Thursday, July 15, 2021

Considering How Relatively Rare They Are As Compared To Most Wars, Most Of Those Most College Credentialed People Can Name Are "Religious Wars" - Hate Mail

TODAY IS GOING to be an extremely busy day as yesterday unexpectedly was.  So I'll answer the same stupid claim George Carlin made part of his scolding atheist sermon as stand up comedy routine after that beatnik shtick failed him with a post where I answered it. 

Sunday, December 2, 2018

Why Let The Facts or Logical Coherence Get In The Way Of A Satisfying Prejudice?

As I said in passing in a short, impromptu post a few days ago, I increasingly don't listen to the CBC's Sunday Edition because its longtime host Michael Enright can get on my nerves.  That was on my mind because last week was one I opted not to listen.

That's too bad because the piece I wrote about the scummy product of too many elite Catholic schools in the United States could have benefited from his piece about the scandal plagued St. Michael's School, which he went to, which had its own, Canadian problems with jock culture and machismo.  It's a good essay which I certainly would have referenced.  Hockey culture can be as anti-Christian as football, though most of that is not an intrinsic part of the game, as it is in American football.   You could, conceivably, play a game of hockey without any violation of anything in the Gospel or epistles.  Though you can certainly violate those as typically they are in all sports.  But you violate everything up to and including the Golden Rule as soon as you start playing football, violence is an intrinsic part of the game, it is more than slightly and more than intentionally like the Roman gladiatorial spectacles that were eventually banned by Christianity in Rome. The presence of American football at any Catholic or supposedly Christian school is a sign that the moral character of the place is a facade covering moral decay.

But my reason for writing this was in the letters Enright read today, a letter writer who talks about the priest-coach who ran a sadistic sports program, him witnessing the priest kicking a player of Italian heritage and calling him a "yellow wop".  The letter writer said that witnessing that put him off "organized religion".  My question is why didn't it put him off organized sports, especially organized sports in schools, such incidents abound in entirely secular contexts, schools, universities, amateur and professional sports, youth sports (wonder what the guy said about the various sex scandals involving prominent coaches in Canadian Youth Hockey a decade or more back).

It comes the day after I heard a podcast in which the host cites GORE VIDAL! as an expert on the history of the culpability of "single-god religions" in producing the long history of warfare and bloodshed.  That someone could believe Gore Vidal on anything much is a head shaker.  The guy was an admitted pederast whose frequent trips to Thailand, rightly infamous as a center of pedophile sex slavery as well as a long and documented life of cruising, sometimes in company with other celebrity writers and celebrities of not even that accomplishment are well known.  Not to mention that his veracity on matters historical is documented to be spotty and suspected of being ideological if not just a reflection of his prejudices and personal preferences.

This isn't what I was looking for by way of citations on this and I'm still worn out from being sick so I'll just post this:

In his hilarious [I'll break in here to stipulate that I've never found a single thing he did "hilarious"] analysis of The 10 Commandments, George Carlin said to loud applause, “More people have been killed in the name of God than for any other reason,” and many take this idea as an historical fact. When I hear someone state that religion has caused most wars, though, I will often and ask the person to name these wars. The response is typically, “Come on! The Crusades, The Inquisition, Northern Ireland, the Middle East, 9/11. Need I name more?”  

Well, yes, we do need to name more, because while clearly there were wars that had religion as the prime cause, an objective look at history reveals that those killed in the name of religion have, in fact, been a tiny fraction in the bloody history of human conflict. In their recently published book, “Encyclopedia of Wars,” authors Charles Phillips and Alan Axelrod document the history of recorded warfare, and from their list of 1763 wars only 123 have been classified to involve a religious cause, accounting for less than 7 percent of all wars and less than 2 percent of all people killed in warfare. While, for example, it is estimated that approximately one to three million people were tragically killed in the Crusades, and perhaps 3,000 in the Inquisition, nearly 35 million soldiers and civilians died in the senseless, and secular, slaughter of World War 1 alone.

History simply does not support the hypothesis that religion is the major cause of conflict. The wars of the ancient world were rarely, if ever, based on religion. These wars were for territorial conquest, to control borders, secure trade routes, or respond to an internal challenge to political authority. In fact, the ancient conquerors, whether Egyptian, Babylonian, Persian, Greek, or Roman, openly welcomed the religious beliefs of those they conquered, and often added the new gods to their own pantheon. 

Medieval and Renaissance wars were also typically about control and wealth as city-states vied for power, often with the support, but rarely instigation, of the Church. And the Mongol Asian rampage, which is thought to have killed nearly 30 million people, had no religious component whatsoever. 

Most modern wars, including the Napoleonic Campaign, the American Revolution, the French Revolution, the American Civil War, World War I, the Russia Revolution, World War II, and the conflicts in Korea and Vietnam, were not religious in nature or cause. While religious groups have been specifically targeted (most notably in World War II), to claim that religion was the cause is to blame the victim and to misunderstand the perpetrators’ motives, which were nationalistic and ethnic, not religious.

I think the reason that lazy-assed journalists, scribblers, babblers, go to that old saw about religion being to blame for everything is exactly that, they're lazy and they know that it's the easiest accusation in the world to make and, being easy, it will get the universal approval of the bigoted and superficial, risking little in the way of opposition.  And, as it notes in my immediate previous post, its total lack of veracity and documentation will not make the slightest bit of difference, even when the refutation of it is provided.

Wednesday, July 14, 2021

Hate Mail - How Would You Make One That's Better!

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of TRUE speech, or of the press TO PUBLISH THE TRUTH; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

To tell you the truth, considering how judges,"justices" etc. are fully capable of pretending they're too stupid to be able to do things like tell the truth from lies, religion from  hucksters gulling the marginally sane and stupid into not only giving them money but doing stupid and terrible things, the problems go a lot deeper than merely addressing the worst aspects of the Bill of Rights.  You'll have to entirely change the culture of the legal racket to get far in this.   I have absolutely no doubt that most judges and "justices" can tell the difference but so many of them are as capable of pretending not to for the most corrupt and base of reasons and the others know they're going to get overturned if they don't play that game that it will take removing those who either are that stupid or pretend to be, giving them that to worry about.  I'd start by removing Kavanaugh for lying through his teeth during his confirmation and go on from there.  As I recently pointed out every single person in the room at the Roberts and Alito hearings knew they were lying through their teeth as much so, just not as brazenly. 

If the Congress or other legislatures made liars vulnerable to civil action or loss of license or otherwise were driven out of business, I anticipate having far fewer problems with that than I do things as they stand now.   If liars were so removed from the media the quality of Congress and the state legislatures would improve enormously. 

I'd make religion prove that at least 75% of their intake goes to legitimate charitable purposes for the least among us, too.  There should be definitions of what is and what isn't religion.  You can start by excluding the grifters from that category. 

Update:  I really don't care what Simps listens to, if he likes it, good for him as long as I don't have to listen to it.  It's not immoral.  It's not like listening to Toby Keith.

The Same Founders And First Congress Members Who Wrote This Piece Of Crap Wrote The First Amendment That Lets The Fasicst Lie Us Into Perpetual Mass Shooting

 


Tuesday, July 13, 2021

David Fink Is My Current Hero - Trying To Rescue The Legal Profession From Itself Is Next To Impossible But Someone Has To Try To

 


Of course the liar-lawyers were nowhere near the most irresponsible, reckless, carriers of Trump's Big Lie, they weren't the major force in trying to destroy democracy even by inciting violent insurrection, that would be the media's role in this. 

Don't expect any journalist to try to rescue their profession in this way, they wouldn't even make the attempt  to get to this level.  Those who might want to would be inhibited into enabling by "The First Amendment," in the age when lies can be told with impunity from even civil court consequences.  Thanks to the First Congress as amended by the Warren and subsequent courts, that danger to democracy won't be removed but enabled to be even more dangerous in the future.

"Public Intellectualism" Is Largely A Whore House Supported By The Oligarchs Today - To Declare Yourself One Is Absurd, To Be Called One Should Be Insulting

THE SECTIONS OF THIS "PUBLIC INTELLECTUAL" BULLSHIT invoking things like "cognitive psychology" are things I'd very much like to go into but that would take background reading and analysis that there isn't time for.  I'd give some general advice to be on your guard when someone makes recourse to  the ideological sciences such as that or anythings with the prefixes "cog" or "neuro" unless what they are claiming is purely and demonstrably physiological - though, since they are very highly susceptible to manipulation to get the response desired, anything resorting to MRI in that area of speculation is probably unsafe.   That's especially true when it's a right-winger doing it for political or legalistic purposes.  I'm hard pressed to remember one of those who isn't a liar to start with.

Wehner: You were a key figure in the same-sex marriage debate in the 1990s. How did you see your role in the same-sex-marriage debate at the time?

I would jump in there and say that that isn't something I recall and I was reading and taking an active interest in that issue from before 1990.   I think both of these "public intellectuals" are highly devoted to the creation and promotion of their own personal mythology.  If either of them were "key figures" of anything it somehow escaped my notice. 

Rauch: One is that I thought I had the right answer. I realized right away that this was an issue for me because I was, by that point, a social conservative and said: This is a conservative movement. This is gay people saying, “We’ve had it with being isolated individuals who live in our own separate world and are alienated from norms like marriage and family. That failed us in the AIDS crisis.” And I said, Here’s a case where all my core beliefs come together—equality for gay people; better lives for young people, who need the prospect of marriage; and joining, upholding, and strengthening possibly society’s most important nonpolitical institution. So I saw myself as having something to say that only a few other people were saying, and doing it in a more systematic way.

Another thing I thought I was doing was just more political, which is helping the public understand that the case for gay marriage is a conservative case. That’s why progressive gay and lesbian people and leaders were at best ambivalent about marriage, especially at first. A lot of them were against it because they perceived it, rightly, to be an embrace of this bourgeois norm that they didn’t want. So I thought I could have a public and political role in explaining that this was a conservative movement.

This is absolute, ahistorical bullshit that starts in the assumption that marriage is properly the property of conservatives - look at who among which party remained married and whose marriages split among presidents and presidential candidates as an exercise.  

What is most outrageous of this statement for me is that I don't remember conservatives being the ones struggling for gay marriage, I remember them using the issue to attack Democrats - IN EVERY CASE IT WAS LIBERAL DEMOCRATS PUTTING THEMSELVES ON THE LINE FOR MARRIAGE EQUALITY IN THOSE YEARS - it was conservatives who wrote DOMA and it was Republicans and Democrats who knew how Republicans were setting up gay marriage as a wedge issue to use in elections against them who voted for it,  Bill Clinton, though having opposed it, signed it into law for that purpose IT WAS LIBERAL DEMOCRATS WHO OPPOSED IT.   The court cases, even the Windsor case that pointed out that the law violated the Constitution allowing states to nullify the same-sex marriages recognized in other states - all of those states in which gay marriage was early made legal were liberal states, with conservatives opposing those changes - Roberts, Alito, Thomas and Scalia wrote or joined in dissents opposing even that clearly constitutional relief to those so denied their rights explicitly recognized by the Constitution.   That Roberts got cold feet or, more likely someone he knows or was related to him (or was him)  got to him and persuaded him that "people like them" had their rights violated by DOMA is all that accounts for it being overturned.

These two right-wingers are trying to change recent history so blatantly in the Atlantic magazine that it was going to be the entire focus of my dealing with it before I realized the whole thing was dishonest bullshit.  It is outrageous that any magazine that publishes such not only ahistorical nonsense but nonsense known by people who were paying attention to the issue those years and not suffer a complete loss of face.  The Atlantic should be mocked and ridiculed into publishing a retraction of this crap and firing the idiot who wrote it.  

I also co-founded a group call the Independent Gay Forum, which was a network of conservative, center-right, and libertarian writers and thinkers who are gay, and we wanted to take back at least the gay intellectual world from the monotonal progressives, extreme leftists in many cases who had basically commanded it to that point. These were people who thought if you were gay, it meant you had to be pro-choice and anti-capitalist. And we thought that was nonsense. Marriage was also a good way to open up a new front and take back the agenda from the left. And it succeeded in that, but unfortunately only for a while.

Just to show the kind of double-speak, two-faced intellectualism this is an example of.   While my preference for handling the issue would have been for the government to ONLY involve itself with civil union for any couple, leaving the question of marriage up to couples - whether or not churches wanted to "bless" them or not being a non-governmental thing, if that was not going to happen, as I knew it wasn't because straight people would never give up governmental recognition of their marriages,  to oppose marriage equality while gay was to accept inequality in every way.  

I will point out that the idea that he was making common cause against a woman's ownership of her body with "libertarians" in this way would be quite funny if that issue were not so fraught.  Is the state nationalizing a woman's body ever a position compatible with "libertarianism?"   Well, maybe for a white gay man of privilege. 

That is exactly what he is,  a white male faggot of privilege like all of those gay and lesbian and bisexual Republicans from those years till today, including Lindsay Graham, Denny Hastert, Larry Craig and others who supported and voted for DOMA and other anti-LGBTQ laws.   Not to mention the likes of Ken Mehlman.  It's been a common enough feature of LGBTQ history (Senator Joe McCarthy, likely, Roy Cohn, certainly was an example) that there are many such hypocritical scumbags in our midst.  Such people apparently can live in the billionaire-millionaire financed whore house that is the "public intellectualism" of raised-pinky magazine publishing, institutes, foundations, etc.  But I'll be damned if I'll let them lie like this over the record of who was publicly fighting for and who was against LGBTQ equality.   Get a load of this, remembering just who it was who finally overturned the right-wing, Republican ban on equality, including against LGBTQ members of the military remaining there AND WHO IT WAS NOT WHO DID THAT AND TOOK THE POLITICAL HIT FOR IT. 

Wehner: What do you mean by that? What’s happening now?

Rauch: For 15 or 20 years, the focus of gay and lesbian equality was more about responsibilities than rights. It was about service to our country in the military, service to each other in our communities in marriage, and service to children as mentors and parents. And that was a transformative thing for how the world saw gay and lesbian people. It allowed the flourishing of a gay center. But then we won all those things. And so people like me said, Okay, good, we can hang up our spurs and focus on something else. I went off and did polarization and now the epistemic crisis, and other people went off and did other things. And meanwhile, the progressives hadn’t gone anywhere. If anything, a lot of them got even more rabidly left-wing, and they just swooped down from the hills and retook all the villages. So unfortunately, with very important exceptions, intellectually speaking, the movement is now very left-wing and a lot of the people in the driver’s seats are gender radicals. Which is a very different point of view than gay and lesbian marriage advocates had. So it’s a different world now.

I've known lots of white, conservative gay men who were totally OK with leaving other people in the rainbow flag out of it, to which I say they are jerks and are idiots because without a united insistence on equality, there are not enough gay men to secure it for us.  Even if that were possible, I'd be with the ones who insisted on full equality on an equal basis because it is a moral imperative.   

Most of the section dealing with religion is banal and unremarkable but I will comment on this because it's another distortion of the history. 


Rauch: I would like Christians, especially evangelicals, to understand that we are not a threat to your moral order. That the Bible, properly understood, does not condemn the loving, permanent, binding commitment of two same-sex individuals to each other and to their community. I want them to understand that vast numbers of gay people are religious. I want them very much to come to grips honestly with the fact that the evangelical world and much of mainstream Christianity turned its back on gay people, not only condemned us and singled us out for condemnation as if homosexuality were the worst sin in the world—they did that, of course, for centuries—but when the AIDS crisis came, they turned away. We had to open our own churches in order to do the job of ministering to the spiritual and physical needs of the gay community. That’s disgraceful. And we still haven’t seen the Christian world face up to that. So I want them to look into their souls and do better.

Only a lot of them did, some of the hardest working, hardest caring were not from the gay community,  some of them were straight people or celibate religious from liberal and mainstream Protestant religious efforts, Catholic religious, even clergy.   A lot of the gay men I knew who died of AIDS had most of their care given to them by people from outside of what was called "the gay community" much of the solidarity in what would develop as LGBTQ came from Lesbians who took care of and advocated for gay men who were infected and died from AIDS.  Since these white boys seem to not think them worth considering, many of those I know of, especially one who I am sure would be one of this guys conservative buddies if he had lived till today, was cared for by People of Color who were not gay men or Lesbians.  I think his revision of history is self-serving and dishonest, in the same line with his revision of recent history generally.  Such is the way of such "public intellectualism."   

I have decided to let it go with this because most of what they say is tedious as it is odious and I've got things to do.  Wouldn't you really rather be listening to Brueggemann than this?  I know I would. 

Monday, July 12, 2021

Deep In The Hate Mail File

YOU CAN GET PEOPLE to buy nonsense and even entertainment junk, doesn't mean it signifies anything.  I remember when they successfully gulled more than a million people into buying . . . And Ladies of the Club because the old bat who wrote it was old and previously unpublished, but I'll bet almost no one read that massive pile of crap once they started.  

There's lots of crap that gets peddled, most of the big-name writers of my lifetime were heavily sold through promotion and discussion of their stuff while they were alive but most of them, including some of the biggest names with the biggest careers fell almost immediately into non-readership as soon as they dropped off the twig.  I once asked who reads John Updike or Gore Vidal unless some college teacher assigns them.  Most of the books published are in that category, including lots of NYT best sellers. No, most of publishing is as much PR as selling junk food or over-priced tech, it's no more elevated than that.

Update: More Hate:   No, I've never been fat, I used to be called scrawny then wiry and I've lost weight since then (tendency to hyperthyrodism).  If I weighed 500lb wouldn't make what I said about the asshole who snarked about the death of the Granados' by drowning less true.   He's an asshole.

I've known several very fat people who were among the most generous people I've known and I've known more than a few of my fellow thin men who were selfish, stingy uncaring assholes.  BMI has little to do with whether or not someone is a good person.  I'm hardly as nice as many of the fat people of my acquaintance, a number of them would not push back on this like I have and would be a lot more polite than I'm willing to be with such a total asshole as you are.  

"a resolution that will bring the argument right back where it began"

CONTINUING ON WITH the dissection of the article from the Atlantic that I started tearing up yesterday, there is some of this I think is correct though hardly all of it and hardly in the way that Rauch and Wehner consider it brilliant, much of it is so obviously true as to be obvious and the unremarkable spin put on it by them diminishes its usefulness as analysis.    And all over this is the studied refusal to address the role of racial discrimination and worse, racial genocide, racial enslavement, and disenfranchisement while raising up Madison who not only practiced all of those, the Constitution he and his fellow founders set up is still saturated with it, something which is becoming obvious under the mainstream of Republican politics and Republican domination of the Supreme Court.  And that is not something that started with Trump but has been a feature of Republican politics since 1964 when Goldwater used racism and racists to dominate the Republican convention.  Other than the double-speaking, two-faced efforts of the likes of Jack Kemp and George W. Bush, there has been little to use in denial of that.   Remember that as these two conservatives talk about a pluralism that leads them to ignore that mastodon in the room.  That use of racism, that harnessing of racism that was Goldwater and Nixon's Southern strategy preceded Trump and it will survive him, dominating the Republican power in states where they dominate, in their congressional caucus, in Republican presidencies and on the Roberts' court and as long as there are Republican-fascists on that court. 

Jonathan Rauch: What Trump has done to America

Wehner: Pluralism provides a context for how citizens can live together and even flourish amidst differences over priorities and values. So how does a nation like America cohere, when citizens are divided along the lines of truth and falsity, reality and unreality, and are living in different epistemic universes? How can a shared sense of reality be recovered?

See what I pointed out about their discussion of the Civil War and its causes yesterday for a sense of the "reality" they would like "recovered."  It is a "reality" that I have a feeling looks like the on-screen make-up of 1950s TV or, on its most "pluralistic" end, like the lily-white casting of Woody Allen's filmography. 

Rauch: At the theoretical level, James Madison had the answer to that problem, and he had the answer both in politics and in the epistemic realm, the realm of knowledge. The answer is that when you’ve got a large, diverse society, you have to harness that diversity by putting people into managed conflict with each other so that they’re forced to come to some kind of understanding in order to get anything done and no one group can dominate in the long term.

The U.S. Constitution is basically a mechanism that forces compromise and disperses power in order to make that happen, and it forces people to follow rules. That’s the only way you can run a large society with a lot of political diversity. It requires that individuals and institutions commit themselves to those rules and those values. If they don’t commit themselves to those rules and values, no paper constitution will defend them
.

This "constitution of knowledge" business is his shtick, what I assume he hopes to ride into his career as a "public intellectual."  It is about as remarkable in its originality as a card catalog is and about as significant and useful as the hagiographic high school civics of the 50s and early 60s, one which didn't mention the civil rights movement or the labor movement and considered such things as the abolition of slavery and women's' equality as battles won with the passage of laws and the 19th amendment.   

For establishment Republicans, for never-Trump conservatives, I will admit that it's rather remarkable for one of them to admit that the Constitution isn't self-acting, self-governing and entirely reliant in itself.   But considering the stunning obviousness of the point, it's not any kind of compliment to say that.  He goes on self-evidently in that way for a while, stating the obvious as if it's an original insight.

The same is true of the constitution of knowledge, which is not written down but is very similar to the U.S. Constitution. It’s a way of creating managed conflict about opinions, ideas, facts—forcing them into contention and making people persuade each other in order to make knowledge—and do that in a systematic, structured way. It’s a very, very similar kind of thing. To make it work, first, you need a lot of diversity, because we never see our own biases. We have to have people with different biases, however wrong-headed they might seem to me or to you. Then you need people who are committed to making knowledge by putting those into managed conflict and living with the outcome, even if it’s not always favorable and even if they think it’s wrong. So those are the values and structures you need, and they work fantastically well.

I claim that the constitution of knowledge is the greatest social technology ever invented by human kind. It’s transformed us as a species. It makes possible the global network of knowledge seekers and error checkers who put the COVID vaccine in my arm a couple months ago. It makes possible the organization of millions of expert minds in hundreds of countries, thousands of institutions who can pivot and decode a genome in two days. It’s astonishing. So the big-picture answer to your question is the constitution of knowledge and sticking with those values and defending those values and understanding them.
 

It's a lot less astonishing if you consider that the sciences behind epidemiology, virology, immunology have been under constant, world-wide development and learning for a long while, now.  And that that effort was not without resistance from, mostly, conservative Republicans who attacked it and thwart it, today.  Not only Republicans here but Conservatives in Britain and elsewhere.  These conservatives don't seem to notice that it is their ideological side which has done that in many countries.  As an aside, considering what is said about gay issues later in the conversation, you might want to go back and look at the state of conservative governance during the previous health emergency of HIV-AIDS during the Reagan and Bush I administrations and the irresponsibility of Andrew Sullivan in that regard. 

Unfortunately, it worked so well for so long that we forgot it was there. We decided, Well, free speech is enough. You have free speech; you’ll have a marketplace of ideas; truth will emerge from that. That’s how the internet was supposed to work. No structure, just peer-to-peer conversations. Well, that’s a disaster. Madison knew that. So we need to recommit to these rules; we need to understand what they are; we need to defend them in an active way.

Here I think he reaches the apogee of his daring,  which is, again, rather stunning merely in its self-evidence.  Though he, again, uses it to blame the internet while totally ignoring the earlier venues of media which proved to be no less culpable in lying and deceiving and creating the myths and racist common received POV which Trump and his puppet master, Putin, merely exploited.  There was nothing they used which was not already long in place, the internet and the technology of targeted propaganda - something which, as I recently pointed out, Richard Vigurie was doing for Republicans with targeted mail before the internet became a force in society, culture and commerce.   The evidence of the use of such propaganda methods are as old as human literature and certainly far older than that.   The Mosaic prohibition on bearing false witness is a response to that. 

The next question and its answer is a mix of self-promotion, promotion of the kinds of  oligarchy financed "institutions" both of these clowns live on and in and more self-evident generality and non-specificity in what is to be done.  

Wehner: And what, specifically, can be done?

Rauch: In terms of responding to disinformation, this is the hardest part of my book to talk about because you want to be able to say, “Here are the three things you need to do and you solve it.” And it’s not like that. Major epistemic disruptions, like the development of the printing press or, in the 19th century, offset printing, require all-of-society responses, mostly nongovernmental but including many, many actors and institutions figuring out how to change the rules, revise the rules so that you can adapt to these new technologies and tactics.

So what are we talking about? Social media and digital media need systemic redesign. The press needs to get savvier about the use of disinformation and not fall for it hook, line, and sinker by repeating every conspiracy theory in order to debunk it. The public needs to be made aware of what’s going on; that’s why I wrote this book. A population that understands it’s being manipulated and understands the tactics can still be manipulated because they’re very powerful tactics, but we’ll have more resistance if they understand what’s going on.

Civic activism on matters like depolarization can make a difference. That’s where groups like Braver Angels come in. It turns out that when people actually know that the real level of disagreement is lower than they’ve been led to believe, that itself can reduce polarization. Direct civic action can help. Setting up watchdogs, monitors, and academic centers that understand this information, and penetrate the networks where the campaigns are hatched in order to disrupt them, alert social-media companies, intelligence agencies, and so on. I can go on in this vein, but you get the idea. We’ve got a long way to go, but all of those things are already starting to happen.

You can always tell that one of these guys has nothing to say when it comes to how to really address the problems, leaving things to the same set of designated "responsible people" who have gotten us here to start wit.   What it really comes down to is that they don't really want it to change.  "Nothing more can be done," is the inevitable stage that elite talk about such public problems.  It's the stage of elite public grief which doesn't even have the theoretical benefits of that less than helpful road map of how one is to cope.  Marilynne Robinson in her great analysis of elite British social thought in her book Mother  Country exactly describes what these two creatures of American foundations, institutions, "public intellectualism" are engaged in here in a sort of sub-committee of two.   It might help see that if you consider how Madison keeps being brought back into it.

British social thought can well be imagined as occurring this way.  It takes place in a country house built and furnished to accord with conventions polished by use, a house filled with guests, great and minor luminaries, ornaments of literature, the sciences, the church and of philosophy and politics.   Most of them, not coincidentally, are cousins at some remove.  They are charmed to find in one another just that streak of intuitive brilliance they had always admired in themselves and to be confirmed in their sense that they are true members of a group in which there are no impostors by a very great similarity of taste, of interest  of sympathy.  It is a leisurely visit, some centuries in length, and in due course everyone has confessed his weakness for Hesiod, and admired the garden, and regretted the weather.  The evenings would perhaps have begun to weigh, if someone had not suggested a game called Philanthropy.  The rules of the game are very simple.  One must justify things as they are by attacking things as they are.  It is a philosophic game, perfectly suited to showing off a fine wit.  It has even the thrill of risk, since it invites subversive ideas.  But the point is always, of course, to achieve a resolution that will bring the argument right back where it began.

Among the things that really need to be done, apart from things like licensing FOX and the other cable networks THE REAL POWER BEHIND TRUMPISM and re-instituting things like the Fairness Doctrine, public service requirements, ownership diversity YEAH, HOW ABOUT THAT, WHITE BOYS, OWNERSHIP DIVERSITY, is letting people like Al Gore and Hillary Clinton sue those in the media who carry lies about them into the flames of hell.  But you'll find those have gone out before the likes of these two consider anything that will really change things.


Sunday, July 11, 2021

Whining That I'm Not Posting The Comments I Answer

YOU LEAVE A COMMENT in my moderation file, you slander me elsewhere,  I'll use what you give me on my terms, not on yours.

You Say "Enrice" He Said "Enrique - Let's Call Th Whole Thing Off

AS I HAVE WRITTEN about before, I'm not a huge fan of the standardized spelling of the English language which I think is more a blight than a virtue.   Like most English speakers, even those with college-credentials and even many of those who you can call "college-educated" without stretching truth, I am not a master of that standardized spelling, or, rather of the American standard spelling, which would, if observed totally, would render them a "bad speller" in places which practice the English or Canadian rules for the same.   

In researching this the last time my tireless little meter-maid of orthography got all schoolmarmish over my posts, I read some of Noah Webster's biography and writing on the topic and have to say that my view of him, which previously had been based on a 20th century bio for children I read in grade school, rose enormously.  Here's just one of my more recent pieces on the topic.  He would have been a far more radical reformer of spelling from the English system than the establishment of his time allowed him to be, democratizing the written language by getting rid of the "futile classicism" to a large extent and making the spelling far closer to phonetic spelling, even with the variations in pronunciation then current.

Democratizing and facilitating the written form of English is a vitally important thing if things are to get better.  I know that after I learned to use a word processor and started typing (which I can do a hell of a lot faster than I could write with a pen) and I started typing out a lot of the notes I would have taken by hand and my thinking, it helped me to clarify a lot of things that I didn't realize were muddled before.   That most English speaking people are inhibited from writing for any number of reasons - the other merely mechanical issue of  (un)standardized punctuation of English being another of those - is a real danger, not only to personal memory and understanding but, also, in unreviewed thinking.  I think one of the things that they could do to help that is to require students to type out something, anything important to them in school every day and to read it and edit it before some of them (chosen at random) had them read aloud to the class for criticism.  Just requiring them to write and think about what they wrote would have an enormous effect in clarifying thinking and expression.  If it would help, having them read it themselves might be good, though if someone has trouble doing that, they might need help on that count too. 

I don't think there is any substitute for writing and reading text, words on a screen or on a page in semi-permanent form, easily edited and reviewable.  I have come to deeply distrust extempore oral expression such as in presidential "debates" and interviews and question and answer sessions.  Not everyone is as honest or as brilliant as Jen Psaki who might be the bst I've ever seen in that format.  I'll bet she's a great writer, too. 

An oral culture such as ours has become - even texting, tweeting and online commenting is more that than writing - is bound to have that be a problem for it.  Memory failure, alone, is a guarantee if it's not written down and kept.   Accurate memory seems to count for little to us resulting in a tsunami of lies, which is a big part of our problem.  I'd illustrate with examples from my personal meter-maid of "correct writing" but I'm already spending more time with this than I'd intended to. 

Failing the ever failing effort to "reform" the spelling of English, I say let's go back to the pre-Dr. Johnson time of unstandardized spelling being the standard.  Many of the greatest works in the English language have that feature in the original manuscript AND IN THE ORIGINAL PRINT VERSIONS.   In fact a lot of the worst of "correct spelling" of English were atrocities introduced because a lot of the printers in England at the time printing was introduced were imported from the Low Countries where such combinations as "eight" and ight" etc. were introduced.  How stupid does an intellectual class have to be to allow such a thing to continue for so many centuries?   Noah Webster's original reforms should be adopted but without that, let the chaos begin!

------------------------

This time it's over my intentionally annoying said troll with an intentional "misspelling" because the idiot let me know that really set him off.  That one was intentional but another one came up unknowingly on my part when I copied what I have to believe was a Castilian writer writing it "Enrice Granados" using what I afterwards read was the way it was written where Granados lived in Barcelona while he used the more typically Spanish spelling "Enrique" which I have now changed that to.  It wasn't something Simps noticed but I do respect Granados enough to change it to his spelling.  Apparently people think it was something of a political thing as well, but that's their business, I'll concentrate on his music.   

Update:  Looking around, I saw some idiot writing for a well respected venue made light of one of the stories that claimed Amparo, Enrique Granados' wife was too fat to get into a life-boat, the implication that he should have just let her drown because, you know, she was fat.   Which I think is one of the kind of disgusting things that is casually said that shows how vile contemporary speech is.  The claims that Granados took the route home that ended up in getting them killed was due to him longing to be with his current mistress makes him risking and losing his life to save his wife, the mother of their six children all the more a testimony to his heroic death.   Clearly, he loved her in ways that entirely go over the heads of such scribbling class wits for whom things like looks matter more than love and devotion, bravery and courage, the willingness to sacrifice yourself to save others, which is why such superficial asses should never be considered seriously or hired to write things.   

If there's one thing I've learned from reading the reality behind some of our great wits, its remarkable how many of them were total scum and complete assholes.  Especially those who write as "critics" of the popular variety.

I Used To Call Think Tanks "Guess Pools"

IN AN INTERVIEW published on Atlantic Monthly the day before last,  Peter Wehner , "a contributing writer at The Atlantic and a senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. He writes widely on political, cultural, religious, and national-security issues, and he is the author of The Death of Politics: How to Heal Our Frayed Republic After Trump,"  who I was unaware of before I read it starts nicely enough.

America is in the grips of an epistemic crisis—an assault on reality, a rising inability to distinguish fact from fiction, an effort to shut down free inquiry—that poses an existential threat to liberal democracy. Which is why Jonathan Rauch’s new book, The Constitution of Knowledge: A Defense of Truth, is so timely and so essential. It helps us understand this moment better than anything else I’ve read and offers insights into what can be done to strengthen what Rauch calls a “reality-based community.” Rauch’s “constitution of knowledge” is a structured system of institutions and rules that we depend on to settle disagreements and discover truth. As Rauch puts it, “Free speech is not enough; you have to get a lot of the settings right.”

To which I thought, isn't that pretty much what I've been telling people for the last 20 years and more?   Alas, the interview ended up being as much what it claims to have identified as the problem as anything else.  In fact, the problems with what both of them say are so extensive and so much an example of the kind of thing they're identifying as "the problem" that I wonder how what was once considered a major venue of intellectual activity could have not noticed that.  The problems start in paragraph 3, see how many false equivalents and outright lies told in the interest of getting everything your own way it contains and where those lies start in the both-siderism.

I called him recently to talk about his book, and about polarization, epistemic disruption, and the blast radius of Donald Trump, whom Rauch describes as “a genius-level propaganda operative.” The Republican Party has become “an institutionalized propaganda outlet,” he argues. But we also talk about the dangers of so-called “cancel culture” and the left’s “totalistic ideology,” what cognitive psychology can teach us about politics, the writers who have shaped his political sensibilities and philosophy, his pivotal role in the gay-rights debate and his concerns about where it’s heading, his thoughts on atheism and Christianity, and his aspirations as a writer and a public intellectual.

As if there is ANYTHING on the left, the real political left in American politics that begins to compare with the Republican-fascists, the billionaires who finance such projects as the Ethics and Public Policy Center, a right-wing project started by Ernest Warren Lefever who, I have absolutely no doubt would have been part of the Trump regime if he were in the prime he was in when Reagan nominated him to a position at the State Department and had his record as thickly involved with Latin American fascist regimes exposed, including the Argentinian fascist regime that murdered so many - one of its victims, the tortured Jacobo Timmerman opposed his nomination as well as two of Lefever's own brothers.  I don't think his "Ethics" and Policy Center has put that legacy behind it.  I am prepared to believe that if Trump had not been so bizarre and so extreme in his cartoonishness, they'd have had no problems with many if not most of the crimes against people he committed.   

But this is about the interview so I'll let you read and research the source of it.  As there are things I partly agree with and things I think are everything from partially false to totally false I will interject from time to time.

Peter Wehner: What’s different and more dangerous about American politics today than before, and why is this epistemic disruption so much worse now than ever before? Or is it worse now than ever before?

Jonathan Rauch: It probably tracks polarization, to which it’s closely related. And indications are that polarization is at its worst since approximately the time of the Civil War. That’s not a sentence anyone enjoys saying or thinking about. And I think the same is true of the epistemic crisis.

There was a big one in the 1850s. The South engaged in a campaign to create an alternative reality in which the North was the aggressor and it was coming down to destroy the South and its lifestyle. And that was very effective in ginning up war fever, which was the intention. I don’t think we’ve seen anything remotely like that since that time in terms of magnitude and danger. And the present crisis, of course, is of a very different nature.

So why now? It’s been building for a long time. Polarization per se is not new, but the more polarized a society gets, the easier it is to manipulate people by hating on the other side. Polarization opens the door for propaganda campaigns. And then propaganda exploits polarization, because it seeks to further divide the society. That’s what Putin was doing in 2016 when he used the Internet Research Agency to stimulate protests, even opposite protests across the street from each other. Divide the society. That in turn weakens your opponents; weakens the society; lays the groundwork for cultism, demagoguery, and so on. So first, polarization creates a substrate that’s favorable to propaganda.

The first thing that jumps out at me about that is this is obviously one white male of privilege talking to another white male of privilege so they can get through paragraphs like that without mentioning People Of Color, especially Black People and their treatment by White People as the background to all of American history.   It would seem that the central issue to all of that SLAVERY AND THE FACT THAT IT WAS THE ENTIRE BASIS OF THE WEALTH OF THE SOUTHERN ARISTOCRACY(said by some to, actually be the wealthiest class of people in the world, at the time, their billionaire class) AND A LARGE PART OF NORTHERN FINANCIAL ARISTOCRACY SUCH AS WHO WROTE THE CONSTITUTION FOR THEIR OWN SELF-INTEREST, granting a few piddling rights to propertied white men and a few left overs to others.  Doing so in such a way that the Supreme Court in the Dred Scott decision, more than a bit to do with the actual start of the Civil War, could claim that the Constitution excluded Black People from all of the rights of citizenship and many of the rights of non-citizen humans.  And the corruption baked into the Constitution allowed that abomination to stand as the law of the land until the Civil War amendments overturned it.  If those hadn't passed in the wake of the Civil War, I'm not prepared to say they would not still be the law of the land and that our politics would not have more closely resembled hose of apartheid South Africa which maintained such a system against a far larger percentage of Black People into recent history.  AND IN FACT OURS DID UNTIL THE VOTING RIGHTS AND CIVIL RIGHTS LAWS WERE PASSED.  That is all allowed under our Constitution AS IT REALLY IS AND WILL NOW BE AGAIN UNDER THE ROBERTS' RULINGS.   I don't recall the conservative think-tank, public intellectual class testifying against the nomination of Samuel Alito the author of the death warrant for the Voting Rights Act.   I do remember a memorable testimony by a Black Yale law school member against him as well as the establishment "liberals" Alito went to law school and worked with. including "liberal judges"  testifying that he'd be just swell on the court.

And what you can say about Black People and slavery you can say about Native Americans and genocide, the other great source of American wealth in our history.   To think those are not so much more than ghosts that haunt our governmental system, our laws, the tradition of that abomination, Supreme Court written law but are still vital forces in that is THE GREAT LIE of American culture and life.


The second one is technology. We had a major information revolution in the form of internet, digital media, social media. And those turned out to be designed much better for propaganda and disinformation and “canceling” than they were for truth. They did not evaluate truth in transmitting information. They simply evaluated addictiveness, which means they prioritized outrage and enticing the false conspiracy theories over truth. 

This pretends that all of this started with online media, online social media when the grounds laid for Trump are older than that.  The attack on the truth is as old as our national myths and they were accelerated with the arrival of the movies, radio, most of all television and the rise of the networks and, before that newspaper syndicates and media corporations.  William Randoph Hurst, of course, springs to mind as a print source the Rupert Murdoch of his time, credited with having the power to start a terrible war based on a lie told about a boat blowing up.   Donald Trump as a public figure first depended not on the internet but on NBC putting him on as a dictatorial CEO in what, tellingly in regard to peddling lies as "the truth" is called "reality television".   Before him Hollywood created Ronald Reagan, the real predecessor of Trumpism being Reaganism.  All of which had the skids greased for them by the Supreme Court allowing the mass media to lie with impunity and libertarians of the kind who opposed such measures as kept things from going completely to hell for a while, things like the Fairness Doctrine and public service requirements.   Things which, BY THE WAY, were not gotten rid of by "the left" but by the conservative Reagan administration.  I will grant that the Warren Court gave them the Sullivan Decision, which started in the permission of the media to lie about politicians with impunity, something they started doing immediately and put the previous standard of presidential criminality,  Richard Nixon in the White House in 1968.

And then a third thing that happened, and I argue it must not be underestimated, and that’s the arrival of Donald Trump and conservative media, which he co-opts and exploits.

Donald Trump is a genius-level propaganda operative. He had the audacity and skill to look at Russian-style disinformation and adapt it to American politics. He used all the power of his campaign, then his presidency, then his entire political party, plus conservative media, to push disinformation and conspiracy theories and trolling through every possible channel on a scale that was never dreamed of in America before. So this is the first time America has ever been exposed to Russian-style disinformation on a massive scale from a domestic actor. And when you take that, which is just an enormous change, and you add it to the technology and the polarization, you get what we’ve got

He certainly had lessons in how to do that from the NYC and other media which he played well before there was an internet,  especially the lightly to never really fact-checked features sections of newspapers and interview programs who knew they could turn to him for audience interesting outrageousness and bombast.   The style of media he practiced owed as much to the broadcast-cabloid form of the TV commercial, made to gull, persuade and cheat, something much closer in proximity to the idiot Trump whose mastery is more that of an idiot savant appealing to the others so propagandized, the natural audience for FOX - another omission from this very curious interview.  Considering the rise of Trump in terms of intellectualism is a lie because that's not what created him, though many such as float in the think tanks and their patrons used him once he was so created.

Wehner: Pluralism provides a context for how citizens can live together and even flourish amidst differences over priorities and values. So how does a nation like America cohere, when citizens are divided along the lines of truth and falsity, reality and unreality, and are living in different epistemic universes? How can a shared sense of reality be recovered?

Rauch: At the theoretical level, James Madison had the answer to that problem, and he had the answer both in politics and in the epistemic realm, the realm of knowledge. The answer is that when you’ve got a large, diverse society, you have to harness that diversity by putting people into managed conflict with each other so that they’re forced to come to some kind of understanding in order to get anything done and no one group can dominate in the long term.

The U.S. Constitution is basically a mechanism that forces compromise and disperses power in order to make that happen, and it forces people to follow rules. That’s the only way you can run a large society with a lot of political diversity. It requires that individuals and institutions commit themselves to those rules and those values. If they don’t commit themselves to those rules and values, no paper constitution will defend them.

This is NPR-PBS-Ken Burns DC think tank nonsense.  It is not the way the Constitution has worked, certainly not as James Madison intended, he was hardly a modern egalitarian democrat.  His alleged paternity of the Bill of Rights is, as the fine historian Paul Finkleman has noted, it was a "reluctant paternity" and the results have been the source of much of what has led to Trump.  The absurdity of the cultural deification of the "balance of powers" which have never been much balanced and with the Supreme Court assuming powers never granted to it in the Constitution to act as a super-veto over laws duly adopted by the Congress, even those signed into law by the Executive, have, throughout our history, exercised a pernicious and unbalanced role in preserving the interests of the oligarchs.  Not to mention such things as "corporate person-hood and the stream of innovations that are coming in under the Roberts Court as under Rehnquist when the court blatantly overturned an election, putting Bush II in power with the blessings of the "free press".   Madison and the other "founders" were primarily amateurs who were trying to set up a government without a governing monarch and their results are something that literally everything good in American history has had to struggle with or against.   That's a lie I swore I'd stop letting get by without challenging it well before Trump was raised up by entertainment TV as a force in American politics. 

I could go on and on with the problems of this interview which I see as mostly a lab test for what's wrong with the conventional line of "public intellectualism" (how anyone can use that term for themselves or others as in this interview without getting laughed in the face is, perhaps, another such lab test for just what's wrong with our intellectuals, these days).  I'd dearly love to go into the advocacy about a group I'd never heard of before "Braver Angels" and its origins and issues positions as what happens among those who live inside the daisy-chain of "public intellectualism" and the think tanks and billionaire-millionaire funded "institutes" and foundations such as appear in such magazines as The Atlantic.   But there are other piles of outrageous crap in this I want to address and I think this is as much as I can ask someone to digest in one post.   So I'll deal with more of the huge loads of crap that are contained in this effluent from these "public intellectuals" over the coming days.  It is amazing as a document of two-faced crap that comes out of the well-funded alleged intellectual establishment such as who gets in such magazines and who show up on PBS and NPR and other such venues.



Saturday, July 10, 2021

Saturday Night Radio Drama - Ray Bradbury - Zero Hour

 

Another re-performance by the Riverside Township Radio Players. 

 

How Republican-fascists Are Just Like Al Qaeda

 Image

Last Words On The First Recordings

THE EARLIEST PRE-ELECTRIC recordings by legendary artists are generally fascinating, especially if they were made well enough and are in good enough condition to give you some real ideas of how they sang or played, the idea that you could name one or, more as "the greatest" isn't artistic judgement, it's ad copy.  

Ephraim Zimbalist (the violinist, not his son the actor) and Fritz Kreislers' 1915 performance of the Bach Double Concerto is an interesting recording by two legendary violinists of that era, interesting for a lot of things but as historically informed Bach performance, not so much.   On the other hand there are recordings of legendary performer-composers such as Eugen Ysaye playing their music and others such as Joseph Joachim playing music composed for them by composers such as Brahms, pieces they played in front of and sometimes with the composers.  Some of the early singers were still impressive performers of pieces they sang for the composers in the period before recording.  Emma Eames, Adelina Patti, Pol Pancon, etc.  Alas, there were no students of Bach or Mozart or even Beethoven alive to make it to even the earliest recordings.  If the students of their students of their students are a dim reflection of the performance practice of them is highly doubtful.   We know that even Liszt, answering a critic, admitted that he played Beethoven, who he had heard and played for, in an audience pleasing way instead of as Beethoven would have.  

In regard to the comment, while there's no way to really know, Joachim's Bach recording of the g minor adagio from the Suite BWV 1001strikes me as closer to the performance practice as described by contemporary musicians of Bach's time.   I'd rather hear either Zimbalist (who really was, by evidence of the recordings, a great violinist) or others in repertoire more suited to their style of playing.   But when I go looking for the early stuff the most interesting to me is hearing composers playing their own music or those who composers chose to premier their music and who learned it under the composers' instruction playing it.  Fritz Kreisler also shines better in repertoire closer to his own time, including his own composition.   His use of vibrato and his choice of tempos in Brahms is especially fascinating.  

-------------------

Though I haven't really listened to a lot of them and haven't really studied them, I have come to have my opinion of SOME of the player piano rolls recorded by composers who were great performers changed for the better.  Those of Enrique Granados strike me as genuine artistic artifacts.  Here is one he made in 1908 of his own piece.

Quejas, ó la maja y el ruiseñor

I've always thought Granados was a far more significant composer than he is generally considered to be, though some of that may have been his untimely death when the Germans sank the Sussex at the height of his creative life.  The witness stories that he died trying to save his wife Amparo - neither of whom would have been on the boat if Woodrow Wilson hadn't requested he play a  recital for him - might make a tragic opera.

For comparison, here's an acoustic recording of him (not perhaps played back to its best possible effect) playing an improvisation on El Pelele in 1912.


One of the comments says that this recording has been re-done using the Zenph computer system in which acoustic recordings are processed by computer analysis to reproduce the notes, the pitch, the duration, the volume, the attack and their arrangement to be played back on a piano by the computer.  I haven't heard that, given how impressed I've been with the piano rolls maybe that would convince me too.  The one recording I've heard some of by that method was done in order to get a Stereo version of Glenn Gould's "First Goldberg,"  a project I can't say would interest me much to hear.  I am not a Glenn Gould fan, especially not his Bach or Mozart or Beethoven playing.  Especially not those composers.  Even given the recent research into tempo from that period which might, AND THAT'S A BIG MIGHT, justify some AND THAT'S A VERY DEFINITE SOME of the slow tempos Gould was infamous for there are other aspects of his playing that I can't tolerate, especially his playing music he disdained for commercial reasons and his self-indulgences, even extending to altering the composers' note choices.  

Anyway, I think I've gotten this topic out of my system for a while.  Kind of makes me miss being an active musician because of the pandemic.  At my age nostalgia is fatal to continuing the artistic effort as opposed to wallowing in my own past.  I think I'll go see what Stephen Drury and the Callihumpians are getting up to these days. 


UPDATE:  Well, there's a reason I call him "Stupy" a number of them, actually, one is that he was stupid enough to let me know how I could get under his thin skin when he picks a fight with me.  If he were smart he wouldn't pick fights with me and he especially wouldn't let me know how to annoy him when he tries to.   

As to his accusations of antisemitism, I figured that one out.  He's such a jerk that he's always annoying people and if he can pretend they don't like him because of his ethnicity he doesn't have to face the fact it's because he's an asshole.

Friday, July 9, 2021

Something Different

 


 

I've been neglecting the music side of things here over the past year.  I've been listening to the fine restorationist, conservator of early recordings Ward  Marston's Youtubes and have been absolutely fascinated.  This one gives you a good example of how much musical information there is in even the early low-tech recordings.   When he demonstrates the problems involved with finding the right needle and playback speed to get that information back it's pretty surprising how much of a difference that makes.   When he lets us hear what a repressing of the original master on vinyl instead of "shellac" is like was especially surprising.   A lot of what I thought of the early recordings was clearly wrong, some of that was due to bad or incompetent re-recording of those.   I'd already had my mind changed that by the Prima Voce recordings issued by Nimbus, some of which were a revelation.   I had a link, somewhere, once, that showed the enormous wooden horn they played discs back into a concert hall to make those recordings but I don't have time to look for it again. 

One of the things I've learned is that some of those I'd never heard of before were spectacularly good singers.  Probably the one who I was most astonished to hear was one I'd never heard of before, Celestina Boninsegna who was, apparently, famous for how well her voice recorded with the earliest non-electrical recording technology  Here she is singing Tacia la Notte Placida by Verdi in 1905. 

 


From what I read, she was well regarded but wasn't considered as good on stage as some of the other stars of her day.   She sounds pretty amazing to me. 

Got to go work in the greenhouse.  Used to be a piano teacher, now I'm a drudge. 

 

FROM NOW ON I won't be posting anonymous comments.  I have no idea if most of the people who try to post comments here are who they say they are but they should at least adopt a consistent online identity.   I have deleted the anonymous comment I posted two days ago with the request that the writer register.   Most of those who post hate mail here fail on the contents.  If they want to comment they should avoid slandering third parties, they should not lie and they should at least be a source of amusement to me if they choose to be stupid.

Thursday, July 8, 2021

Make Harvard Law Wear Him Like The Cheap Suit He Is

ALAN DERSHOWITZ yesterday using his Harvard Law granted expertise on FOX to declare Trump's ridiculous "First Amendment lawsuit" grift was “the most important First Amendment case of the 21st Century,” should, among other things, lead to either the Harvard Law faculty expelling him and removing his credentials or it should result in them being declared the whore house that the likes of Dershowitz and the right-wing hacks who largely fill it has made it.  Harvard is a whore house, a knocking shop for credentialing the oligarchy and its henchmen, it's not the only one but it's the one responsible for producing Dershowitz in all his sleazy, Neo-fascist, torture advocating,  Epstein expressed, massaged repulsiveness.  It should wear him like the cheap suit he is.

Wednesday, July 7, 2021

The Higher Rearrangment Of Prejudices

ONE THING MY recent fall back into the bad habit of engaging with an idiot has taught me is that for many, perhaps especially those with mere college-credentialing, the idea of thinking, of reasoning, of being informed is merely a matter of reciting the common received "wisdom" of their own conventional ideological preference community, it has nothing to do with fact checking and testing for the rationality of conclusions.  In fact, if you do those two basic acts of responsible scholarship - something they should have started teaching them in about the fifth-grade - you will be regarded as a idiot if you point out the gap between evidence supported truth and what they like to hear repeated.  

I think there's a lot to be learned in why the major venues of the left, the old ones like The Nation and The Progressive, the newer ones like In These Times and the "new media" venues are stuck in the same ever replenished pile of bull shit that the Marxist-anarchist-"free thinking" (read "atheist") left has been in since Karl Marx was alive and distancing himself from the Marxists, not that they took the clue from him.   The anti-religious play-left has never produced shit even as they never produced anything else but that and defeat for the real left.   

There's definitely a means of diagnosing the reason for the failure of the left after 1968 in that.  And from what I see, the Marxists and anarchists are giving their own version of prion disease to the younger generation of lefties.  Don't look to people so gulled to make any headway in defeating the neo-Soviet push for world-wide fascism.   I notice that The Nation was again carrying Putin's water the other day as it once did earlier Russian dictators, though often once removed through the dear old, poor, victimized American commies.  Always beware of a trust-fund lefty bearing funding.   I can imagine some of its better writers are pretty disgusted with the owners.

It's been years since I saw an ink on paper copy, does that personal ad for proving Jesus was a fake still run there?  I wish I had piles of old copies to see if, as I recall, it pretty much appeared in every one of them.  It's like certainly did.  But those have all long since gone to recycling.

The Anti-Religious Left Fails By Its Own Scientific Metric And On Its Other Chosen Tests

IN THE HEADY DAYS when I as so many others were being introduced to the brave new world of online self-publishing, in those early days of 20 years ago, blogs, a lot of us saw the potential for correctives of the corporate media and, maybe, the salvation of democracy.  Alas, it quickly turned out that self-publishing was also available to the fascists and they had financial backing and were the ones that the media would pick up.   C-Span, through Brian Lamb's Washington Journal gave a big leg up to a lot of them, some of them among the worst, Matt Drudge, for example, and, since I still listened to it, NPR was always ready to do the same.   And as well, there where the online magazines which had backing, Politico and  The Hill were favorites for citation at "public radio" (for an example of how naive the left can be in its aspirations) and on "the left" there was always Salon being cited, if my memory of the recent, distant past holds up.

It took me about four years after 2002 to figure out that my early optimism was foolishly optimistic, one of the earliest and most promising of the "new media" venues,  Media Whores Online ceased posting and left it to a host of spin-off blogs, Eschaton and SullyWatch, what one always had to designate as "the good Roger Ailes" blog, . . . some of which kept it up longer than others, some of which quickly decayed into silliness and jr. high for seniors.   I'll give this to Sully Watch and "the good" Roger Ailes, they got out of it with a lot more dignity than others did.

But there were others who kept up a higher level of writing though too few of them got to do what Digby of Hullaballoo did, make the jump to magazine level and not all of them who did make that jump were the best.  My former colleague at Echidne of the Snakes, though a extremely good writer, especially for someone for whom English is a second language and a very fine researcher has not been picked up by anyone - the paid writing profession with the demise of print or, rather, paid advertising for journalism, isn't what it recently once was.  

One of the things I quickly learned from the "new media" and, especially, unmoderated, unedited comment threads is that a lot of "the left" is actually rather conservative, a lot of it frivolous and rather uncommitted to serious change, interested in upholding what is merely a different set of tribal myths and lies and pushing an ideological preference instead of making actual, real change in things. 

And a lot of it was an expression of conceit based on nothing much.  In the process of reading tens, maybe hundreds of thousands of comments on such comment threads, I've come to the conclusion that honesty required that I stop using the phrase "college educated" and admit that a lot of those in my cohort were merely credentialed by their universities and colleges.  If it was always so, I can't say because previous generations never left the evidence of that in an easily accessible form.  My joke which is only about a quarter joke that it's what happened when, during my generation, so many colleges and universities dropped requirements such as Frosh Rhetoric is not entirely unserious.  Though I think the demise of such requirements even earlier in education, as soon as the rage and fever of puberty wanes into what used to be an expectation that achieving actual adulthood was to be tried, is even more true.  Thinking and reasoning are too good to limit the attempt to achieve it to those who go to college.   I've known people who had to drop out of school when they were 16 or even younger who achieved it to a far higher degree than those with a graduate degree have.  I would trade you Abraham Lincoln or even Harry Truman for most of today's elite-Ivy-Ivy-Equivalent graduates in government.  It's possible to promote reasoning and thought in grade school and high school and in the real replacement of those as education, the media,  and it should be required, "free press" without the requirement to serve the interests of egalitarian democracy doesn't work.  

--------------

That was a prelude to going over two articles from the last few days, one at one of the online magazines of more variable quality, from very good to very bad, Raw Story, the other from The Daily Beast which is generally somewhat better.  I got to that through RMJ posting the Raw Story twitter hook for its alleged summary of David Rothkopf's piece at The Daily Beast and read the two articles, seeing immediately that, typical of its anti-religion ideological preference, ignored most of what Rothkopf said in which lies told by religion was only one and hardly the most damning of the sources of lies.   Though I think both of them are seriously wrong headed,  Matthew Chapman's is the worse of the two.  That Chapman has written for the equally anti-religious Alternet is certainly relevant to seeing where he's coming from.  I'll leave it to you to read the pieces and see what I'm talking about for yourselves.  I've got another couple of points to make.

Along with what I wrote yesterday about how the "skeptical" community, the materialist-scientistic-atheist old farts of CSICOP and CSI and Michael Shermer's branch of that industry despise and disdain UFO and extra-terrestrial talk they don't like but are entirely comfortable with the as outrageous claims of their own, Carl Sagan, Francis Crick, etc. the political secular "left" is also seriously hypocritical about religion in politics. 

Right now, one of the major means of voter suppression being passed into now Supreme Court sanctioned law is the suppression of voting on Sunday, especially in the hours right after church services typically let out to thwart the very important "Souls To The Polls" practice of Black Churches, in which they bring large numbers of their congregants to vote directly from church services on Sunday.   The struggle to prevent Republican-fascists from suppressing the votes of Black Voters hinges on the votes of those who have just heard things that David Rothkopf would probably call "lies" that he blames for the rise of Trumpist fascism in the Republican-fascist party.   That is perhaps as true for other religious groups who are important to other Democratic hopes for defeating Republican-fascism, though I don't think many of them are as well organized or which could bring such large numbers to the polls.  A lot of those Black Churches would probably self-identify or be identified as "evangelical."  

I've pointed out many times that the Civil Rights Movement was successful when it was identified primarily with The Reverened Martin Luther King jr, the Southern Christian Leadership Conference and that when secularists grabbed the mic and took over, that success halted.  The things that are under attack by the Republican-fascists on the Supreme Court and, as they have reinstated Jim Crow, in Republican controlled states, were achieved when the movement was identified with and largely brought to effectiveness through the Black Churches, other churches playing an important but lesser role in it. And that is true of the even earlier Civil Rights struggle AND DESPITE WHAT THE SECULARISTS WILL CLAIM THE ABOLITION MOVEMENT.   It was one of the early things I did in response to something written by one of the best of the secular lefty blogs, researching the actual history of the abolitionist movement and finding out that it was, in fact, almost exclusively done by those who cited religion as their primary motive, most of all the Black opponents of their own enslavement, those who "stole" themselves to freedom, those who became free through legal means and those who joined them from the white population from the Germantown Quakers and John Woolman right through till the end of legalized slavery which was reimposed in much of the country through the secular "non-establishment" separation of church and state Constitution.   

Today, as I noted in response to the claim that religion is a major motivation of the Republican-fascists that when I've observed and experienced neo-facist violence adherence to the teachings of Jesus, Paul, James, The Prophets and The Law is not in evidence in their words and actions.  I would bet that in the fascist insurrection of January 6th, the fascists broke the commandment on taking The Lord's name in vain, the ban on bearing false witness (which was the catalyst that set it off) and many other assorted violations of the religion that only some of those fascists profess outnumbered citations of scripture.  If there was any "religion" in evidence it was that of the Qanon "Shaman" and whatever that was, it wasn't something mainstream Christianity, Judaism or Islam would necessarily endorse.  It was closer to the Nazi paganism of Himmler than the Christianity of The Reverend William Barber or the Islam of Keith Ellison.  

What's wrong with "white evangelicals" isn't that they're too religious, it's that they're not really religious.   If they have a religion it's a christianity falsified by the neo-slave power with a large does of Hollywood "bible" epics and other fascist produced garbage.   As RMJ also pointed out, through another Raw Story link, the degenerate Republican-fascist Lauren Boebert is invoking just such an abiblical, Hollywood John Wayne - Charlton Heston kind of "Jesus" in her recent ranting.  

If "religion" is to be faulted for this it is the refusal of those who may be more open to doing the far harder work of following Jesus than the easy as lying "praise the lord" fakery that is the sum and substance of the religion of most "white evangelicals" being too nice and polite to take them on in a religious brawl, a defense of the Gospel, the Law and the Prophets.   I point out MOST WHITE EVANGELICALS because the fact is that there were likely more White Evangelicals who supported Hillary Clinton and opposed Trump than there are atheists and agnostics combined, if the Pew research numbers that everyone cites are to be the basis of discussion.  If you add in all of the Christians and Jews and Muslims who voted for Clinton and the most observant Catholic president in our history, Joe Biden, as to compare that total to the one that Raw Story, Alternet, perhaps David Rothkopf see as the salvation of American democracy, you'll quickly see that they are all mathematically absurd in their contentions, the numbers don't only not support their contentions, they refute them rather definitely.   If Joe Biden and Hilllary Clinton had not had the "white religious vote" behind them, Trump would be in office because there simply are not enough non-religious voters (NOT ALL OF WHOM VOTED AGAINST TRUMP, BY THE WAY) to make up an electoral majority.  On the basis of something like the science that is worshiped by all of them, what David Rothkopf says is a search for "the truth".   Ironically, Rothkopf cites exactly the kind of social science I am skeptical of for its scientific insufficiency but which I cite in refutation of his contention in regard to religion because their own choice of metric refutes them.  

I am afraid—and those people thrive on lies, follow liars, reject the search for truth, fear science and history and math, don’t want to do the work required to figure out what is really happening around them—then we will have an irreparably fucked-up government.

Yes, we will, and I can report that if other people thrive on the lies they like, we'll have an irreparably fucked-up "left" such as the one we have had ever since The Reverend Martin Luther King jr. was martyred, though the Christian left has kept on a lot longer than the Yippies and the various Marxists, secularists and assorted anti-religious lefties of that era have.   

And, though this is already too long, I will point out that all of these "new media" venues have entirely let off the real motivation of the Republican-fascists, the mass media which all take up a lot more of the lives and times of the fascists and the college-credentialed play-lefties than any church ever has excepting, perhaps within a few cloistered religious communities.  The screen, computer, TV, movie, is the school of fascism, the First Amendment has never allowed those who run those a freer hand than it has had in the period in which Trumpian fascism rose TRUMP AS A FASCIST FORCE AS NEWT GINGRICH BEFORE HIM WAS A CREATION OF THE MEDIA.   The media is the church of fascism, Hollywood and Madison Ave (what used to be shorthand for the ad industry, for you younger people who might have gotten this far).   Yet these professional and semi-professional writers, their "new media" venues won't admit that is where all of this has really come from because it's a violation of their secular religious sensibilities, their tribal code and their financial self-interest.

Tuesday, July 6, 2021

According To A College-Credentialed Professional Journalist Who Trolls Me

I have no idea how much of what it says in that article is true, neither do I want to.  

+

As it is, as mentioned,  I have no way of knowing whose memory of what happened is more accurate or if none of them are.  That's for them, individually to figure out. 

=


"nixing the possibility that Don "American Pie" McLean might have been, as his daughter has charged, an abusive father."

Also that my complete agnosticism about life on other planets figured into it but this is enough to prove he's a. an idiot and b. a liar.   I don't think the idiot understands the concept of not jumping to conclusions, the college-credentialed blog-rat community doesn't seem to get withholding judgement on the basis of insufficient information and minding your own friggin' business.   Way too many people got college credentials who should have had to demonstrate a capacity to think they never developed.  

If they wanted to improve education in the United States they'd renew the requirement of all Freshmen passing a rigorous course in basic rhetoric including how to reason and make reasoned arguments.  Way too many people in my generation got away without one of those.  Including that idiot. 


Update:  OK, he's bored me again.  A lifetime in the mines of pop kulcha has given him a fatal case of sillycootsis.

My Excuse For The Interruptions - "It is an endless interpretive negotiation."

WHEN I GET THE TIME to type out parts of the lecture-sermon-Q&As of Walter Brueggemann's lessons on Jeremiah, into and out of the abyss, I'll go into those because there is more in them that would be better if you had the text to look at.  That's one of the problems of posting these things in videos instead of linking to or typing out a transcript, it's easier to listen to and I've got no illusions about it, people will be more likely to listen to a video than read my transcript of it.  But to really engage with what Brueggemann said the text is the most effective way to do it.  

The discussion in the third week between him and the Episcopal pastor who introduced the lectures on the tension between the Jeremiah (the Sinai theology) and Isaiah (the more establishment theology) and how we, depending on the occasion and what was said, choose between them is especially good.  Brueggemann's parallel between Jeremiah and The Reverend Jeremiah Wright's cherry picked, distorted and lied about "God damn America" prophesy is especially powerful.  He, as Jeremiah was saying what was not permitted to be said and, as Brueggemann notes, Obama on the spot "ran for cover."  I can certainly understand why he did that, democratic politics is often no more open to hard truth than the royal house in Jerusalem was - as he noted earlier in the lecture.   If Obama agreed with Wright - which I tend to doubt he would have wanted to - it's understandable that he would do that, it's not the role of a Sinai prophet to say what's popular but to tell the truth - as in the previous discussion of the trial of Jeremiah in which the earlier trial of Malachi is invoked. 

I will leave it to you to go on and hear what he said about how, in the great parable of Lazarus and the rich man, Jesus did what is so hard to do, reconcile those two lines of prophesy that are inherently in some tension with each other. 

In order to do that justice I will have to type out more of it than I have time to right now - unless I'm willing to do it badly which I'd rather not do.   I should have waited till November to do this series but that gets into the holiday season when I don't think this would play well.   People want Isiah around Christmas.   Isiah has good stuff in it, too.  For anyone who claims that this is the easy way out as compared to secularism, they don't know what they're talking about, its conflicts that have to be engaged are built into it and are inescapable.