Saturday, March 9, 2024

No, It Takes Bad Science Accepted As Science To Really Do Evil - Hate Mail In Which I'm Called A Science Hater

ONE OF THE THINGS that I've regretted in the blow-back of a recent post is that the eminent physicist and anti-religious atheist polemicist Steven Weinberg didn't have a blog with a comment thread during the new-atheist fad, the way that the somewhat less eminent physicist and more polemical atheist Sean Carroll did.  I know long term readers might remember that I've bragged several times about forcing Sean Carroll to make a rather embarrassing if not self-impeaching admission in the course of an argument that ranged across at least a couple of somewhat atheist-scientistic blogs.  As I recall it originated from his and Stephen Hawking's declaration that physics was on the verge of a theory of everything, the elusive TOE, and so had disposed of any need for there to be a God. Which only shows that even the most famous physicist of his generation could remain at a first semester freshman level of philosophical competence, one which I know Weinberg sometimes surpasses.  

In the course of a comment thread fight I asked Carroll if there was even one, single object in the universe which physics had described comprehensively and completely.  He dodged the question on the first blog we started out on for going on three weeks but posted his claim on his own blog which I don't think I'd ever commented on before.  I pinned him down there by repeatedly asking the same question in front of his blog community.  But it wasn't until I promised never to post on his blog again if he'd answer the question if physics had a complete and comprehensive knowledge of even one object in the universe.  As I recall I specified an electron, to which he finally admitted that physics, which he and Hawking and others claimed would soon have a complete theory of the universe, didn't have such a theory of everything about even one single object in the universe.  

As a matter of credibility of his claim regarding the imminence of a TOE, physics having no theory of everything about even one object in the universe completely blows the idea that they will have a theory of everything about every object in the universe - not to mention things that aren't objects - out of any plausibility.

If I'd commented farther, I'd have asked him since physics didn't possess a complete description of even one object, how could physics know that there were not an entirely new set of issues that they hadn't known about before, which would have been another refutation of his claim that a TOE was imminently had. That problem, that there may well be, as Eddington said, "laws" of nature that surpass human comprehension, pretty well does in the claims of a "theory of everything" ever being reliably had.

I'd like to be able to ask Weinberg a similar question about his quip that "If you've seen one electron, you've seen them all."  My first question would be, "Have you seen even one electron?"  I mean that quite literally because everything that's known about electrons is inference on those limited aspects of them that physics and chemistry has managed to theorize about and demonstrate. While I don't doubt the existence of electrons or question many of the things physicists assert about them, I doubt that physics has that intimate a knowledge of them so as to make such a claim.  I'd say you have to at least have an actual confirming observation, including a number of indirect observations in different contexts, of something before you can claim to "know" something, to demonstrate it through observation of the universe or observe in a repeatable experiment.

And since science is supposed to reveal the state of the natural universe, I would like to question someone of his expertise on a good part of that experimental evidence which seems to me to be based on some extremely artificial conditions, such as smashing atoms into each other at extremely high energies and velocities to blow them apart, some of which I wonder if there is really a natural analogue of in the known universe.  I'd wonder what the difference between electrons in their typical, natural conditions and those which are put under such atypical conditions might be and how much of the information you got from that state of things can tell you about more typical conditions under which atoms and subatomic particles exist.  I've never heard anyone ask that question before, though it wouldn't surprise me if it had occurred to someone else before I wondered about it.

I would guess that if he were pressed, he'd have to admit that what we know of electrons can't really discern if they are different in ways that might be significant if we could discern them more deeply in nature than we can now.  That is if we could master the equations and concepts which comprise the "knowledge" we might then have of them.  We don't know if they may fall into distinctly different types or kinds or perhaps exhibit some level of individuality.  The image he projected in his quip may be about as complete as the crude classifications of human beings that some of the worst of biology and the so-called social sciences have made of us, ignoring our individuality and differences. Or how 19th century biologists conceived of those cells they could barely make out under their microscopes.   

I do think that Weinberg's quip may have had in it what I doubt Carroll's claim did, an element of humility about the subject matter of Weinberg's specialty, in which the objects that are studied are taken as quite simple and undifferentiated whereas other sciences attempt to study vastly more complex entities such as, you know, the universe.  

Or organisms, everything from single-celled to the largest and most complex of multicellular organisms of many different body-types between and within species,  complex behaviors and changes over long lives and in relation to other very complex and (merely relatively) simple life forms and such things that may not really be alive, such as viruses. And how, at least in humans, learning and choices can make an enormous difference in how they are different and how they are the same.   

And, also, much of what biology studies is so complex that large parts of organisms and, certainly, as those function biologically and, even more so, in their environments, that even the most known aspects of them are a tiny fraction of what they are as living beings.  Science cannot comprehend even the entire life of one single cell either within a larger creature or as a single-cell organism.  Adding speculations about the parts of organisms which are truly and will almost certainly forever exist outside of what is observable such as consciousness, personal experience, change due to experiences and choices and preferences, the effects of unknown aspects of those on future biological functioning, if and how those are determined by past experience, etc. cannot and, I will say, will never really be susceptible to scientific methods of study and discovery, I don't think that there is much reason to think that most of life can ever be the honest subject of science.  Any claims of complete theories of biology or psychology or sociology or, in rapidly declining orders of reliability, anthropology and ethology, are pure and complete sci-superstition.   

Science, especially when it has been extended past where it honestly can presently been done,  has absolutely generated superstitions which, having the confident faith in "science" that some few areas of science have generated about some limited number of natural phenomena, are extremely potent and dangerous.

I think we never really appreciate how dangerous it is to use a word to mean quite different things, such as reliably and rigorously done science and those fields which are more given the title of science with all the substantial content of some idiot who is given an "honorary degree."  

Even most scientists who know better won't consistently and insistently distinguish between hard science (such as hard sciences are) and areas that are called "science" as a professional courtesy when there's little science to them.  That any of the "social sciences" are considered science has to count as one of the greatest of all scandals in science. But even many areas within conventional biology fall outside of that, even some of the most revered and orthodox of holdings of science.

Recently, I mentioned the anti-vaxx superstition that was set off by a disastrously bad and fraudulent paper that was published in The Lancet, one which got at least hundreds of thousands killed in the United States, Sweden and other places in the context of Covid.  

I also noted that in both of those supposedly sophisticated countries, there was a distinct aspect of Darwinism, the theory of natural selection, in the death count, as well.  Trump's regime was advised by those credentialed in the dismal science of economics, specifically those who explicitly claimed to be practicing "Darwinian economics."  And considering what Charles and Leonard Darwin said about the imaginary dysgenic effects of vaccinations, opposing universal vaccination, they weren't unjustified in naming their scientific superstition, that.*  And that was hardly the only deadly superstition set off by the theory of natural selection. I have repeatedly demonstrated here, using the primary documentation from Charles Darwin, Francis Galton, Ernst Haeckel, (look it up in my blog, if I linked the whole thing would be red) and many others including one of the vilest of the Nazis, Reinhardt Heydrich, giving a natural selection argument for killing all Jews at the Wannsee Conference where the industrial genocide of the Jews was planned.  The theory of natural selection has repeatedly motivated attempts to cut entire populations of human beings out of the human future.  

Steven Weinberg is also famous for his claim that "for good people to do evil, that takes religion," probably a claim made out of the typical post-war college credentialed population's ignorance of the primary documentation, given that the Nazis, both by practice and by claim, were not motivated by religion but by what they understood of science.  That's not deniable in any honest way when you read the primary documentation.  Many of them were not only highly credentialed and hired as faculty in the sciences by some of the world's greatest universities, they were knowingly and intentionally engaged in the genocides of the political and military Nazi regime, supplying them with scientific justification for their mass murders, some of that having been also supplied with scientific arguments by scientists outside of Germany such as Karl Pearson and Margaret Moul. A number of them, even some of the worst, not only kept their university positions after the fall of Nazism, but at least one was given a Nobel prize in science, Konrad Lorenz.  

And it's unquestionable that Hitlers rivals in mass murder, the Stalin and Mao regimes, the lesser but still formidable genocidal regimes of Marxism such as in Cambodia were motivated by a totally different stream of would-be scientific assertion from the social sciences.  In the 20th century, any regime that sought to replace religion with science could be counted on to murder millions and millions of people.  His fellow scientists who were active as weaponeers, giving the world the means of killing all of us in a day, were frequently atheists and materialists. Time may yet prove that science has been the deadliest thing that human culture has ever given rise to.  The old argument, such as was used to defend the gas weaponeer Fritz Haber, that his development of nitrogen fertilizer saved more people than his gas weapons killed may not hold for nuclear physics.  In the immediate aftermath of WWI, the war which made him a war criminal, he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Chemistry.  Science demonstrating that his war crimes were nothing scientists felt a need to consider.

If Weinberg spent less time on his anti-religious polemics and more time looking at the primary documentation of the Nazi and other genocides, he might have realized that.  And I'd admit that Weinberg is generally a few steps up when it comes to knowing something about things outside of his narrow specialty than many of his younger colleagues and contemporaries, he has some actual philosophical erudition.  As I quoted Sabine Hossenfelder recently, he has some knowledge of the limits of science which some others don't have.  

------------------

The conception of cells and single cell organisms and, especially DNA has changed drastically since the last advanced biology classes I took in college. I did well enough in those that one of my teachers encouraged me to consider changing majors, though I'd certainly have had to change a lot of what I believed when I took their classes if I'd taken that road.  Much of that was everything from overly simplistic to definitely wrong.  Some of what was known even then, through the work of the latterly famous Barbara McClintok and others, was actually suppressed because it didn't go along with the orthodoxy that reigned and, to a good extent, still does in much of biology.  The science described by James Shapiro in that lecture I posted the other day shows that the complexity of what happens on a molecular level in "simple organisms" and in the cells of multi-cellular organisms is enormously more complex than was imagined by anyone in the 19th or early 20th century, even by the majority of biologists into my adulthood.  

The complexity of just that very famous molecule and surrogate-god of atheism, DNA, and its manipulation by extremely complex and remarkably effective cellular action, on a level that human science would be hard pressed to imitate with the most sophisticated of conscious, rational thought and imagination and technique, has to make traditional materialist-atheists of a scientistic bent extremely uncomfortable when that's discussed.  James Shapiro has tangled with one of the more infamous of those, his University of Chicago colleague, Jerry Coyne who, I'm sure, bristles when Shapiro and others attribute consciousness (quoting McClintock, as I recall) to single-cell organisms or "cognition" to cells and their molecular and physical components.  As the physicist Arthur Eddington might have said, far from it being "turtles all the way down," it's consciousness all the way down.  

Though perhaps not all the way down.  I don't think it's possible or even reliable to attribute consciousness down to a lower order of physical organization, to inorganic molecules or atoms or subatomic particles, I'm deeply skeptical of the latest safety pod of materialism, "panpsychism" because if cellular consciousness might be apparent to us based on its level of sophisticated cognitive functioning, I don't think we can automatically or even reliably identify it outside of biological action. If atoms and subatomic particles have "consciousness" I doubt it would be anything like what the word means to us as the central aspect of our experience and being.  It was just a few years ago that there was a considerable furore in biology when a group of dissident scientists issued a declaration that animals, other than human beings were conscious, many of the hard core materialists among them apparently detesting the idea as much as Thomist theology detests the idea that animals have souls.**  Some of the really hard cases reject the idea that human beings, including, at least in their formal professional make-believe, themselves and their families.

I don't think the old simplistic nonsense of abiogenesis(to talk about pseudo-sciences) can be believable if you think even not that hard about it.  That anything like even the "simplest" of known organisms could come about by sheer chance, random chance (an even more widely propitiated god of atheists), or from knowably non-teleological material causes on the early-Earth.  If there was an extraordinarily simple "first organism" that gave rise to all subsequent life on Earth as a purely random-chance assemblage of molecules, it was no kind of life form that has ever been observed by science.  The idea that it was some imaginary naturally assembled RNA or DNA or even a few random amino acids that just came together would seem to be of such  incredibly remote probability so as to make that idea less believable than the idea that it happened by intelligent design.  Now that cognitive behavior is seen as necessary for even the most rudimentary of cellular functions, given the seeming improbability of any abiogenetic scheme of things which have been peddled as science, the idea that God created life at least has a definite origin for the input of cognitive possibility into it.  It's not science and it never could be but, then, neither is any materialistic-atheist scheme dreamed up by Oparin or Urey or Miller or anyone else.  It couldn't be science because they have no means of observing that original organism (which, I, by the way, believe in while admitting that's not a scientific idea, it's one of conjecture and imagination).   I reject the idea that you can do science in the absence of observation and testing and measurement and honest, NON-IDEOLOGICAL analysis.  I respect science for what it can honestly do, I reject it when it is not based on observation, measurement, etc.  I especially reject it when it is based on the only ideologies that have successfully been injected into science, economic interests and atheist materialist ideology being the most successful of those pollutions.  

*

There is reason to believe that vaccination has preserved thousands, who from a weak constitution would formerly have succumbed to small-pox. Thus the weak members of civilised societies propagate their kind. No one who has attended to the breeding of domestic animals will doubt that this must be highly injurious to the race of man. It is surprising how soon a want of care, or care wrongly directed, leads to the degeneration of a domestic race; but excepting in the case of man himself, hardly any one is so ignorant as to allow his worst animals to breed.  

Charles Darwin, The Descent of Man

When Leonard Darwin, his son, ran for a seat in Parliament, he ran against universal vaccination, luckily, unlike in so many districts in the U.S. now, he lost.

There is also the fact that Charles Darwin, himself, admitted that the theory of natural selection was inspired by his reading of the pseudo-scientific economic theories of Thomas Malthus.  The theory that was generated in the pseudo-science of economics is a constant and continuous valuation of living beings on a scale of economic utility and value.  His use of the economic activity of animal husbandry, with its inherent practice of early killing those which are not chosen for breeding stock, and plant selection and hybridization as the entirely artificial and entirely intentional analogy and inaptly chosen demonstration of "natural" selection only ties those ties to economics tighter and unites them with the immediate product of the belief in natural selection, eugenics.

** As I understand it, Thomas Aquinas reasoned that since humans in the afterlife didn't need to eat, that animals were obviously superfluous in the afterlife, so they had no souls.  From there the idea became common in Western thought.   Considering how often Aquinas was called an ox, you'd have thought he'd have more of a feeling for animals.  I can't imagine anyone who has had a close relationship with an animal could really miss that they have a soul, though apparently most do.  While I doubt that there would have been much less brutality and murder of animals even if he'd concluded that they did have souls, it was an idea that certainly didn't make those who believed it less callous in their treatment of animals.  But, then, when Aquinas experienced a mystical experience late in his life, he told other monks that his enormous theological-philosophical work was mere straw.  As I understand it, he stopped writing at that point.

Friday, March 8, 2024

Oh For Frigs Sake, I Don't Want To Go Over Simp's Old, Tired, Reused Shtick Again

For anyone who wants to see what I had to say about the over-sold "genius" of Ernie Kovacs can go to one of my less used alternative blogs.

Tuesday, March 5, 2024

Strip The Goddamned Supreme Court Of Its UnConstitutional Powers To Destroy Democracy

 A majority held in restraint by constitutional checks and limitations, and always changing easily with deliberate changes of popular opinions and sentiments, is the only true sovereign of a free people. Whoever rejects it does, of necessity, fly to anarchy or to despotism. 

Unanimity is impossible; the rule of a minority, as a permanent arrangement, is wholly inadmissible; so that, rejecting the majority principle, anarchy or despotism in some form is all that is left. 

I do not forget the position, assumed by some, that constitutional questions are to be decided by the Supreme Court; nor do I deny that such decisions must be binding, in any case, upon the parties to a suit, as to the object of that suit, while they are also entitled to very high respect and consideration in all parallel cases by all other departments of the government. 

And while it is obviously possible that such decision may be erroneous in any given case, still the evil effect following it, being limited to that particular case, with the chance that it may be overruled and never become a precedent for other cases, can better be borne than could the evils of a different practice. 

At the same time, the candid citizen must confess that if the policy of the government, upon vital questions affecting the whole people, is to be irrevocably fixed by decisions of the Supreme Court, the instant they are made, in ordinary litigation between parties in personal actions, the people will have ceased to be their own rulers, having to that extent practically resigned their government into the hands of that eminent tribunal.

Abraham Lincoln:  First Inaugural Address 

It's time to strip the Supreme Court of its usurped powers of nullification.  They're not only doing it to duly adopted laws now, they're doing it to parts of the Constitution, itself. 

Saturday, March 2, 2024

Saturday Night Radio Drama - Garret Baker - The Shepherd

The Shepherd 

 

Jim and Louise, a happily married young couple have just moved into a new house with their baby girl, Beth. However, when they receive an unexpected visit from the loquacious Darragh, things start to unravel.

With themes of an adult nature and language some might find offensive, 

Stephen Rea played Darragh
Katie Davis was Louise
Jim was played by Rory Keenan
Music was by Mark Hendrick
Sound supervision was by Philip Cooke
The Shepherd by Garret Baker was directed by Seán Rocks.

Series Producer of Drama On One is Kevin Reynolds

Your god Fails To Perform - Hate Mail

YOUR SNARK CAN BE answered very simply by citing something that the eminent expert in cellular biology, James Shaprio said in a recently posted lecture on Youtube.  The title given to the lecture is "How Biology Brings Cognition Into Evolution."  It comes very early in the lecture but I'll recommend you listen to the whole thing several times, James Shapiro is always worth listening to and trying to understand.   Maybe I'll transcribe more of it someday.   This is only the beginning of why just repeating "random chance" doesn't cut it. 

By "cognition" I mean action based in knowledge.

How does cellular and genome modification occur in evolution?  which is my specialty. And the fact is that it occurs organically (biologically) it doesn't occur randomly!  It's not accidents, it's not physics, it's biology. And we'll see that as we go on.

Random mutation cannot explain evolutionary variation.  If we assumed an impossibly high mutation rate a positive variation of one-percent, which is orders of magnitude too high and we're just looking at random mutations in the genome, in the DNA, to make a sequence of ten base-pairs would have a probability of one in ten to the twenty.  It would take one in the twenty generations to make a sequence of ten base-pairs. And one can't build a genome on that basis.

We know that in organismal reproduction 99.9 percent of all incorporation errors in the DNA are removed by replication proof-reading systems, which are biological systems.  They scan the DNA, they detect changes in the double helix and they detect mis-pairing  and they remove the newly incorporated incorrect nucleotide. So, that's cognition in action in reproduction.

And also, more than 99 percent of the "spontaneous" mutations that occur, so-called spontaneous mutations it turns out are enzymatically induced by various kinds of mutated polymerases or enzymes which modify the bases in the DNA and when those functions are removed we see a drop in so-called spontaneous mutation rate.  

So biology is central to genome change.  


I'm giving you that quote for several reasons, first is that one of the finest of living experts in this area has said "random mutation" can't do what it is claimed to do in the conventional neo-Drainist (and, in fact, the old-fashioned Darwinist) doctrine must depend on it doing for their theories to work.  It's clearly mathematically impossible to explain evolution in those terms.  On top of that there is the resistance to allowing those "spontaneous" imaginary random mutations to be passed on except in the most rare of instances and that even a large number of those will be caused by irregularities in the cellular chemistry which, when removed, the rate of such "spontaneous mutations" drop.

In this the specific type of "random chance" which the old-line materialist claims inserted wherever the materialist has no explanation is the mutation rate.  'RANDOM CHANCE' being one of the many atheist gods of the gaps used in exactly the same way that atheists accuse religious believers of using God.  Only as "random chance" can be known not to work and the more than slight implication of James Shapiro that the very cellular mechanisms that regulate the replication of DNA is cognitive in nature, attributing that to God is a lot more intelligent than empowering numbers to do what Shapiro has demonstrated they can't do.  If, as he says, that is controlled by biology and not "physics" then it is clearly not controlled by probability mathematics.  

If "DNA" can't do what neo-Darwinism insisted it had to do to produce the enormous evolutionary diversity that we know arose, when some of the necessary physical mechanisms needed to do what you guys insist it does do in that case, when it has a far longer time-scale to do it in, the idea that it can account for the instantaneous experience of having new ideas and immediately putting those into use, keeping in mind the rather good provisional definition of "cognition" given by James Shapiro, "action based in knowledge," there's not nearly enough time for DNA to do anything to produce physical structures in our brains to give rise to those ideas, those units of cognition because DNA is entirely too slow to account for the speed with which we think, though in your case perhaps that takes longer.  

Tuesday, February 27, 2024

The Validity of Science Is Utterly Dependent On Morality Which Science Cannot Demonstrate

IT IS SUCH a classic example of the limits of the abilities of science that the most fundamental statement of science as an unlimited entity cannot be sustained with science.  That ideology, scientism, is based in the faith that what science cannot prove cannot be known by human beings, a statement which is, itself incapable of being proved by science. It would have to be false if it were true, so it can't be true.  In the past I've given that statement as said by a man who should certainly have known better than to say it, the great mathematician and logician Bertrand Russell.  He certainly was able to understand that the statement collapsed under the inability of his all-powerful oracle, science, to support the claim of its definitive decisiveness in what can be considered known which proved that the statement was false.  

Every once in a while I go through a math or other textbook to see if I've still got it, I'm doing that right now and so far it would seem I've still got at least a college frosh level of algebra.  At my age it's reassuring to find that out.  It's a book that has a lot of basic set theory in it so evaluating statements as to whether they're true or false through their mathematical support is in my mind.  But even that activity doesn't make much use of the idea that you should prefer a statement of truth over a false statement.  Math, like science might be able to help you decide if something is true or false but it can't tell you why you should prefer the truth nor can it give you a reason to prefer truth over falsity, it obviously didn't inform Bertrand Russell as to why he should prefer the truth that science can't be the sole means of finding truth because the statement that it is the sole means of doing that that can't be demonstrated with science.  

Science, as a method of finding reliable information about the physical world can be a very powerful means of finding information of superior reliability in those areas it can be practiced at any given time.  But science, not even math is a stand-alone entity, both depend on a far broader range of human experience than either of them can contain, the idea that either of those is capable of being a totalizing or monistic system is sheer stupidity.   The idea that either are an entity independent of human minds is as imaginary as Russell's orbiting teapot or almost everything that comes out of FOX Lies. 

Science always has to be done within the limits of what can be observed, measured and honestly analyzed, when it strays far from that the chances of what is asserted by scientists being true falls as certainly as it does in any other field of human activity when objective verification can't be had.  Science done without that quickly become nothing much but a series of ideological holdings as it so often does when there is an over extension outside of what can be effectively observed or measured or honestly analyzed, in my lifetime one of the most significant of those struggles surrounded the completely speculative neo-sciences of Sociobiology and evolutionary psychology in which the assertions of the ultra-Darwinists (as their opponent Stephen Jay Gould called them) could never be confirmed because no one can go back through the tens, scores, even hundreds of millions of years during which evolution happened to trace the persistence of "traits" alleged to have survived into the most distantly related species, everything from ants to human beings and even more distant ones.  It is impossible to even identify such proposed shared "traits" as being the same thing in the species which supposedly share them.  It's impossible to tease out whether or not many of the "traits," especially those invovling alleged behaviors are really there or if they are imagined to be in one or both of the speices by a scientist motivated to see what they want to.  That last thing is something which is ubiqitous in the supposedly scientific study of "behavior" and other aspects of mental activity, especially likely when one or more of the species is inarticulate and can't report on the internal experience of that "behavior" or mental activity.  In fact, even when the organism can articulate that it only adds a whole host of other problems.  If, as is so often done, the behavioral scientist uses college students as their subjects, many of whom may well have some idea of what the study might want to be there.  I had an aquaintance who annoyed his psychology prof by pointing out that many of the studies they discussed in the class he was taking were done on Yale students who couldn't comprise a legitimate sample of the human population, at that time they were uniformly males, just as one of the problems with the validity of it.  

Another thing I do once in a while is look at the latest postings on the very active blog Retraction Watch, one of the few blogs which doesn't seem to have suffered much of a fall off in current and sometimes very hot new content and which doesn't seem to ever lack for informed, interested and insightful readers.  While quite a bit of the stuff that gets retracted is done so through honest mistakes, much of it is a result of clear and obvious fraud and fraud which becomes quite obvious once there has been what there should have been before it was published,  rigorous review of the methodology and substance of the study or experiment which was retracted.  Quite a bit of that right now concerns obvious fraud involving the dishonest use of photographs and images which could not have been used by those publishing the paper without their intending to commit fraud, TO LIE, IN PLAIN ENGLISH.  

As well as being a methodology, an ideology and even an atheist substitute for religion, science is a profession, one which in a professional or academic context carries enormous financial and professional motives to publish something, anything, academia tying advancement and even retaining a professional engagement on the requirement that you publish, no matter whether or not it is legitimate or even honest.  There are a whole host of professional practices that will add to the professional record of an academician, publishing supposedly original work (plagiarism and copying are also covered by Retraction Watch), acting as a peer reviewer, being involved with a professional journal, etc.  And that's on top of everything else a scientist is supposed to do to get and retain a job and, they hope, advance in the profession.  One of the greatest scandals of the recent spate of scandals in science is the grotesque laxity of what so-called "reviewers" review so as to get their colleagues published.  I've mentioned before that during the Marc Hauser scandal I asked a biologist friend of mine how his reviewers could have failed to look at the videos of the "behavior" he was describing, what proved that he had lied about what his very influential papers claimed he was seeing in the lab.  She told me that reviewers never look at that kind of thing, they take it on faith that their colleagues are being honest about that kind of thing, they just look to see if the reported results are in line with the claims made about what they saw.   Clearly that faith would often fail the truth test if it were tested in line with what scientific method is claimed to be.  

In the brawls I got a on many a Scienceblog and many a play-lefty blog frequented by scientistic materialist-atheists, I was decreasingly surprised to find out the extent to which honesty was beside the point when discussing science or anything else with them.  I can't say that my former assumption that atheists don't lie more than the general population survived the new atheism, my experience of arguing with so many of them wouldn't support the idea that they especially value the truth, especially among the true believers in science as an ideology, their ideology, their religion.  That was true whether the atheist was a scientist or mathematician who allegedly valued science for its method which is alleged to be a heightened method for discerning the truth, I never found they had an especially well developed passion for the truth no matter where it lay, especially when it could be demonstrated to lie somewhere other than where they wanted it to.  In that they are not especially different from the general run of human beings.  The difference is that they claim to be better than that by virtue of their higher sciencyness.  In that they are no better than the frequently encountered whited supulchers of conventional religiosity.  In the age of Trump and the pseudo-Christianity of his fascists, no one could honestly go through this exercise without mentioning them.  Perhaps the fact that religion and its methods can discern that it is a sin to tell a lie makes the religious liar more wicked than the scientific one, though they'd certainly pretend that they were better than them.   To me a liar is a liar, especially when what they lie about is so dangerously consequential.  One of the recent listings on Retraction Blog was a paper alleging that there were serious health problems from taking Covid vaccinations.  In that the two kinds of lying intersect at a mountain of corpses from those who bought into fatal lies.  The ground for that was set in the scientific fraud of a British doctor who got published in the Lancet, one of the most prestigious of all science publications, one whose paper was retracted but well after it set off a horrific and deadly superstition and cult which is entirely relevant to the Ivermectin cult.  And it has far reaching consequences, I recently found out that one of my relatives needed to be treated with Ivermectin and had trouble getting it as a consequence of its use by the anti-vaxx, Trump chumps.  He had to climb through extra hoops to get it for one of its licensed uses in the United States.  

Science, to be any good at all, depends on what it cannot generate but which is properly a religious holding, that you should tell the truth and you shouldn't lie.  It's not much use without that.

Monday, February 26, 2024

Hate Mail - The Stupidity At The Blue Blog

used to be fun to write about but it's just boring now.   I mean, they believe what Simps says without ever verifying what he says so how interested in the truth could they be?

They can soak their heads.   

I'm planning on posting a real piece tomorrow.   Oddly enough, it's on the topic of science being reliant on a moral value that science can't support, the need to tell the truth. 

Saturday, February 24, 2024

Someone Writes To Me

 that Simps says that I write like old people have sex.   

As if he'd know.

Wednesday, February 21, 2024

Maybe I Should Give Up Hate Mail Posts For The Rest of Lent

But they're sooooo easy to write!

SOMEONE APPARENTLY WANTS
me to fight the Darwin wars today, so soon after I'd thought about limiting myself to a major post a month repeating what I've pointed out which Darwin's Defenders have never yet once addressed honestly.  

I'm still sick from whatever it is - Covid test was negative, no idea what it is, so I'll do something easy that I haven't done so recently.  I'm going to bring up the more basic level of materialist nonsense, that our thoughts, our consciousness is a mere epiphenomenon of material structures in our brains.  I think that like so much of materialist, atheist, scientistic lore, it suffers from a mistaken belief that a static, abstract model of something can be made to account for the most basic phenomena of our experience which is the opposite of static and abstract.  Maybe most telling of so many such materialist, atheist, scientistic models, this one is remarkably set apart from one of the most basic aspects of our experience of consciousness, that it happens in time. You could only hold with any of the various models if you refuse to acknowledge how fast things happen in our experience, when our experience of consciousness has to be that part of "nature" against which such models are compared to test their adequacy.  Instead, materialst-atheist ideology insists that it is consciousness that must be fit into the confines of their ideology, not the various and inadequate  schemes they come up with to explain it in materialist terms.

One of the more basic problems with that is in the question of novel ideas, new to us and new to, perhaps, the entire previous line of life on Earth. Certainly the majority of ideas that organisms on Earth came up with had to, at some point, be entirely unprecedented in living beings.   How would our brains know how to construct the right material structures to give rise to the right ideas for us to have any hope of knowing or navigating reality external to our bodies and brains.  How our brains could construct, in real time, the right structures to give rise to new and novel thoughts in order for us to act appropriately to, for example, keep us from being involved in fatal accidents.  That is something that happens to each of us pretty much starting with getting out of bed in the morning and starting to navigate around the house, seeing things we couldn't have expected to see, encountering new things.  Listening to the news or reading it, etc.

Remember any proposed mechanism for our bodies making the right structures to give rise to those novel ideas has to account for how we experience that happening in time, which is realistically estimated to be almost immediate. Any proposed biological action would have to happen that fast or it is not credible as an explanation.

In previous brawls with materialists about this, that would pretty much take care of one of their materialist creator gods, "DNA."  The time which it would take for DNA to come up with a sufficiently novel and appropriate string of amino acids to form a protein (what DNA "does," though not without an extremely complex and largely unknown series of cellular actions).  Structures WHICH WOULD THEN HAVE TO BE BENT INTO THE CORRECT SHAPE FOR IT TO PERFORM THAT FUNCTION would take too many minutes to account for our experience of having, using and confirming the validity of new ideas.  A car you don't expect to see coming at you, for example.  And that proposed solution would merely force the question of how "DNA" would know how to do that.  The same thing can be said for the other atheist creator gods within our brains that would have to know:

1. That it needed to make a novel structure to give rise to the right idea in the brain before the materialist model of consciousness would allow the information to do that to be present in the brain;

2. What it needed to make in order to give rise to the right idea in the near instantaneous time that such ideas arise in our conscious experience.  

3. How to make that correct structures and not the wrong ones to account for the efficacy of the hundreds if not thousands of novel ideas we deal with to get through the day;

4. How it could know that it had made the correct structure and not the wrong one by mistake since, in that case, only the wrong one would be present in the brain.

The other creator gods of atheism that were brought up, such as "natural selection" are even less credible because "natural selection" as it is imagined doesn't exist within our brains, it is supposed to be a force of nature that is always actively trying to kill us.  Though that would get me into the philosophical incompetence of the idea of natural selection and its scientific deficiencies, exactly what I didn't feel like going into again right now.  

One of the most common resorts of materialist-atheist ideology, "probability," certainly doesn't work to step in and rescue the materialist, atheist, scientistic model of consciousness because any given probability would almost certainly not allow for the consistent effective correctness of what goes on to give rise to successful ideas, I'd think if it were possible to tease out a plausible probabilistic calculation, it would soon start making the vanishingly small, generally abstract calculations of the improbability of our life-supporting universe seem unimpressively  small by comparison.  You would have to account for the absence of all of those perhaps quadrillilions of possible outcomes which couldn't show up much or our very existences would be swamped by them.   I've got some real questions about the way that probability is imagined as applying to the real world.

I am struck that those improbabilities that gave rise to desperate materialist, atheist, scientistic physicists and cosmologists inventing jillions and jillions of universes to make it go away would have to become ever more remote from the facts of the observable universe we know something of the more elaborate the phenomena and experiences of life that would have to be accounted for under any complete theory of the improbability of our reality being real.  I think that the reality of our lives and consciousness makes the idea that material probability accounts for it to be far less credible than intelligent design is, though I don't think that science as it exists now could deal with that question, either.  

I don't remember which scientist it was who said that a little learning gives rise to atheism but deeper knowledge gives rise to faith but that's been my experience, especially in considering, deeply, the claims of current atheists during the new atheism fad of the 00's.  I'm far more confident in both the Creation of the universe by God and the design of life, as well, the more I've thought deeply about the claims of the atheists.  And I mean the higher brow atheism, not the pop version of it.  In recent weeks I've been amazed at how readily the scientistic atheists are to violate everything there is about science to promote their ideology through its manipulation, especially the premature and entirely outsized claims surrounding those recently discovered giant galaxies so close to the Big Bang.  I'd come to see that it's not just people like Jerry Coyne who, much as I disagree with him and very much dislike him [confession, I think he's a real pill] at least his formal science generally has links to actual observation.  It's especially true of those like Stephen Hawking and Roger Penrose whose careers in conjecture are entirely unrelated to any observations of nature.  I wasn't surprised by Hawking and his colleagues in cosmology doing it, I was shocked to realize recently that Penrose does the same thing.  I have too much respect for science to not notice the claim that it can be done in the absence of observation.  
 

Sunday, February 18, 2024

Having Criticized Hossenfelder Yesterday

I recommend the video she posted today about the horrific extent of and the growing problem of scientific fraud.  

I left a comment pointing out that science absolutely depends on something that science can't generate or support, a moral obligation to tell the truth and honestly follow the supposed methods of science, honesty in reporting, honesty in review and the independent replication of results.   If they don't do those things there is no reason for anyone to believe any of it.   And that would be a disaster but scientists, in whose hands science is, don't seem to be taking care of the problem very effectively.


William Bolcom - Gospel Prelude 1 What A Friend I Have In Jesus

 

Gabriel Dessauer

Göckel Orgel der Liebfrauenkirche in Frankfurt/Main im Rahmen

Saturday, February 17, 2024

Ours Is The Darkest Age

TWO THINGS I recently heard have gotten me quite depressed about the near term future, a future which is near enough if I live as long as some of my direct ancestors did, might mean I'll still be here to see it.

One was a comment that David Cay Johnston made about the abysmal ignorance of some of his university students about the most basic and simple facts of current events.  He had to tell them a reason that they should care if Putin invades a NATO country would be because they would be drafted into the military and not all of them would come back from the fighting.  Apparently the "information age" that idiots in the media were going on about twenty-five years ago has produced even more of those kinds of idiots among the kollege kredentialed kohort than were paying customers when I was in college.  And there were plenty of ignorant narcissists then, too.  I had a distinct feeling that the generation I was in was a decline from previous years when you were expected to pay attention to the world and take reality seriously if you were to be a respectable adult.  Now even more of them don't even seem to want adulthood while getting all of the legal privileges, thereof.

The second one was while listening to one of Sabine Hossenfelder's youtubes in which Hossenfelder talked about a survey of "artificial intelligence" experts who speculated on several things, one was the terrible effect that AI simulations of information would have on the ability of even experts to distinguish between artifice and reality, truth and fiction and the effect of that on things like the possibility of the conduct of our daily lives, not to mention that such lies saturating the body politic would remove one or more of the absolutely essential prerequisites a society and country must have for egalitarian democracy to even be possible.  

That last point may not have bothered Hossenfelder much as she, out of her devotion to materialism, atheism and scientism doesn't think very highly of democracy.  Here's something she said eight years ago in an interview she did with John Horgan:

Horgan: What’s your utopia?

Hossenfelder: That we finally use scientific methods to restructure political and economic systems. The representative democracies that we have right now are entirely outdated and unable to cope with the complex problems which we must solve. We need new systems that better incorporate specialized knowledge and widely distributed information, and that better aggregate opinions. (I wrote about this in detail here.) It pains me a lot to think that my children will have to live through a phase of economic regress because we were too stupid and too slow to get our act together.


I'd point out to her that we saw what governments who intended to "use scientific methods to restructure political and economic systems" were capable of doing in the 20th century,  Today's united Germany experienced both the Nazi and the Soviet attempts to do that, as, in fact, the western and Asian liberal democracies have, though not so totalistically as the hard-core true believers in that sciency road to "progress."   Every Marxist dictatorship was an attempt to do just that, including the Soviets, the various countries under its hegemony,  China, Pol Pot's regime in Cambodia and the Kim dynasty in North Korea.  

The results of that are directly relevant to another thing that she rather blithly talked about in the speculations of the surveyed AI experts, that they believed the capacity of AI systems to mimic information would, by 2040,  lead governments (perhaps corporations?) to take actions that would produce at least one "megadeath," a term which is, itself a product of the application of science without much democratic input, the nuclear arms military-industrial complex. Of the AI experts who didn't agree with that believed that AI would produce large, though lesser numbers of those murdered through buying into computer created irreality.  But that's nothing new in that kind of instrumental thinking.  The devotees of scientism didn't need AI to be blinded by science in that way.   The French Revolution which immediately took the form of the Reign of Terror was an early such attempt to "use scientific method to restructure political and economic systems."  That would be a use of "scientific methods to restructure political and economic systems," as, I would argue, the thing which led liberal democracies to permit a situation that has demoted the value of truth over lies starting with the extremely dangerous framing of the First Amendment in the United States, one which does not explicitly value truth above lies,* one which has led the United States directly into the line of presidencies starting with Nixon in the wake of the Supreme Court issued carte blanche to the media to lie about political figures and "public figures," to Reagan who destroyed requirements of public service and the presentation of alternative view points in broadcast media, on to the Bushes and the logical conclusion of that in Trump and on to a situation in which even with the disastrous lessons of terrible experience, with a very large body count, of both the Bush II and Trump regimes, a seriously large number of Americans and probably a far larger percentage of the American "free press" are ready to have a re-do of that.  

The "enlightenment" philosophy, which is based in a clearly false and illusory imitation of scientific method, a notion of which pervades our legal system based in the amateur attempts of such as Madison and Hamilton and the rest of the "founders" may be a somewhat better attempt at the use of scientific methods to restructure political and economic systems than the totalitarian ones, but it is also pervaded with the treatment of human beings, other living beings and the environment as if they were mere objects of commerce and wealth creation and concentration, none of which "scientific methods" has the least problem with because science was, by mutual agreement, exempted from considering such moral questions which are important in the wider reality which science cannot possibly cover and which scientism and its habits of thought have no interest in or feeling for.  

How insane is our darkest of dark ages when the possibility of computer simulated "reality" can be believed capable of producing "megadeaths" and not only societies but governments are going head first into that out of the possibility of money being made from it?   Who will those millions killed by us looking into the carnival mirror of computer created reality be?  I wonder if the proponents of AI have ever seriously entertained the possibility that it wouldn't be those who they consider far off and "exotic" or biologically inferior to them who are the ones who will be killed as a result of computers grinding out a convincing simulation of reality to the likes of Putin or Trump or which ever idiot who rules in Britain or France or any other nuclear country?  Have they never considered that it could be them and anyone they might care about?   In her libretto for the self-congratulatory "modern" and supremely stupid opera, Four Saints in Three Acts Gertrude Stein posited the question, "If it were possible to kill five thousand chinamen by pressing a button would it be done."   Being as stupid as she was, she didn't discuss it but had her imaginary "St. Teresa" bush the question aside because she wasn't interested in it.  Which proves how far from reality that an imaginary person could be in the superficial mind of an idiotic modernist.  I doubt the collaborationist Gertrude Stein who, as late as the last years of the 1930s believed that Hitler wasn't going to go to war with anyone and believed enough in his "greatness" that she nominated him for the Nobel Peace Prize could have imagined a world in which it might be a "Chinaman" who was duped by AI into killing a million people, not that I think it would bother the reportedly quite stupid Xi anymore than it would the obviously stupid Trump or the criminally insane Putin (or whoever the idiot Tories gull the British public into leadership).  I wouldn't put it past any of them from killing a million of the people in the countries they control.   You can add the dictators of Pakistan to that list and the Kim regime in North Korea, thanks to a Pakistani nuclear physicist selling them the knowledge of how to get nuclear weapons for his own profit.   I really meant it when I said in response to the scientistic, atheist, materialist Sam Harris proposing to murder "tens of millions" of PEOPLE in Islamic countries in a day that a far more rational act would be to kill all of the scientists capable of producing and maintaining and deploying nuclear weapons, perhaps using the threat of wider annihilation as a means of turning them over to make the world save from their intelligent designs.  As insane as such an idea is, it's far more sane than murdering tens of millions of entirely innocent and incapable people living under a government they never had a hand in choosing.   I'd like to hear what Sabine Hosenfelder would think of that modest alternative proposal of getting rid of those in her profession as a superior act of instrumental reasoning.

It is one of the supreme ironies of the history of humanity that the age of science, the "enlightenment" has produced such a depraved and fraudulent view of life and reality as to produce an educated class who can accept such possibilities, and if we are to believe in the expertise  of such experts, probabilities.  If that's true then it is far more depraved than any previous age which we imagine out of the evidnece of the historical record.  Only I doubt they were as arrogantly unaware of the reality of what they chose to believe and live out.  You need modernism for that, modernism as began when science was transformed from a method into an ideology and a totalizing system of thought.

* It should be remembered that so many of the framers were lawyers.  The legal profession is certainly inclusive of those who have little use for the truth as opposed to lies, choosing either as long as it serves their purpose.  And such are the highest paid members of the legal profession.  The legal profession has "ethics" that don't lead to the removal of such people from it in very large numbers.  Roy Cohn was only removed from it while he was dying of AIDS, I will be interested to see if Rudy Giuliani is really removed from it in the final years of his rakes progress if liquor doesn't do him in first.  I would say that the elevation of so many of those, not only to the judiciary but the highest levels of the judiciary, many quite adept at lying and contorting reason in service to, ultimately, their self-interest, could probably produce nothing but a legal system which elevates lying to an equal level of valuation to the truth and gives lies the protection of law.   It's the lesson of the replicability crisis and the exposure of widespread corner-cutting, outright fraud and the fraudulence of "peer review" in science in the last twenty or so years that the legal profession isn't the only area of educated eliteness that does that.   These days I'm a lot more impressed with the less formal and pretentious level of review that exists among historians, though plenty of lies get told through that academic field and, even more so, on the popular level.   

PS.  I thought I'd add this as a preemptive update:

Horgan: Steven Weinberg recently told me that science will never explain why there is something rather than nothing.

Hossenfelder: I agree with him. It’s not a scientific question, or at least I don’t see how to make a scientific question out of it. Unless of course you want to reinterpret “nothing” as “quantum vacuum” as Lawrence Krauss does. I would argue though that even a quantum vacuum is still something.

Horgan: If physics can’t solve that problem, does that mean we’ll always be stuck with religious explanations?

Hossenfelder: Religious explanation is an oxymoron. Religion is what people draw upon if they don’t want to admit that they have no explanation. Will we always be stuck with problems to which scientists don’t have an answer? Yes, I think so.

Horgan: Do you believe in God?

Hossenfelder: No.


Horgan: What is “the free will function”? And why doesn’t it persuade you that free will is real?

Hossenfelder: The free will function allows the universe to evolve in such a way that the future is neither determined by the past nor its becoming fundamentally random. If you want to hang on to the belief in free will, then you need to find a law for the universe’s evolution which is different from the laws in our current theories. This new evolution law must partly be based on a process that was neither random nor pre-determined. This process is what the free will function provides.

It doesn’t persuade me because the example that I constructed isn’t embedded into the current theories of nature and I don’t know whether it’s possible to do this. It is not a realistic construction – it is merely a proof of principle to demonstrate that is possible at all. And of course I am cognitively biased to believe in free will, so how much can I trust myself in my own argument?


Clearly, among the other things which her high intelligence and expertise in her field don't provide her with is a particularly informed knowledge of the enormously varied phenomenon of religion (she only knows of a God of the gaps) nor one of free will.   Free will would be a mental ability which, in order to be free, would have to exceed in its action her conception of causality despite whatever resulted from it. Many, even most People could choose the same thing freely, even to believe in whatever of physics they might be able to conceive of.  Even if that turned out to be quite wrong. Even to have a blind faith in physicists.  Physicists certainly have done that as have other scientists in other fields.  Science is no guarantee of omniscience.  If free will is real, and I think the consequences of not believing in that are sufficiently bad to choose to believe in it, physics would probably be the worst possible means of thinking about it because it is based in an ill-defined and largely unknown causality that even physics can't make much of a dent into defining.  Her specialty of particle physics can't even come up with a firm definition of what a "particle" is.  The rational conclusion of such realities is that the "current theories of nature" are hardly able to exclude possibilities that can't be fit into it, though she chooses to believe that they can.  Why anyone who values egalitarian democracy or even the corrupt approximation of something like that, liberal democracy would find the denial of free will a respectable ideological position has more to do with ignorance of the consequences of it or a particularly naive acceptance of the authority of scientists.  As I pointed out, such an ignorance of the most consequential lessons of 20th century history discredits that ideological faith.   They're not gods, they generally aren't very good when they get far outside of their narrow specialties, especially those they don't value such as history and the wider consideration of hard human experience.  A lot of them are unable to distinguish their ideological preference from validly demonstrated science, a lot of them are as immune from looking at what they don't like  as possibly being true as the most benighted fundamentalist or a fan of Donald Trump or Vladimir Putin.  

I would love to hear her give a detailed description of how her government under the rule of science would work, how in lieu of "representative democracy" laws would be adopted and enforced, how the legal system would work, how economic inequalities would be either evened out or, as I suspect it would be under such a scientistic, atheistic, materialistic priesthood, ignored.   I think Benjamin Franklin got it right when he said a government of wise men would be a very foolish thing.  While I think science should inform government, a government of scientists would be even stupider.  I've known scientists who would have a hard time knowing their ass from an elbow joint.  


Friday, February 16, 2024

"Too High" - Dave Stryker Trio w/ Warren Wolf

 

Dave Stryker, guitar

Jared Gold, organ, 

Warren Wolf, vibes 

McClenty Hunter, drums

Thursday, February 15, 2024

The Lamb Of God - Ash Wednesday (Posted a day late by accident)

I thought this posted yesterday but I was wrong.   So I'm posting it a day late.

THE CHRISTIAN IDENTIFICATION of Jesus as the Pascal Lamb is something I have always found unsettling, enough so that I never much thought about it seriously.  The timing of the trial and execution of Jesus in regard to the Passover meal forces the question as to why was it followed on the day of the slaughter of so many lambs, probably thousands in Jerusalem alone, lambs such as the one which, no doubt, Jesus and his followers ate at the Last Supper.  The traditional answer that Jesus was the unique sacrifice, making later such sacrifices unnecessary never sat right with me.  But, then, I grew up in the Christian milieu in which such sacrifices of animals was left behind more than nineteen centuries before I was born.  Of course most People don't think of the animals they eat as being sacrifices, they think of them as objects to be killed and eaten.  That makes the identification of the crucified Jesus with one especially fraught, if you think about it which I have to admit I'm doing for the first time in my life.

When I made the change from my decades long vegetarian diet to veganism it was in response to two things, a speech that the Chief Rabbi of Dublin made in which he said that the world situation, especially climate change made veganism a moral duty, as well as the moral duty to treat sentient beings well.  The second followed on reading that speech, I remembered a poem by the early 20th century Maine Poet Holman Day about a farmer selling calves to be slaughtered, something which I've posted here before, if I recall correctly.   Growing up on a farm I know baby cows are extremely appealing animals, as are baby goats and lambs, I remember a women I knew who raised goats telling about a Greek family who bought a kid from her right before Orthodox Easter and how when they bound its legs to transport it to be killed she was so appalled that she gave them their money back and kept the animal, her husband slaughtered goats but she knew he'd do it humanely.  Though I don't think there's any such thing as a humane method to kill a sentient creature.  

I know from growing up on a farm and among farm people that there is no such a thing as raising animals for food which doesn't involve killing them, whether as young adults or as juveniles.  The number of male chicks killed as soon as they're hatched is appalling as, in fact, is that it's not uncommon for them to be sorted from females and sent into a shoot where they are chopped to pieces.  That's something you should know about even if you only eat eggs and not flesh.  Even before I became a vegan I'd only eat eggs from our hens which were never slaughtered but allowed to die of natural causes (though in some cases those natural causes were raccoons and dogs and foxes.  And the slaughter of baby mammals can't be separated from the consumption of milk products.  The calves, kids, etc. are superfluous to the goal of making their mothers lactate so humans consume the milk instead of the babies they give milk for.  That is until the still fairly young cows are considered less profitable and they are sent to slaughter, as well, something that happens even sooner for chickens in an egg factory.  The cruelties of the dairy industry are extensive and inescapable.  It's not as if that paused for even a second as ritual sacrifice of animals was left behind with the destruction of The Temple and the adoption of Rabbinical Judaism and Christianity.  The people who have refused to eat all animal products for moral reasons is probably one of the smallest groupings of human beings in the history of our species.

What does it mean for God incarnated as a human being to so obviously take the role, not of Moses but of a sacrificed baby animal?  A human being who did not resist the  slaughter he knew was coming before he even started out for Jerusalem.   What are Christians supposed to conclude from that?  That's a real question, I don't know the answer to it.  I'd think that we're supposed to think hard and without regard to what we want about what it means not only for us, human beings, but also as to how we treat animals.  As a vegan I know what I'd want to conclude about it though that's complicated by the passage in which Jesus is given a piece of fish to eat after he appears to his followers after the Resurrection.  

The meaning of the Eucharist, instituted by Jesus breaking the bread and passing a cup of wine telling his followers to eat and drink his body and blood must tie his sacrifice to our eating and drinking, though I'm somewhat heretical in thinking that it was in the sharing of food and drink that contains his essence as much as the bread and wine.  I think any time food is shared has  Eucharistic content embedded in it, especially when it is vitally needed food and drink.  

Ash Wednesday's most notable sacramental of anointing with ashes, being told to remember that our bodies came from unliving matter and our bodies will return to unliving matter has to tie into that too.   The traditional expectation of so many Christians that our bodies will be resurrected goes against that declaration, though people can know that their bodies will decay or be burned up into ashes before there's any such resurrection.

Sunday, February 11, 2024

Apparently Simps Never Heard Of

 Lord Haw Haw

Note what a piece of crap he was from the start, an Irish guy who betrayed Ireland by being a Unionist spy and likely murderer as a teenager, later one of Mosley's Brit fascists before becoming a Nazi propagandist.   Yeah, Lord Ca Ca has more than a little in common with him.   But, Simps only knows what he got from TV, the movies and post-WWII crap kulcha so he misses a lot of references.

Friday, February 9, 2024

Reading About Tucker Carlson's Emasculation By Putin Just Now

 I realized that from now on he's Lord Ca Ca to me.

Dump Garland

THE OUTRAGEOUS deceptive structure and partisan bias of the Robert Hur report on President Biden's retention of classified materials is just the latest of the many obvious bad judgements of Merrick Garland.   I'd have said before the loss of his membership of the Supreme Court was mitigated by his bad judgement and all-too-lawyerly cowardice in avoiding criticism from those who had blocked his nomination, once he became Attorney General.  Now his idiotic enablement of Republican-fascism in his appointment of Hur, who obviously briefed himself as an unofficial operative of the Trump campaign should be the final nail in the coffin of his career.   If I were President Biden I'd wait till after the election and fire him, especially if he wins reelection, having such a Republican-enabling jackass in that position will do him and the country no good.  

After listening to the Harvard product as sits on the Court yesterday I'm in favor of a long term moratorium on the appointment of the graduates of Harvard Law to the courts and other positions in the legal realm.   Hearing them seemingly not realizing that states keep people off of ballots ALL THE FRIGGIN' TIME and for less weighty and democracy threatening reasons was the final straw.   I am convinced that those elite law schools that prepare elites for profitable and, or eminent careers in the lawyer industry produce self-protecting cowards who ill serve the People of the United States and egalitarian democracy.   The same can be said, generally, of the products of other Ivys and Ivy equivalent schools of law.   I will say again that during the House hearings on that led to Trump's first impeachment for trying to involve the Ukrainian government in his efforts to sandbag Joe Biden, I was stunned at how all of the courage, risking themselves in service to the People and democracy,  came from the diplomats and the military officers as the lawyers pretty well stuck to covering their own asses.   These years of observing, not only the things lawyers get away with and cover up for each other over BUT THE CONDUCT OF THE COURTS, JUDGES IN MANY CASES BEING AS OPENLY PARTISAN AS JAMES COMEY AND ROBERT HUR HAVE BEEN BUT GETTING AWAY WITH IT WITH NO ISSUES BEING RAISED,  has made me far more cynical about the lawyering industry and its senior branch on the bench, certainly none so deserving of such cynicism as the Supreme Court.

President Biden, I'm begging you, as soon as the election is over, fire Garland, don't be sentimental about it due to him losing the court seat, you gave him his chance and he has repeatedly reenacted "the laws delay" and not infrequently it's forfeiture.   Find someone who will not be partisan BUT WHO WON'T BE THE GODDAMEND REPUBLICAN-FASCISTS' HANDMAIDEN.    Democratic Presidents from Carter to you have suffered for the bad choices their Attorneys General have made, for their scrupulosity in wanting to avoid the cabloids and tabloids and liars in the media making the slightest criticism of them and the clearly cowardly and corrupt Department of Justice.   Since it's clear not even the Supreme Court under Republican-fascism is not pretending to be "even-handed" in the administration of "justice," there's no reason not to play that same game for the angels instead of the spawn of Satan.   Dump Garland.

Thursday, February 8, 2024

Notice

 Been sick, getting better.  Lots of Covid around here right now, not sure that's what I had.  Not dead, yet.

Wednesday, February 7, 2024

I'm not big on nil nisi bonum,

so I'll leave it at I'll never think of Toby Keith without thinking of the pro-lynching song he sang at Trump's inauguration non-star concert.   I agree with Natalie Maines' shirt.  What happens to him now isn't my responsibility.  

Update:  I wonder why when someone like that dies, they say he's a country music legend, or he's a show-biz legend.   Legends are make believe, I'd rather be remembered for reality not PR bull shit. 

Friday, February 2, 2024

Nunc Dimittis - George Dyson

 


Sung by the boys of Lichfield Cathedral

I've posted the Magnificat from the same Service in c minor a number of times but never the following canticle.   

Here's another setting of the text in Latin by Paul Smith, sung by his group VOCES8.  It puts a slant to the canticle I'd never considered while reading it.  It reminds me of some of Schubert's heavier music for male quartet.