I was busy with family matters when Barney Frank came out as a "pot smoking atheist" on Bill Maher's show. It, apparently, wasn't big enough news in New England that it made it up here from the Boston news market. What it means, who knows? Frank's record in office is quite good, how it relates to him being an atheist would be for Frank to parse. I would love to ask Frank some questions about what he thinks of the wide-spread atheist denial of the reality of free will, free thought, things I'd expect Frank believes in. I would love to discuss where he believes rights come from and where the moral obligation to respect those rights arises.
Once, years ago, I heard him on TV on the topic of suicide responding to Henry Hyde going on about suicide being a violation of the right to life. Frank made what I've always thought was a good point, that a right resides in the person who has it and, in the case of suicide, it would be the person who possessed the right who would be violating it. I'd like to ask him how he squares his view of rights as an inherent possession of persons with his atheism. If he has come to some non-materialist atheism, it would be fascinating to hear someone of his intelligence and practical experience as a politician elucidate it. I don't read anywhere that Bill Maher pursued any of those interesting topics. I know, shocking how Maher could have let those pass.
I have always liked Frank, have favored his election and would have loved to vote for him and I still would based on his record. This isn't about whether or not I'd vote for Barney Frank, it's about whether or not the ideological declarations of atheists over the centuries have made atheism a legitimate issue for people to consider in whether or not to vote for an atheist. Atheism isn't a neutral attribute, it is an ideological position generally containing a belief in materialism and materialism has no ability to generate the bases of egalitarian democracy. It has proven unable to do that. An atheist has no more right to someone's vote than a biblical fundamentalist does and a politicians thinking about rights, obligations to respect those rights, etc. are entirely legitimate questions when they will be voting on exactly those issues and making laws affecting us. And, have you ever heard an atheist declare that someone has the right to someone's vote because they were religious?
-------
This is all about a rather silly article by Mary Elizabeth Williams who cites Frank and a handful of other out atheists who are politicians claiming that we need to vote for more atheists. She cites a Win-Gallup survey to claim that the number of atheists has grown enormously in the past nine years, 1 to 5 % and that religion has dropped 13% in the same time. Perhaps Williams missed a few details in the news report of the survey that SHE LINKED TO but there are some rather bizarre features to it.
Barry Kosmin, the principal investigator for the ARIS report, said he’s skeptical of the new study.
“The U.S. trends are what we have found and would expect, but the actual numbers are peculiar to say the least,” he said. “The drops in religiosity seem too sharp for the time period — people just don’t change their beliefs that quickly. Most of the trend away from religion has demographic causes and demography moves ‘glacially.’”
Specifically, he points to the poll’s finding that Vietnam, while showing a sharp 23 percent drop in religiosity since 2005, also shows no atheists. “Eight million Communist Party members but zero atheists?” he said. “That statistic makes me very doubtful of the accuracy of the survey overall and some of the international comparisons.”
Which would lead one to strongly suspect that there is something wrong with the study, which is quite at odds with the Pew Surveys that are usually the go-to organization for atheists to make claims about the success of their insurgency, generally either misunderstanding or falsifying what those surveys say. Did she actually read her own citation?
Furthermore what the report Williams cites says about other countries makes you wonder how she could make her claims from it:
— Besides Vietnam, Ireland had the greatest change in religiosity, down from 69 percent to 47 percent.
— China has the most “convinced atheists,” at 47 percent, followed by Japan (31 percent), Czech Republic (30 percent) and France (29 percent)
— The most religious countries are in Africa (Ghana, Nigeria, Kenya), South America (Brazil, Peru) and Eastern Europe (Macedonia, Romania, Armenia).
— Countries with the same percentage of atheists as the U.S. are Poland, Moldova and Saudi Arabia.
I strongly suspect that Win-Gallup conducted and published this poll to get some news attention, which is why I think Williams wrote what she did and the reason Salon published it. I've come across lots of atheist-click bait of the same quality, when you click on the links to their citations, those don't say what the article claims. I mean, the article she cites pretty much trashes the credibility of the Win-Gallup survey that she makes her claims from.
But it isn't until the end of her column that the real problems become obvious.
Nevertheless, it’s frustrating that in a nation that built the ideal of keeping God out of government into its foundation, voters are still so reluctant to support candidates who keep God out of their own lives. As a Catholic, I want leaders who don’t interfere with my faith but I don’t need them to share in it. In fact, I strongly prefer they not. I want politicians who can serve all their constituents, without moral conflicts of interest. You’d better believe I don’t like what happens when the dictates of a faith collide with the healthcare needs of women. That’s why I vote in a manner that works toward keeping religion out of government. And one of the easiest ways to bring that about is to support more candidates without religion in the first place.
There are so many problems with this paragraph that it would take a really long post to go through them. The United States was not founded on "the ideal of keeping God out of government" it was founded on the ideal that governments were there to "establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity". The only relevance of religion in that is exactly the opposite of what Williams says, IT IS TO KEEP THE GOVERNMENT OUT OF RELIGION. Especially that the government not establish one religion, to the discredit of it when the government is discreditable, and the disadvantage of members of other religions.
But her assumption that religion shouldn't and has not informed the decisions of The People, including those in who they vote for, to good effect is what's really wrong with it. While it's fashionable to pretend otherwise, every single advance in rights, including the rights of women and GLBT people, certainly of Black people, Latinos and others has been more based on religious belief than it has on standard civics. The Constitution with The Bill of Rights didn't end slavery, it didn't enfranchise women and poor men, it didn't provide welfare to the destitute or do much of anything that wouldn't be perfectly OK with the most right-wing, paleo-federalist sitting in a well upholstered office at any neo-fascist DC area think tank.
Every single effort to make the aristocratic 18th century document that the original Constitution was into a vehicle of equality and rights, was either explicitly religious or it included a major component of religious involvement. The People are the real foundation of government, in the past I said it was the trunk from which the branches of government take its life and from whom it derives its only legitimacy. It has been when The People are convinced that there is a religious requirement to pay a cost to provide justice, the exercise of rights to other people, AT A COST TO THEMSELVES, that real progress has been made. Atheism has provided no such motivation, it has, most typically, resorted to some analysis under the guise of natural selection, which is inevitably an unequal competition in which the "fittest" survive and the weakest die.
On issue after issue fought out in the 19th and early 20th century, it was religious belief that powered movements to change laws. There is no record of atheism powering any of that change, frankly, I doubt that in any form I'm aware of, atheist ideology would most likely either be impotent or counter-productive in pursuing those goals. Materialism, for its entire existence, has most often denied anything so metaphysical as inherent rights which it can't account for either existing or being equally distributed in the population. It can't account for where a moral obligation to universally respect those rights exists in equal distribution, falling as much on the most intelligent, most favored by circumstances as it does on the least intelligent and most unlucky.
When you are talking about politics, making laws, being a judge, those are what governments do. Unless someone has an absolute belief in the equal distribution of rights as an inherent endowment of people and the moral obligation to respect those then The People have more than a right to reject them, they have a moral obligation to reject them. The only people who can tell us how atheism is compatible with those metaphysical endowments are atheists and, frankly, I read more of them denying the possibility that those are real than have demonstrated any kind of respect for them. Barney Frank's record is what needs explaining in those terms. If he can provide what generations of atheists have not, a secure and powerful foundation for rights and moral obligations, a powerful motive for people to trouble themselves and pay a cost for people unconcerned with them, he should do so. He should because the common materialist rejection of them has been articulated for centuries.
"It seems to me that to organize on the basis of feeding people or righting social injustice and all that is very valuable. But to rally people around the idea of modernism, modernity, or something is simply silly. I mean, I don't know what kind of a cause that is, to be up to date. I think it ultimately leads to fashion and snobbery and I'm against it." Jack Levine: January 3, 1915 – November 8, 2010 LEVEL BILLIONAIRES OUT OF EXISTENCE - MARBURY DELENDA EST
Thursday, May 22, 2014
Tuesday, May 20, 2014
Also from June 2006
MORE TROLL LORE
My friends, a troll on Kevin Drum's blog has brandishd another weapon from the trolls armamentarium. I have been accused of conceit.
The late John Kenneth Galbraith didn't have much use for the virtue of modesty. He held it to be overrated. He might have been right about that, but more practically, when a leftist lets modesty get in the way they don't fight aggressively for the leftist agenda.
My fellow leftists, please, make the same sacrifice I have. Put aside that most charming of personal traits, demure modesty. It has no place in a brawl and politics is a brawl. If someone, even your inner liberal niceness angel, scolds that you are being immodest, consider it to be a noble and worthwhile sacrifice for the cause. If your angel keeps bugging you, promise it you'll try to cut down on the use of the first person.
Conservatives, motivated only by greed and hate, have much to be modest about. But you don't see them hiding behind the couch.
My friends, a troll on Kevin Drum's blog has brandishd another weapon from the trolls armamentarium. I have been accused of conceit.
The late John Kenneth Galbraith didn't have much use for the virtue of modesty. He held it to be overrated. He might have been right about that, but more practically, when a leftist lets modesty get in the way they don't fight aggressively for the leftist agenda.
My fellow leftists, please, make the same sacrifice I have. Put aside that most charming of personal traits, demure modesty. It has no place in a brawl and politics is a brawl. If someone, even your inner liberal niceness angel, scolds that you are being immodest, consider it to be a noble and worthwhile sacrifice for the cause. If your angel keeps bugging you, promise it you'll try to cut down on the use of the first person.
Conservatives, motivated only by greed and hate, have much to be modest about. But you don't see them hiding behind the couch.
Tuesdays Are Hard
Even with my reduced work schedule (got to get more students) Tuesdays are my difficult days this year. Sorry for the slighter posting. Here's a little something from my early days of blogging.
Untitled
The Civil War dead
Painted the house
ashes of roses.
The parlor, olive.
The girl went out,
Took off her shoes
And ran through
the June weeds.
None of them grey.
Untitled
The Civil War dead
Painted the house
ashes of roses.
The parlor, olive.
The girl went out,
Took off her shoes
And ran through
the June weeds.
None of them grey.
What Don't These "Brights" Get About Their Intention To Offend People?
Jim Reed Anthony_McCarthy • 9 hours ago
This is an asymmetrical battle. Catholics have nothing to gain and much to lose. The Satanist side has nothing to lose and they can make a point. The Catholics are prisoners to their own feeling of importance. They lost at the point where they took the disrespect shown them by the Satanists, and did what they could to apply pressure and shut them down. From the Satanist point of view it doesn't matter if they are shut down because the point has already been made, so they have already won, and they didn't even need to hold their meeting. Some of the Catholics can see the problem, and wish it could have been worked out differently, but there is nothing they can do. Those on the attack won't get it, and if there is any more conflict like this they will dig themselves in deeper. They see their religion as more important, and something they must fight to protect, and that blinds them to what they are doing.
Anthony_McCarthy Jim Reed • 34 minutes ago
The point is a bunch of atheists who are calling themselves "Satanists" purposely do something to offend Catholics and Catholics do the rational thing, they are offended. Then the atheist-"Satanists" whine that the people they intended to offend were offended. The Catholics didn't shut them down, they protested the offense and someone else decided they'd rather not be part of offending a large number of people so they shut them down.
Let me repeat, kid, if you decide to intentionally offend someone they are entirely within their right to have the reaction you intended and they have the right to do something about it. The Catholics did nothing wrong in this, they did what anyone has a right to do, defend themselves. That you don't get that is only proof that you're not as "Bright" as people like Daniel Dennett have told you you are.
This much is clear about how internet atheists think. When people react to their offensive behavior in a way to protest the offense or to defend themselves against the offense, the online atheist's brilliant response is
"THAT'S NOT FAIR!"
The temptation is to point out that they're twelve. But I think that's giving them too much credit. They're about four.
This is an asymmetrical battle. Catholics have nothing to gain and much to lose. The Satanist side has nothing to lose and they can make a point. The Catholics are prisoners to their own feeling of importance. They lost at the point where they took the disrespect shown them by the Satanists, and did what they could to apply pressure and shut them down. From the Satanist point of view it doesn't matter if they are shut down because the point has already been made, so they have already won, and they didn't even need to hold their meeting. Some of the Catholics can see the problem, and wish it could have been worked out differently, but there is nothing they can do. Those on the attack won't get it, and if there is any more conflict like this they will dig themselves in deeper. They see their religion as more important, and something they must fight to protect, and that blinds them to what they are doing.
Anthony_McCarthy Jim Reed • 34 minutes ago
The point is a bunch of atheists who are calling themselves "Satanists" purposely do something to offend Catholics and Catholics do the rational thing, they are offended. Then the atheist-"Satanists" whine that the people they intended to offend were offended. The Catholics didn't shut them down, they protested the offense and someone else decided they'd rather not be part of offending a large number of people so they shut them down.
Let me repeat, kid, if you decide to intentionally offend someone they are entirely within their right to have the reaction you intended and they have the right to do something about it. The Catholics did nothing wrong in this, they did what anyone has a right to do, defend themselves. That you don't get that is only proof that you're not as "Bright" as people like Daniel Dennett have told you you are.
This much is clear about how internet atheists think. When people react to their offensive behavior in a way to protest the offense or to defend themselves against the offense, the online atheist's brilliant response is
"THAT'S NOT FAIR!"
The temptation is to point out that they're twelve. But I think that's giving them too much credit. They're about four.
Monday, May 19, 2014
"Sex Pos" Hucksters Are The Anti-Vaxxers Of The "Reality Community" If Not Its Climate Change Deniers
It probably is the second most serious of mortal sins on the pseudo-left, the denial of science. What else does the febrile anger at creationists by people, some of whom know as little as they do about evolution consist of by damning the sinners to the hellishness of being them? The most serious sin among the pseudo-left is being not being all up to date and modernistic, the ultimate fashion faux pas, what replaces a sense of sin when the reality of sin is to not to be considered real on pain of being not kewl.
And it is the reason that when it comes to the real and undeniable results of sexual promiscuity, sleeping around, screwing around, one is required to pretend that the massive science documenting those results is wrong. Or, failing that, to pretend that the science doesn't exist. Of course the results of promiscuous sex are well documented even in the popular culture, known to just about anyone as soon as they find out what sex is. Pregnancy, in the case of straight sex, infections in any instance when an exchange of bodily fluids is possible. No one who has an understanding of the most basic biology of the matter can misunderstand that. Only you are required to pretend that you don't understand it, you are to suppress that knowledge.
The conflict between some of the most obvious, relevant and life saving science that identifies sleeping around as a dangerous practice* and that grooviness requires a breezy, insouciant, contra-scientific requirement to approve of sexual promiscuity proves that the coercion to be in step with fashion wins out over science and personal experience among the "rational class". Their objects of worship, their substitute state of grace, are, arguably, more powerful than those of the fundamentalist religion that leads unfashionable people to deny the far more remote reality of evolution.
The denial of science by the "sex pos" hucksters and their dupes is a far greater denial of known reality than the denial of science by those who will never experience or observe evolution. I doubt there is a sentient adult who has not know of, observed or experienced the negative consequences of sexual promiscuity.
The arithmetic of infection with STDs isn't complex, your chances of infection increase with both the numbers of people you have sex with AND with the number of people the person or people you have sex with have had sex with. This is the same as with any communicable disease. The "sex pos" people who deny that is the case are at least as stupid and irresponsible as the anti-vaxx people. The result of both practices will be larger numbers of people contracting preventable diseases and the endangerment of other people, some of whom have the misfortune of being married or in what they believe is a monogamous relationship with someone who engages in a known risk factor to them.
The "sex pos" people are as irresponsible as the Muslim fundamentalists who prevent vaccination programs because they encourage a risky behavior, they recruit people to turn their bodies into the vector of infection. The few ways we have of reducing the risks of sleeping around, chlamydia vaccines, various drugs that may reduce risk of other infections**, don't anticipate the evolution of viruses into new pathogens. The time between the evolution of HIV as a human pathogen and the first conclusions that something was happening in gay men was long enough for a catastrophic, world-wide pandemic to have developed.
IT IS AFTER PEOPLE BECOME SICK AND DIE THAT NEW PATHOGENS ARE EVEN NOTICED BY THE SCIENTISTS WHO ARE LOOKING FOR THINGS LIKE THAT. In the case of HIV-AIDS and antibiotic resistant forms of old fashioned STDs, those incubate in the bodies of people who have been exposed to them through people having multiple sex partners, especially those who have had many. Yet that is what "sex pos" encourages, especially to young people who can reasonably claim to not have seen the results of that behavior, yet. It's too bad that they will probably have to experience it themselves to understand that they were being lied to, often by old people in the pay of the sex industry or those who are desperate to remain trendy and groovy well after their days of finding non-paying sex partners in large numbers are past.
There is as much if not more denial of science and what it means for people and their lives among what passes, pathetically, as hipsters these days as there is among the creationists and the dupes of FOX, it's just different science that is denied. And the difference in what is acceptable to who isn't based on anything more serious than in-crowd identity or fundamentalist coercion.
* There is so much science done on this and the basic facts of it are so well known to the people who are reading this that it is ridiculous to keep pointing it out. I doubt that among people old enough to remember the 1980s and 90s those facts aren't known except among the least intelligent and most willfully ignorant. Though anyone who knows that science and denies it probably shouldn't qualify as being smarter than them.
** In looking to see how this issue is covered at the "Scienceblogs" I came across this post that looks rather realistically about the problems of the recently developed prophylactic pill that may "help" prevent the spread of infection. Among other things noted, people are notorious for not taking pills as prescribed. I am skeptical that it will turn out to be an unmitigated success due to that and due to its inevitable use in convincing people that they are safe to sleep around without the use of a condom. If it works as advertised, it will work in some cases but its use won't be entirely successful. The post also talks realistically about problems that even what would seem to be a more reliable means of prevention, inoculations, are problematic.
And it is the reason that when it comes to the real and undeniable results of sexual promiscuity, sleeping around, screwing around, one is required to pretend that the massive science documenting those results is wrong. Or, failing that, to pretend that the science doesn't exist. Of course the results of promiscuous sex are well documented even in the popular culture, known to just about anyone as soon as they find out what sex is. Pregnancy, in the case of straight sex, infections in any instance when an exchange of bodily fluids is possible. No one who has an understanding of the most basic biology of the matter can misunderstand that. Only you are required to pretend that you don't understand it, you are to suppress that knowledge.
The conflict between some of the most obvious, relevant and life saving science that identifies sleeping around as a dangerous practice* and that grooviness requires a breezy, insouciant, contra-scientific requirement to approve of sexual promiscuity proves that the coercion to be in step with fashion wins out over science and personal experience among the "rational class". Their objects of worship, their substitute state of grace, are, arguably, more powerful than those of the fundamentalist religion that leads unfashionable people to deny the far more remote reality of evolution.
The denial of science by the "sex pos" hucksters and their dupes is a far greater denial of known reality than the denial of science by those who will never experience or observe evolution. I doubt there is a sentient adult who has not know of, observed or experienced the negative consequences of sexual promiscuity.
The arithmetic of infection with STDs isn't complex, your chances of infection increase with both the numbers of people you have sex with AND with the number of people the person or people you have sex with have had sex with. This is the same as with any communicable disease. The "sex pos" people who deny that is the case are at least as stupid and irresponsible as the anti-vaxx people. The result of both practices will be larger numbers of people contracting preventable diseases and the endangerment of other people, some of whom have the misfortune of being married or in what they believe is a monogamous relationship with someone who engages in a known risk factor to them.
The "sex pos" people are as irresponsible as the Muslim fundamentalists who prevent vaccination programs because they encourage a risky behavior, they recruit people to turn their bodies into the vector of infection. The few ways we have of reducing the risks of sleeping around, chlamydia vaccines, various drugs that may reduce risk of other infections**, don't anticipate the evolution of viruses into new pathogens. The time between the evolution of HIV as a human pathogen and the first conclusions that something was happening in gay men was long enough for a catastrophic, world-wide pandemic to have developed.
IT IS AFTER PEOPLE BECOME SICK AND DIE THAT NEW PATHOGENS ARE EVEN NOTICED BY THE SCIENTISTS WHO ARE LOOKING FOR THINGS LIKE THAT. In the case of HIV-AIDS and antibiotic resistant forms of old fashioned STDs, those incubate in the bodies of people who have been exposed to them through people having multiple sex partners, especially those who have had many. Yet that is what "sex pos" encourages, especially to young people who can reasonably claim to not have seen the results of that behavior, yet. It's too bad that they will probably have to experience it themselves to understand that they were being lied to, often by old people in the pay of the sex industry or those who are desperate to remain trendy and groovy well after their days of finding non-paying sex partners in large numbers are past.
There is as much if not more denial of science and what it means for people and their lives among what passes, pathetically, as hipsters these days as there is among the creationists and the dupes of FOX, it's just different science that is denied. And the difference in what is acceptable to who isn't based on anything more serious than in-crowd identity or fundamentalist coercion.
* There is so much science done on this and the basic facts of it are so well known to the people who are reading this that it is ridiculous to keep pointing it out. I doubt that among people old enough to remember the 1980s and 90s those facts aren't known except among the least intelligent and most willfully ignorant. Though anyone who knows that science and denies it probably shouldn't qualify as being smarter than them.
** In looking to see how this issue is covered at the "Scienceblogs" I came across this post that looks rather realistically about the problems of the recently developed prophylactic pill that may "help" prevent the spread of infection. Among other things noted, people are notorious for not taking pills as prescribed. I am skeptical that it will turn out to be an unmitigated success due to that and due to its inevitable use in convincing people that they are safe to sleep around without the use of a condom. If it works as advertised, it will work in some cases but its use won't be entirely successful. The post also talks realistically about problems that even what would seem to be a more reliable means of prevention, inoculations, are problematic.
Sunday, May 18, 2014
Charles Tomlinson Griffes Three Tone Pictures op. 5
Denver Oldham Piano,
Of all of the composers who were heavily influenced by Debussy I think Griffes was the one who most successfully avoided becoming entirely submerged under that ocean.
Score
Perhaps Legacy Admissions at Harvard Are At The Bottom of This
I hadn't paid that much attention to the "Black Mass" stunt announced by the Harvard Extension Cultural Studies Club until it was called off, sort of. Like PZ Myer's ersatz "Great Desecration" the stunt is supposed to center around the desecration of a consecrated communion wafer, an act that is intentionally offensive to Catholics and what they hold to be sacred. I strongly suspect that, whatever communion wafer is used when this kind of thing happens, it would likely not be consecrated. I'm almost certain it probably wouldn't have been, just as I am almost certain that the one in Myer's stunt was not. So we are left with the intentionally offensive act.
Oddly, for a bunch of Harvard students, supposedly representative of the cream of intellectual potential in their generation, the kiddies who commissioned the "Black Mass" seem to be upset that people who were intended to be offended got offended by their adolescent level attention getting. Perhaps someone at Harvard should inform these kids that that's how giving intentional offense works. You do something to offend, those you intend to offend are offended. To pretend to confusion as to why they were offended by feigning an innocent desire to merely satisfy intellectual curiosity is a lame trick teenagers have been pulling for generations. No, kiddies, by the time you're in college, it's time that you stopped pretending to not understand what you're doing. Grow up. Perhaps they only teach that at land-grant universities, these days. Places that don't harbor the kinds of clubs that the Ivy League day care centers for the elite do. The extension of adolescence well into adulthood, if not right through senescence is a luxury more common to those with too much money.
As is common with acts of intentional offensiveness, those marked to be offended seldom ask to be offended, in this case Catholics. That so many on the pseudo-left are both delighted that they were offended while pretending to be outraged that they are offended only points to their immaturity, similar to that of the kids at the Harvard Extension Cultural Studies Club. As a matter of political realism, I'll point out that the Holy Hour held to counter the "Satanic" stunt was standing room only. The planned for crowd at the "Black Mass" was never intended to be more than a few hundred at most. It's a pretty stupid political calculation that needlessly offends more people than it attracts. But such is the pseudo-left's political arithmetic. I am pretty disgusted that, with the response of the "left" that leaves conservatives an open field to gain the good will of those so offended.
In my response to an article chiding the Catholic Church for its response, I said this:
Oh, for crying out loud, the central aspect of this, the organizing of the stunt by Harvard Extension School Cultural Studies Club was juvenile thrill seeking through that most superficial of cultural acts, being all naughty and transgressive by offending other people believed to represent some kind of oppressive authority. Well, what a surprise, an act that is intended to be offensive, offended an got all involved lots of attention. While there is a lot in this "eulogy" that is worth thinking about, one thing that isn't addressed is that of all of those involved, the Catholic hierarchy and laity, those designated as the offended, didn't choose to start the entire affair. I'm sure that the Cardinal and others would have rather spent their time on something productive rather than addressing an adolescent attention getting and thrill seeking stunt.
The real harm, the real violation of Jesus is done by the dogmas taught at the Harvard Business School, is Law School, other Harvard entities like the Kennedy School of Government, which oppress the least among us for the benefit of the class that goes to Harvard as legacy admissions, the ones who make Harvard's endowment so obscenely enormous while schools within easy walking distance or a quick subway ride away, those which try to serve poor people, are dying for lack of funds. The real violation of the Body of Christ happens by the preferential option for the rich that is taught at Harvard and other elite institutions, something which any group, Catholic or "Satanist" or even those within the Harvard community would not be wasting their time addressing and, heaven help us, actually doing something to help. And I'd include Boston College and Holy Cross among those who should look at who their teaching prefers, some of their product is as truly Satanic as the "Justices" and lawyers and government officials [not to mention businessmen and women, economists, bankers, etc.] who come out of Harvard.
If you want to read the exchange that led to with a few atheists, or, as I suspect, one atheist using sock puppets, the people who are blathering the most about this, online, here's the link.
Update: Allergy season, benadryl, the editing is the first casualty. Sorry for the more the usual screw ups and overdependence on spell check to fix things to bad results.
Oddly, for a bunch of Harvard students, supposedly representative of the cream of intellectual potential in their generation, the kiddies who commissioned the "Black Mass" seem to be upset that people who were intended to be offended got offended by their adolescent level attention getting. Perhaps someone at Harvard should inform these kids that that's how giving intentional offense works. You do something to offend, those you intend to offend are offended. To pretend to confusion as to why they were offended by feigning an innocent desire to merely satisfy intellectual curiosity is a lame trick teenagers have been pulling for generations. No, kiddies, by the time you're in college, it's time that you stopped pretending to not understand what you're doing. Grow up. Perhaps they only teach that at land-grant universities, these days. Places that don't harbor the kinds of clubs that the Ivy League day care centers for the elite do. The extension of adolescence well into adulthood, if not right through senescence is a luxury more common to those with too much money.
As is common with acts of intentional offensiveness, those marked to be offended seldom ask to be offended, in this case Catholics. That so many on the pseudo-left are both delighted that they were offended while pretending to be outraged that they are offended only points to their immaturity, similar to that of the kids at the Harvard Extension Cultural Studies Club. As a matter of political realism, I'll point out that the Holy Hour held to counter the "Satanic" stunt was standing room only. The planned for crowd at the "Black Mass" was never intended to be more than a few hundred at most. It's a pretty stupid political calculation that needlessly offends more people than it attracts. But such is the pseudo-left's political arithmetic. I am pretty disgusted that, with the response of the "left" that leaves conservatives an open field to gain the good will of those so offended.
In my response to an article chiding the Catholic Church for its response, I said this:
Oh, for crying out loud, the central aspect of this, the organizing of the stunt by Harvard Extension School Cultural Studies Club was juvenile thrill seeking through that most superficial of cultural acts, being all naughty and transgressive by offending other people believed to represent some kind of oppressive authority. Well, what a surprise, an act that is intended to be offensive, offended an got all involved lots of attention. While there is a lot in this "eulogy" that is worth thinking about, one thing that isn't addressed is that of all of those involved, the Catholic hierarchy and laity, those designated as the offended, didn't choose to start the entire affair. I'm sure that the Cardinal and others would have rather spent their time on something productive rather than addressing an adolescent attention getting and thrill seeking stunt.
The real harm, the real violation of Jesus is done by the dogmas taught at the Harvard Business School, is Law School, other Harvard entities like the Kennedy School of Government, which oppress the least among us for the benefit of the class that goes to Harvard as legacy admissions, the ones who make Harvard's endowment so obscenely enormous while schools within easy walking distance or a quick subway ride away, those which try to serve poor people, are dying for lack of funds. The real violation of the Body of Christ happens by the preferential option for the rich that is taught at Harvard and other elite institutions, something which any group, Catholic or "Satanist" or even those within the Harvard community would not be wasting their time addressing and, heaven help us, actually doing something to help. And I'd include Boston College and Holy Cross among those who should look at who their teaching prefers, some of their product is as truly Satanic as the "Justices" and lawyers and government officials [not to mention businessmen and women, economists, bankers, etc.] who come out of Harvard.
If you want to read the exchange that led to with a few atheists, or, as I suspect, one atheist using sock puppets, the people who are blathering the most about this, online, here's the link.
Update: Allergy season, benadryl, the editing is the first casualty. Sorry for the more the usual screw ups and overdependence on spell check to fix things to bad results.
Saturday, May 17, 2014
Foreshortened Lives: Kevin Oldham Symphony for Organ
Kevin Oldham was one of the composers who died of AIDS, he was also the one who began The Estate Project, to collect and preserve the work of composers and artits who were dying of AIDS
When the Estate Project for Artists with AIDS was established in 1991, its first public face was a composer. Thirty-two year-old Kevin Oldham appeared on the cover of The New York Times on December 27, 1992, in an article announcing this new initiative to assist artists who face foreshortened lives in planning for the care and preservation of their creative legacies.
"Whether you stay alive or not seems to be the trivial part," Oldham told The Times. "It's your work itself that must have a life of its own. If I can make sure that my music will continue to have life, that seems to be the more important consideration."
Kevin Oldham Symphony for Organ
Kevin Oldham died when he was 33, I never knew him, different musical circles.
Here is an article about just the composers who were included, and a lot of others could have been (see the list of organists and the comments about that). I have counted the number of people I knew who died of AIDS and gave up at about 70. It was just too depressing to remember, almost all of them of them young, in the prime of life, as they say.
Charles Tomlinson Griffes Sonata
Thomas Hunter (?) piano
This sonata is, by wide agreement, the greatest work of Charles Tomlinson Griffes who died in the influenza pandemic in 1920. He was 35. His relativly small body of very distinguished works shows that he was one of the great composers of his generation, someone whose work showed continual growth and development. Like all great music, in the hands of good players, it will show different things. Some, like that last one, I don't agree with but the piece is still there. This piece was a major departure from Griffes' earlier music and we can only guess where he was headed with it.
This is a very fine performance that presents things about it that other very fine performances don't and which doesn't contain everything those performances do. In that it shows how a great piece can contain different meanings, that the music is a collaboration between the composer and performers. And that leaves out the third participant, the listener. It's the performer's responsibility to try to find what the composer put there and to communicate that and that is as much an act of creative imagination as the original composition of it was, though the primary responsibility of the composer comprises the greatest act of the three. This pianist fulfilled his part, very well.
Score
Believing "Sex Pos" Propaganda Is More Likely To Kill You Than Creationism Is
That I live in the country and seldom go to cities anymore, that I'm an old man, means that I don't often talk to young LGBT people as I did Friday. What I found out was a reminder that my generation's hard lessons learned from watching a large percentage of our friends and family die of HIV-AIDS may as well have been the Black Death for young people today. Nothing I've heard outside of the risk to all life from global warming and environmental destruction has been so profoundly depressing as what these young people told me they believe about AIDS. The porn-prostitution industry, the columnists (who are often in the pay of the porn-prostitution industry) the "sex pos" pimps and others had convinced these college students that promiscuity is perfectly safe and, indeed, a positive good and that it had nothing to do with the rise and spread of AIDS. It isn't because these people are stupid, they are all good students who are interested in progressive politics.
I got heated responses when I told them that promiscuity had everything to do with the AIDS epidemic, that it would have spread a lot more slowly, if at all, if men had not been promiscuous, that, contrary to the line of tripe they'd been sold, needle exchange was a relatively minor venue of infection. Of the dozens of men and several women I knew who died of AIDS, not one of them was an IV drug user, though one of the was married to one.
While I know that these same young folks would be outraged by the denial of evolution as a violation of scientific fact they had no problem with denying the far, far more certain science conducted by institutions such as the Center for Disease Control and the World Health Organization, science which is far more important to them than whether or not we evolved from a common ancestor we share with chimpanzees or bonobos.
This campaign of lies is directly traceable to the media, to places such as Salon, Alternet, to blogs peddling "sex pos" which these kids read. As the advertising industry long ago proved, it's the easiest thing in the world to sell false information using sex and the media didn't take long to figure out they could use the same fact. Through such media, young people have learned a series of slogans that are as wrong as those peddled by the Discovery Institute while being far more dangerous to them. And it is forbidden on the alleged left to talk about that violation of fact, of that violation of science because, unlike an issue of minor importance in these peoples' lives, like evolution, well, it's all about sex and those vulgar right-wingers, "Xians", people with cooties are against promiscuity. I really don't think there is much more to it than that mixed with the juvenile desire to have sex with lots of people, pretending there are no consequences to that or, as was true, traditionally of straight me, that any consequences for that would fall most on other people.
That was a possible delusion to maintain when penicillin and other cheap antibiotics could take care of most of the infections you were bound to get by sleeping around, though there were still things like hepatitis and pregnancy. But, with the knowledge learned from the AIDS pandemic, which is continuing and killing people around the world, today, that short period of breezy innocence shouldn't be possible.
One of the kids in the discussion, during the assertion that needle exchange, not sexual promiscuity is to blame for AIDS, mentioned hemophiliacs who were infected. Apparently some columnists and/or "sex pos" bloggers are using them to lie about the overwhelmingly predominant role that sexual promiscuity played in spreading HIV.
I pointed out that no one predicted that something like AIDS was going to result from the would-be freedom of the 1970s and even in their naive belief that drugs had taken care of that problem, there is no reason that the same medium in which HIV mutated into a pathological form and spread, the bodies of those engaged in world-wide promiscuity, won't give rise to other deadly pathogens, perhaps some more deadly and even more intractable than HIV has been. The publishing industry, the broadcast, cabloid and online media are engaged in an anti-scientific campaign that is far more dangerous and consequential than the one that the creationism industry is. Only it's supposed to be all right because it's our side that's doing it, not theirs.
Update: I have decided to publish this comment because it is such a good example of the kind of lies that have come to be believed by younger people, pushed by professional scribblers such as the one who wrote it. I will comment on it more when I get the chance to give it the response it deserves.
I got heated responses when I told them that promiscuity had everything to do with the AIDS epidemic, that it would have spread a lot more slowly, if at all, if men had not been promiscuous, that, contrary to the line of tripe they'd been sold, needle exchange was a relatively minor venue of infection. Of the dozens of men and several women I knew who died of AIDS, not one of them was an IV drug user, though one of the was married to one.
While I know that these same young folks would be outraged by the denial of evolution as a violation of scientific fact they had no problem with denying the far, far more certain science conducted by institutions such as the Center for Disease Control and the World Health Organization, science which is far more important to them than whether or not we evolved from a common ancestor we share with chimpanzees or bonobos.
This campaign of lies is directly traceable to the media, to places such as Salon, Alternet, to blogs peddling "sex pos" which these kids read. As the advertising industry long ago proved, it's the easiest thing in the world to sell false information using sex and the media didn't take long to figure out they could use the same fact. Through such media, young people have learned a series of slogans that are as wrong as those peddled by the Discovery Institute while being far more dangerous to them. And it is forbidden on the alleged left to talk about that violation of fact, of that violation of science because, unlike an issue of minor importance in these peoples' lives, like evolution, well, it's all about sex and those vulgar right-wingers, "Xians", people with cooties are against promiscuity. I really don't think there is much more to it than that mixed with the juvenile desire to have sex with lots of people, pretending there are no consequences to that or, as was true, traditionally of straight me, that any consequences for that would fall most on other people.
That was a possible delusion to maintain when penicillin and other cheap antibiotics could take care of most of the infections you were bound to get by sleeping around, though there were still things like hepatitis and pregnancy. But, with the knowledge learned from the AIDS pandemic, which is continuing and killing people around the world, today, that short period of breezy innocence shouldn't be possible.
One of the kids in the discussion, during the assertion that needle exchange, not sexual promiscuity is to blame for AIDS, mentioned hemophiliacs who were infected. Apparently some columnists and/or "sex pos" bloggers are using them to lie about the overwhelmingly predominant role that sexual promiscuity played in spreading HIV.
I pointed out that no one predicted that something like AIDS was going to result from the would-be freedom of the 1970s and even in their naive belief that drugs had taken care of that problem, there is no reason that the same medium in which HIV mutated into a pathological form and spread, the bodies of those engaged in world-wide promiscuity, won't give rise to other deadly pathogens, perhaps some more deadly and even more intractable than HIV has been. The publishing industry, the broadcast, cabloid and online media are engaged in an anti-scientific campaign that is far more dangerous and consequential than the one that the creationism industry is. Only it's supposed to be all right because it's our side that's doing it, not theirs.
Update: I have decided to publish this comment because it is such a good example of the kind of lies that have come to be believed by younger people, pushed by professional scribblers such as the one who wrote it. I will comment on it more when I get the chance to give it the response it deserves.
steve simelsMay 17, 2014 at 4:48 PM
Oh puhleeze. The usual half-truths and out and out paranoid pulled out of your ass bullshit ("the columnists (who are often in the pay of the porn-prostitution industry").
Here's a clue, Sparky. HIV is a really difficult bug to get -- you have to really, really work hard at it to get infected. Unfortunately, in the 70s and 80s, far too many people -- mostly homosexual men, and the occasional straight woman who was unlucky enough to be shtupping a homosexual man and/or IV drug user -- were working really really hard at it.
Those days are long gone, thank the Invisible God Being who doesn't do shit, and here in 2014, the average 20 something in a First World Country who engages in the average amount of non-promiscuous casual sex is about as likely to get infected with HIV as I am to be stomped on by Godzilla on the New Jersey Turnpike.
And please, spare me the sob stories about your dead friends. I lived in NYC back then, and I lost just as many as you. Schmuck.
Here's a clue, Sparky. HIV is a really difficult bug to get -- you have to really, really work hard at it to get infected. Unfortunately, in the 70s and 80s, far too many people -- mostly homosexual men, and the occasional straight woman who was unlucky enough to be shtupping a homosexual man and/or IV drug user -- were working really really hard at it.
Those days are long gone, thank the Invisible God Being who doesn't do shit, and here in 2014, the average 20 something in a First World Country who engages in the average amount of non-promiscuous casual sex is about as likely to get infected with HIV as I am to be stomped on by Godzilla on the New Jersey Turnpike.
And please, spare me the sob stories about your dead friends. I lived in NYC back then, and I lost just as many as you. Schmuck.
Friday, May 16, 2014
The Ear Is Faster Than The Eye
This is fun to try to follow, a transcription of John Coltrane's solo of Countdown. I'm a pretty good sight reader and, like everyone, I'm familiar with the solo but I lose track every time I try to read it.
Why Would These Be Provocative Questions?
Is a tee-shirt that says, "So many Christians, never enough Lions," morally different from one that would say, "So many Jews, never enough Zyklon-B"? Why? And why is the first one acceptable whereas the unacceptability of the second one obvious? It isn't because recent history has not produced the murders of many Christians because it has.
Thursday, May 15, 2014
Stravinsky The Our Father, Ave Maria and Credo in Old Church Slavonic
Just because of the comment I read somewhere else just now.
Mozart, Sonata C minor K 457, Ivo Sillamaa, Fortepiano
I should try playing again. It's been a long recovery from my accident last winter.
Baptizing Aliens, etc.
I don't know if Carl Sagan really said it or not because I haven't been able to find the source of it, more on that in a minute, but I got into an argument at one of the allegedly leftist blogs over someone saying that he said it. The alleged quote was, to the effect, that as soon as extraterrestrial life was contacted, it would be the death of religion. Which, if it were true, would be one of the long series of predictions that this or that would be the end of religious belief. The end of religious belief is the topic of so many prophecies and precognitions from a group that is, officially against both, it is remarkable how obsessed those guys and gals are with trying to convince themselves that their atheist millennium is just around the next corner.
As I recall the argument, the sentiment that the existence of extraterrestrial life would be proof, positive that religion was the bunk was shared by a number of others, I would guess it was at Eschaton where that is something of the house religion. But what, I asked, if the extraterrestrial life, presumably much more technically advanced than we are - they'd be the ones coming here since we definitely can't get there - were religious? Which doesn't seem to be a possibility they accounted for in their speculations since they obviously don't believe it's possible to be religious and smart. I proposed that some form of extraterrestrial life could have faculties of thought that made what is unavailable to us in a form that can be processed by us with OUR science as obvious as two resulting when you add one and one.
My recollection is that the other participants in the argument didn't like the idea but, since we haven't had the first bit of evidence that "other life" is there, it's not something they could really argue with. Of course, if I'd wanted to be really mean I could have pointed out that their "extraterrestrials" were entirely the result of their imaginations, just as all of those that their hero, Carl Sagan, was want to invent were his imaginary friends. Unlike any real "other life" they were limited by what those guys could and desired them to be. In that they are like many of the more anthropomorphic gods of the kind that atheists love to believe are the sum total of human conceptions of God. They didn't want their extraterrestrials to be religious so they merely assumed they were atheists - just as so many online atheists seem to want their Copernicus or Galileo to have been atheists when they certainly were Christians and Catholics. And they certainly don't want the God we believe in to be those things that God was described as being as early as the book of Exodus, inconceivable to human imagination, infinitely beyond our powers of conception.
Though I can imagine what they said, having read their group-think so often, I haven't bothered to go look at the atheists response to the story that Pope Francis said that if an extraterrestrial asked him to be baptized that he would baptize them.
So here's how Francis tried to illustrate that point on Monday, with a much more modern example:
That was unthinkable. If – for example - tomorrow an expedition of Martians came, and some of them came to us, here... Martians, right? Green, with that long nose and big ears, just like children paint them... And one says, 'But I want to be baptized!' What would happen?"
What would happen? They'd get baptized, that's what would happen. He goes on:
"When the Lord shows us the way, who are we to say, 'No, Lord, it is not prudent! No, lets do it this way'... Who are we to close doors? In the early Church, even today, there is the ministry of the ostiary [usher]. And what did the ostiary do? He opened the door, received the people, allowed them to pass. But it was never the ministry of the closed door, never."
The Vatican's astronomer — the same one who dismissed 'Intelligent Design' as 'bad theology' — said in 2010 that he'd baptize an alien because "any entity – no matter how many tentacles it has – has a soul." But, again, only if they request it. So glad that's settled. Now all we have to do is wait.
The first thing that jumped out at me in that story was that in both the Pope's and Fr. Guy Consolmagno, the astronomer said was that the decision to baptize an alien would be the decision of the alien to be baptized. So, as we can see, these two Catholic clergymen could conceive of one having free will that may or may not be in line with their own beliefs. As I've gone over here so often recently, many of the sciency atheists don't believe that such freedom of thought is even possible. The Catholic's imagination of extraterrestrials that have free will that we are bound to respect, that they are free to choose and that their inherent dignity as a fellow being created by God would compel them to include them within the Christian religion strikes me as enormously more generous than the atheist imagination of them.
The second thing that struck me was Consolmagno saying that "any entity ... has a soul" which contradicts what we were taught in catechism where we were told that only human beings have a soul. I never believed that, I couldn't believe that animals didn't have souls. Some of my recent reading seems to indicate that idea came from Descarte and, ironically, today, was part of his conception of living beings as machines, something that is insisted on, these days, most stridently by atheists. Only the atheists want those ghosts out of their machine entirely.
-----
In looking for that quote from Sagan I was struck by how, contrary to the presentation of him as being something of a pacifist in the atheist war against religion, he was continually and stridently, arrogantly and dismissively hostile to religion. That was true even as he was presenting his Cosmos and it, apparently, became more true after that. He coupled his dismissal of religion with a ridiculously romantic presentation of what science is, how scientists behave* and the inevitably beneficial results of science. I think that, now that the mantle of Sagan has descended on Neil Degrasse Tyson, he's doing pretty much the same thing, only with a bit more of care being taken to preserve deniability that his anti-religious goal isn't really there. You don't have to be a creationist to notice the real goal of the Seth Macfarlane, Ann Druyan, NDT Cosmos is not really the promotion of science so much as it is a promotion of scientism and the hostility to Christianity and other religions that has been a feature of all of their work in the past.
-----
It really is important to the neo-atheist effort that religion has to, in each and every case, be the villain. As I noticed in the discussion of a recent Salon piece asserting that gay marriage was not in conflict with The Bible, it was obvious that the atheists, who seemed to have more to say on it than anyone else, couldn't stand the idea that The Bible wasn't in conflict with marriage equality. It was obvious that they cared entirely less about gay rights than they did about their hatred of Christianity and other religion. And that is what motivates the kind of atheists who make hatred of religion one of their central activities, the kind of atheists we hear from. They don't care nearly as much about science as they do their hatred of religion. On a practical level, that makes them unreliable allies in the struggle for rights and progress, the reason that they are always trying to distract us from the real goals with their divisive and futile war against religion.
* This quote, given to a CSICOP gathering was rather hilariously hypocritical, considering what happened during CSICOP's one and only bungled scientific investigation.
In science it often happens that scientists say, "You know that's a really good argument; my position is mistaken," and then they would actually change their minds and you never hear that old view from them again. They really do it. It doesn't happen as often as it should, because scientists are human and change is sometimes painful. But it happens every day. I cannot recall the last time something like that happened in politics or religion.
Considering that Sagan was there as the sTARBABY scandal happened, a witness to how CSICOP's co-founder, Paul Kurtz and his fellow "fellows and councilors" George Abell and Marvin Zelen massively screwed up and covered up, conducting a campaign of slander and expulsion against Dennis Rawlins, the guy who understood the problem AND WHO WARNED Kurtz, Abell and Zelen that they were screwing up and, when they lied about what they were doing, tried to set the record straight. Obvioulsy, Kurtz, Abell and Zelen didn't welcome being told they were wrong. They continued to behave badly, with the full knowledge of and acquiescence of the CSICOP "fellows and councilors" for a number of years, as you can read in the first link in this paragraph.
Rawlins pointed out that Sagan, a member of CSICOP would have certainly understood the problem and would have been a better person to address it, at the time. So Sagan saying that, to that group, which kicked Rawlins out over his crime of scientific honesty, several years after the scandal was known to him and to them was extremely hypocritical. As a general statement it is so absurdly romantic about the way that scientists act, especially in protection of the basis of their scientific and professional reputations, as ready to use dishonest means to suppress anything that endangers them as any other profession, that it's amazing that Sagan could have had the gall to say it. To say it to the very people who brought about the scandal by a witness to it is jaw-dropping hypocrisy.
As I recall the argument, the sentiment that the existence of extraterrestrial life would be proof, positive that religion was the bunk was shared by a number of others, I would guess it was at Eschaton where that is something of the house religion. But what, I asked, if the extraterrestrial life, presumably much more technically advanced than we are - they'd be the ones coming here since we definitely can't get there - were religious? Which doesn't seem to be a possibility they accounted for in their speculations since they obviously don't believe it's possible to be religious and smart. I proposed that some form of extraterrestrial life could have faculties of thought that made what is unavailable to us in a form that can be processed by us with OUR science as obvious as two resulting when you add one and one.
My recollection is that the other participants in the argument didn't like the idea but, since we haven't had the first bit of evidence that "other life" is there, it's not something they could really argue with. Of course, if I'd wanted to be really mean I could have pointed out that their "extraterrestrials" were entirely the result of their imaginations, just as all of those that their hero, Carl Sagan, was want to invent were his imaginary friends. Unlike any real "other life" they were limited by what those guys could and desired them to be. In that they are like many of the more anthropomorphic gods of the kind that atheists love to believe are the sum total of human conceptions of God. They didn't want their extraterrestrials to be religious so they merely assumed they were atheists - just as so many online atheists seem to want their Copernicus or Galileo to have been atheists when they certainly were Christians and Catholics. And they certainly don't want the God we believe in to be those things that God was described as being as early as the book of Exodus, inconceivable to human imagination, infinitely beyond our powers of conception.
Though I can imagine what they said, having read their group-think so often, I haven't bothered to go look at the atheists response to the story that Pope Francis said that if an extraterrestrial asked him to be baptized that he would baptize them.
So here's how Francis tried to illustrate that point on Monday, with a much more modern example:
That was unthinkable. If – for example - tomorrow an expedition of Martians came, and some of them came to us, here... Martians, right? Green, with that long nose and big ears, just like children paint them... And one says, 'But I want to be baptized!' What would happen?"
What would happen? They'd get baptized, that's what would happen. He goes on:
"When the Lord shows us the way, who are we to say, 'No, Lord, it is not prudent! No, lets do it this way'... Who are we to close doors? In the early Church, even today, there is the ministry of the ostiary [usher]. And what did the ostiary do? He opened the door, received the people, allowed them to pass. But it was never the ministry of the closed door, never."
The Vatican's astronomer — the same one who dismissed 'Intelligent Design' as 'bad theology' — said in 2010 that he'd baptize an alien because "any entity – no matter how many tentacles it has – has a soul." But, again, only if they request it. So glad that's settled. Now all we have to do is wait.
The first thing that jumped out at me in that story was that in both the Pope's and Fr. Guy Consolmagno, the astronomer said was that the decision to baptize an alien would be the decision of the alien to be baptized. So, as we can see, these two Catholic clergymen could conceive of one having free will that may or may not be in line with their own beliefs. As I've gone over here so often recently, many of the sciency atheists don't believe that such freedom of thought is even possible. The Catholic's imagination of extraterrestrials that have free will that we are bound to respect, that they are free to choose and that their inherent dignity as a fellow being created by God would compel them to include them within the Christian religion strikes me as enormously more generous than the atheist imagination of them.
The second thing that struck me was Consolmagno saying that "any entity ... has a soul" which contradicts what we were taught in catechism where we were told that only human beings have a soul. I never believed that, I couldn't believe that animals didn't have souls. Some of my recent reading seems to indicate that idea came from Descarte and, ironically, today, was part of his conception of living beings as machines, something that is insisted on, these days, most stridently by atheists. Only the atheists want those ghosts out of their machine entirely.
-----
In looking for that quote from Sagan I was struck by how, contrary to the presentation of him as being something of a pacifist in the atheist war against religion, he was continually and stridently, arrogantly and dismissively hostile to religion. That was true even as he was presenting his Cosmos and it, apparently, became more true after that. He coupled his dismissal of religion with a ridiculously romantic presentation of what science is, how scientists behave* and the inevitably beneficial results of science. I think that, now that the mantle of Sagan has descended on Neil Degrasse Tyson, he's doing pretty much the same thing, only with a bit more of care being taken to preserve deniability that his anti-religious goal isn't really there. You don't have to be a creationist to notice the real goal of the Seth Macfarlane, Ann Druyan, NDT Cosmos is not really the promotion of science so much as it is a promotion of scientism and the hostility to Christianity and other religions that has been a feature of all of their work in the past.
-----
It really is important to the neo-atheist effort that religion has to, in each and every case, be the villain. As I noticed in the discussion of a recent Salon piece asserting that gay marriage was not in conflict with The Bible, it was obvious that the atheists, who seemed to have more to say on it than anyone else, couldn't stand the idea that The Bible wasn't in conflict with marriage equality. It was obvious that they cared entirely less about gay rights than they did about their hatred of Christianity and other religion. And that is what motivates the kind of atheists who make hatred of religion one of their central activities, the kind of atheists we hear from. They don't care nearly as much about science as they do their hatred of religion. On a practical level, that makes them unreliable allies in the struggle for rights and progress, the reason that they are always trying to distract us from the real goals with their divisive and futile war against religion.
* This quote, given to a CSICOP gathering was rather hilariously hypocritical, considering what happened during CSICOP's one and only bungled scientific investigation.
In science it often happens that scientists say, "You know that's a really good argument; my position is mistaken," and then they would actually change their minds and you never hear that old view from them again. They really do it. It doesn't happen as often as it should, because scientists are human and change is sometimes painful. But it happens every day. I cannot recall the last time something like that happened in politics or religion.
Considering that Sagan was there as the sTARBABY scandal happened, a witness to how CSICOP's co-founder, Paul Kurtz and his fellow "fellows and councilors" George Abell and Marvin Zelen massively screwed up and covered up, conducting a campaign of slander and expulsion against Dennis Rawlins, the guy who understood the problem AND WHO WARNED Kurtz, Abell and Zelen that they were screwing up and, when they lied about what they were doing, tried to set the record straight. Obvioulsy, Kurtz, Abell and Zelen didn't welcome being told they were wrong. They continued to behave badly, with the full knowledge of and acquiescence of the CSICOP "fellows and councilors" for a number of years, as you can read in the first link in this paragraph.
Rawlins pointed out that Sagan, a member of CSICOP would have certainly understood the problem and would have been a better person to address it, at the time. So Sagan saying that, to that group, which kicked Rawlins out over his crime of scientific honesty, several years after the scandal was known to him and to them was extremely hypocritical. As a general statement it is so absurdly romantic about the way that scientists act, especially in protection of the basis of their scientific and professional reputations, as ready to use dishonest means to suppress anything that endangers them as any other profession, that it's amazing that Sagan could have had the gall to say it. To say it to the very people who brought about the scandal by a witness to it is jaw-dropping hypocrisy.
Wednesday, May 14, 2014
Got To Plant Carrots and Beets So Here's a Recently Made Comment on Another Blog
I think that Tyson is being a bit too cute about his alleged "accommodation". He doesn't come right out and slam religion but that is the end of what I've seen of it online. It is certainly how it is being taken all over the internet, certainly at Alternet. Considering that scientists have been a lot more important in inhibiting innovation and progress in science, they certainly have had a bigger hand in producing intentional fraud and ideology masquerading as science, you would think a series dealing with impediments to science would pay more attention to that than to the quite often entirely mythical impediment that religion has been to science. I suspect that any series produced by professional atheists such as Seth Macfarlane and Ann Druyan (she and Sagan met through the production of his "Cosmos" as I recall) is unlikely to avoid distorting that history. I don't think that Tyson, who has been working in that area of sci-showbiz for quite a number of years now, is unaware of what was likely to result. I think he's just trying to have it both ways, participating in the neo-atheist fad while hedging his bets in case it goes out of style. I think that Larry Krauss was doing the same thing, though he has certainly put all his money on the fad lasting.
I haven't trusted a TV science show since Nova went bad about a decade or so ago. And Tyson was part of that as well. I remember when I first became aware of Sagan, on Nova programs where he talked about his area of scientific competence, I thought he was fascinating. Then he went on to become The Greatest Genius In The World, gassing on about stuff he didn't know anything about, producing intellectual atrocities such as The Amniotic Universe and The Dragons of Eden and before long I couldn't stand the guy. His Cosmos, whenever it touched on the history of science, was mostly a rehashing of old-line Brit anti-Catholic, anti-religious bromides and slogans. When you look at what people such as Copernicus, Galileo, etc. actually said, what their lives actually were and their relationship with the Catholic church was, the show-biz presentation is as much of a falsification of reality as the worst of creationism. I know that's not supposed to matter because it is mere history and that a sci-guy like Sagan or Tyson pushes false information is, meh. But we happen to be people and our history is as much vital information necessary to understanding our lives and our position in the universe as theoretical physics is. Considering how much of theoretical physics turns out to be wrong and, based on speculations on fragmentary information it's bound to turn out lots of wrong guesses, history, based on a far more certain, far richer and far less ambiguous range of evidence, can tell us a lot more about us than science can. I think it's probably a more serious matter with more consequences to lie about history than it is about many of the issues that we are supposed to be continually in a swivet about.
I have gone over this before but the most serious suppression of science in the past century was the suppression of genetics in the Soviet Union by atheists and the most serious crimes committed in the name of science were those that grew out of eugenics, invented by viciously anti-religious people, Galton, Haeckel, etc. Not to mention the use of science to produce weapons of mass destruction, just about every one of those people I know of were atheists as well. It would seem to me that looking to see if an ideology that so often includes a denial of and refutation of morality mixes salubriously with the potent efficacity of science might be a bit more important than rehashing the old line Brit Catholic bashing accounts of those two life long Catholics, Copernicus and Galileo. That's especially true since Catholics haven't been in the business of offing people for heresy for quite a long time now, whereas the history of atheist regimes murdering scientists has happened within living memory. I suspect it goes on today in places like North Korea and China to little notice by western popular media.
I haven't trusted a TV science show since Nova went bad about a decade or so ago. And Tyson was part of that as well. I remember when I first became aware of Sagan, on Nova programs where he talked about his area of scientific competence, I thought he was fascinating. Then he went on to become The Greatest Genius In The World, gassing on about stuff he didn't know anything about, producing intellectual atrocities such as The Amniotic Universe and The Dragons of Eden and before long I couldn't stand the guy. His Cosmos, whenever it touched on the history of science, was mostly a rehashing of old-line Brit anti-Catholic, anti-religious bromides and slogans. When you look at what people such as Copernicus, Galileo, etc. actually said, what their lives actually were and their relationship with the Catholic church was, the show-biz presentation is as much of a falsification of reality as the worst of creationism. I know that's not supposed to matter because it is mere history and that a sci-guy like Sagan or Tyson pushes false information is, meh. But we happen to be people and our history is as much vital information necessary to understanding our lives and our position in the universe as theoretical physics is. Considering how much of theoretical physics turns out to be wrong and, based on speculations on fragmentary information it's bound to turn out lots of wrong guesses, history, based on a far more certain, far richer and far less ambiguous range of evidence, can tell us a lot more about us than science can. I think it's probably a more serious matter with more consequences to lie about history than it is about many of the issues that we are supposed to be continually in a swivet about.
I have gone over this before but the most serious suppression of science in the past century was the suppression of genetics in the Soviet Union by atheists and the most serious crimes committed in the name of science were those that grew out of eugenics, invented by viciously anti-religious people, Galton, Haeckel, etc. Not to mention the use of science to produce weapons of mass destruction, just about every one of those people I know of were atheists as well. It would seem to me that looking to see if an ideology that so often includes a denial of and refutation of morality mixes salubriously with the potent efficacity of science might be a bit more important than rehashing the old line Brit Catholic bashing accounts of those two life long Catholics, Copernicus and Galileo. That's especially true since Catholics haven't been in the business of offing people for heresy for quite a long time now, whereas the history of atheist regimes murdering scientists has happened within living memory. I suspect it goes on today in places like North Korea and China to little notice by western popular media.
Tuesday, May 13, 2014
Not So Stupid As To Say That Kind of Stuff Either, Neilsie
Since Neil Degrasse Tyson is to be believed to be The Greatest Genius in the World, taking over that post from Issac Asimov and Carl Sagan, it is pretty stupid of him to have said what he did about philosophy (from a post by Massimo Pigliucci)
Neil made his latest disparaging remarks about philosophy as a guest on the Nerdist podcast, following a statement by one of the hosts, who said that he majored in philosophy. Neil’s comeback was: “That can really mess you up.” The host then added: “I always felt like maybe there was a little too much question asking in philosophy [of science]?” And here is the rest of the pertinent dialogue:
dGT: I agree.
interviewer: At a certain point it’s just futile.
dGT: Yeah, yeah, exactly, exactly. My concern here is that the philosophers believe they are actually asking deep questions about nature. And to the scientist it’s, what are you doing? Why are you concerning yourself with the meaning of meaning?
(another) interviewer: I think a healthy balance of both is good.
dGT: Well, I’m still worried even about a healthy balance. Yeah, if you are distracted by your questions so that you can’t move forward, you are not being a productive contributor to our understanding of the natural world. And so the scientist knows when the question “what is the sound of one hand clapping?” is a pointless delay in our progress.
[insert predictable joke by one interviewer, imitating the clapping of one hand]
dGT: How do you define clapping? All of a sudden it devolves into a discussion of the definition of words. And I’d rather keep the conversation about ideas. And when you do that don’t derail yourself on questions that you think are important because philosophy class tells you this. The scientist says look, I got all this world of unknown out there, I’m moving on, I’m leaving you behind. You can’t even cross the street because you are distracted by what you are sure are deep questions you’ve asked yourself. I don’t have the time for that. [Note to the reader: I, like Neil, live and work in Manhattan, and I can assure you that I am quite adept at crossing the perilous streets of the metropolis.]
interviewer [not one to put too fine a point on things, apparently]: I also felt that it was a fat load of crap, as one could define what crap is and the essential qualities that make up crap: how you grade a philosophy paper?
dGT [laughing]: Of course I think we all agree you turned out okay.
interviewer: Philosophy was a good Major for comedy, I think, because it does get you to ask a lot of ridiculous questions about things.
dGT: No, you need people to laugh at your ridiculous questions.
interviewer: It’s a bottomless pit. It just becomes nihilism.
dGT: nihilism is a kind of philosophy.
The latter was pretty much the only correct observation about philosophy in the whole dialogue, as far as I can tell.
I very strongly suspect that like most sci-guys these days, Neil Degrasse Tyson has read little to no philosophy and he obviously doesn't have the slightest idea of what he's talking about. As Pigliucci notes he's said such stupid things before:
“Up until early 20th century philosophers had material contributions to make to the physical sciences. Pretty much after quantum mechanics, remember the philosopher is the would be scientist but without a laboratory, right? And so what happens is, the 1920s come in, we learn about the expanding universe in the same decade as we learn about quantum physics, each of which falls so far out of what you can deduce from your armchair that the whole community of philosophers that previously had added materially to the thinking of the physical scientists was rendered essentially obsolete, and that point, and I have yet to see a contribution — this will get me in trouble with all manner of philosophers — but call me later and correct me if you think I’ve missed somebody here. But, philosophy has basically parted ways from the frontier of the physical sciences, when there was a day when they were one and the same. Isaac Newton was a natural philosopher, the word physicist didn’t even exist in any important way back then. So, I’m disappointed because there is a lot of brainpower there, that might have otherwise contributed mightily, but today simply does not. It’s not that there can’t be other philosophical subjects, there is religious philosophy, and ethical philosophy, and political philosophy, plenty of stuff for the philosophers to do, but the frontier of the physical sciences does not appear to be among them.”
Makes you wonder if the Cosmos guy has ever dipped much into cosmology, which can't escape questions of philosophy or his ideological buddies, such as Larry Krauss, whom the philosopher William Lane Craig mopped the floor with and Sean Carroll, who came closer to that fate than I think he could believe he might.
As an informal student of Arthur Stanley Eddington, a far greater astrophysicist than Tyson is likely to develop into, I especially liked this from Pigliucci's answer.
You and a number of your colleagues keep asking what philosophy (of science, in particular) has done for science, lately. There are two answers here: first, much philosophy of science is simply not concerned with advancing science, which means that it is a category mistake (a useful philosophical concept ) to ask why it didn’t. The main objective of philosophy of science is to understand how science works and, when it fails to work (which it does, occasionally), why this was the case. It is epistemology applied to the scientific enterprise. And philosophy is not the only discipline that engages in studying the workings of science: so do history and sociology of science, and yet I never heard you dismiss those fields on the grounds that they haven’t discovered the Higgs boson. Second, I suggest you actually look up some technical papers in philosophy of science to see how a number of philosophers, scientists and mathematicians actually do collaborate to elucidate the conceptual and theoretical aspects of research on everything from evolutionary theory and species concepts to interpretations of quantum mechanics and the structure of superstring theory. Those papers, I maintain, do constitute a positive contribution of philosophy to the progress of science — at least if by science you mean an enterprise deeply rooted in the articulation of theory and its relationship with empirical evidence.
Call me skeptical but I doubt Tyson is going to take much time from his career as The World's Greatest Genius (granting that title seems to have moved from PBS to FOX, nowadays) to do much boning up on current philosophy of science and no one on TV or radio or podcast is going to call him on it. I have noted before how Paul Feyerabend dressed down an earlier generation of scientists on their ignorance of philosophy
The younger generation of physicists, the Feynmans, the Schwingers, etc., may be very bright; they may be more intelligent than their predecessors, than Bohr, Einstein, Schrödinger, Boltzmann, Mach, and so on. But they are uncivilized savages, they lack in philosophical depth.
If there's one thing obvious about the guys mentioned in Pigliucci post, they ain't no Feynmans or even Schwingers. As I recall Pigliucci took part in the round table discussion led by Carroll that motivated my post, linked to. It makes me wonder why he doesn't see through the arrogant ideological position that has led to the ignorance of these conceited geniuses.
Rupert Sheldrake recently commented on the massive ignorance of most scientists whose training was so incredibly narrow as to make them entirely ignorant of other things that used to be part of a general, liberal education. If I can find a transcript I'll post that. It's especially hilarious for someone who has read philosophy to hear how often these guys gas on in a philosophical manner even as their education doesn't clue them into the fact that they are philosophizing.
Update: Here's where Rupert Sheldrake made that point, at 20:55, a point which even Colin Blakemore has to agree with, for the Sheldrake detractors out there.
Update: 2 RMJ has written a better piece about this.
Neil made his latest disparaging remarks about philosophy as a guest on the Nerdist podcast, following a statement by one of the hosts, who said that he majored in philosophy. Neil’s comeback was: “That can really mess you up.” The host then added: “I always felt like maybe there was a little too much question asking in philosophy [of science]?” And here is the rest of the pertinent dialogue:
dGT: I agree.
interviewer: At a certain point it’s just futile.
dGT: Yeah, yeah, exactly, exactly. My concern here is that the philosophers believe they are actually asking deep questions about nature. And to the scientist it’s, what are you doing? Why are you concerning yourself with the meaning of meaning?
(another) interviewer: I think a healthy balance of both is good.
dGT: Well, I’m still worried even about a healthy balance. Yeah, if you are distracted by your questions so that you can’t move forward, you are not being a productive contributor to our understanding of the natural world. And so the scientist knows when the question “what is the sound of one hand clapping?” is a pointless delay in our progress.
[insert predictable joke by one interviewer, imitating the clapping of one hand]
dGT: How do you define clapping? All of a sudden it devolves into a discussion of the definition of words. And I’d rather keep the conversation about ideas. And when you do that don’t derail yourself on questions that you think are important because philosophy class tells you this. The scientist says look, I got all this world of unknown out there, I’m moving on, I’m leaving you behind. You can’t even cross the street because you are distracted by what you are sure are deep questions you’ve asked yourself. I don’t have the time for that. [Note to the reader: I, like Neil, live and work in Manhattan, and I can assure you that I am quite adept at crossing the perilous streets of the metropolis.]
interviewer [not one to put too fine a point on things, apparently]: I also felt that it was a fat load of crap, as one could define what crap is and the essential qualities that make up crap: how you grade a philosophy paper?
dGT [laughing]: Of course I think we all agree you turned out okay.
interviewer: Philosophy was a good Major for comedy, I think, because it does get you to ask a lot of ridiculous questions about things.
dGT: No, you need people to laugh at your ridiculous questions.
interviewer: It’s a bottomless pit. It just becomes nihilism.
dGT: nihilism is a kind of philosophy.
The latter was pretty much the only correct observation about philosophy in the whole dialogue, as far as I can tell.
I very strongly suspect that like most sci-guys these days, Neil Degrasse Tyson has read little to no philosophy and he obviously doesn't have the slightest idea of what he's talking about. As Pigliucci notes he's said such stupid things before:
“Up until early 20th century philosophers had material contributions to make to the physical sciences. Pretty much after quantum mechanics, remember the philosopher is the would be scientist but without a laboratory, right? And so what happens is, the 1920s come in, we learn about the expanding universe in the same decade as we learn about quantum physics, each of which falls so far out of what you can deduce from your armchair that the whole community of philosophers that previously had added materially to the thinking of the physical scientists was rendered essentially obsolete, and that point, and I have yet to see a contribution — this will get me in trouble with all manner of philosophers — but call me later and correct me if you think I’ve missed somebody here. But, philosophy has basically parted ways from the frontier of the physical sciences, when there was a day when they were one and the same. Isaac Newton was a natural philosopher, the word physicist didn’t even exist in any important way back then. So, I’m disappointed because there is a lot of brainpower there, that might have otherwise contributed mightily, but today simply does not. It’s not that there can’t be other philosophical subjects, there is religious philosophy, and ethical philosophy, and political philosophy, plenty of stuff for the philosophers to do, but the frontier of the physical sciences does not appear to be among them.”
Makes you wonder if the Cosmos guy has ever dipped much into cosmology, which can't escape questions of philosophy or his ideological buddies, such as Larry Krauss, whom the philosopher William Lane Craig mopped the floor with and Sean Carroll, who came closer to that fate than I think he could believe he might.
As an informal student of Arthur Stanley Eddington, a far greater astrophysicist than Tyson is likely to develop into, I especially liked this from Pigliucci's answer.
You and a number of your colleagues keep asking what philosophy (of science, in particular) has done for science, lately. There are two answers here: first, much philosophy of science is simply not concerned with advancing science, which means that it is a category mistake (a useful philosophical concept ) to ask why it didn’t. The main objective of philosophy of science is to understand how science works and, when it fails to work (which it does, occasionally), why this was the case. It is epistemology applied to the scientific enterprise. And philosophy is not the only discipline that engages in studying the workings of science: so do history and sociology of science, and yet I never heard you dismiss those fields on the grounds that they haven’t discovered the Higgs boson. Second, I suggest you actually look up some technical papers in philosophy of science to see how a number of philosophers, scientists and mathematicians actually do collaborate to elucidate the conceptual and theoretical aspects of research on everything from evolutionary theory and species concepts to interpretations of quantum mechanics and the structure of superstring theory. Those papers, I maintain, do constitute a positive contribution of philosophy to the progress of science — at least if by science you mean an enterprise deeply rooted in the articulation of theory and its relationship with empirical evidence.
Call me skeptical but I doubt Tyson is going to take much time from his career as The World's Greatest Genius (granting that title seems to have moved from PBS to FOX, nowadays) to do much boning up on current philosophy of science and no one on TV or radio or podcast is going to call him on it. I have noted before how Paul Feyerabend dressed down an earlier generation of scientists on their ignorance of philosophy
The younger generation of physicists, the Feynmans, the Schwingers, etc., may be very bright; they may be more intelligent than their predecessors, than Bohr, Einstein, Schrödinger, Boltzmann, Mach, and so on. But they are uncivilized savages, they lack in philosophical depth.
If there's one thing obvious about the guys mentioned in Pigliucci post, they ain't no Feynmans or even Schwingers. As I recall Pigliucci took part in the round table discussion led by Carroll that motivated my post, linked to. It makes me wonder why he doesn't see through the arrogant ideological position that has led to the ignorance of these conceited geniuses.
Rupert Sheldrake recently commented on the massive ignorance of most scientists whose training was so incredibly narrow as to make them entirely ignorant of other things that used to be part of a general, liberal education. If I can find a transcript I'll post that. It's especially hilarious for someone who has read philosophy to hear how often these guys gas on in a philosophical manner even as their education doesn't clue them into the fact that they are philosophizing.
Update: Here's where Rupert Sheldrake made that point, at 20:55, a point which even Colin Blakemore has to agree with, for the Sheldrake detractors out there.
Update: 2 RMJ has written a better piece about this.
Allergies, Too Stupid from Taking Benadry To Write
But not as stupid as the guy I just read at Alternet who claims that Copernicus was burned at the stake. On days I'm not fit to write, I'll try to post items of interest to people who read my blog.
Dedication of the Revolutions of the Heavenly Bodies to Pope Paul III
Nicolaus Copernicus (1543)
I CAN easily conceive, most Holy Father, that as soon as some people learn that in this book which I have written concerning the revolutions of the heavenly bodies, I ascribe certain motions to the Earth, they will cry out at once that I and my theory should be rejected. For I am not so much in love with my conclusions as not to weigh what others will think about them, and although I know that the meditations of a philosopher are far removed from the judgment of the laity, because his endeavor is to seek out the truth in all things, so far as this is permitted by God to the human reason, I still believe that one must avoid theories altogether foreign to orthodoxy. Accordingly, when I considered in my own mind how absurd a performance it must seem to those who know that the judgment of many centuries has approved the view that the Earth remains fixed as center in the midst of the heavens, if I should, on the contrary, assert that the Earth moves; I was for a long time at a loss to know whether I should publish the commentaries which I have written in proof of its motion, or whether it were not better to follow the example of the Pythagoreans and of some others, who were accustomed to transmit the secrets of Philosophy not in writing but orally, and only to their relatives and friends, as the letter from Lysis to Hipparchus bears witness. They did this, it seems to me, not as some think, because of a certain selfish reluctance to give their views to the world, but in order that the noblest truths, worked out by the careful study of great men, should not be despised by those who are vexed at the idea of taking great pains with any forms of literature except such as would be profitable, or by those who, if they are driven to the study of Philosophy for its own sake by the admonitions and the example of others, nevertheless, on account of their stupidity, hold a place among philosophers similar to that of drones among bees. Therefore, when I considered this carefully, the contempt which I had to fear because of the novelty and apparent absurdity of my view, nearly induced me to abandon utterly the work I had begun.
My friends, however, in spite of long delay and even resistance on my part, withheld me from this decision. First among these was Nicolaus Schonberg, Cardinal of Capua, distinguished in all branches of learning. Next to him comes my very dear friend, Tidemann Giese, Bishop of Culm, a most earnest student, as he is, of sacred and, indeed, of all good learning. The latter has often urged me, at times even spurring me on with reproaches, to publish and at last bring to the light the book which had lain in my study not nine years merely, but already going on four times nine. Not a few other very eminent and scholarly men made the same request, urging that I should no longer through fear refuse to give out my work for the common benefit of students of Mathematics. They said I should find that the more absurd most men now thought this theory of mine concerning the motion of the Earth, the more admiration and gratitude it would command after they saw in the publication of my commentaries the mist of absurdity cleared away by most transparent proofs. So, influenced by these advisors and this hope, I have at length allowed my friends to publish the work, as they had long besought me to do.
But perhaps Your Holiness will not so much wonder that I have ventured to publish these studies of mine, after having taken such pains in elaborating them that I have not hesitated to commit to writing my views of the motion of the Earth, as you will be curious to hear how it occurred to me to venture, contrary to the accepted view of mathematicians, and well-nigh contrary to common sense, to form a conception of any terrestrial motion whatsoever. Therefore I would not have it unknown to Your Holiness, that the only thing which induced me to look for another way of reckoning the movements of the heavenly bodies was that I knew that mathematicians by no means agree in their investigations thereof. For, in the first place, they are so much in doubt concerning the motion of the sun and the moon, that they can not even demonstrate and prove by observation the constant length of a complete year; and in the second place, in determining the motions both of these and of the five other planets, they fail to employ consistently one set of first principles and hypotheses, but use methods of proof based only upon the apparent revolutions and motions. For some employ concentric circles only; others, eccentric circles and epicycles; and even by these means they do not completely attain the desired end. For, although those who have depended upon concentric circles have shown that certain diverse motions can be deduced from these, yet they have not succeeded thereby in laying down any sure principle, corresponding indisputably to the phenomena. These, on the other hand, who have devised systems of eccentric circles, although they seem in great part to have solved the apparent movements by calculations which by these eccentrics are made to fit, have nevertheless introduced many things which seem to contradict the first principles of the uniformity of motion. Nor have they been able to discover or calculate from these the main point, which is the shape of the world and the fixed symmetry of its parts; but their procedure has been as if someone were to collect hands, feet, a head, and other members from various places, all very fine in themselves, but not proportionate to one body, and no single one corresponding in its turn to the others, so that a monster rather than a man would be formed from them. Thus in their process of demonstration which they term a “method,” they are found to have omitted something essential, or to have included something foreign and not pertaining to the matter in hand. This certainly would never have happened to them if they had followed fixed principles; for if the hypotheses they assumed were not false, all that resulted therefrom would be verified indubitably. Those things which I am saying now may be obscure, yet they will be made clearer in their proper place.
Therefore, having turned over in my mind for a long time this uncertainty of the traditional mathematical methods of calculating the motions of the celestial bodies, I began to grow disgusted that no more consistent scheme of the movements of the mechanism of the universe, set up for our benefit by that best and most law abiding Architect of all things, was agreed upon by philosophers who otherwise investigate so carefully the most minute details of this world. Wherefore I undertook the task of rereading the books of all the philosophers I could get access to, to see whether any one ever was of the opinion that the motions of the celestial bodies were other than those postulated by the men who taught mathematics in the schools. and I found first, indeed, in Cicero, that Niceta perceived that the Earth moved; and afterward in Plutarch I found that some others were of this opinion, whose words I have seen fit to quote here, that they may be accessible to all:—
“Some maintain that the Earth is stationary, but Philolaus the Pythagorean says that it revolves in a circle about the fire of the ecliptic, like the sun and moon. Heraklides of Pontus and Ekphantus the Pythagorean make the Earth move, not changing its position, however, confined in its falling and rising around its own center in the manner of a wheel.”
Taking this as a starting point, I began to consider the mobility of the Earth; and although the idea seemed absurd, yet because I knew that the liberty had been granted to others before me to postulate all sorts of little circles for explaining the phenomena of the stars, I thought I also might easily be permitted to try whether by postulating some motion of the Earth, more reliable conclusions could be reached regarding the revolution of the heavenly bodies, than those of my predecessors.
And so, after postulating movements, which, farther on in the book, I ascribe to the Earth, I have found by many and long observations that if the movements of the other planets are assumed for the circular motion of the Earth and are substituted for the revolution of each star, not only do their phenomena follow logically therefrom, but the relative positions and magnitudes both of the stars and all their orbits, and of the heavens themselves, become so closely related that in none of its parts can anything be changed without causing confusion in the other parts and in the whole universe. Therefore, in the course of the work I have followed this plan: I describe in the first book all the positions of the orbits together with the movements which I ascribe to the Earth, in order that this book might contain, as it were, the general scheme of the universe. Thereafter in the remaining books, I set forth the motions of the other stars and of all their orbits together with the movement of the Earth, in order that one may see from this to what extent the movements and appearances of the other stars and their orbits can be saved, if they are transferred to the movement of the Earth. Nor do I doubt that ingenious and learned mathematicians will sustain me, if they are willing to recognize and weigh, not superficially, but with that thoroughness which Philosophy demands above all things, those matters which have been adduced by me in this work to demonstrate these theories. In order, however, that both the learned and the unlearned equally may see that I do not avoid anyone’s judgment, I have preferred to dedicate these lucubrations of mine to Your Holiness rather than to any other, because, even in this remote corner of the world where I live, you are considered to be the most eminent man in dignity of rank and in love of all learning and even of mathematics, so that by your authority and judgment you can easily suppress the bites of slanderers, albeit the proverb hath it that there is no remedy for the bite of a sycophant. If perchance there shall be idle talkers, who, though they are ignorant of all mathematical sciences, nevertheless assume the right to pass judgment on these things, and if they should dare to criticise and attack this theory of mine because of some passage of Scripture which they have falsely distorted for their own purpose, I care not at all; I will even despise their judgment as foolish. For it is not unknown that Lactantius, otherwise a famous writer but a poor mathematician, speaks most childishly of the shape of the Earth when he makes fun of those who said that the Earth has the form of a sphere. It should not seem strange then to zealous students, if some such people shall ridicule us also. Mathematics are written for mathematicians, to whom, if my opinion does not deceive me, our labors will seem to contribute something to the ecclesiastical state whose chief office Your Holiness now occupies; for when not so very long ago, under Leo X, in the Lateran Council the question of revising the ecclesiastical calendar was discussed, it then remained unsettled, simply because the length of the years and months, and the motions of the sun and moon were held to have been not yet sufficiently determined. Since that time, I have given my attention to observing these more accurately, urged on by a very distinguished man, Paul, Bishop of Fossombrone, who at that time had charge of the matter. But what I may have accomplished herein I leave to the judgment of Your Holiness in particular, and to that of all other learned mathematicians; and lest I seem to Your Holiness to promise more regarding the usefulness of the work than I can perform, I now pass to the work itself.
Dedication of the Revolutions of the Heavenly Bodies to Pope Paul III
Nicolaus Copernicus (1543)
I CAN easily conceive, most Holy Father, that as soon as some people learn that in this book which I have written concerning the revolutions of the heavenly bodies, I ascribe certain motions to the Earth, they will cry out at once that I and my theory should be rejected. For I am not so much in love with my conclusions as not to weigh what others will think about them, and although I know that the meditations of a philosopher are far removed from the judgment of the laity, because his endeavor is to seek out the truth in all things, so far as this is permitted by God to the human reason, I still believe that one must avoid theories altogether foreign to orthodoxy. Accordingly, when I considered in my own mind how absurd a performance it must seem to those who know that the judgment of many centuries has approved the view that the Earth remains fixed as center in the midst of the heavens, if I should, on the contrary, assert that the Earth moves; I was for a long time at a loss to know whether I should publish the commentaries which I have written in proof of its motion, or whether it were not better to follow the example of the Pythagoreans and of some others, who were accustomed to transmit the secrets of Philosophy not in writing but orally, and only to their relatives and friends, as the letter from Lysis to Hipparchus bears witness. They did this, it seems to me, not as some think, because of a certain selfish reluctance to give their views to the world, but in order that the noblest truths, worked out by the careful study of great men, should not be despised by those who are vexed at the idea of taking great pains with any forms of literature except such as would be profitable, or by those who, if they are driven to the study of Philosophy for its own sake by the admonitions and the example of others, nevertheless, on account of their stupidity, hold a place among philosophers similar to that of drones among bees. Therefore, when I considered this carefully, the contempt which I had to fear because of the novelty and apparent absurdity of my view, nearly induced me to abandon utterly the work I had begun.
My friends, however, in spite of long delay and even resistance on my part, withheld me from this decision. First among these was Nicolaus Schonberg, Cardinal of Capua, distinguished in all branches of learning. Next to him comes my very dear friend, Tidemann Giese, Bishop of Culm, a most earnest student, as he is, of sacred and, indeed, of all good learning. The latter has often urged me, at times even spurring me on with reproaches, to publish and at last bring to the light the book which had lain in my study not nine years merely, but already going on four times nine. Not a few other very eminent and scholarly men made the same request, urging that I should no longer through fear refuse to give out my work for the common benefit of students of Mathematics. They said I should find that the more absurd most men now thought this theory of mine concerning the motion of the Earth, the more admiration and gratitude it would command after they saw in the publication of my commentaries the mist of absurdity cleared away by most transparent proofs. So, influenced by these advisors and this hope, I have at length allowed my friends to publish the work, as they had long besought me to do.
But perhaps Your Holiness will not so much wonder that I have ventured to publish these studies of mine, after having taken such pains in elaborating them that I have not hesitated to commit to writing my views of the motion of the Earth, as you will be curious to hear how it occurred to me to venture, contrary to the accepted view of mathematicians, and well-nigh contrary to common sense, to form a conception of any terrestrial motion whatsoever. Therefore I would not have it unknown to Your Holiness, that the only thing which induced me to look for another way of reckoning the movements of the heavenly bodies was that I knew that mathematicians by no means agree in their investigations thereof. For, in the first place, they are so much in doubt concerning the motion of the sun and the moon, that they can not even demonstrate and prove by observation the constant length of a complete year; and in the second place, in determining the motions both of these and of the five other planets, they fail to employ consistently one set of first principles and hypotheses, but use methods of proof based only upon the apparent revolutions and motions. For some employ concentric circles only; others, eccentric circles and epicycles; and even by these means they do not completely attain the desired end. For, although those who have depended upon concentric circles have shown that certain diverse motions can be deduced from these, yet they have not succeeded thereby in laying down any sure principle, corresponding indisputably to the phenomena. These, on the other hand, who have devised systems of eccentric circles, although they seem in great part to have solved the apparent movements by calculations which by these eccentrics are made to fit, have nevertheless introduced many things which seem to contradict the first principles of the uniformity of motion. Nor have they been able to discover or calculate from these the main point, which is the shape of the world and the fixed symmetry of its parts; but their procedure has been as if someone were to collect hands, feet, a head, and other members from various places, all very fine in themselves, but not proportionate to one body, and no single one corresponding in its turn to the others, so that a monster rather than a man would be formed from them. Thus in their process of demonstration which they term a “method,” they are found to have omitted something essential, or to have included something foreign and not pertaining to the matter in hand. This certainly would never have happened to them if they had followed fixed principles; for if the hypotheses they assumed were not false, all that resulted therefrom would be verified indubitably. Those things which I am saying now may be obscure, yet they will be made clearer in their proper place.
Therefore, having turned over in my mind for a long time this uncertainty of the traditional mathematical methods of calculating the motions of the celestial bodies, I began to grow disgusted that no more consistent scheme of the movements of the mechanism of the universe, set up for our benefit by that best and most law abiding Architect of all things, was agreed upon by philosophers who otherwise investigate so carefully the most minute details of this world. Wherefore I undertook the task of rereading the books of all the philosophers I could get access to, to see whether any one ever was of the opinion that the motions of the celestial bodies were other than those postulated by the men who taught mathematics in the schools. and I found first, indeed, in Cicero, that Niceta perceived that the Earth moved; and afterward in Plutarch I found that some others were of this opinion, whose words I have seen fit to quote here, that they may be accessible to all:—
“Some maintain that the Earth is stationary, but Philolaus the Pythagorean says that it revolves in a circle about the fire of the ecliptic, like the sun and moon. Heraklides of Pontus and Ekphantus the Pythagorean make the Earth move, not changing its position, however, confined in its falling and rising around its own center in the manner of a wheel.”
Taking this as a starting point, I began to consider the mobility of the Earth; and although the idea seemed absurd, yet because I knew that the liberty had been granted to others before me to postulate all sorts of little circles for explaining the phenomena of the stars, I thought I also might easily be permitted to try whether by postulating some motion of the Earth, more reliable conclusions could be reached regarding the revolution of the heavenly bodies, than those of my predecessors.
And so, after postulating movements, which, farther on in the book, I ascribe to the Earth, I have found by many and long observations that if the movements of the other planets are assumed for the circular motion of the Earth and are substituted for the revolution of each star, not only do their phenomena follow logically therefrom, but the relative positions and magnitudes both of the stars and all their orbits, and of the heavens themselves, become so closely related that in none of its parts can anything be changed without causing confusion in the other parts and in the whole universe. Therefore, in the course of the work I have followed this plan: I describe in the first book all the positions of the orbits together with the movements which I ascribe to the Earth, in order that this book might contain, as it were, the general scheme of the universe. Thereafter in the remaining books, I set forth the motions of the other stars and of all their orbits together with the movement of the Earth, in order that one may see from this to what extent the movements and appearances of the other stars and their orbits can be saved, if they are transferred to the movement of the Earth. Nor do I doubt that ingenious and learned mathematicians will sustain me, if they are willing to recognize and weigh, not superficially, but with that thoroughness which Philosophy demands above all things, those matters which have been adduced by me in this work to demonstrate these theories. In order, however, that both the learned and the unlearned equally may see that I do not avoid anyone’s judgment, I have preferred to dedicate these lucubrations of mine to Your Holiness rather than to any other, because, even in this remote corner of the world where I live, you are considered to be the most eminent man in dignity of rank and in love of all learning and even of mathematics, so that by your authority and judgment you can easily suppress the bites of slanderers, albeit the proverb hath it that there is no remedy for the bite of a sycophant. If perchance there shall be idle talkers, who, though they are ignorant of all mathematical sciences, nevertheless assume the right to pass judgment on these things, and if they should dare to criticise and attack this theory of mine because of some passage of Scripture which they have falsely distorted for their own purpose, I care not at all; I will even despise their judgment as foolish. For it is not unknown that Lactantius, otherwise a famous writer but a poor mathematician, speaks most childishly of the shape of the Earth when he makes fun of those who said that the Earth has the form of a sphere. It should not seem strange then to zealous students, if some such people shall ridicule us also. Mathematics are written for mathematicians, to whom, if my opinion does not deceive me, our labors will seem to contribute something to the ecclesiastical state whose chief office Your Holiness now occupies; for when not so very long ago, under Leo X, in the Lateran Council the question of revising the ecclesiastical calendar was discussed, it then remained unsettled, simply because the length of the years and months, and the motions of the sun and moon were held to have been not yet sufficiently determined. Since that time, I have given my attention to observing these more accurately, urged on by a very distinguished man, Paul, Bishop of Fossombrone, who at that time had charge of the matter. But what I may have accomplished herein I leave to the judgment of Your Holiness in particular, and to that of all other learned mathematicians; and lest I seem to Your Holiness to promise more regarding the usefulness of the work than I can perform, I now pass to the work itself.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
