Monday, May 6, 2024

The Variable Uses And Abuses Of Calling Out Bigotry And Racism - An answer

IT REALLY IS TELLING how the abominable expression of antisemitism on college campuses in the aftermath of the atrocities of the Netanyahu regime, carried out by the Israeli military are getting such fevered and universal coverage EXACTLY IN THE WAY THAT THE FAR MORE WIDESPREAD AND FULLY PRESENT ANTI-BLACK RACISM ON CAMPUS NEVER HAS GOTTEN.   Almost as telling, though it's been talked about a bit is the obsession with the American media about the small percentage of college aged kids (and non-student agitators) disrupting campuses, especially on the Ivy level INSTEAD OF CONCENTRATING ON THE ATROCITIES HAPPENING IN GAZA.  The media did the same thing during the widespread student protests against the war in Vietnam which are the obvious models for today's would-be student radicals.   The romanticization of that previous, failed,  counter-productive debacle which didn't end the war, though it brought Nixon to power, is a criminal use of free press privileges.

And even more telling about the American "free press," the media, the laughably self-congratulating and glorified business of "journalism" has made that antisemitism the fault of antisemitism rejecting Democrats and, especially, Joe Biden while not attributing it to a man who  regularly spouts the old chestnuts and lines of the crudest antisemitism, Donald Trump and his racist, not infrequently antisemitic Republican-fascist part.  The corporate media's motives in this could hardly be more transparent than they were in 1968 when they actively but tacitly supported the election of Nixon.

The stupidity of the reaction against the crimes against humanity of the Israeli government and military which risks putting the tool of Netanyahu (and, so, I'd argue Putin and, ironically the Iranian government) Trump back in power doesn't shock me, now.  Americans, whose "educations" has long been in the hands of the mass media aren't equipped to even begin to grasp the reality of the situation.   While I'd have to do something I'd be loathe to repeat, re-reading the writing and words of the big-name student "radicals" of my youth to find out,  I have the feeling that fifty-years on in the dumbing of America by the media that today's media presented student "radicals" sound atl least if not as stupid as my generation's student radical.  And I was one of those radical who has become, if anything, far more radical than I was then.   

I would favor giving the Israeli government an ultimatum, either stop the war crimes and genocides and, I have every confidence this might turn into, another land-grab in Gaza or they are cut off.   I have no patience for the argument that the Israeli population wants to dump Netanyahu and his corrupt government because they've had literally decades of supporting that fascist at this point as they supported his fascistic godfather, Menachem Begin.   The fact is that for the last half century of Israel's existence, it has been mostly in the hands of those who have more than a tendency towards fascism,  as I've pointed out here for many years now,  when, at the start of the Israeli government, Begin was touring the United States looking for funding and support for his faction,  a group of the most prominent Jewish intellectuals warned in the New York Times that Begin and his gang were fascists with a record of terrorist violence and murder.   That same gang in the form of the Likud party* has, in fact, dominated Israel for most of its existence, now.  

But it can be pointed out that the factions governing Palestinians in Gaza and elsewhere are hardly any better,  Hamas committed a crime against humanity in its attack on Israel which gave Netanyahu his excuse for his far larger crimes against Palestinians in Gaza and humanitarian workers carried out by the wrongly idolized Israeli military.   That Hamas certainly did that at the urging of the Iranian fascist-theocrats and with training widely reported coming from the big boss of current fascism, Vladimir Putin certainly does nothing to raise the moral status of the Hamas government.  There is, however, a difference between its relationship to the population they dictate to and that of Israel to the Netanyahu government, they have regular elections in Israel and Hamas followed that tragic pattern in so much of the third word where there's one free election then not another after that.  It's the same pattern that Putin retains power through, as well as the Iranian theocratic-fascists.   There is a lot harder case to make that the Netanyahu government lacks legitimacy through the support of the majority in Israel, though at this point it's quite possible he is merely kept in place through the corrupting inertia of political process.   I think another condition of continued aid from the U.S. is that there be an immediate referendum on the fascists in Israel, that aid being conditioned on them not being returned to power.  If the Israeli population puts it back in out of anger at that condition, that's their choice but it should not govern the choice of the American People or our government.  

Back when the odious antisemite and otherwise bigot Louis Farrakhan was much in the news, back in the 90s, it became the practice in the American media to demand that any Black Person being interviewed be required to condemn him, even those who had absolutely no connection with or previous association with him or the Nation of Islam.   Even those in show biz and the entertainment industry, having nothing to do with politics or religion.   That became so ubiquitous that I remember the poet Gwendolyn Brooks pointed out that she'd been the target of that phenomenon in one of her talks about her work. 

I never remember any similar requirement that members of other groups be required to automatically condemn the far more often expressed anti-Black racism, anti-Latino hatred, or other far more widespread and demonstrably murderously   consequential tidal-waves of such ethnic and racial hatred in the United States.   I don't remember anyone in the same business being required to condemn Andrew Dice Clay or Jackie Mason or John Wayne or even David Duke by those in the media.   I don't even remember the racists and bigots in the media such as Lou Dobbs being the focus of such an on-demand degradation ritual.   

I'm not complaining about the media calling out antisemitism when the topic or person being interviewed has some relationship to it or to a legitimately identified antisemitism - there is certainly more than enough blatant antisemitism and enough blatant antisemites  without unjustly or dishonestly assigning that lable where they aren't in evidence.  I'm pointing out the dishonest political uses to which that particularly potent political label by the corporate media, the social-disease of social-media (ironically, the primary spreader of such diseased thinking today) and not a few would-be more legitimate authorities. 

I've pointed out that distinguishing between different groups of targeted people to put a variable value on their lives and bodies is exactly how Nazis thought,  declaring that I refused to think like a Nazi does, to behave like Nazis did.  That isn't restricted to Nazis, it's how white supremacists or any other species of bigots think and act.   That is, though, demonstrably, how the American media behaves in its actions and words.   I think it does that because there is nothing to prevent them from doing it, things such as anti-hate talk laws in other countries.  While those might not work perfectly, especially in this age of the social-disease of "social" media, not having them is a certain guarantee that hate talk will flourish and double-standards of valuation among different human groups and different human beings will become the standard default of thinking, talking and action.   

It has long been astonishing to me when the members of any group targeted for bigotry takes up bigotry instead of realizing they are on the same side as those who are targeted.  That used to be true of Irish Catholics in the United States, it isn't anymore, not much.   I think that the less that a formerly targeted group experiences that kind of bigotry, the less likely they are to allow that experience to impinge on their habits of thoughts and what's left of their moral discernment and sense of obligation.   I think there are far too few People who know the experience of real, dangerous discrimination in the media, certainly too few of those in charge of the media, which I think accounts for all of the above.   I don't know if being a gay man was what saved me from that kind of hypocrisy, maybe it did, it's clear that among gay men who can pass that's no kind of a reliable inoculation against it.  Lindsay Graham, Andrew Sullivan, those fascist and neo-Nazi gay boys that Trump has to dinner, getting a pass from the media and political punditry.  

* In line with my critique of 18th century, libertarian style "liberalism" it should be pointed out that Likud organized by a number of smaller fascistic parties styled itself as an expression of "liberalism,"  the National Liberal Movement.   No liberalism which rejects equality will avoid devolving into fascism,  I suspect.  

Sunday, May 5, 2024

this particular denial is the strangest thing that has happened in the whole history of human thought, not just the whole history of philosophy - A response

RUPERT SHELDRAKE, unlike many of his critics, is a working scientist who does some of the most ingeniously inexpensive and simple experiments that rigorously fulfill the requirements of scientific methods and some of his experiments actually do get that rare replication that seems to have become a non-requirement in late stage science.   He is regularly published going into his ninth decade, he continues to do groundwork in asking questions and gathering evidence from the public.  Just last week he made such an appeal to the public for information in regard to the possibility of inherited traits in animals.    He has been a fellow at Cambridge University, until 2010 he as a director of a project at Cambridge University, he was a research fellow of the Royal Society,   He did groundbreaking research in biology and agricultural science in India and Malaya, some of his work there has probably been more important in the lives of more People than that done by just about any of his critics, some of his basic work in studying auxin and related topics is among the most important science of the 20th century.  So there's no doubt about it, he has every right to be considered a scientist.  That he is unafraid to do what I said the "skeptics" obviously don't,  trust scientific methods to discern the truth even when they show things that are controversial is obvious.  

Unlike most of his critics, as well, Rupert Sheldrake has done serious graduate work and continuing reading and study of philosophy.  If there's one thing that is remarkable about those educated in science, it is how many of them are less than novices in that area of thought.  That used to not be a rarity among scientists, especially those from Europe and Britain but it has been among scientists, especially in the English speaking People for quite some time, now.  I think it's one of the reasons that he thinks and writes with a clarity and consistency that is unusual.  He clearly does what even some of his critics renowned for their writing ability, such as Richard Dawkins, fails to do, he is a critic of his own ideas as well as theirs.  Which is one of the reasons that I have every confidence that Dawkins' evolutionary psychology and its associated ideas will go onto that scrap-heap of discarded science where you can find Freudianism and Behaviorism, both credentialed science of their time and, Lord help us, still having rump communities that believe in them.  Some of them allowed to keep shop as practitioners.  

It's planting season and I don't have the time to write what I'd like to have so I'm going to type out some more from Rupert Sheldrake's book Science Set Free.  Right before a section titled Minds that deny their own reality, he says:

The strongest argument in favor of materialism is the failure of dualism to explain how immaterial minds work and how they interact with brains.  Te strongest argument in favor of dualism is the implausibility and self-contradictory nature of materialism.  

The dualist-materialist dialect has lasted for centuries.  The soul-body or mind-brain problem has refused to go away.  But before we can move forward, we need to understand in more detail what materialists cliam, since their belief system dominates institutional science and medicine, and every one is influenced by it.


I have pointed out that an immaterial mind - one which is not composed matter of or the consequence of material causation, could be expected to have qualities and abilities that aren't covered by the properties of matter and material causation.  An immaterial mind could not be subjected to scientific discovery because of that, science is structured only to discover things about things that exist within the properties of matter and material causation.  It is irrational to think that science could do more than notice discrepancies between physical systems and such minds, they couldn't even go far in explaining much about those discrepancies.  Materialists, rigidly holding with a rigidly monistic ideology that insists everything that exists must be restricted to the properties of material existence and the human made "laws of nature," insist that their promise that all will be explained even as they have failed to explain it for centuries, now.  Someone who believes minds surpass the qualities and limits of such a conception of matter and existence should realize that science can't handle the idea of such a mind, though they have certainly been trying to answer the question of how minds influence or control brains or our bodies in the same way instead of admitting that their idea can never have a scientific explanation.  They shouldn't feel bad about that because the materialists have never fulfilled that major promissory note they keep issuing, generation after generation, century after century, I'd argue for millennia, now, only they've structured things so their creditors are suckered into never calling for payment.  

Going on to his discussion of the materialists' irrational and decadent declarations that minds are, to one extent or other, illusory, he says.

Most neuroscientists do not spend much time thinking about the logical problems that materialist beliefs entail.  They just get on with the job of trying to understand how brains work,  in the faith that more hard facts will eventually provide answers.  They leave professional philosophers to defend the materialist or physicalist faith.

Physicalism means much the same as materialism, but rather tan asserting that all reality is material, it asserts that it is physical, explicable in terms of physics, and therefore including energy and fields as well as matter.  In practice, this is what materialists believe too.  In the following discussion I use the more familiar word "materialism" to mean "materialism or physicalism."


I'd add to that that recently some materialists have used the dodge of declaring themselves "naturalists" (which previously meant nudists, as I recall) which is just a ruse as it means pretty much the same thing as the other labels.  I interpret that to mean that even some of the slightly more philosophically astute materialists feel if not realize that there are deep problems with their ideology but they don't want to admit that or give it up.  Covering up their naked materialism, sort of.

Among materialist philosophers there are several schools of thought.  The most extreme position is called "eliminative materialism."  The philosopher Paul Curchland, for example, claims that there is nothing more to the mind than what occurs in the brain.  Those who believe in the existence of thoughts, beliefs, desires, motives and other mental states are victims of "folk psychology," an unscientific attitude that will in due course be replaced by explanations in terms of the activities of nerves.  Folk psychology is a kind of superstition, like belief in demons, and it will be left behind by the onward march of scientific understanding.  Consciousness is just an "aspect" of the activity of the brain.   Thoughts or sensations are just another way of talking about activity in particular regions of the cerebral cortex;  they are the same things talked about in different ways.  

Of course such eliminative materialists exempt their language about their own unevidence talk about these things from the rigid model they have created when, by their own claims, what they believe about all of it, from their academically snobbish and insulting labels for the ideas of those who disagree with him to their declared faith in the not yet reached triumph of science, to the very science they ask us to put our faith into, must all fall within the same countentless, purposeless chemical and material causation which cannot be anything but a huge crap shot at a hugely improbable picture of what is really true.  Such academic scribbleage and babblage gives away its own disbelief in that by even making the attempt to convince other People that their favorite line of belief is what they should believe because such a materialist faith would hold that none of it is meaningful, including their desire to be believed.  It cannot have more legitimacy than any other aspect of "folk psychology" only they insist that while most of humanity swims in that self-deceiving ignorance, they and their allies, alone, can, somehow, escape from it.  Many of those who hold university professorships and chairs in departments of philosophy aren't especially rigorous in their own criticism of their own ideas, especially those who hanker after the repute and status that is given to scientists.  That last thing is ubiquitous among those with college credentials in the humanities, in my experience.  It reached absurd lengths even among some of the more astute composers of the 19th and 20th centuries who should have known better.  

I think any university or college or school which hires and pays someone who denies the reality of or significance of consciousness, teaching students that what the university is in the business of providing them is, in effect, meaningless, is guilty of consumer fraud.  They, despite their desire to appear properly sciency, are promoting the ultimate act of intellectual decadence.  There's a lot of that in this late state of eutrophic modernism.  That is what materialism can be counted on to produce because it is, ultimately, a self-refuting and undermining ideology.  

Sheldrake continues:

Other materialists are "epiphenomenalists": they accept rather tahn deny the existence of consciousness, but see it as a functionless by-product of the activity of the brain, an "epipenomenon," like a shadow.  T. H. Huxley was n early advocate of this point of view, and in 1874 he famously compared consciousness to "the steam whistle that accompanies the work of a locomotive engine. . . without influence upon its machinery."  He concluded, "We are conscious automatons."  People might just as well be zombies, with no subjective experience, because all their behavior is a result of brain activity alone.  Conscious experience does nothing and makes no difference to the physical world.

Again, you have to wonder why someone who believes that would not only make an attempt to discern anything, never mind spend a lifetime in science, but to issue polemical statements, declarations, books, to convince other such minds of anything because, in the end, none of it makes any difference to anything and has an absurdly remote possibility of coming to an accurate description of reality.  Everything they come up with and believe would have as much of a chance as any other of finding reality on the basis of chemicals and physical structures which were a product of random chance in their particular situation.  You have to wonder how such a person accounts for the possibility that any two such organisms would contain the physical basis of that they could agree on anything.  How any two brains could make precisely the same structure to give rise to the same epiphenomenon - how brains would know how to do that is a question I've been posing, off and on, to materialists for a number of years now and I have never had any response that wasn't an expression of atheist materialist faith lacking any real explanation of how it is supposed to work.  

A recent form of materialism is "cognitive psychology," which dominated academic psychology in the English-speaking world in the late twentieth century.  It treats the brain as a computer and mental activity as information processing.  Subjective experiences, like seeing green, or feeling pain, or enjoying music, are computational processes inside the brain which are themselves unconscious.  

I've discussed that before, how computers are a deliberate creation made to mimic BY ANALOGY modeling of human mind, of humans thought, they have a relationship to minds as an anatomical statue made of sculptures of human organs, bones and other structures have to human bodies. To claim that human bodies function like anatomical models is about as astute as claiming that computers can serve as a means of understanding human minds.  Circular reasoning and inapt analogies flourish when science and philosophy are governed by materialists ideology.

Some philosphers, like John Searle, think that minds can emerge from matter by analogy with the way that physical properties can emerge at different levels of complexity, like the wetness of water emerging from the interactions of large numbers of water molecules.  In nature, there are indeed many different levels of organization (Figure 1.1)*, each of which has new properties that are not present in their parts alone.  Atoms have properties over and above nuclear particles and electrons.  Molecules have properties over and above atoms; the molecules of water, H2O, are fundamentally different from uncombined hydrogen and oxygen atoms.  Then the wetness of liquid water is not explained by water molecules in isolation, but through their organization together in liquid water.  New physical properties "emerge" at every level.  In the same way, consciousness is an emergent physical property of brains.  It is different from other physical processes, but is is physical nonetheless.  Many non-materialists would agree with Searle that consciousness is in some sense "emergent" but would argue that while mind and conscious agency originate in physical nature, they are qualitatively different from purely material or physical being.

Apart from the extremely fuzzy and, it seems to me, diffuse idea that so many different dissimilarities there are between larger physical entities and the properties of their component physical entities on lower levels of organization can be reified into the same kind of thing, this idea doesn't seem to explain much about minds.  Does water have wetness except as a product of perception, an action of minds?  And it would depend on what you define "wetness" as being, which is another action of minds.  Often a scientific definition of some phenomenon is created to limit what aspects of it will be under scientific discussion but I'd be surprised if science can come up with a definition of something like "wetness" or the perception of a color that will really encompass everything that's meant by the word when we use it.  I would question how anyone could really determine that all of the various such experiences which are called "physical properties" are connected except as they are experienced by living beings' minds.  Given the recent biology of such scientists as James Shapiro and Denis Noble, I think it makes at least as much and more sense to think that bodies are epiphenomena of minds.  

This last one was one of the things that those who tried to answer me with on those questions of how brains could make the physical structure(s) to give rise to an idea could be physically present in that brain, structures that would be entirely novel to that brain, structures that would need to be extremely precise and complex enough to give rise to a new idea in any particular brain, before the materialists' model of "brain only" minds would have any possibility of even knowing the brain needed to make a new structure - not to mention the problem of how it would know how to make that structure in that case.  Only the answer "natural selection" was no answer at all.

Finally, some materialists hope that evolution can provide an answer.  They propose that consciousness emerged as a result of natural selection through mindless processes from unconscious matter.  Because minds evolved, they must have been favored by natural selection and hence they must actually do something;  they must make a difference.  Many non-materialists would agree.  But materialists want to have ti both ways; emergent consciousness must do something if it has evolved as an evolutionary adaptation favored by natural selection;  but it cannot do anything if it is just an epiphenomeon of brain activity, or another way of talking about brain mechanisms.  In 2011, the psychologist Nicholas Humphrey tried to overcome this problem by suggesting that consciousness evolved because it helps humans survive and reproduce by making us fee "special and transcendent."  But as a materialist Humphrey does not agree that our minds have any agency;  that is to say, they cannot affect our actions.  Instead our consciousness is illusory;  he describes it as "a magical mystery show that we stage for ourselves inside our own heads."  But to say that consciousness is an illusion does not explain consciousness;  it presupposes it.  Illusion is a mode of consciousness.  

My guess would be that the psychologist Nichols Humphrey would take enormous offense of some skeptic of psychology and materialism such as myself would brush off his entire professional and academic work in the very terms that it must, itself, brush off every product of every conscious mind, only I'd do it on the basis of the central and basic logical disconnect that is baked into the entire field of academic dismissal of minds and consciousness in favor of atheist-materialist ideology, that it's clear that those academics pushing it don't really believe it when it comes to their own minds, their own consciousness and what they choose to believe and insist that others believe.    A point Sheldrake made earlier in the chapter about the published declarations dismissing consciousness by the pudding-headed Daniel Dennett.  I call him "pudding-headed,"  Rupert Sheldrake has much better manners than I do.   It's entirely legitimate to critique the behavior of the eliminative materalists of academia because everything about their actions proves they don't really believe it when it comes to them and their own meaningless burps and noises coming from those random molecular actions in their brains.   I'd bet if someone cribbed them for sale they'd assert in court that they were more than meaningless and not really attributable to their creativity. 

If all of these theories sound unconvincing, that is because they are.  They do not even convince other materialists, which is why there are so many rival theories.  Searle has described the debate over the past fifty years as follows:  

"A philosopher advances a materialist theory of the mind . . . He encounters difficulties . . . Criticisms of the materialist theory usually take a more or less technical form, but, in fact, underlying the technical objections is a much deeper objection; the theory in question has left out some essential features of the mind. . . and this leads to ever more frenzied attempts to stick with the materialist thesis.


The philosopher Galen Strawson, himself a materialist, is amazed by the willingness of so many of his fellow philosophers to deny the reality of their own experience;
 
"I think we should feel very sober, and a little afraid at the power of human credulity, the capacity of human minds to be gripped by theory, by faith.  For this particular denial is the strangest thing that has happened in the whole history of human thought, not just the whole history of philosophy."  


I am unaware of any materialist whose primary motivation is anything but their attachment to atheism, though some may have been led to atheism through a naive conception of materialism, the two seem to be linked pretty firmly in most minds that hold those ideologies.  Though  that would be those who consider the matter at any higher level of thought.  Materialism can be held even by non-atheists on the basis of conformity to the ambient requisite thoughts of secular culture, as a default, respectable, reputable and profitable mode of going along with that to get along.  I don't think most atheists or materialists really think about it very deeply at all, no more than those who maintain a naive, primitive, even quite mistaken notion of Darwinism, natural selection or, as many even college-credentialed folks abbreviate that "evolution."   I don't think most materialists, atheists or true-believes in scientism hold those on a particularly deep or sound basis, I think most of it is a product of wanting to fit in with the kind of People taken to have higher status in a secular, materialist, atheist, scientistic milieu.  I doubt most of the media figures, including some of those "public scientists" I ridiculed to such objection the other day are especially intellectually engaged with their own adopted ideology.  As I mentioned, even those as fully engaged as the eliminative materialists don't engage with the logical consequences of their own claims for the intellectual legitimacy of those very claims.   Materialism is one of the most philosophically inastute conceptions ever held and it is ubiquitous in our decadent stage of materialism as vulgar materialism has almost always ruled in those who gain power.  

Francis Crick admitted that the "astonishing hypothesis" was not proved.  he conceded that a dualist view might become more plausible.  But he added.

"There is always a third possibility;  that the facts support a new alternative way of looking at the mind-brain problem that is significantly different from the rather crude materialistic view that many neuroscientists hold today and also from the religious point of view.  Only time and much further scientific work, will  enable us to decide."


Yeah, there could be a third possibility or it could be that minds are non-material and, so, will never be able to be directly discerned by analogies to the properties of material causation.  It may be just a hard fact that we, in our thinking which is so tied to the experience and analysis of material objects and experiences, will never be able to articulate more than a vague sense of minds and consciousness.  It could be similar to the speculation by A. S. Eddington that there are laws of nature which our minds are not capable of discerning and will never know because of that.  If other species on some other planet, somewhere, may be able to conceive of those, it would be interesting to think about how we'd deal with that.  I'd imagine that materialist scientists on Earth would deny that those properties of matter which their minds could not comprehend could possibly exist.  But that's just speculative imagining on my part.  Maybe they'd learn the kind of humility and acceptance they figure non-sci-guys should practice in regard to their incomprehensible claims.

Before going on in the next section to discuss the latest fashion (or desperate resort) in panpsychism, the idea that matter has consciousness as an intrinsic property and our minds emerge out of that subatomic, atomic . . . consciousness, Rupert Sheldrake says, "There is indeed a third way."  

How panpsychism isn't just another from of the very fuzzy and vague notion of emergentism, I'd need to have explained to me.

I would point out to the panpsychists that there is religious precedent for their materialistic last resort, in fact it's in Scripture.  Jesus told the religious high and mighty of his day that God could raise up children of Abraham from rocks (Matthew 3:9} and, during his dramatic entry into Jerusalem that if the crowds didn't proclaim him the stones would do it (Luke 19:40).  Not to mention the scriptures tell us we are made of Earth (Genesis 2:7). The dualism of matter and spirit in some of Christian philosophy and theology was an artifact of Greek pagan philosophy, not the Hebrew tradition, certainly not as that was extended so drastically through the Gospel of Jesus and the theological explanations of the Glorified Jesus after his death by Paul and the Catholic Epistles.  The mind-body dilemma that has given rise to the ultimate decadence of brain sci-guys and their philosopher groupies in consciously denying the existence of significance of consciousness may well be attributable to pagan proto-science, perhaps as filtered through atheist materialism, of the classical period atomists (as popularized by a deeply flawed book by Stephen Greenblatt that was all the rage a while back) and was never much more than a product of that ideological assertion irrationally retained in the ideological basis of science.  

I am extremely skeptical of panpsychism, for a start the idea that any molecular, atomic, subatomic, "consciousness" any consciousness of rocks or crystals or other non-living entities could ever be conceived of in a way that connected them to the consciousness that we experience is as fraught with problems as the other materialist's ways of dealing with consciousness.  And it has the same problem as my rejection of ethology, the supposed science of animal behavior) as anything but lore passed off in the guise of science - and with a particularly nasty association with Darwinist eugenics.  The hard fact is that we have no way to consult even animals who are living as to what their experience of consciousness is, what any explanation of their own behavior is, we can't even know if human reports of that are accurate or honest.  How are we supposed to verify that for rocks and atoms?  How are we to even define what that would be?   I think it's just the latest or perhaps last straw of old-line materialism among those who have thought honestly enough about all of those other schemes of it to realize they are bunk but not being willing to admit that minds, consciousness, must well surpass the limits of material causation, to give that property to atoms does nothing to change that, to give it to subatomic particles does no more to remedy that problem.

I will say that there are ways to scientifically study some animal behavior as Rupert Sheldrake rather ingeniously does in his study of animal behavior to study such phenomena as animals who seem to know when their human companions are going to come home, but even that has its limits because no animal can tell us that's what they're doing and what motivates them to do it.  Sheldrake is one of the great living shoe-string practitioners of basic science research.  He said he learned a lot about how to do that kind of science among the scientists in India where there wasn't money to do fancier science.  His books are some of my favorite science reading as his talks, lectures, dialogues and conversations are in online listening.  His work is an example of the possibilities of using scientific method and intellectual searching  when it's freed of ideological straight-jacketing and the requirements to conform to the dominant materialist-atheist-scientistic hegemony in decaying modernism.

*  I don't have the book with me as I'm editing this, but I think it was an image that looked like this one I found online diagramming such a hierarchy. 

A nested hierarchy or holar- | Download Scientific Diagram

Thursday, May 2, 2024

You Can't Have It Both Ways And None Of Us Is Obligated To Let You Have It Both Ways- A "Skeptic" Objects

THE IDEOLOGICAL GAME of "skepticism" as practiced by the so-called Committee for Skeptical Inquiry* and other such largely boys' clubs is supposedly done in the interest of upholding "science" as it is commonly claimed to exist by materialist-atheists who are true believes in scientism, rather ironically not only violates the foundations and methodologies of science, but makes science into one of those ideologically self-refuting entities due to their insistence of turning it into an ideological position instead of an open method of testing ideas, theories and claims.  

The scientism of the self-identified "skeptics" alone would do that because, as I'll never stop pointing out, scientism is a claim that cannot be tested with science and, so, cannot withstand logical analysis as a self-consistent idea.  Materialism and atheism fall into the same category of non-scientific ideas.   It's one of the richer ironies of the "enlightenment" that the biggest fattest champions of "science" are among its most basic non-practitioners of scientific method and thinking.  

The common lore of "skepticism," especially as that exists after the mid 1970s, itself imposes self-defeating ideas onto their conception of science.

One of the widest spread stands of would be "skepticism" that is easiest to refute has two aspects of self-defeat contained in it.  One of the biggest names in "skepticism" of that kind was and is the late but once very prominent "public scientist" the planetary scientist Carl Sagan who popularized the slogan that is often given as "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence" before they are admitted into what is held to be true.  

But that claim is extremely anti-scientific.  What constitutes an "extraordinary" claim as opposed to an "ordinary" one?   How can such a claim be identified as such on any basis that controls against the prejudices and ideological rejection of the one making that designation?   I will state that I've never heard anyone recite that formula except as an expression of their ideological preference, that's how Sagan used it.   

As that slogan is used "extraordinary" means anything that is inconvenient or inconsistent with the ideology of the one using it and noting more.  Science regularly publishes papers and books that make some pretty unusual and, at times, contra-experiential claims.  Not only in such "sciences" as psychology (the history of psychology since at least Freud is full to the top of such claims) but modern physics and cosmology make all kinds of such claims, often on the slightest of evidence or none at all but "science" accepts those claims without any or much objection.  That can be seen in the claims of such untestable speculations as multiverse cosmology, any number of attempts to get round the Big Bang as the absolute beginning of our universe for clearly ideological reasons, and in such things as the "science" that Carl Sagan more or less founded, "exobiology" or the biology of extraterrestrial organisms, organisms of which there is no evidence at all and which organisms science has not and likely never will have to examine (that is unless those come by UFO, which would make other claims by Sagan and the CSICOPs vulnerable).   What are we to make of a science which is funded and credentialed WHEN THERE IS NO POSSIBILITY OF HAVING ANY EVIDENCE OF ITS SUBJECT AT ALL, making some pretty extraordinary claims of its own in the process.  Yet I don't know of any time that Sagan was asked to test his own such untestable science by his slogan, never mind many of those within "skepticism" who practiced such science.  Considering one of the foremost activities of "skeptics" has been to get science they didn't like defunded and shut down, their liking of and practice of science that is based on no evidence at all is rather noteworthy.  And also psychology, which I'll get to in a while.

It also calls into question the legitimacy of the ordinary methods of scientific testing, if those aren't sufficient to confirm some ideas, their ability to confirm any other idea is as insufficient.  Such a standard, if taken seriously,  would obliterate the most basic legitimacy of scientific method whenever those are applied.   You can't have two (or in practice more) standards in such a thing or you have no standard.

As such,  the slogan also forces us to look at something even more basically wrong with the claims and methods of organized "skeptics" especially in regard to actual science they don't like, the controlled, rigorous testing of what falls under "psychic abilities".   Considering how many of those in organized "skepticism" are credentialed and hired within one of the most lax of all the so-called sciences, psychology, such major figures of the past as Ray Hyman, James Alcock, Barry Beyerstein, Richard Kammann, , a "science" which typically practices the sloppiest and loosest and, quite frankly, most scientifically fraudulent of methodologies.  As compared to psychology and much other science which is fully accepted as official science, the parapsychologists run one of the tightest scientific operations there ever has been.   That is in no small part due to their knowledge that the materialist-atheists will always be there to find any flaw in their experimental methods and analyses of their data.  Over and over and over again they have faced that opposition, redesigned their experiments to answer their critics and, over and over again, come up with the positive results that the materialist-atheists hate so much.  And the response of their critics is to either lie about what they've done to create fraud or incompetence that isn't there or to, as in the case of those like Ray Hyman, come up with some unstated and unspecified objection that there MUST be something wrong because they don't like the results of the experiments when they reluctantly have to acknowledge the positive results.   That has been going on since the start of such experiments into "ESP" and much other such tested  phenomena.  No other part of scientific experimentation has ever faced the forces of ideological opposition that such scientists have faced and persistently continue to get positive results, often doing what hardly any conventional psychology does, a. reporting negative results and b. replicating experiments, sometimes over and over again.  Yet the "skeptics" pretend they haven't done that.   

The question is how can the "skeptics" claim to uphold the methods of science, rigorous observation, measurement and analysis as a superior means of discerning AND DETERMINING what is true and what isn't while they so baldly reject some of the most rigorous procedures in doing that kind of science just because they don't like the findings?   How have they been getting away with that for literally more than a century?   Either those methods are capable of finding the truth or they aren't. You can't claim they have universal power to discover the truth about things that can be subjected to those methods if you reject what those methods find, over and over again.  

When the methods of science were first being developed by such people as Francis Bacon, one of the things that they explicitly sought to avoid was the insertion of preference and self-interest into the procedures of science.   While there are several items in his Novum Organum that would fit here, this one is particularly relevant to such ideological skepticism, seeing how it largely traffics in public relations, show biz and has so many magicians and conjurers in its membership.

XLIV. Lastly, there are idols which have crept into men’s minds from the various dogmas of peculiar systems of philosophy, and also from the perverted rules of demonstration, and these we denominate idols of the theatre: for we regard all the systems of philosophy hitherto received or imagined, as so many plays brought out and performed, creating fictitious and theatrical worlds. Nor do we speak only of the present systems, or of the philosophy and sects of the ancients, since numerous other plays of a similar nature can be still composed and made to agree with each other, the causes of the most opposite errors being generally the same. Nor, again, do we allude merely to general systems, but also to many elements and axioms of sciences which have become inveterate by tradition, implicit credence, and neglect. We must, however, discuss each species of idols more fully and distinctly in order to guard the human understanding against them.

Particularly notice the sentence I underlined and the part about wanting to "guard the human understanding against them."

What the "skeptics" do, what some of the major figures in the public face of science do is exactly that, THEY INSERT THEIR IDEOLOGICAL PREFERENCES AND SELF-INTEREST DIRECTLY INTO THE CULTURE AND EVEN LITERATURE OF SCIENCE.   Some, such as the noted scientific fraudster, Marc Hauser, do their "science" to support their ideology, in his case his atheism, or at least there seems to be a high degree of coincidence between their personal ideology and the direction their "science" takes, especially in those sciences in which the least rigorous of methodologies and analyses reign, alleged science dealing with "behavior."   His fraud, successful for many years within science, was in that loosest of scientific fields, the interpretation of animal behavior.  I, personally, don't think any of that is scientific as they can't even get one animal to testify as to their motivations and thinking about it.  But, then, there's no possibility to verify any self-reporting in most of such "science" when it's People who can articulate something about that.  But such fully credentialed and privileged "science" has no such control of that, not such as the rigorous testing of psychic ability 0ften does.   You can tell if someone guessed the right card or closely approximated a remotely viewed image or, in some of the most impressive telepathic-precognitive experiments I know of, the experiments into what Dean Radin has called "presentiment" if they had the physical reaction to the telepathically received stimulus.  I doubt there's anything in conventional psychology that has that level of rigorous scientific verification, the kind of psychology that so many a card-carrying "skeptic" teaches to gullible students as reliable science.  That is until the entire cathedral of that particular school of psychology rots and tumbles down to be covered by the next fashion in such "science."  That's happened at least twice during my lifetime (Freudianism and behaviorism) with many a minor movement within the "science" rising and falling, as well.  

You can't have it both ways, your likes and dislikes either can or can't decide the truth or falseness of ideas that have verification through the regular methods of science.  If you decide they can, then science isn't the producer of objective truth you're claiming it is. The "skeptics" demand the right to do exactly that.  

You can't decide that scientific methods, followed as closely as its possible to follow them, can discern even the seemingly implausible truth in something going in the direction of objective verification when you like the results but refuse to acknowledge when those methods verify what you don't like.  Consider especially what the cosmologists and current physicists have demanded we believe in on the merely theoretical without any evidence, not to mention such currently popular ideologies as evolutionary psychology and myriad other such credentialed sciences  

You can't claim a privilege for inserting your preferred ideological or merely personal preferences into science and demand that everyone acknowledge the validity of the results because none of us is morally or intellectually obligated to go along with something like that anymore than we are when it's done in any other area of life.  

And admit when you do that you are establishing science as just another ideological preference, such as is a frequent atheist criticism of religions because any of us is justified to point out that's what you're doing.   I think science has been going down that road at an accelerating rate, which is too bad because legitimate science, honestly done, is extremely important.  When you consider how important climate change science, environmental science, epidemiological, medical and other such sciences are, it's a crime against humanity to do that.  

All of those anti-scientific ruses are what the "skeptics" from their slickest organized operations down to the blog comment rabble of the James Randi "Educational" Foundation, do all of those and more while suckering or coercing those in the media and academia to go along with it.  Science, as if science were a thing apart from those credentialed and accepted as being "science," is more prone to that ideological bullying and gulling than the general public is because the profession of science maintains that practice and the taboo on a whole Index of Prohibited Ideas.  And it wastes a lot of time doing that and, through putting out some of the most annoyingly smug and conceited jerks as the public face of science, Sagan, Randi, Degrasse Tyson, Shermer, . . . probably does more to discredit science than it does to interest People in it.  Their audience tend to be the conceited and ignorant and philosophically incompetent with college credentials.  

So, no, I have looked at organized "skeptics" and their antics and I'm impressed that they are not especially honest or especially interested in science, they are interested in maintaining a rigid adherence to their preferences.  Their atheism, foremost, their afterthoughts of materialism and scientism.  Those preferences are and never can be a legitimate thing within science, though the scientists, themselves, insert those into science.  If science has problems, a lot of it starts right there.  Not that I'm expecting they're going to do much about it.  Not during my lifetime.  Too many conceited bigots, especially among the guys of science.  Though some gals do it too.   You almost have to to get along in science.

* The "CSI" is the rebranding of the self-discredited CSICOP,  The "Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal:   self-discredited itself in their one and only "scientific investigation."  That was into the "Mars effect" a statistical study by the French investigators and bio-statisticians Michel and Francois Gauquelin in which they found that a randomly selected and statistically significant sample of French and Belgian athletic champions had a strongly statistically significant chance of having been born when the planet Mars was in two certain positions in relation to the Earth and the sun.   CSICOP was led into catastrophe by two of its prominent members who should have understood they proposed an incompetently framed challenge to the Gauquelins, the Harvard employed bio-statistician Marvin Zelin and the UCLA astronomer George Abell, at the urging of the central figure of CSICOP and organized "skepticism" the statistically and scientifically incompetent University of New York at Buffalo philosophy prof Paul Kurtz.  

A fairly good but somewhat biased description of the origin of the affair was given by Ricard Kammann, a former member of the "skeptics" group:

Michel and Francoise Gauquelin found that European sports champions were born in Mars sectors 1 and 4 at a rate of 22% instead of the 17% expected by chance. However, the definition of "chance" requires making assumptions, for example, about the times of day that people are born which are not truly random. While one can try to take all such factors into account to calculate a chance baseline, Marvin Zelen proposed a shortcut in 1976 by looking at the Mars sectors of ordinary people to see how often they are born in sectors 1 and 4. As a method of finding the right baseline, the Zelen challenge is a definitive test.

The first error by the skeptics occurs in the funny way Zelen designed this challenge. Quite logically he said that the control group should be born at the same times and places as the champions. He suggested using 100 or 200 of the original champions to locate the matched control group. Practically nobody noticed in the fine print of Zelen's statistical design that he planned to see if the Mars effect in these 100 or 200 champions was above the baseline effect in their birth mates.

The catch-22 is the small sample size Zelen suggested. If there really is a Mars effect of 22% above 17%, a sample of 100 champions is far too small to detect the effect reliably. The Gauquelins not only spotted the error, but presented Zelen with a mathematical proof of it. As far as I know, Zelen has never admitted the point.


Taking up a corrected version of the Zelen challenge, the Gauquelins deleted a part of their champions group because it would be too difficult to get their control data, and used as many of the remaining champions as they could. Since the local French birth records offices would not always supply the data, the champions group dwindled to 303, but through them, a large control group of 16,756 non-athletes was located. When Zelen analyzed the data, the control group baseline came in almost perfectly, at 16.4%, and the 303 champions incidentally came in with a Mars effect of 21.8%, both as Michel Gauquelin had predicted.

Even the observed Mars effect in the 303 champions subsample was significant at the .02 level. This says that if there really is no Mars effect, and we ran the experiment 100 times, always using 303 champions, we should only observe a value as high as 21.8% in a mere 2 experiments. By a scientific rule of thumb, the investigator is allowed to claim a real effect whenever the "chance probability" of the observed result falls below 5 in 100 experiments. (This arbitrary .05 threshold will appear over and over again here as the "litmus test of truth.")


I will note that much of the best of formal, controlled psychic research has reached or surpassed that "litmus test of truth."  Yet it is held by those who stand by that standard as invalid.  They certainly have had a hand in its arbitrariness.  

The CSICOPs were warned they had made an incompetently constructed challenge by Dennis Rawlins one of CSICOP's co-founders.  Rawlins, in this issue at least, was the honest astronomer but is a pretty unlikable and militant materialist-atheist devotee of scientism in the typical "skeptics" 12-year-old boy style. His specialty was in rather brilliantly analyzing historical issues related to astronomy and supporting himself as a more or less free-lance writer.  Rawlins' account of the botched procedures of Zelen, Kurtz and Abell and their and CSICOP's extraordinarily sleazy cover-up and denial of their mistakes was published in FATE magazine in 1981,  CSICOP's cover-up and sleazy behavior were carried out by a contemporary who's who of materialist-atheist-scientism and makes lively reading, even if the necessary understanding of the statistical issues involved takes some time to understand.  A couple of other analyses of the problem were done by Richard Kammann (a member of CSICOP who resigned once he realized that Rawlin's accusations were valid and that nothing was going to be done within CSICOP to set the record straight) and  Patrick Curry published in the now defunct more scholarly and openly inquiring journal of skepticism, Zetetic Scholar.  All three can be found online.  

I will point out that after the "sTARBABY" debacle, none of the statistically-scientifically incompetent champions of materialist-atheist-scientism, such as the big names in it, Paul Kurtz, James Randi, Phil Klass, etc.  seems to have ever gone back and learned much about statistics and the issues involved.  Considering that a knowledge of such stuff would be necessary before understanding the validity or invalidity of the scientific research they disliked and attacked and got shut down, it's remarkable that the scientists among their colleagues don't seem to have done much to correct those deficenies in their "skepticism."  It's remarkable that those big fat self-proclaimed campions of free scientific inquiry, such as those in CSICOP, have probably shut down more science than the Vatican court that tried Galileo did.  

Tuesday, April 30, 2024

Sort Of Confirmation Of An Idea

MICHAEL SEAN WINTERS has written a two-part book review of a book by Jason Blakely, the second part of which was posted after I made the point about the fact that the Communism and Marxism which the powers of the United States Government, the mass media and the popular culture rose up to oppose so strongly BUT WHICH WE HAVE NEVER BEEN ANY KIND OF DANGER OF GAINING POWER HERE was more than matched by our indigenous form of fascism, white supremacy which is a constant and powerful danger, having been fixed into the Constitution from its inception, made universal by the Supreme Court in Dred Scott, Plessy v Ferguson and in many other decisions and which has almost always been the dominant force in many, at times most of states and, so the Congress and often the presidency.   That thing which the Rehnquist and now Roberts Court is trying their best to revive so as to put its coalition with Big Money into permanent control of the country.   

An interesting point made in that second part of it is worth considering.  I will point out that what is called "liberalism" in the book and the review is that 18th century European "liberalism" and not the older tradition which was based on liberal provision of material support for the poor and destitute.   In its political form it might almost be summed up in the phrase "liberal democracy, " which I've criticized as a dangerous opponent of equality and, so the egalitarian democracy I hold is the only form of government that might withstand the tendencies of all other forms of government to turn into some variety and intensity of gangsterism.

This last point is especially relevant when Blakely turns to socialism which is both a reaction to classical liberalism and a vehicle for progressive politics, the kind of hybridization of ideologies that Blakely's cultural analysis explains and highlights. And, his approach is essential when he considers fascism. Unlike liberalism with Locke's Second Treatise, conservatism with Burke's Reflections on the Revolution in France, and socialism with Marx and Engels' Capital, fascism has no urtext to guide and shape the movement, making it even more likely to almost spontaneously adopt items from other, even opposing, ideological programs if it helps in the moment:

    "Fascism often befuddles contemporary people as it appears disguised and diluted by more familiar ideological traditions than those typical of the classical, twentieth-century fascisms of Hitler's Germany and Mussolini's Italy. But the Western democracies have for some time been busy incubating their own homegrown fascist varietals. If these are less obvious than the original fascisms, it is only because the cultural fusions in which they participate have become head-spinning in their eclecticism."

And he correctly notes what is, in the United States, a key ingredient in fascism's appeal: "Fascist politics provides what appears to its followers as a potent antidote to a modern crisis of spiritual homelessness and nihilism." Fascism may critique rationalism and traffic in romantic ideas of blood and soil, but it is a mistake to think that it is irrational. It corresponds to a need other ideologies have failed to address.

I might disagree with the idea that fascism "corresponds to a need" though what need Winter and Blakley mean when that is said.    I would say that fascism pretends to address that but it's no deeper than any form of dishonest PR.  

Saturday, April 27, 2024

Saturday Night Radio Drama - Tina Fitzpatrick - Marginalia

 Marginalia 

With Gary Murphy, Norma Sheahan, Roger Gregg and by Irene Kelleher. Marginalia directed by Aidan Stanley.

then you have not lived — or have denied the reality of your life

"whatever faith you emerge with at the end of your life is going to be not simply affected by that life but intimately dependent upon it, for faith in God is, in the deepest sense, faith in life — which means, of course, that even the staunchest life of faith is a life of great change. It follows that if you believe at 50 what you believed at 15, then you have not lived — or have denied the reality of your life."
 
Christian Wiman

I'VE POINTED OUT before that there are lots and lots of atheists who proudly declare they'd had it all figured out by the time they were fourteen, or twelve, or nine.   Or eight.  They had it all figured out that religion was all bunk and, it's pretty clear they've never changed their minds since.  I could add that their arguments about religion generally show that their thinking remains at about that age level if you engage with them on the issue.  Unfortunately, they're not the only ones who are cases of frozen development, there are lots of people within religion who never thought seriously enough about religion to question their beliefs to come to a more mature view of things.  

That quote at the top of this post comes from an article by Jonathan Merritt about a famous biblical scholar who I'm not very familiar with, Richard B. Hays, who wrote a book in 1996 which contained a  argument against LGBTQ relationships that, apparently, was much cited by those who wanted to discriminate against us.  I don't travel much in white evangelical circles so I'd never had "chapter 16" from that book pulled on me in arguments, oddly, I don't think I've ever had a Catholic care to get into it with me and any arguments I had on it were on grounds of would-be science and secular stereotyping.  But a lot of People do get into it with "evangelicals."  The article gives some of the angry, frightened responses from white evangelicals to the news that the man who provided them with their arguments has changed his mind in a forthcoming book he wrote with his son, also an eminent biblical scholar.  Some of them are blaming the son with leading the father into apostasy.

I was interested in that because another very respected bible scholar, the very Luke Timothy Johnson who I've cited a lot recently, said that he had been guilty of the sin of homophobia until some of his out of the closet students and his own Lesbian daughter had shown him what he believed about LGBTQ+ People was wrong. The accusation made by one evangelical conservative that Hayes had been led into apostasy by his son makes me think that it's not surprising that it would be younger People who did because the older generation, including mine, grew up with LGBTQ+ People being invisible and silent.   By the time the elder Hayes reached adulthood, he might have lived his life in a milieu in which LGBTQ+ People didn't figure much, just as some can live a life in which they don't have much direct contact with members of other targeted minority groups.  Their concepts of us were based, not on direct and open knowledge, but on lurid stereotypes and imaginations.  Their knowledge of the lives of gay people might be like someone basing their knowledge of straight Peoples' sex lives on what was presented in pornography.  Younger People  are more likely to have grown up knowing out of the closet LGBTQ+ People and knowing their lives showed the full range of relationships, from faithful, equal marriages to those who acted as bad as any straight immoralist.  Ranging from moral, responsible adults to self-indulgent perpetual 12-year-old boys to sadistic assholes and down to the likes of Lindsey Graham or Peter Thiele.

Johnson comes out of a Catholic background so there are differences in his own view of Scripture is bound to differ from that of someone with an evangelical orientation.  One that holds Scripture as important, even authoritative and at times to be taken literally but holding it loosely and not so tightly as to squeeze the life out of it.  The differences in quality and type of authority, perhaps, too.  I take Scripture as something to be considered and studied and thought about in coming to a variety of contingent conclusions as to how to live and think about things that can't be discovered through history or science or secular literature.  And that exercise can't possibly be done without thinking about it apart from our own, lived experience.  The Scriptures are full of People doing that, especially the literature of the Bible that Jesus cited the most, the Psalms and the Prophets.   That's especially true of a Christian whose understanding of Jesus the Christ is that Jesus is the Living Christ.  

Luke Timothy Johnson has pointed out that Scripture is merely one way of knowing the living Jesus and said one of the ways we learn about the living Jesus is in our life experience and, especially, in our interactions with other People, those close to us in our families and acquaintances and also in those who live lives on the social, economic and political margins, those without power.  There are certainly Biblical, especially Gospel and New Testament texts that support that idea, especially that the "Kingdom of God" is open to those on the sexual margins.  Jesus told the religious establishment, the "white evangelicals" or "good Catholics" of his time that prostitutes as well as tax collectors would enter into the Kingdom of God before they would.  He didn't say "reformed prostitutes" or even "reformed tax collectors" though in the case of Zacchaeus the tax collector who climbed a tree to see him, he said he'd stop stealing and give back what he'd stolen.   I could point out that in another Gospel Jesus didn't give the Samaritan woman a lecture on her less than faithful sex life before he offered her the "living water" which is certainly the same as an invitation to the Kingdom.  Paul might have had qualms about those who practiced same-sex sex, though it's pretty clear he had no idea about People who had an exclusively same-sex orientation, he figured they were out of control hetero-sexual libertines.  As the theologian Cheryl Anderson and Audre Lorde would say, he was thinking of everyone as a member of his expected authoritative default.   I think it's quite possible that two thousand years of hostility to LGBTQ+ People is based on the naivety of Paul in regard to sex and a misunderstanding of his use of that in his more general arguments in Romans and elsewhere, out of those are a few other clobber passages in the Bible which, as I've pointed out before, are as fraught with issues as the parts of the Bible dealing with slavery and other issues.  Johnson, a deep scholar of the Pauline literature, says that whenever Paul was up against the dominant mores of Mediterranean patriarchal culture, his radical egalitarianism went out the window.  He then made distinctions that he otherwise and eloquently rejected as being relevant to the Church he was helping to establish.

The Bible is not read today as it was written in societies in the very ancient and classical Eastern Mediterranean regions.  We can't reproduce the mind-sets of that time or the times and conditions lived under, we can't un-live the cultural accretions that are part of the world and lives we have lived and continue to live.  We can try to understand it on something closer to the writers own terms and thinking than a naive and dishonest "literal reading" of it will produce.  We can understand when churches doctrines and dogmas are an inheritance from the past that was, as well, conditioned by their own lives and understanding to judge if those are valid interpretations and valid ways to decide how to live.  And we can certainly grow in our understanding of it as we learn from living our lives, that is if we choose to learn anything from experience and, really, how can you exclude that and not be spiritually as well as intellectually dead.  But ignoring Scripture, a rich repository of the inspired writing of many People like us and unlike us in so many ways would be to give up one of the richest spiritual and literary and, for want of a better word, psychological resources there is. So that's not a productive option, either.  

Friday, April 26, 2024

The Six Fascists On The Court Are Trying To Turn This Into A Republican Presidential Fascism

THAT IS THE PLAIN reading of the hearing on Trumpian immunity.    The Court has to be stripped of its usurped powers and cut down to size by first imposing a term limit that will remove the RAT in that putrid building, Roberts, Alito and Thomas, and then the others as they have sat on that bench for a term.   Along with the absolute and strict ban on them and their spouses profiting off of anything to do with anything they did on the court.   

The Supreme Court, the Corrupt Court is the most corrupt branch of the government and it has been since they were ruling in favor of their own slave-holding.  

baleful effects on our general culture - A Footnote

LATE LAST night I remembered reading this in Rupert Sheldrake's book Science Set Free,  it also supports my use of Denis Noble's talk in discussing politics.

The belief that genes are the basis of almost all inheritance is not just an intellectual theory but has had enormous economic and political consequences.  It has resulted in the investment of hundreds of billions of dollars in genome and biotechnology projects.  If genes are the keys to life, then people want to own them and exploit them.  But if genes are grossly overrated, genomics will never live up to the high hopes it once engendered.  A few companies make useful products, but many make promises that never come true.

The gene-centered view of life has dominated science since the 1960s with baleful effects on our general culture.  Jeffrey Skilling, the CEO of Enron, a corporation noted for its greed and predatory behavior, said that his favorite book was The Selfish Gene, and the selfish-gene theory was a major part of Enron's corporate culture until the company collapsed in 2001.  Skilling, who is serving a long jail sentence, interpreted neo-Darwinism to mean that selfishness was ultimately good even for its victims, because it weeded out losers and forced survivors to become strong.


Genes are not individualistic and selfish, despite the rhetoric suggesting they are.  As parts of larger wholes, they work cooperatively in the development and functioning of organisms.  If they have any moral message for humans, it is that life depends on working together and not on ruthless competition.  

A broader understanding of heredity that includes genes, gene modifications and morphic resonance opens up many new questions, and helps free the life sciences from the tunnel vision of molecular biology.  It makes a big difference scientifically.  For a start, the word "hereditary" is no longer synonymous with "genetic."  Genes are part of heredity, not all of it. . . 


Which gives only one of so many possible examples of how neo-Darwinism has had a malignant effect on the general culture of the modern period, businessmen making use of it goes back into the gilded age robber barons,  John D. Rockefeller brought his understanding of natural selection into the infamous YMCA lecture he gave.

The growth of a large business is merely a survival of the fittest. … The American Beauty rose can be produced in the splendor and fragrance which bring cheer to its beholder only by sacrificing the early buds which grow up around it. This is not an evil tendency in business. It is merely the working-out of a law of nature and a law of God.

Anticipating the repetition of the common received lie that "survival of the fittest" isn't the same thing as natural selection, Darwin, himself said they were identical in the fifth edition of On the Origin of Species, something which I never seem to have to stop pointing out.*    But even if Darwin had not said that is irrelevant because what matters is how such people as Charles Sumner,  Rockefeller or Skillings reads Darwin, or how Galton, for that matter reads and uses his ideas and how anyone uses the ideas of neo-Darwinism as popularized by those such as O. E. Wilson and Richard Dawkins.  

Earlier in the same chapter Sheldrake said after a brief mention of John Stuart Mill's ideas about modifying the society to change "human nature" for the better:

On the other hand, Francis Galton, Charles Darwin's cousin, made a strong scientific case for the predominance of heredity which is often taken to support a more conservative philosophy.  In his book Hereditary Genius (1869), he argued that the prominence of Britian's most distinguished families depended more on nature than on nurture.  Galton was a pioneering advocate of eugenics, a word he coined.  He also realized that the question of nature and nurture could be studied with the help of identical twins.  He argued that identical twins had a similar hereditary constitution, while non-identical twins were no more similar than ordinary brothers and sisters.  And, sure enough, he found remarkable similarities between identical twins in a wide range of characteristics including the onset of disease and even time of death.

Some political philosophers used Galton's ideas on heredity to justify the British class system, and Galton himself proposed that the state should regulate the fertility of the population in such a way to favor the improvement of human nature through selective breeding.  The eugenics movement had a large following in the United States  and reached its apogee in Nazi Germany.  Not surprisingly, Nazi scientists were very interested in twins who were kept in special barracks.  Mengele told one of his colleagues, "It would be a sin, a crime . . . not to utilize the possibilities that Auschwitz had for twin research.  There would never be another chance like it."   

Sheldrake gives ample citations, as he always does even in his more popular writing such as Science Set Free,  If you haven't read the book, it's very interesting and provocative reading and you can check out his footnotes and citations.

I would fault him for missing several points that I made, that Darwin's theory of natural selection was the absolute inspiration and basis for Galton's eugenics, Galton said so in his Memoir in which he published Darwin's letter praising Hereditary Genius and we know that Darwin used Galton's eugenics writings to support his theory of natural selection in his later The Descent of Man (1871), rather an instance of circular reasoning, using an application of the theory in the theories support.  And, his point about the use of Galton's eugenics to support the British class system is a wider instance of circular reasoning because Darwin, himself, said that one of his greatest inspirations in inventing natural selection was his reading of Thomas Malthus on Population, in which Malthus props up the British class system and the laws that produced it and the extreme economic inequality that Darwin and Galton, as well as Malthus got the better end of the stick of that inequality.   As I recently pointed out you cannot possibly disassociate the British class system (and the self-interest of those who benefited from it)  from natural selection because its intellectual inspiration is utterly saturated with it, supports it and identifies its inequality with the way of "nature" when it is entirely man-made, artificial and the result of intentionally pursued self-interest.  The fact that the basis of that unholy trinity is based, not on natural conditions but the artifice of the English crown and aristocracy during the Tudor period and then expanded during the British period plays no small part in my complete skepticism in regard to the theory of natural selection, that and the fact that no instance of natural selection or even an artificial selection experiment has produced a new species in line with the entire stated motive of coming up with the theory to start with, to explain how the present diversity of life came about with myriads of "favored races" surviving as "unfavored" ones died out or, quite graphically in Darwinian fantasy as a result of a struggle for life or death.  

He could also, in line with what I added, have noted that through Galton's eugenics, Nazism was a direct consequence of a belief in Darwin's natural selection theory because what he abbreviated in a line I've shown in a long series of posts with citations, long passages given and often links to online publications of original documents.  

So, I'm hardly the only one who has noticed that this particular line of science has a strong dramatic and often extremely dangerous impact on politics and laws.   I could go on at length, but I already have, many times.  There's some difference between someone who knows the territory who accepts that evolution has happened and someone who is a "young earth creationist" who does or doesn't.  And there's a complete difference between anyone who is familiar with the primary literature and those who are too lazy or cowardly to look at it and admit what it says.

* I should point out that in looking for material for this post I ran into several online sources (here, for example) that repeat the lie that Darwin never intended his theory to be applied to the human species when his second major book on the topic, The Descent of Man had exactly that application as its theme and motivation.   I've come to believe that just about everything in that regard is either Darwinists who have never actually read what Darwin wrote or Darwinists who have read it and who are blatantly lying about it.  


Wednesday, April 24, 2024

The list goes on because no aspect of today's society can have escaped dogmas like

 "we are born selfish," "they, genes, have created us body and mind," . . .

DENIS NOBLE'S talk that I've been transcribing and commenting on ended very laudably with this:

Now I want to come to a final plea, back to the question of water. Because I want to finish this talk by returning to the unusual and amazing properties of water.  And you People in Iran will know only too well the importance of water.  You have sessions at this congress on the importance of water preservation.  And you might think this is a concern only in the traditionally arid areas of the world.  But I tell you it's much more serious than that.  My own country, England, illustrated in this image is also suffering a drought this year.  The whole of the Eastern part of my country is, at the moment, in a disastrous drought state.  You can see the ground is brown, not green.  So, even in England's "green and pleasant land" water is now a scarcity and the countryside is no longer green.  It is, therefore, urgent.  Young People everywhere in the world should plead with their rulers to save the world because life, as we've seen, cannot exist without water.  

So, I want to finish this talk with a wake-up call to the world everywhere, not only in Iran and my country, England, but everywhere in the world because the challenge is on a scale which human society has never faced before.  The climate change problem is a problem for a new generation, to create a world fit for the challenges of the 21st century.  They, that upcoming generation, they will face many looming signposts to warn them what went wrong.  The fires, the droughts, and the other problems.  So their generation will be the one that has to take responsibility for the way in which the Earth's ecosystems need rescuing.  Even for our own species, we humans, to survive.  Theirs will be a generation who can try to recover from the damage to society that results from reductionist models of physiology and evolution that have metaphorically shaped our ideas and models in fields as diverse as economics, sociology, philosophy, ethics, politics, , ,  The list goes on because no aspect of today's society can have escaped dogmas like "we are born selfish," "they, genes have created us body and mind," "it's in his DNA," and all the myriads of other tropes of related types that we now use almost without thinking.  Those future generations will also need to rewrite the textbooks, not only because they see the virtue of, "let us therefore teach our children"  to quote Richard Dawkins, but also because their politicians, economists, sociologists and philosophers will also need to find new strategies in collaboration with biologists and ecologists to lead them out of the gene-centric impasse.  It is, arguably, a challenge the scale of which human society has never faced before because the very future of life, of humans on this planet is at stake.  So I wish them all well.  

The chemistry of life begins and ends with water.

So thank you for your attention at this congress in Iran you can download all of the articles I've referred to free of charge from my website, www.denisnoble.com


Thank you very much and thank you for asking me, yet again, to talk to the Iranian Congress of Biology.


So, you can see that my diversions into politics as well as within biology aren't that far from the thinking of Denis Noble, but that's where I'll leave it for now.  I'm sure there will be more reasons to go into what he and his colleagues have said on these topics and their social, legal and political consequences.  

Monday, April 22, 2024

Harold Darke - O Brother Man

 

 
 
Boston Trinity Church Choir
 
O Brother man! fold to thy heart thy brother;
Where pity dwells, the peace of God is there;
To worship rightly is to love each other,
Each smile a hymn, each kindly deed a prayer.

Follow with reverent steps the great example
Of Him whose holy work was " doing good " ;
So shall the wide earth seem our Father's temple,
Each loving life a psalm of gratitude.

Then shall all shackles fall; the stormy clangor
Of wild war music o'er the earth shall cease;
Love shall tread out the baleful fire of anger,
And in its ashes plant the tree of peace!
 
John Greenleaf Whittier  

I resolved to post more music this year and I haven't been keeping it yet. 

given all of that, that kind of free action must surely be true

FOR THIS NEXT TO LAST post on Denis Noble's short lecture The Chemistry of Life Begins With Water, I'll comment just a little on his summary of why he believes that the actual, detailed molecular chemistry of life supports concepts of free will that the old-fashioned, cartoonish view of DNA and even cruder concepts of life and reproduction and evolution are used to actively refute in service to the ideology of materialist-atheist-scientism.  Not that I couldn't point out the relevance of many of his points to what I'm interested in, political, legal and social implications of this but I'll wait to do that seeing how I must have strained your tolerance for that in my last couple of posts.   Later, I might risk posting my transcript of his talk without my commentary some time in the future along with a link to the video in which you can compare what I've typed out to what he said and, don't forget, his, for once, extremely useful slides.    

Nerve cells are densely packed with ion channels in their membranes.  And those channels are also continuously jiggling around in a stochastic dance.  Nervous systems are almost designed to be harnessing chance. Just as the immune system can distinguish between the forms of DNA variation to enable it to latch on to a new virus or a new bacterium so our nervous systems can latch on to the neural mechanisms that satisfy the criterion of social choice.  This is not a new idea incidentally, it was originally formulated by Gerald Edelman who won the Noble prize in 1972 for his discovery of the structure of the immune system's immunoglobulin proteins.  He went on to suggest the same harnessing of chance could be operating in the nervous system. He even called it "neural Darwinism" in a book he published many years ago.

So, I've pursued this question together with my brother zoologist and philosopher Raymond Noble to ask the question, does that enable values to influence physiology?  The choice of what we should do.  And where, in those articles, I argue that conscious organisms have the ability to match up their behavioral routines with the constraints of social interactions.  Including, for example, the concepts of fairness and for many other values for which we all live our lives.  If that is so then we have a process by which natural stochasticity, chance can be harnessed, that is used to enable us to act with what philosophers call the only free will worth having.  But can conscious choice influence our biochemistry?  Can it control the genome that way?  

Passing up the temptation of the phrase "neural Darwinism" in line with my skepticism about the existence of natural selection, I'll point out that this series of posts really began back with my posting of Thomas Merton's short essay "What is Liberty?"  in which he defined the basic level of liberty, freedom as being the ability to choose what was good over what was evil.  Certainly, in my context of political, social and legal use of freedom as a good thing, opposed to the kind of libertarian freedom which, under "liberal democracy" holds that all kinds of evil actions and oppression and even killings are permissible as "liberty,"  that IS the most important question. 'Liberal democracy" as it is encoded in most political and legal systems facilitates individuals to harm others, other People, other animals, the environment we all depend on as "liberty."   Egalitarian democracy depends on our choosing to restrain our inner two-year-old brat to allow others to live a decent, safe life.  But even more than that is under attack from the ideological choices and decisions of many influential People presented to us by the publishing media and industry.   As I will never stop pointing out, the kind of denial of the possibility of free thought, "free will" that is all the rage among materialist-atheist-scientistic academics and babblers and scribblers is rightly seen as a basic and direct attack on democracy as much as anything the billionaires, especially those with political control of some of the largest and richest countries on Earth are financing, today.  

Considering the use of "twin studies" by those whose Darwinism turns to eugenics and scientific racism, concentrating on seemingly uncanny similarities in twins separated a birth, this use of more detailed studies of twins by Denis Noble is very welcome.  

Now I come to a very interesting study that physiologists have done over many years looking at identical twins.  Identical twins have nearly identical genomes.  There are small differences but they're very slight.  Now imagine that one of them is brought up in an environment that leads him to choose to train as an athlete and the other does not.  Not surprisingly, as shown in the photo here, the body builds are completely different.  And in an extensive study of such cases of identical twins, physiologists have been able to identify the control RNAs in the athletic ones that enable their muscle proteins to grow so much.  So, the decision to train as an athlete, provided that decision is implemented in practice, leads to precisely those changes at the molecular level that enable the athlete to succeed.

Now, what is impressive about this study is that it identifies the small RNA molecules that control the genome.  And, in fact, this is happening all the time.  Our decisions to do whatever we do are inevitably controlling our genomes because similar physiological processes must be involved.   There are armies of small RNAs, of control RNAs wait to do just this.  


Now, is this what we call free will?  What I have shown is the harnessing of stochasticity, the use of stochasticity or chance clearly enables a form of creativity in behavior that allows social constraints the ideas of value and judgement that go with them to influence the physiology of our bodies.  But why should we call this "free will?"   Doesn't it mean that,  after all, we are determined but just by social interaction processes rather than physical processes?   

Well, yes, that's true in a sense. But what surely would disturb us as a challenge to our ability to choose would be a demonstration that there we are always impelled to do what we do by purely physical processes.  "My Genes Made Me Do It" is even the title of a book.  


So, being physically compelled and socially influenced are very different forms of determination.  Being influenced, even feeling compelled by the social influences of shared values and judgements surely does not worry us in the same way.  We can even observe the same processes in other species.  Packs of dogs illustrated in my image here, and groups of monkeys have both been shown in careful studies to be capable of discriminating against the members of the pack who are not cooperating.  These distinctions, therefore, between the physical and the social influences are surely the basis for what many philosophers   refer to when they talk about the kind of free will worth having.

You see, as the person, Denis Noble, I'm not worried by the fact that my upbringing and my social interaction has greatly influenced my values and, therefore, my actions.  Why ever should I wish it to be otherwise?


So, social freedom is the form of freewill worth having.  Furthermore, influence by social factors does not imply compulsion.  Social factors and the reasons we may give for our actions are what philosophers call defeasible.  Meaning, that in retrospect we may give the reasons for what we do.  Legal processes in our law courts illustrate that process all the time.

The concept of defeasibility was developed as a legal concept as well as having a philosophical basis.  


Now, clarifying what kinds of free will are worth having is, indeed, a philosophical question.  But what I hope I have done is to outline a way in which physiological processes, dependent upon the stochastic properties of water and, in turn, the stochastic properties of all the molecules that are in and dissolved in or suspended in water can exist and enable that kind of free will to occur.  Indeed, I would go further.  Given what we know of the chemistry of life, of its dependence on these interesting properties of water and the ability of water to give us the variability that we need to make choices, given all of that, that kind of free action must surely be true.

All of this is certainly welcomed by an egalitarian democrat like me because it gives a physical mechanism by which we can exercise free thought, free choice and it should be welcomed by anyone who has any esteem for human thinking, human reasoning, the long and large academic heritage and, even in its frequently decadent and self-destructive forms current in academia today, it defeats the simplistic, cartoon of physical determinism that is the default ideology imposed by the social and intellectual coersion that has hegemonic control of academia, the media and, increasingly, the legal and political mainstream.  Even those hardest of hard core physical determinists, and almost all of them are some species of materialist-atheist-true believer in scientism, don't want the logical conclusions of their ideological holdings because, as I've pointed out, it can't but help undermine any esteem that their professional product is held in.  

I don't, however, think that what Denis Noble says goes far enough, though as a scientist he is properly keeping in bounds with what his profession can honestly say about any of this.  You might have noticed that in the beginning of this section of his talk, Denis Noble said, "Nervous systems are almost designed to be harnessing chance."   In that "almost" is the formal reticence of a scientist who knows his science cannot determine if even something so reasonably concluded to have been a product of design because the design would require a designer.  Whether that designer is in line with the traditional concept of God, the Creator or if it is the design of an individual, overseeing living mind that does what he attributes to the molecules and cells and systems of cells in the body, harnesses the physical properties of water and fats and other molecules to do things toward an end, witnessing such a process makes it intellectually allowable, maybe even respectable to conclude that someone is in control of it all just as someone would have to make the choice above even the social influences and coercions, in the end.  

Having been steeping myself in the late plays of Eugene O'Neill during this same time as I've been doing this series, plays in which addition to alcohol and opiates are at the center of the tragedies he presented, plays about his family members and himself, we aren't only given one set of social influences to choose among, we are not compelled to choose one or another even on that level.  And the choices we make are not determined by our environments, those are defeasible as well.  We can reject or accept what our families and communities present as a better choice.   Listening to Long Days Journey Into Night, I heard the excuses the mother gives for her remaining addicted to morphine and recognized every excuse that the alcoholics in my family gave for not giving up alcohol.  I have said here before that when my brother refused to try AA because he "rejected a higher power" I could tell him he had chosen a higher power in the form of the ethyl alcohol molecule, that was his higher power to which he had sacrificed his health, his mental health, his job, his family, his home and car and everything else.  It's a rather bitter joke to me that ideological atheists have adopted a cartoon picture of an atom as the equivalent of a cross or star of David or a crescent moon.  To me that choice says everything there is to know about the choice that they have made and why it is incompatible with life.  

Though it isn't directly relevant to my use of Denis Noble's lecture, I will try to get around to typing out the last five or so minutes in which he makes a highly moral and laudable choice to concentrate on the politics, laws and social aspects of the provision of clean water which is as much in danger as egalitarian democracy is under the various gangster legal regimes from the worst dictatorships to the less corrupt liberal democracies which allow millionaires and billionaires to buy "water rights" and deprive People of the very basis of life, itself.  I think it's telling about the limits of traditional biology that this is the first time I've heard or read an in-depth analysis of that fact, that our bodies are mostly water, the substance that all of my previous reading in biology and related sciences just considered as if it was there to fill up space while the larger, more complex molecules operated independent of it.  Such a basically simplistic and incompetent view of life has been what has dominated the culture of biological sciences in my experience.  For that alone, this is a landmark lecture in my understanding of science.   

Sunday, April 21, 2024

Spring Cleanin' Getting Ready To Blog - With A Response

LOOKING AT yesterday's posts this morning, I notice that I'd accidentally posted a rough draft of the long post instead of something more like one I'd want to post.   I've gone through it and added some things that got deleted in the rough edit and fixed a couple of problems with verb agreement,  something that's bound to happen when you decide to change a single or plural subject around.    

Since materialism is a monistic ideology, holding that everything that exists is a product of material causation in line with what science claims about that, in responding to the real-life consequences of materialist-atheist-scientistic ideology I have every right to relate that to the very real political situation in which egalitarian democracy is thwarted and prevented and endangered, especially as those with academic credentials and a platform are undermining the very foundations of equality and democracy on behalf of that ideology,  denying the reality of the possibility of freedom of thought.   That seemingly academic polemical self-impeaching ideological struggle does have real life consequences, as can be seen in that ideology being held, either formally or loosely by some of the worst despots and mass murderers in history.   Having Robert Sopolsky out there promoting the belief that free thought is impossible as Trump, with the neo-Stalinist, Putin's and Xi's support, is trying to destroy democracy in the U.S., in Europe and elsewhere has to count as among the most irresponsible antics by an academic yet in  this century. 

And it's on the basis of old-fashioned, outmoded, refuted biological orthodoxy which started to crumble about eight decades ago. 

Saturday, April 20, 2024

Saturday Night Radio Drama - Eugene O'Neill - Hughie

 Hughie


Jason Robards - Erie

Jack Dodson - Night Clerk 

Jason Robards was a great O'Neill actor,  Jack Dodson, the only thing I ever saw him in was as Howard Sprague on the Andy Griffiths Show.   I think this is the audio of the stage performance that was shown on Great Performances more than thirty years ago.   It works really well as an audio play because it's mostly the monologue of Erie with a little bit of interaction with Hughes, the night clerk who has a few short monologues himself. 

I've been binging on O'Neill and needed something a little more upbeat.  When he was writing his first plays, his father, the famous actor James O'Neill asked him if he were trying to get his audience to go home and commit suicide.