character of these big, bold, iconoclasts who present themselves as brave in the footsteps of Giordano Bruno when they are not only in absolutely no danger from the modern establishment or even, really, from religious fanatics, they generally have great expectations of profiting from their writing, maybe even getting a teaching gig out of it, talk show invitations, at least. I think the force of cowardice should never be ignored in the culture of modernism which is generally the merely credentialed gulling the gullible that they are the biggest, boldest trash talkers there are. Much of the method of any era's peddlers of words and ideas is related to the kind of PR that is not unknown in the phony illusion of American or Japanese pro-wrestling. Only it's physically less rigorous and even less likely to injure those applying merely words of violence.
I have to say I read with pleasure Marilynne Robinson's take down of John Spong, who I've always thought was a jerk. I should mention that one of the reasons for the influence of the debunkery bunch is that it's a lot easier and breezier to read than real scholarship. It's easy, one of the greatest motives in corruption that plagues popular culture.
Re-reading it for corrections, I left out two of the biggest reasons I think the criticism and debunkery racket is generally considered to be above criticism, other than the inefficiency of fact checking in the ink on paper era. I think one of those is the thing farthest from the truth, that such debunkery presents the best facts out of the diligence of the critic or debunker which is ironic when it is generally the shallowest of intellectual endeavors. It is a rare critic, as such, who is as careful as the constructive quasi or genuine scholar of a subject. I have said that in the period since I started reading theology that it has astonished me how many of them, and not only in the modern era, are among the most careful, the most wide reaching the most even handed and fair minded of academic writers I'm aware of. Hans Kung is only one of many such modern scholars and he is carrying on what is a long tradition of such expansive breath, depth of scope and rigorous and fair consideration of his intellectual opponents.
Related to the misrepresentation of the debunkery of modern criticism as rigorous scholars is the cowardice that is the most common response to a bully, which is the general character of these big, bold, iconoclasts who present themselves as brave in the footsteps of Giordano Bruno when they are not only in absolutely no danger from the modern establishment or even, really, from religious fanatics, they generally have great expectations of profiting from their writing, maybe even getting a teaching gig out of it, talk show invitations, at least. I think the force of cowardice should never be ignored in the culture of modernism which is generally the merely credentialed gulling the gullible that they are the biggest, boldest trash talkers there are. Much of the method of any era's peddlers of words and ideas is related to the kind of PR that is not unknown in the phony illusion of American or Japanese pro-wrestling. Only it's physically less rigorous and even less likely to injure those applying merely words of violence.
I have to say I read with pleasure Marilynne Robinson's take down of John Spong, who I've always thought was a jerk. I should mention that one of the reasons for the influence of the debunkery bunch is that it's a lot easier and breezier to read than real scholarship. It's easy, one of the greatest motives in corruption that plagues popular culture.
Friday, June 26, 2020
After Re-Reading The Fate Of Ideas
Once you step out of the various ideological framings of reality, which we are presented for our adoption by the "failed project" of modern thought - I agree with that assessment of it as failed by Marilynne Robinson - you can see a lot of things that you won't see if you remain in them. One of the things you see is that though they present themselves in opposition to each other, even "dialectical" opposition, they share the same motivation if not point of view which make all of them toxic and all of them hostile to The Law, the Prophets, The Gospel of Jesus, The Letters of Paul and, I'd say especially James, and the various other parts of the Scriptures and to the religions that try to express those.
One of the most interesting proofs of the hypocrisy of the secularists who love to hate on the Old Testament is that in almost every other case of them waxing in theatrical outrage over the ancient wrongs of the Children of Israel, ascribed to the commands of the God who has become a cartoon in the secular non-reading or, more typically, shallow skimming of those old and very knotty texts, will inevitably excuse similar and far greater records of wrong done by contemporary forces and governments. That Biblican Fundamentalism shares the same cartoon image of God and the modern conception of how to read a text for literal meaning betrays the fact that Fundamentalism is, as well, a product of modernism.
Some specimens of the various ideological framings:
- A Richard Dawkins type will minimize the horrors wrought by the theory of natural selection, something which the eminent biologist of a century ago, a convinced Darwinist, himself, Vernon Kellogg warned of as he heard his scientific colleagues in the German military give that for their already rather developed plans for conquest, dominance and disposal of those lesser than them. What he learned from his pacifist mission to talk to the Germans before the US entered World War One, turned him from a pacifist to someone who said that that was something which it was inevitable we would have to go to war against. And, I'll remind you, that hadn't turned into Nazism until after World War One had ended. It is the major intellectual force which Hitler's second in command said Nazism was merely an application of when he declared National Socialism was "applied science, nothing else." Dawkins and a number of his neo-atheist colleagues are rather warm to the notion of eugenics, something which will be a recurring danger as long as natural selection is the required framing in which to think about evolution.
- A secular capitalist or, in fact, one who professes religious belief - will totally overlook the horrific violence done by capitalists, those not designated as capitalist, those who are, those who claim to do so from "democratic" countries, discrediting a good which they never had any intention of ever allowing to exist. A Christopher Hitchens will go from being a Trotskyite to being a neo-con, supporting the Bush - Cheney crime family disaster of the invasion of Iraq, overthrowing a secular despot and plunging the region into a regime of violence and upheaval which will be killing and maiming people, providing opportunities for terrorists and other thugs to gain power and impose gangster governance that makes Saddam Hussein's crime regime look relatively benign, it wasn't but what has succeeded it has been far worse.
- Most ironic of all are those secular, anti-religious Zionists who will join in the general modernist mockery and slamming of the Old Testament for the claimed subduing of the inhabitants of the lands Israel was established on thousands of years ago even as they will do anything to protect the present Israeli government from criticism for reenacting those things confessed to in the ancient Scriptures.
I have little doubt that some of the accounts of the wiping out of peoples by the Children of Israel are told with the typical exaggeration of such ancient accounts, perhaps especially around the Mediterranean, just as I have no doubt that God didn't need to tell any kings or local potentates to war against their enemies, people are all too able to do that all on their own informed of nothing more remote from their attention as their own perceived self-interest. I have every confidence that the present day reporting of the crimes against the Palestinians of the secular Israeli government, its other crimes are more reliably taken as accurate. One of the few things I appreciate about modern culture are those rare instances where facts get checked and reported fairly, not that that isn't always easy to separate from propaganda. If you have to read the present day record carefully and, often, not thinking that things are as they say on the surface, reading the Scripture accounts of such things is even less reliably done as if they are reporting an unvarnished accurate record of the facts.
- And there is that other great category of the Marxists who have supported some of the bloodiest. most oppressive, most murderous and enslaving regimes in human history, knowing how their favorite Communist regime, their heroes, were oppressing and murdering, at times issuing manifestos and letters of support for show trials, executions even of their fellow Communists, their fellow writers or artists or academics, even their fellow scientists - the non-famous victims in their millions and tens of millions known but not much considered to count among the generally elite or at least college-credentialed Marxist champions of "the workers" "The Masses".
I was never a Communist but I was their dupe which is one of the reasons I have such unending contempt for them. It wasn't until I realized that to reject them and oppose them was not to accept their "other side" that I could really be free of that stupid habit cultivated as "anti-anti-communism". I could be anti-the antis for their own, particular evils. I should note the irony that some of those Commies pose as champions of the Palestinians, who I pity if they are so desperate that they might accept that bunch of bumbling hypocrites professed support of them.
Those are only a few of the major framings of modernism, each of them could certainly be listed with subheadings and you might find exceptions to most of them, though not all of them. Nazis, white supremacists never come in any variety except murderous, racist, homicidal evil.
It can be pointed out that the crimes of the Children of Israel, of Christians, of Muslims are generally opposed by major statements of morality contained in their Scriptures, you can't say the same thing about the foundations of modern secularism for the most part, especially the more developed parts of modernist thought. Modernism, as it develops, tends to go from the morally relative to the morally depraved to the homicidal. The luke-warm "socialism" of Fabianism was capacious enough to contain the proto-Nazi antisemtism and hatred of the disabled and congenitally ill of Karl Pearson to the early calls by another of its stars, George Bernard Shaw, even before the Nazis existed before Stalin or even Lenin came to power, to advocate constructing and using the gas chambers the Nazis did to dispatch many of the same categories of people they would going on in Shaw's lifetime to his open and flagrant adoration of Hitler and Stalin praising their murderous brutality in terms of economic efficency even as they were engaged in murdering people - still being produced as a daring and fashionable figure in the latest thing, a hero to many a bright young thing as he wrote exactly what I just said he said.
It is one of the more tellingly strange things about modernism that even someone like Shaw is to be taken as a normal, respectable figure within it, others who are even more obviously a friend of if not an actual collaborator with even the Hitler and Stalin regimes, or Mao's later can be quite respectable. That is true while someone who believes in, for example, the Resurrection of Jesus will be considered quite outré.
I respect the Jewish tradition of which Christianity and Islam are certainly a part. I have come to see that it has been the primary force in producing that other strain in contemporary thought that leads to egalitarianism and real democracy and whatever measure of decency we are ever to achieve as a society. I can see no other competing candidate for having produced what of it that we have or, perhaps, had than that. That it comes from a people enormously self-conscious of themselves as escapees from slavery, saved from that by divine help is not shocking to anyone seeing the general character of Black Americans. As one outraged woman said in the wake of the George Floyd murder, "White people are lucky that we want equality, not revenge."
I think huge parts of the Old Testament are confessions of crimes and wrongs and shortcomings - especially short comings in the wake of them receiving The Law that they and their governments found difficult to keep - and I think that huge parts of that confessional history are done in some of the most impressive self-criticism I'm aware of in any large collection of writings or in any culture.
I trust the Jewish prophetic tradition far more than I trust modernism, an impressive number of modernism's major figures - people in the arts, in literature, in popular culture, in academic and legal and political life who we were all taught to respect - were supporters of fascism, Nazism and Marxim even as they were known to be piling up mountains of bodies in their scientific regimes. And the atheist haters of the Jewish tradition were some of those most enthusiastic in their support of those well-documented murders.
And I think that most of what maintains that among people who are not supposed to be vulgar materialists looking for personal gain is the kind of learned respectability that is expected of people to maintain their place in the better ranks of life, academia, the media, among those in daily life who have bought into that on an unthinking level and those who merely sense that they'd better go along with it if they want what's good for them. I think there is no one around who has a deeper feeling for that than Marilynne Robinson as can be read in the first paragraphs of that article which I linked to yesterday. If you haven't read it, you really are missing out on a spectacular experience. Notice her critique of criticism and its sacrosanct position that we have been suckered into granting it. I think a lot of that was due to fact checking in paper-based culture to be difficult when not impossible. I'm hoping a lot of that fades as paper gives way to computer and internet based scholarship where documents can be easily had and searched and used. Even the Bible which so few have actually read along with the commentaries on it. I've learned an enormous amount that modernism wasn't about to tell me, it has astonished me how much of what I was never told was known in, for example. the 4th century. Modernism is hardly an advance of the kind we were sold it as being.
One of the most interesting proofs of the hypocrisy of the secularists who love to hate on the Old Testament is that in almost every other case of them waxing in theatrical outrage over the ancient wrongs of the Children of Israel, ascribed to the commands of the God who has become a cartoon in the secular non-reading or, more typically, shallow skimming of those old and very knotty texts, will inevitably excuse similar and far greater records of wrong done by contemporary forces and governments. That Biblican Fundamentalism shares the same cartoon image of God and the modern conception of how to read a text for literal meaning betrays the fact that Fundamentalism is, as well, a product of modernism.
Some specimens of the various ideological framings:
- A Richard Dawkins type will minimize the horrors wrought by the theory of natural selection, something which the eminent biologist of a century ago, a convinced Darwinist, himself, Vernon Kellogg warned of as he heard his scientific colleagues in the German military give that for their already rather developed plans for conquest, dominance and disposal of those lesser than them. What he learned from his pacifist mission to talk to the Germans before the US entered World War One, turned him from a pacifist to someone who said that that was something which it was inevitable we would have to go to war against. And, I'll remind you, that hadn't turned into Nazism until after World War One had ended. It is the major intellectual force which Hitler's second in command said Nazism was merely an application of when he declared National Socialism was "applied science, nothing else." Dawkins and a number of his neo-atheist colleagues are rather warm to the notion of eugenics, something which will be a recurring danger as long as natural selection is the required framing in which to think about evolution.
- A secular capitalist or, in fact, one who professes religious belief - will totally overlook the horrific violence done by capitalists, those not designated as capitalist, those who are, those who claim to do so from "democratic" countries, discrediting a good which they never had any intention of ever allowing to exist. A Christopher Hitchens will go from being a Trotskyite to being a neo-con, supporting the Bush - Cheney crime family disaster of the invasion of Iraq, overthrowing a secular despot and plunging the region into a regime of violence and upheaval which will be killing and maiming people, providing opportunities for terrorists and other thugs to gain power and impose gangster governance that makes Saddam Hussein's crime regime look relatively benign, it wasn't but what has succeeded it has been far worse.
- Most ironic of all are those secular, anti-religious Zionists who will join in the general modernist mockery and slamming of the Old Testament for the claimed subduing of the inhabitants of the lands Israel was established on thousands of years ago even as they will do anything to protect the present Israeli government from criticism for reenacting those things confessed to in the ancient Scriptures.
I have little doubt that some of the accounts of the wiping out of peoples by the Children of Israel are told with the typical exaggeration of such ancient accounts, perhaps especially around the Mediterranean, just as I have no doubt that God didn't need to tell any kings or local potentates to war against their enemies, people are all too able to do that all on their own informed of nothing more remote from their attention as their own perceived self-interest. I have every confidence that the present day reporting of the crimes against the Palestinians of the secular Israeli government, its other crimes are more reliably taken as accurate. One of the few things I appreciate about modern culture are those rare instances where facts get checked and reported fairly, not that that isn't always easy to separate from propaganda. If you have to read the present day record carefully and, often, not thinking that things are as they say on the surface, reading the Scripture accounts of such things is even less reliably done as if they are reporting an unvarnished accurate record of the facts.
- And there is that other great category of the Marxists who have supported some of the bloodiest. most oppressive, most murderous and enslaving regimes in human history, knowing how their favorite Communist regime, their heroes, were oppressing and murdering, at times issuing manifestos and letters of support for show trials, executions even of their fellow Communists, their fellow writers or artists or academics, even their fellow scientists - the non-famous victims in their millions and tens of millions known but not much considered to count among the generally elite or at least college-credentialed Marxist champions of "the workers" "The Masses".
I was never a Communist but I was their dupe which is one of the reasons I have such unending contempt for them. It wasn't until I realized that to reject them and oppose them was not to accept their "other side" that I could really be free of that stupid habit cultivated as "anti-anti-communism". I could be anti-the antis for their own, particular evils. I should note the irony that some of those Commies pose as champions of the Palestinians, who I pity if they are so desperate that they might accept that bunch of bumbling hypocrites professed support of them.
Those are only a few of the major framings of modernism, each of them could certainly be listed with subheadings and you might find exceptions to most of them, though not all of them. Nazis, white supremacists never come in any variety except murderous, racist, homicidal evil.
It can be pointed out that the crimes of the Children of Israel, of Christians, of Muslims are generally opposed by major statements of morality contained in their Scriptures, you can't say the same thing about the foundations of modern secularism for the most part, especially the more developed parts of modernist thought. Modernism, as it develops, tends to go from the morally relative to the morally depraved to the homicidal. The luke-warm "socialism" of Fabianism was capacious enough to contain the proto-Nazi antisemtism and hatred of the disabled and congenitally ill of Karl Pearson to the early calls by another of its stars, George Bernard Shaw, even before the Nazis existed before Stalin or even Lenin came to power, to advocate constructing and using the gas chambers the Nazis did to dispatch many of the same categories of people they would going on in Shaw's lifetime to his open and flagrant adoration of Hitler and Stalin praising their murderous brutality in terms of economic efficency even as they were engaged in murdering people - still being produced as a daring and fashionable figure in the latest thing, a hero to many a bright young thing as he wrote exactly what I just said he said.
It is one of the more tellingly strange things about modernism that even someone like Shaw is to be taken as a normal, respectable figure within it, others who are even more obviously a friend of if not an actual collaborator with even the Hitler and Stalin regimes, or Mao's later can be quite respectable. That is true while someone who believes in, for example, the Resurrection of Jesus will be considered quite outré.
I respect the Jewish tradition of which Christianity and Islam are certainly a part. I have come to see that it has been the primary force in producing that other strain in contemporary thought that leads to egalitarianism and real democracy and whatever measure of decency we are ever to achieve as a society. I can see no other competing candidate for having produced what of it that we have or, perhaps, had than that. That it comes from a people enormously self-conscious of themselves as escapees from slavery, saved from that by divine help is not shocking to anyone seeing the general character of Black Americans. As one outraged woman said in the wake of the George Floyd murder, "White people are lucky that we want equality, not revenge."
I think huge parts of the Old Testament are confessions of crimes and wrongs and shortcomings - especially short comings in the wake of them receiving The Law that they and their governments found difficult to keep - and I think that huge parts of that confessional history are done in some of the most impressive self-criticism I'm aware of in any large collection of writings or in any culture.
I trust the Jewish prophetic tradition far more than I trust modernism, an impressive number of modernism's major figures - people in the arts, in literature, in popular culture, in academic and legal and political life who we were all taught to respect - were supporters of fascism, Nazism and Marxim even as they were known to be piling up mountains of bodies in their scientific regimes. And the atheist haters of the Jewish tradition were some of those most enthusiastic in their support of those well-documented murders.
And I think that most of what maintains that among people who are not supposed to be vulgar materialists looking for personal gain is the kind of learned respectability that is expected of people to maintain their place in the better ranks of life, academia, the media, among those in daily life who have bought into that on an unthinking level and those who merely sense that they'd better go along with it if they want what's good for them. I think there is no one around who has a deeper feeling for that than Marilynne Robinson as can be read in the first paragraphs of that article which I linked to yesterday. If you haven't read it, you really are missing out on a spectacular experience. Notice her critique of criticism and its sacrosanct position that we have been suckered into granting it. I think a lot of that was due to fact checking in paper-based culture to be difficult when not impossible. I'm hoping a lot of that fades as paper gives way to computer and internet based scholarship where documents can be easily had and searched and used. Even the Bible which so few have actually read along with the commentaries on it. I've learned an enormous amount that modernism wasn't about to tell me, it has astonished me how much of what I was never told was known in, for example. the 4th century. Modernism is hardly an advance of the kind we were sold it as being.
An Explanation
It is coming clear to me that I need to explain that for a while now I have had a medical condition that is going to eventually lead me to stop this, Unanticipated extraordinary events not withstanding. This year it has taken a turn for the worse and it could not have happened at a worse time, the time of pandemic criminal irresponsibility and other Republican-fascist crises. That is why there has been a lapse in the writing the past few weeks. It has, perhaps, also made me a little cranky. Though, perhaps, I was not entirely lacking crank before.
For politicians, judges, legislators, bureaucrats, especially those who work in the executive branch, there should be a felony of criminal irresponsibility that is more uniformly severe and precisian in its application to the people who want such power. There will have to be a special part of government created, a special court which is apart from the other one, with an absolute wall between them - no good buddies such as William Barr's good buddy Robert Mueller can be allowed in it - charged with its application because, given things like those right-wing judges trying, perhaps succeeding in giving Barr and Trump what they want in throwing Flynn's conviction out the window, I don't trust the American legal system at all. The fascists have succeeded in corrupting the courts and the Supreme Court, they can't be trusted to deliver even uneven justice - doing worse than that injustice will increasingly something which we will either deal with or be tyrannized through.
For politicians, judges, legislators, bureaucrats, especially those who work in the executive branch, there should be a felony of criminal irresponsibility that is more uniformly severe and precisian in its application to the people who want such power. There will have to be a special part of government created, a special court which is apart from the other one, with an absolute wall between them - no good buddies such as William Barr's good buddy Robert Mueller can be allowed in it - charged with its application because, given things like those right-wing judges trying, perhaps succeeding in giving Barr and Trump what they want in throwing Flynn's conviction out the window, I don't trust the American legal system at all. The fascists have succeeded in corrupting the courts and the Supreme Court, they can't be trusted to deliver even uneven justice - doing worse than that injustice will increasingly something which we will either deal with or be tyrannized through.
Thursday, June 25, 2020
The Motive Of Privilege And Snobbery In The Rejection Of The Jewish Tradition, Both As Judaism And Christianity
Continuing on with the three ways Hans Kung listed as to "how far love goes particularly in ordinary life" as taught by Jesus:
b. Love means service; humility, having the courage to serve,is the way to true greatness. This is the meaning of the parable of the wedding feast; abasement follows self-exaltation - the embarrassment of demotion - and exaltation follows self-abasement - the honor of promotion.
It is typical of Jesus to demand self-denying service, regardless of rank. It is significant that the same saying of Jesus on service is recorded in a variety of forms (at the dispute among the disciples, at the Last Supper, at the feet-washing): the highest should be the servant (waiter at table) of all. Hence, among Jesus' disciples, there can be no offices as established merely by law and power and corresponding to the office of those who hold power in the state; nor can tere be an office established simply on the basis of knowledge or worth, corresponding to the office of the scribes.
Jesus' requirement of service is not to be understood as a law forbidding any super- or subordination among his followers. It is however a decisive appeal for service even on the part of superiors toward subordinates, that is, for reciprocal services on the part of all.
It has been one of the most useful means of understanding of the modernist hostility to Christianity to consider that modernism is a product of an educated elite, either those born to wealth and, so, power or those who hoped to gain it through education and credentialing, that such people are generally not very open to sharing their resources and power, held by them as privileges of rank and legalized hoarding with those without wealth, talent or luck, even when those people need what is so hoarded to live a decent life or even a miserable one. I think that, certainly more than the spotty history of official, organized churches, political-legal establishments doing terrible things accounts for the hostility towards Christianity as the teachings of Jesus. There is some hostility that arises out of the animosity of some Jews in academia and the writing professions due to their traditional rejection of the messianic theory of the identity of Jesus. But in my experience believing, observant Jews are generally far less hostile to Christianity than those who have, as well, rejected the religion of Judaism. I think that rejection of the radical egalitarianism of the Mosaic law, of which the interpretation of it by Jesus is the most radical of all interpretations of it, among such secularized Jews is exactly the same manifestation as the rejection of Christianity by the secular descendants of professed Christians under modernism, due to similar rejections of the egalitarianism of both forms of Mosaic economic, social and personal justice. It is no accident that the Christianity so mocked and rejected accounts for, by far, the largest percentage of the human population who take the Jewish Law seriously. I think it is also no accident that the professed Christian rejection of Moses, documented so brilliantly and analyzed so well by Marilynne Robinson in her great essay The Fate of Ideas: Moses, is done under the corroding effects of modernist academic culture.
In fact, she wrote it so well that instead of continuing with this today, I am going to recommend you follow that link and read it, instead. I would, as well, recommend the wonderfully insightful treatment of Christianity and particularly Paul by the great Jewish scholar Susanna Heschel. I will continue with this tomorrow, if I am able.
b. Love means service; humility, having the courage to serve,is the way to true greatness. This is the meaning of the parable of the wedding feast; abasement follows self-exaltation - the embarrassment of demotion - and exaltation follows self-abasement - the honor of promotion.
It is typical of Jesus to demand self-denying service, regardless of rank. It is significant that the same saying of Jesus on service is recorded in a variety of forms (at the dispute among the disciples, at the Last Supper, at the feet-washing): the highest should be the servant (waiter at table) of all. Hence, among Jesus' disciples, there can be no offices as established merely by law and power and corresponding to the office of those who hold power in the state; nor can tere be an office established simply on the basis of knowledge or worth, corresponding to the office of the scribes.
Jesus' requirement of service is not to be understood as a law forbidding any super- or subordination among his followers. It is however a decisive appeal for service even on the part of superiors toward subordinates, that is, for reciprocal services on the part of all.
It has been one of the most useful means of understanding of the modernist hostility to Christianity to consider that modernism is a product of an educated elite, either those born to wealth and, so, power or those who hoped to gain it through education and credentialing, that such people are generally not very open to sharing their resources and power, held by them as privileges of rank and legalized hoarding with those without wealth, talent or luck, even when those people need what is so hoarded to live a decent life or even a miserable one. I think that, certainly more than the spotty history of official, organized churches, political-legal establishments doing terrible things accounts for the hostility towards Christianity as the teachings of Jesus. There is some hostility that arises out of the animosity of some Jews in academia and the writing professions due to their traditional rejection of the messianic theory of the identity of Jesus. But in my experience believing, observant Jews are generally far less hostile to Christianity than those who have, as well, rejected the religion of Judaism. I think that rejection of the radical egalitarianism of the Mosaic law, of which the interpretation of it by Jesus is the most radical of all interpretations of it, among such secularized Jews is exactly the same manifestation as the rejection of Christianity by the secular descendants of professed Christians under modernism, due to similar rejections of the egalitarianism of both forms of Mosaic economic, social and personal justice. It is no accident that the Christianity so mocked and rejected accounts for, by far, the largest percentage of the human population who take the Jewish Law seriously. I think it is also no accident that the professed Christian rejection of Moses, documented so brilliantly and analyzed so well by Marilynne Robinson in her great essay The Fate of Ideas: Moses, is done under the corroding effects of modernist academic culture.
In fact, she wrote it so well that instead of continuing with this today, I am going to recommend you follow that link and read it, instead. I would, as well, recommend the wonderfully insightful treatment of Christianity and particularly Paul by the great Jewish scholar Susanna Heschel. I will continue with this tomorrow, if I am able.
Trump Amps Up the Racism Because He’s Failed at Everything Else
I would have posted this for no other reason that Seth Meyer's rendition of Susan Collins is brilliant. So is the rest of it. I respect all of the late night hosts trying to do their show from home but I think he's done it the best.
FOX is the most destructive force in America, today and they're pulling out all of the lies to try to save Republican-fascists. It is sociopathy as an intentional means to steal and keep power for the worst person to have ever been put into the presidency by illegitimate means, in this case the Electoral College instead of the Supreme Court Republicans doing it in 2000.
Wednesday, June 24, 2020
John Bolton Is Still A Republican-Fascist Liar
He is lying on behalf of the Congressional Republicans, Stephen Colbert clearly knows that he was lying his ass off but he wasn't going to risk the interview to go as far honesty requires.
I hope John Bolton ends up making no money out of this book because he is a lying, partisan scumbag.
You're Trying To Sell Me The Same Old Play-Lefty Whine In A Newer Bottle
I have had to point this out before, either you believe in egalitarian democracy or you favor some form of gangster government, mildly bad to the worst humans are capable of forming, those are the two alternatives. Any "democratic" scheme which is non or anti-egalitarian is merely a somewhat tempered form of gangsterism, the original Athenian "democracy" was, in fact, an oligarchic gangster government under which women and slaves and foreigners were excluded and treated as the chattels of the ruling class of male Athenian citizens, the only ones who got to vote and decide things. That is what the original Constitution of the United States tried to impose here, the extent to which the wealthy, aristocratic Founders dared under those circumstances I noted here the other day. Too many poor white men had been gulled into fighting their revolution with promises of equality - many of them trained as soldiers - for the aristocrats to try to totally stiff them. That is an insight that it took me many years to see past, getting past the framing of such issues around ideologies that pretend that their preferences are not anything from mildly bad to the worst humans can do. That the farming of the ideologies makes understanding how they harm egalitarian democracy a little or completely essential to understanding what we face, though as we have all been gulled into looking at things through them, it is hard to break out of the "which side are you on" stupidity.
Marxism, sold to the materialist-scientistic 19th-21st century mindset as the best turned out to be among the worst in human history, not that those tens of millions of murder victims and the hundreds of millions, billions oppressed, terrorized, enslaved and maintained poorly as a resource by the gangster class have much bothered western academics and writers and journalists and movie makers who chose, so notably, NOT to live under it.
And, well, that's Marxism. The other extremes run from Nazism, the announced murderers whose explicit intent was their choice to replace their selection for what of "natural selection" they assert civilization inhibits Their nightmare scenario of people and institutions, religious organizations and - worst of all in their thinking - governments keep the "unfit" alive.
It's worth pointing out that the Nazis embodying all that is morally depraved is based directly and logically in their conception of natural selection. That imagined inhibition of "natural selection" consists of pretty much every truly moral act, doing to others as they would have done unto them, feeding the poor, clothing the naked, treating the imprisoned with decency and - worst of the worst- caring for and treating the sick and disabled. Not to mention killing those they designated as "the stranger" among them.
Trumpian Repubican-fascism is merely somewhat diluted form of that, diluted for at least as long as they figure they can't get away with going farther. Most in the news these days is a pretty shocking example of how far they are willing to take it, his and Republicans's determination to not only not treat the sick and disabled, it is to actively PROMOTE the spread of pandemic illness, choosing to treat it by not diagnosing and counting the numbers of them as they become sick and die. Those in nursing homes and other such institutions and in prisons among the worst hit, Black, Native American and other "strangers" among the affluent white among those left to die in far higher percentages. This pandemic could be suspected to be a divinely provided preview of how the worst could happen here under an elected fascist as it did in Central Europe within the just barely living memory of some dying of Trump's pandemic.
Scientism, the framing which produced both Marxism and Nazism, will inevitably harm egalitarian democracy, though that's more an accident of culture - the manditory adoption of Darwinism to be respectable - than it is a direct consequence of science. The extent to which "science" upholds the myth of natural selection, to that extent it is a danger to egalitarian democracy. As Ernst Haeckel said in a book translated by one of his earliest followers, prefaced by his "bull dog" Thomas Huxley and which Charles Darwin, himself, endorsed completely, Darwin's foremost champion in Germany, Ernst Haeckel made the obviously true conclusion you have to draw if you believe in natural selection:
Darwinism, I say, is anything rather than socialist! If this English hypothesis is to be compared to any definite political tendency—as is, no doubt, possible—that tendency can only be aristocratic, certainly not democratic, and least of all socialist. The theory of selection teaches that in human life, as in animal and plant life everywhere, and at all times, only a small and chosen minority can exist and flourish, while the enormous majority starve and perish miserably and more or less prematurely. The germs of every species of animal and plant and the young individuals which spring from them are innumerable, while the number of those fortunate individuals which develop to maturity and actually reach their hardly-won life's goal is out of all proportion trifling. The cruel and merciless struggle for existence which rages throughout all living nature, and in the course of nature must rage, this unceasing and inexorable competition of all living creatures, is an incontestable fact; only the picked minority of the qualified "fittest" is in a position to resist it successfully, while the great majority of the competitors must necessarily perish miserably. We may profoundly lament this tragical state of things, but we can neither controvert it nor alter it. "Many are called but few are chosen." The selection, the picking out of these "chosen ones," is inevitably connected with the arrest and destruction of the remaining majority. Another English naturalist, therefore, designates the kernel of Darwinism very frankly as the "survival of the fittest," as the "victory of the best." At any rate, this principle of selection is nothing less than democratic, on the contrary, it is aristocratic in the strictest sense of the word. If, therefore, Darwinism, logically carried out, has, according to Virchow, "an uncommonly suspicious aspect," this can only be found in the idea that it offers a helping hand to the efforts of the aristocrats.
The extent to which scientism adopts the ideology of materialism, and it pretty much all does, that, itself poses as basic a danger to egalitarian democracy as natural selection does because materialism inevitably must insist that freedom of thought and freedom of conscience are illusory, that material causation governs what we experience of our minds, that any equality of people is as illusory and, inevitably, some form of economic valuation will unequally sort the human population on pretty much the same lines as that quintessential proponent of scientistic materialism, Haeckel, asserted in that anti-democratic passage which Darwin endorsed completely. Anyone who believes in natural selection holds any notions of democracy as an internal contradiction as much as any Biblical fundamentalist holds notions compatible with it in contradiction, as well. I've noted that many of the greatest political exponents of Darwinism in practice are, for the record, haters of the idea of evolution which he has been made the figure-head of.
That you can believe in evolution while rejecting natural selection, that's always been quite possible, should be mentioned, since in the muddled thinking of, especially, the college credentialed, seeing that they are not the same is an unimaginable truth. But that's a longer issue.
That's just the background for your complaint that I'm being unfair to those trolling atheists the other night who insisted on inserting their, not only entirely irrelevant anti-Christian, anti-religion shtick into a discussion of how to defeat Republican-fascism, but visably turning off others discussing how to defeat fascism with their self-indulgence in their own personal hatred. And on top of that the total cluelessness as to how their insisted on ballot-box poison issue - most people in the United States rejecting atheism and, in fact, most of them if not actual Christians, not hostile to it - helps the fascists at the ballot box THE REASON THAT THE ANTICHRIST, HIMSELF, TRUMP AND THE WHORE OF THE DOJ, BARR ARE TRYING TO CLAIM THE ISSUE FOR THEMSELVES.
I have looked very hard at the role that atheists have played in American politics and it's clear that they have been one of the most damaging forces on the American left. Whether in the form of Marxists or the non-Marxist materialists and those whose faith isn't science but scientism - they generally choosing not to learn enough math to do any science - have consistently, especially in the post-war period, been the most useful means of the fascists to discredit Democrats and that's when the Marxists, Greens, etc. haven't been joining with the Republican-fascists to defeat Democrats, at times taking Republican-fascist money to do it. And when it wasn't Republican money they were taking, it was sometimes directly from the gangsters in the Kremlin or other such foreign funders. That Putin is encouraging them in the last election and this one is no shock to anyone who has looked at the actual history of the losing lefties of secular materialism.
And, as can be seen from the last week or more of posts here, the actual morality as taught by Jesus and his earliest followers as recorded in the Gospels and the Letters is not only consistent with egalitarian democracy, it is the most radical expression of what it consists of and aspires to ever recorded. To attack Christianity instead of pointing out to those who profess Christianity what the actual teachings of Jesus are and what those mean is to do the gangsters work for them. No, atheists are not only no help to those who want a decent life for all under democracy, they are one of the most damaging faction to it around. They don't belong on any real left, they belong to and of the play-left that will never govern the United States, though they have been mighty helpful to the fascists.
Marxism, sold to the materialist-scientistic 19th-21st century mindset as the best turned out to be among the worst in human history, not that those tens of millions of murder victims and the hundreds of millions, billions oppressed, terrorized, enslaved and maintained poorly as a resource by the gangster class have much bothered western academics and writers and journalists and movie makers who chose, so notably, NOT to live under it.
And, well, that's Marxism. The other extremes run from Nazism, the announced murderers whose explicit intent was their choice to replace their selection for what of "natural selection" they assert civilization inhibits Their nightmare scenario of people and institutions, religious organizations and - worst of all in their thinking - governments keep the "unfit" alive.
It's worth pointing out that the Nazis embodying all that is morally depraved is based directly and logically in their conception of natural selection. That imagined inhibition of "natural selection" consists of pretty much every truly moral act, doing to others as they would have done unto them, feeding the poor, clothing the naked, treating the imprisoned with decency and - worst of the worst- caring for and treating the sick and disabled. Not to mention killing those they designated as "the stranger" among them.
Trumpian Repubican-fascism is merely somewhat diluted form of that, diluted for at least as long as they figure they can't get away with going farther. Most in the news these days is a pretty shocking example of how far they are willing to take it, his and Republicans's determination to not only not treat the sick and disabled, it is to actively PROMOTE the spread of pandemic illness, choosing to treat it by not diagnosing and counting the numbers of them as they become sick and die. Those in nursing homes and other such institutions and in prisons among the worst hit, Black, Native American and other "strangers" among the affluent white among those left to die in far higher percentages. This pandemic could be suspected to be a divinely provided preview of how the worst could happen here under an elected fascist as it did in Central Europe within the just barely living memory of some dying of Trump's pandemic.
Scientism, the framing which produced both Marxism and Nazism, will inevitably harm egalitarian democracy, though that's more an accident of culture - the manditory adoption of Darwinism to be respectable - than it is a direct consequence of science. The extent to which "science" upholds the myth of natural selection, to that extent it is a danger to egalitarian democracy. As Ernst Haeckel said in a book translated by one of his earliest followers, prefaced by his "bull dog" Thomas Huxley and which Charles Darwin, himself, endorsed completely, Darwin's foremost champion in Germany, Ernst Haeckel made the obviously true conclusion you have to draw if you believe in natural selection:
Darwinism, I say, is anything rather than socialist! If this English hypothesis is to be compared to any definite political tendency—as is, no doubt, possible—that tendency can only be aristocratic, certainly not democratic, and least of all socialist. The theory of selection teaches that in human life, as in animal and plant life everywhere, and at all times, only a small and chosen minority can exist and flourish, while the enormous majority starve and perish miserably and more or less prematurely. The germs of every species of animal and plant and the young individuals which spring from them are innumerable, while the number of those fortunate individuals which develop to maturity and actually reach their hardly-won life's goal is out of all proportion trifling. The cruel and merciless struggle for existence which rages throughout all living nature, and in the course of nature must rage, this unceasing and inexorable competition of all living creatures, is an incontestable fact; only the picked minority of the qualified "fittest" is in a position to resist it successfully, while the great majority of the competitors must necessarily perish miserably. We may profoundly lament this tragical state of things, but we can neither controvert it nor alter it. "Many are called but few are chosen." The selection, the picking out of these "chosen ones," is inevitably connected with the arrest and destruction of the remaining majority. Another English naturalist, therefore, designates the kernel of Darwinism very frankly as the "survival of the fittest," as the "victory of the best." At any rate, this principle of selection is nothing less than democratic, on the contrary, it is aristocratic in the strictest sense of the word. If, therefore, Darwinism, logically carried out, has, according to Virchow, "an uncommonly suspicious aspect," this can only be found in the idea that it offers a helping hand to the efforts of the aristocrats.
The extent to which scientism adopts the ideology of materialism, and it pretty much all does, that, itself poses as basic a danger to egalitarian democracy as natural selection does because materialism inevitably must insist that freedom of thought and freedom of conscience are illusory, that material causation governs what we experience of our minds, that any equality of people is as illusory and, inevitably, some form of economic valuation will unequally sort the human population on pretty much the same lines as that quintessential proponent of scientistic materialism, Haeckel, asserted in that anti-democratic passage which Darwin endorsed completely. Anyone who believes in natural selection holds any notions of democracy as an internal contradiction as much as any Biblical fundamentalist holds notions compatible with it in contradiction, as well. I've noted that many of the greatest political exponents of Darwinism in practice are, for the record, haters of the idea of evolution which he has been made the figure-head of.
That you can believe in evolution while rejecting natural selection, that's always been quite possible, should be mentioned, since in the muddled thinking of, especially, the college credentialed, seeing that they are not the same is an unimaginable truth. But that's a longer issue.
That's just the background for your complaint that I'm being unfair to those trolling atheists the other night who insisted on inserting their, not only entirely irrelevant anti-Christian, anti-religion shtick into a discussion of how to defeat Republican-fascism, but visably turning off others discussing how to defeat fascism with their self-indulgence in their own personal hatred. And on top of that the total cluelessness as to how their insisted on ballot-box poison issue - most people in the United States rejecting atheism and, in fact, most of them if not actual Christians, not hostile to it - helps the fascists at the ballot box THE REASON THAT THE ANTICHRIST, HIMSELF, TRUMP AND THE WHORE OF THE DOJ, BARR ARE TRYING TO CLAIM THE ISSUE FOR THEMSELVES.
I have looked very hard at the role that atheists have played in American politics and it's clear that they have been one of the most damaging forces on the American left. Whether in the form of Marxists or the non-Marxist materialists and those whose faith isn't science but scientism - they generally choosing not to learn enough math to do any science - have consistently, especially in the post-war period, been the most useful means of the fascists to discredit Democrats and that's when the Marxists, Greens, etc. haven't been joining with the Republican-fascists to defeat Democrats, at times taking Republican-fascist money to do it. And when it wasn't Republican money they were taking, it was sometimes directly from the gangsters in the Kremlin or other such foreign funders. That Putin is encouraging them in the last election and this one is no shock to anyone who has looked at the actual history of the losing lefties of secular materialism.
And, as can be seen from the last week or more of posts here, the actual morality as taught by Jesus and his earliest followers as recorded in the Gospels and the Letters is not only consistent with egalitarian democracy, it is the most radical expression of what it consists of and aspires to ever recorded. To attack Christianity instead of pointing out to those who profess Christianity what the actual teachings of Jesus are and what those mean is to do the gangsters work for them. No, atheists are not only no help to those who want a decent life for all under democracy, they are one of the most damaging faction to it around. They don't belong on any real left, they belong to and of the play-left that will never govern the United States, though they have been mighty helpful to the fascists.
Tuesday, June 23, 2020
No President Should Be Able To Pardon Those Who Commit Crimes On Their Behalf
It must be noted that forgiveness of personal wrongs is not the same thing as allowing a criminal chief executive to pardon those who commit crimes to put and keep him in power. Considering the character of the Founders when it came to things like punishing slaves and meting out rough justice to petty criminals, it is amazing that their framing of the pardoning power of the president is so glaringly stupid as to allow him to pardon people in his own administration and campaign - as clear an invitation to despotism as was ever enjoyed by a monarch of the type they wanted to be rid of. Scripture has God warning of the consequences of having kings as soon as the Children of Israel start hankering after one, that list of evils as recounted to Samuel is the story of such power, even when they are quasi-elected presidents. And about that "quasi", the Electoral College must be on the list of things to abolish.
There are a number of serious Constitutional amendments that should be adopted as fast as possible in the wake of the Trump-McConnell attempt to destroy egalitarian democracy, the rule of law instead of thugs, one of the most serious is to reign in the power of presidential pardon so they can never again pardon members of their own administration as George H.W. Bush did - with the drafting of William Barr, to protect himself from being charged with crimes he certainly committed, as has been used by subsequent presidents to shield law-breakers working on their orders or in their interests as Trump is doing, no doubt Barr expecting a pardon to shield him from his florid criminality as well as the others, Pence, Mnuchin, Voss, you can go down the list, I would bet that you as well as I could come up with at least a dozen off the top of our heads.
Presidents should be barred from ever pardoning members of their own administration, their appointees, members of their campaigns from having to face prosecution and conviction for their crimes. Those who accept pardons should face a life-time bar on ever being part of not only an administration or an employee of the government or in congress or the courts, their acceptance of a pardon should be considered the equivalent of an admission of guilt to the crimes they have been pardoned for, those known at the time, those that come to light later. They and their estates should never be shielded from recovery of funds gotten through their criminality while working as part of government.
The things that the Founders depended on the honors system for are clearly not working to an unacceptable level, now. The Federalist Society and other criminal encouraging anti-democratic syndicates have brought up a large number of legal types whose main work in life is to tell mobsters and gangsters with political power how to rig things so they can commit crimes and get away with them.
There are a number of serious Constitutional amendments that should be adopted as fast as possible in the wake of the Trump-McConnell attempt to destroy egalitarian democracy, the rule of law instead of thugs, one of the most serious is to reign in the power of presidential pardon so they can never again pardon members of their own administration as George H.W. Bush did - with the drafting of William Barr, to protect himself from being charged with crimes he certainly committed, as has been used by subsequent presidents to shield law-breakers working on their orders or in their interests as Trump is doing, no doubt Barr expecting a pardon to shield him from his florid criminality as well as the others, Pence, Mnuchin, Voss, you can go down the list, I would bet that you as well as I could come up with at least a dozen off the top of our heads.
Presidents should be barred from ever pardoning members of their own administration, their appointees, members of their campaigns from having to face prosecution and conviction for their crimes. Those who accept pardons should face a life-time bar on ever being part of not only an administration or an employee of the government or in congress or the courts, their acceptance of a pardon should be considered the equivalent of an admission of guilt to the crimes they have been pardoned for, those known at the time, those that come to light later. They and their estates should never be shielded from recovery of funds gotten through their criminality while working as part of government.
The things that the Founders depended on the honors system for are clearly not working to an unacceptable level, now. The Federalist Society and other criminal encouraging anti-democratic syndicates have brought up a large number of legal types whose main work in life is to tell mobsters and gangsters with political power how to rig things so they can commit crimes and get away with them.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)