"It seems to me that to organize on the basis of feeding people or righting social injustice and all that is very valuable. But to rally people around the idea of modernism, modernity, or something is simply silly. I mean, I don't know what kind of a cause that is, to be up to date. I think it ultimately leads to fashion and snobbery and I'm against it." Jack Levine: January 3, 1915 – November 8, 2010 LEVEL BILLIONAIRES OUT OF EXISTENCE - MARBURY DELENDA EST
Friday, May 2, 2014
Because I Missed Easter: Those Problematic Creeds
In the various bits of atheist propaganda I've run across, I recall one long piece claiming Franz Schubert for them, the evidence being one anti-religious brother and the relative paucity of choral music on a religious theme. As I recall their argument hinged on the various omissions from the Creeds of some of his masses. That they had to acknowledge that Schubert wrote a number of masses, quite fine works which are still performed, seems to be to present a rather steep hurdle for the argument for Schubert as an atheist, though I've never researched more into the issue than that. So much of Schubert's music is text based that it's possible to make all kinds of arguments as to what those show about the "real Schubert," whose supernatural genius for composing is a real life miracle that is there for anyone to hear. If the final three piano sonatas aren't a testament of inspired truth then they have no meaning that I can see. At random, here are some of the creeds from various masses
I also remember reading an analysis of Beethoven's great Missa Solemnis which claimed that he obscured part of the text because he disagreed with that particular part of the creed. Without an explanation by Beethoven, in his own words, that would seem to be an unwarranted assertion. Unlike an omission from the text, it could merely be him assuming that everyone who was listening would know the text and not need to hear it declaimed as if they'd never heard it before. Though I think the supposed obscurity might be the product of the conducting and not of Beethoven's intentions. There are certainly performances that concentrate on singing the words and those that ignore there are words.
But, that said, the text of The Creed has always been problematic because I doubt that much of anyone really understands all of the thorny theological and philosophical issues packed into the text. Afterall, they were often written to be a declaration to not believe in other ideas, some of which I don't really see much of a point in worrying about. I believe Jesus because of what he said not because of what people claimed about him. I believe that what is done to the least among us is done to God, I have no idea if the various ideas about the incarnation or The Trinity are true or which if any of the various expositions of those are true. Never considered setting the mass text to music, The Creed would have been the section that would have given me the most trouble. I'd probably just have left it out.
Here's an interesting passage from a recent Krista Tippett rebroadcast of an interview with the late Jaroslav Pelikan about his book, Credo, about many different Creeds.
Ms. Tippett: This is giving me a lovely and exalted way to think about a remark you make in your book, that one thing that someone who studies all these creeds, as you've done, is struck by is the sheer repetitiveness of them. Right?
Dr. Pelikan: You should try to proofread them all in the course of a few weeks, as we did, and then you discover just how — you wonder, didn't I read this one yesterday?
Ms. Tippett: No, and it — but it's so interesting, because I think that where someone goes when they hear that there are these thousands of creeds is that everybody's doing it differently all the time, and that's not really what you find. But I did want to dwell briefly on one that I sense is near and dear to your heart, which is this Maasai Creed…
Dr. Pelikan: Oh, yes.
Ms. Tippett: …the Maasai people of Africa, which was written around 1960, the Congregation of the Holy Ghost in east Nigeria. I don't know. Would you like to read some of your favorite…
Dr. Pelikan: Like most creeds, it is designed on a threefold pattern of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit and comes out of the experience of Christians in Africa who were animists, fetishists who worshiped things in nature and the mystery of life and who then, upon receiving the Christian faith, began reciting the creeds as they had been taught, in this case by Roman Catholic missionaries, in other cases by Evangelical or Orthodox missionaries. But after a couple of generations of that, a Christian community gradually comes of age, achieves a level of maturation where you want to do it for yourself, do it your way, speaking in your context, using the images of your culture. And the question is can you do that without sacrificing the integrity of what you have received? It's easy just to repeat, but then it's not your own. It's easy to say what is your own as though nobody had ever said it before, but then the question is whether it's authentically Christian. And I think this one manages to do both of those in a remarkable way.
Dr. Pelikan: "We believe in one high God, who out of love created the beautiful world. We believe that God made good His promise by sending His Son, Jesus Christ, a man in the flesh, a Jew by tribe, born poor in a little village, who left His home and was always on safari doing good, curing people by the power of God, teaching about God and man, and showing that the meaning of religion is love. He was rejected by His people, tortured and nailed, hands and feet to a cross, and died. He lay buried in the grave, but the hyenas did not touch Him, and on the third day He rose from the grave."
Dr. Pelikan: Now for one thing, the Nicene Creed as well as the Apostles' Creed go directly from born of the Virgin Mary to suffered under Pontius Pilate. And the whole story in the Gospels…
Ms. Tippett: The life of Christ.
Dr. Pelikan: …yeah, is just leapt over.
Ms. Tippett: And that's what a lot of modern people have criticized in the creeds.
Dr. Pelikan: You go from Alpha to Omega. And here, see, He was born, as the creed said, He left His home — the creeds don't say that — and He was always on safari in Africa. When I read that the first time, a student of mine who'd been a member of a religious order, she was a sister, and she had been in a hospital in east Nigeria, and that's the creed they recited at their liturgy. And so she brought it to me, and I just got shivers, just the thought, you know, the hyenas did not touch Him and the act of defiance — God lives even in spite of the hyenas. But it's a good example of this model that I quoted earlier, that it is not enough to Christianize Africa. We have to Africanize Christianity. No, the dangers in there are enormous.
Ms. Tippett: Mm-hmm.
Dr. Pelikan: In the 1930s, under the Nazis, a movement that wanted to purify Germany of foreign — that is to say Jewish — influences and to affirm Aryanism — that is to say, we do not want to Christianize Germany, we want to Germanize Christianity — taking the same model, and they ended up…
Ms. Tippett: …completely destroying…
Dr. Pelikan: …denying that Jesus was Jewish, refusing to ordain as priest or minister anyone who had one-fourth Jewish blood. And so intuitively, one knows that this Maasai creed has the ring of authenticity and that that Nazi creed does not.
Ms. Tippett: Yes.
Dr. Pelikan: But specifying that, explaining what is the real difference between this kind of — as they use the technical word — acculturation and that kind, is not easy. And by the time you're done, you've got to be talking about the nature of creeds.
Ms. Tippett: OK. Oh, it's very exciting though. It's very exciting. So you are one of the great, religious historians, uh, I believe theological minds of our time and I can't not ask you about your conversion. In 1998 you converted from Lutheran tradition in which you had grown up to Eastern Orthodoxy. And I just wondered, I'm sure we could talk about that for hours.
Dr. Pelikan: I could but I won't.
Ms. Tippett: You could but you won't. But I wonder, just given what we've been talking about, about the Creeds, how does your reverence for and your knowledge of this kind of Christian expression, you know, how is that part of your reasons for this conversion?
Dr. Pelikan: The centrality of tradition as a force, as the bearer of the message, as what the Church believes even if I don’t believe anything at a particular moment and it — the capacity of tradition to sustain itself and to sustain the church is something with which I have been impressed, partly through my own studies and partly by my faith. And then realization that the, of course, there was tradition before there was a bible.
---------
And from my recent down time,
Fun With Pop-Atheism
"Bronze age goat herders"
Ha! I happened to hear part of the second Psalm the other day and went back to read the whole thing and came across this:
You shall break them with a rod of iron. Psalm 2:9
The first thing I thought was that old saw about "Bronze Age goat herders" and it made me curious to see where else those guys talked about iron in the earliest books of The Bible and found it all over the place.
Zillah also had a son, Tubal-Cain, who forged all kinds of tools out of bronze and iron. Tubal-Cain's sister was Naamah. Genesis 4:22
And I will break the pride of your power; and I will make your heaven as iron, and your earth as brass: Leviticus 26:19
For only Og king of Bashan remained of the remnant of giants; behold his bedstead was a bedstead of iron; is it not in Rabbath of the children of Ammon? nine cubits was the length thereof, and four cubits the breadth of it, after the cubit of a man. Deuteronomy 3:11
But the LORD hath taken you, and brought you forth out of the iron furnace, even out of Egypt, to be unto him a people of inheritance, as ye are this day. 4:20
A land wherein thou shalt eat bread without scarceness, thou shalt not lack any thing in it; a land whose stones are iron, and out of whose hills thou mayest dig brass. 8:7
And there shalt thou build an altar unto the LORD thy God, an altar of stones: thou shalt not lift up any iron tool upon them. 27:5
And thy heaven that is over thy head shall be brass, and the earth that is under thee shall be iron. 28:23
Thy shoes shall be iron and brass; and as thy days, so shall thy strength be. 33:25
Bronze Age goat herders have nothing to answer for their ignorance of stuff that came far after they lived but conceited, post-literate, Plutonium Age professors and assistant professors who can't even bother to read the book that they're dismissing in such ignorance and arrogance have no excuse at all. And, note how often they do it while pushing their ACADEMIC standing to do so.
I also remember reading an analysis of Beethoven's great Missa Solemnis which claimed that he obscured part of the text because he disagreed with that particular part of the creed. Without an explanation by Beethoven, in his own words, that would seem to be an unwarranted assertion. Unlike an omission from the text, it could merely be him assuming that everyone who was listening would know the text and not need to hear it declaimed as if they'd never heard it before. Though I think the supposed obscurity might be the product of the conducting and not of Beethoven's intentions. There are certainly performances that concentrate on singing the words and those that ignore there are words.
But, that said, the text of The Creed has always been problematic because I doubt that much of anyone really understands all of the thorny theological and philosophical issues packed into the text. Afterall, they were often written to be a declaration to not believe in other ideas, some of which I don't really see much of a point in worrying about. I believe Jesus because of what he said not because of what people claimed about him. I believe that what is done to the least among us is done to God, I have no idea if the various ideas about the incarnation or The Trinity are true or which if any of the various expositions of those are true. Never considered setting the mass text to music, The Creed would have been the section that would have given me the most trouble. I'd probably just have left it out.
Here's an interesting passage from a recent Krista Tippett rebroadcast of an interview with the late Jaroslav Pelikan about his book, Credo, about many different Creeds.
Ms. Tippett: This is giving me a lovely and exalted way to think about a remark you make in your book, that one thing that someone who studies all these creeds, as you've done, is struck by is the sheer repetitiveness of them. Right?
Dr. Pelikan: You should try to proofread them all in the course of a few weeks, as we did, and then you discover just how — you wonder, didn't I read this one yesterday?
Ms. Tippett: No, and it — but it's so interesting, because I think that where someone goes when they hear that there are these thousands of creeds is that everybody's doing it differently all the time, and that's not really what you find. But I did want to dwell briefly on one that I sense is near and dear to your heart, which is this Maasai Creed…
Dr. Pelikan: Oh, yes.
Ms. Tippett: …the Maasai people of Africa, which was written around 1960, the Congregation of the Holy Ghost in east Nigeria. I don't know. Would you like to read some of your favorite…
Dr. Pelikan: Like most creeds, it is designed on a threefold pattern of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit and comes out of the experience of Christians in Africa who were animists, fetishists who worshiped things in nature and the mystery of life and who then, upon receiving the Christian faith, began reciting the creeds as they had been taught, in this case by Roman Catholic missionaries, in other cases by Evangelical or Orthodox missionaries. But after a couple of generations of that, a Christian community gradually comes of age, achieves a level of maturation where you want to do it for yourself, do it your way, speaking in your context, using the images of your culture. And the question is can you do that without sacrificing the integrity of what you have received? It's easy just to repeat, but then it's not your own. It's easy to say what is your own as though nobody had ever said it before, but then the question is whether it's authentically Christian. And I think this one manages to do both of those in a remarkable way.
Dr. Pelikan: "We believe in one high God, who out of love created the beautiful world. We believe that God made good His promise by sending His Son, Jesus Christ, a man in the flesh, a Jew by tribe, born poor in a little village, who left His home and was always on safari doing good, curing people by the power of God, teaching about God and man, and showing that the meaning of religion is love. He was rejected by His people, tortured and nailed, hands and feet to a cross, and died. He lay buried in the grave, but the hyenas did not touch Him, and on the third day He rose from the grave."
Dr. Pelikan: Now for one thing, the Nicene Creed as well as the Apostles' Creed go directly from born of the Virgin Mary to suffered under Pontius Pilate. And the whole story in the Gospels…
Ms. Tippett: The life of Christ.
Dr. Pelikan: …yeah, is just leapt over.
Ms. Tippett: And that's what a lot of modern people have criticized in the creeds.
Dr. Pelikan: You go from Alpha to Omega. And here, see, He was born, as the creed said, He left His home — the creeds don't say that — and He was always on safari in Africa. When I read that the first time, a student of mine who'd been a member of a religious order, she was a sister, and she had been in a hospital in east Nigeria, and that's the creed they recited at their liturgy. And so she brought it to me, and I just got shivers, just the thought, you know, the hyenas did not touch Him and the act of defiance — God lives even in spite of the hyenas. But it's a good example of this model that I quoted earlier, that it is not enough to Christianize Africa. We have to Africanize Christianity. No, the dangers in there are enormous.
Ms. Tippett: Mm-hmm.
Dr. Pelikan: In the 1930s, under the Nazis, a movement that wanted to purify Germany of foreign — that is to say Jewish — influences and to affirm Aryanism — that is to say, we do not want to Christianize Germany, we want to Germanize Christianity — taking the same model, and they ended up…
Ms. Tippett: …completely destroying…
Dr. Pelikan: …denying that Jesus was Jewish, refusing to ordain as priest or minister anyone who had one-fourth Jewish blood. And so intuitively, one knows that this Maasai creed has the ring of authenticity and that that Nazi creed does not.
Ms. Tippett: Yes.
Dr. Pelikan: But specifying that, explaining what is the real difference between this kind of — as they use the technical word — acculturation and that kind, is not easy. And by the time you're done, you've got to be talking about the nature of creeds.
Ms. Tippett: OK. Oh, it's very exciting though. It's very exciting. So you are one of the great, religious historians, uh, I believe theological minds of our time and I can't not ask you about your conversion. In 1998 you converted from Lutheran tradition in which you had grown up to Eastern Orthodoxy. And I just wondered, I'm sure we could talk about that for hours.
Dr. Pelikan: I could but I won't.
Ms. Tippett: You could but you won't. But I wonder, just given what we've been talking about, about the Creeds, how does your reverence for and your knowledge of this kind of Christian expression, you know, how is that part of your reasons for this conversion?
Dr. Pelikan: The centrality of tradition as a force, as the bearer of the message, as what the Church believes even if I don’t believe anything at a particular moment and it — the capacity of tradition to sustain itself and to sustain the church is something with which I have been impressed, partly through my own studies and partly by my faith. And then realization that the, of course, there was tradition before there was a bible.
---------
And from my recent down time,
Fun With Pop-Atheism
"Bronze age goat herders"
Ha! I happened to hear part of the second Psalm the other day and went back to read the whole thing and came across this:
You shall break them with a rod of iron. Psalm 2:9
The first thing I thought was that old saw about "Bronze Age goat herders" and it made me curious to see where else those guys talked about iron in the earliest books of The Bible and found it all over the place.
Zillah also had a son, Tubal-Cain, who forged all kinds of tools out of bronze and iron. Tubal-Cain's sister was Naamah. Genesis 4:22
And I will break the pride of your power; and I will make your heaven as iron, and your earth as brass: Leviticus 26:19
For only Og king of Bashan remained of the remnant of giants; behold his bedstead was a bedstead of iron; is it not in Rabbath of the children of Ammon? nine cubits was the length thereof, and four cubits the breadth of it, after the cubit of a man. Deuteronomy 3:11
But the LORD hath taken you, and brought you forth out of the iron furnace, even out of Egypt, to be unto him a people of inheritance, as ye are this day. 4:20
A land wherein thou shalt eat bread without scarceness, thou shalt not lack any thing in it; a land whose stones are iron, and out of whose hills thou mayest dig brass. 8:7
And there shalt thou build an altar unto the LORD thy God, an altar of stones: thou shalt not lift up any iron tool upon them. 27:5
And thy heaven that is over thy head shall be brass, and the earth that is under thee shall be iron. 28:23
Thy shoes shall be iron and brass; and as thy days, so shall thy strength be. 33:25
Bronze Age goat herders have nothing to answer for their ignorance of stuff that came far after they lived but conceited, post-literate, Plutonium Age professors and assistant professors who can't even bother to read the book that they're dismissing in such ignorance and arrogance have no excuse at all. And, note how often they do it while pushing their ACADEMIC standing to do so.
Thursday, May 1, 2014
I'm Back
but I'm not done being cranky about it. I'm beginning to think someone's trying to tell me I'm too old to do things I did when I was in my fifties. And it wasn't even something fun enough or scandalous enough to make talking about it worth while. You know you've gotten old when your follies aren't even interesting. Not even to you.
Monday, April 28, 2014
The Reports of My Death
Are Wildly Optimistic.
I had a setback, I hope to be back within a few weeks. If not, I've left instructions as to how to inform my readers.
I had a setback, I hope to be back within a few weeks. If not, I've left instructions as to how to inform my readers.
Saturday, April 19, 2014
Holy Saturday Afternoon
Holy Saturday afternoon, most dismal of the calendar.
Just waiting in the paraffin air.
There is a place where wild oats grow,
The stone wall that goes up hill.
Dull flowers, more winter, not spring,
Olive, nodding lilies made for a waiting day.
Sighting up the line to where you’re buried.
Up the hill, where the stone wall didn't reach
In the plot of cousins
Who gave you room, finally,
The shame of death with the shame of life, notwithstanding,
By quick subtraction, going on twenty-seven years.
A young death, for me,
You bastard son of a hard family.
Drunk
Too far gone to shake any more heads.
Tall, strong, day laborer.
Strong, like your hard-assed brother
You should have lasted a drunk till now.
He has.
But drunk to death, even so.
Not even the romance of a car crash
To bury you by.
You weren't hard,
I remember.
Seven, or maybe six, in town, after school,
Falling in the street, cut my knee,
Afraid of visible tears and shame.
Suddenly, was stood on my feet.
“You ‘ll right kid?”
Never heard you again.
But eyes, blue and red,
Your face too old for its age.
The smell of liquor and cigarettes.
Scared me sober.
In your gaze,
The first time I ever saw
The ground of everything.
Your hand tight on my arm.
No more than a second, you held me up,
A drunk, I’d heard,
No more than another before you went on
To drink the rest,
But two were enough
To draw me up the hill,
Twice as old as you, now.
To hope for, but never to stand you up.
One of My Biggest Pet Peeves
I love to argue. That could hardly be news to people who have read anything I write. I had some training in formal debate and could, I suppose, do it if I had to but what I really like is informal argument that is unstructured. But I am familiar with the more common terms for the various types of fallacious tactics in argument and what those mean and I try to avoid being guilty of them.
But there's all the world of a difference between knowing how to say a word and knowing what it means. The typical use of terms such as "ad hominem" "straw man" and the more recently asserted ones, "cherry picking" etc. online proves that a lot of people learned the words but they don't know what they mean. They also can't apply them to arguments made against their position by other people, never mind the far more important, far more difficult and less gratifying use of those tests of ideas, applying them to what they want to be true.
The most frequently encountered sloppy use of those terms is by online atheists, the kind of people who learned everything they know about them from reading Carl Sagan or some other atheist ninja in their own minds. Only the terms, as used by them have all been conglomerated into synonyms to mean "I don't like that". Here's a good example of a callow young atheist making an accusation of "ad hominem" and a good explanation by one of the more accomplished of recent debaters as to why he doesn't have the first idea of what he's talking about.
But there's all the world of a difference between knowing how to say a word and knowing what it means. The typical use of terms such as "ad hominem" "straw man" and the more recently asserted ones, "cherry picking" etc. online proves that a lot of people learned the words but they don't know what they mean. They also can't apply them to arguments made against their position by other people, never mind the far more important, far more difficult and less gratifying use of those tests of ideas, applying them to what they want to be true.
The most frequently encountered sloppy use of those terms is by online atheists, the kind of people who learned everything they know about them from reading Carl Sagan or some other atheist ninja in their own minds. Only the terms, as used by them have all been conglomerated into synonyms to mean "I don't like that". Here's a good example of a callow young atheist making an accusation of "ad hominem" and a good explanation by one of the more accomplished of recent debaters as to why he doesn't have the first idea of what he's talking about.
Friday, April 18, 2014
Sophia Gubaidulina St. John Passion
"This is a religious work but not a church work" Sophia Gubaidulina
Sophia Gubaidulina is one of the greatest of living composers, this is a masterpiece.
Good Friday
My friend, RMJ, has made an in-depth commentary on my posts yesterday which is better than what I've come up with for today. I'll keep working on a post but his is really a lot better. Please read it.
Thursday, April 17, 2014
Paul Mealor Ubi Caritas et Amor, Deus Ibi Est
Cape Town Youth Choir
Conductor: Leon Starker
I'm not sure if this was written in the context of the Holy Thursday Washing of the Feet but this is the antiphon that is sung during it.
Here's the Gregorian chant.
Choeur Gregorien de Paris.
What Materialism Robs From The Left
Listening to the second of the videos below, of James Cone's magnificent sermon, The Cross and the Lynching Tree, he says exactly what I've managed to miss saying in so many of my posts. He explicitly says why it is is that a de-religionized left fails, what materialism steals from the left, the very power that makes change possible in even a hopeless situation.
What I'm talking about is love, it's not something you can prove empirically or articulate adequately but the truth of it is self-evident in living it.
I have seen the transforming power of this faith in the cross among many black Christians who struggle especially among the black freedom fighters in the civil rights movement. Many knew that they were going to be beaten and tortured and possibly even killed. They knew that they were not going to win the obvious way of winning. But they had to do what they did because the transcendent reality encountered in their fight for justice was more powerful than their opposition, more meaningful than that which contradicted it.
People respond to what empowers them inside. That spirit that lets them know that they are somebody when the world treats them as nobody. When you can act out of that spirit then you know there is a reality in this world bigger than you. And that is what black religion bears witness to, in all of its flaws, it bears witness to a spiritual resource that empowers marginalized people to do things that seem impossible
That is certainly a key, perhaps the key to why the left has failed, continually, why the gains of the Civil Rights movement have been endangered and destroyed in the period since religion has been largely driven out of the left, or at least the white left. Nothing will happen until we learn that lesson again, until we believe what our eyes saw happen in the successes of the Civil Rights movement until we make the willing choice to believe that our own experience of human history is more to be believed than empty abstractions that don't even deal with that experience.
What I'm talking about is love, it's not something you can prove empirically or articulate adequately but the truth of it is self-evident in living it.
I have seen the transforming power of this faith in the cross among many black Christians who struggle especially among the black freedom fighters in the civil rights movement. Many knew that they were going to be beaten and tortured and possibly even killed. They knew that they were not going to win the obvious way of winning. But they had to do what they did because the transcendent reality encountered in their fight for justice was more powerful than their opposition, more meaningful than that which contradicted it.
People respond to what empowers them inside. That spirit that lets them know that they are somebody when the world treats them as nobody. When you can act out of that spirit then you know there is a reality in this world bigger than you. And that is what black religion bears witness to, in all of its flaws, it bears witness to a spiritual resource that empowers marginalized people to do things that seem impossible
That is certainly a key, perhaps the key to why the left has failed, continually, why the gains of the Civil Rights movement have been endangered and destroyed in the period since religion has been largely driven out of the left, or at least the white left. Nothing will happen until we learn that lesson again, until we believe what our eyes saw happen in the successes of the Civil Rights movement until we make the willing choice to believe that our own experience of human history is more to be believed than empty abstractions that don't even deal with that experience.
Good Tidings To Those Who Are Cast Down: The Cross And The Lynching Tree
I'd forgotten that Holy Thursday is when a lot of diosces hold the Chrism Mass, when the oils and chrisms are blessed. They also read Isaiah 61.
The Spirit of the Lord GOD is upon me because the LORD has anointed me; he has sent me to preach good tidings unto those who are cast down; to bind up the wounds of the broken-hearted, to proclaim liberty to the captives, and the opening of the prison to those that are bound; to proclaim the year of the LORD’s favour, and the day of vengeance of our God; to comfort all that mourn....
Which reminded me of James Cone on The Cross and the Lynching Tree.
The black liberation theologians are so much more intellectually impressive than the "Brights".
Because an Online Atheist Claimed That Martin Bormann Was A Christian
Having found, over and over again that the atheist conception of history and historical figures encountered online is anything from fanciful to false, ludicrously fictitious to full and damnable lies, I've, from time to time, tried to present a corrected record. Well, last night, after claiming that Galileo was executed for believing in a heliocentric universe, one of them told a really damnable lie, that the infamously anti-religious Martin Bormann was a Catholic. And for that I will point out, before presenting him, in his own words, what I said last night, that his anti-religious rants would fit right in on many atheist dominated comment threads today.
Here, as quoted in The Third Reich Source Book by Anson Rainbach, Sander L. Gilman University of California Press 2013 pg. 440-441, (any typos are mine).
Confidential memorandum circulated on 6 June 1941. First published in The Trial of the Major War Criminals Before the International Military Tribunal, Nuremberg, 14 November 1954 - 1 October 1946, document 075-D, XXXV (Nuremberg, 1947-49), 7-13.
National Socialist and Christian concepts are irreconcilable. The Christian churches build upon man's ignorance and endeavor to keep the greatest possible number of people in a state of ignorance. For it is only in this fashion that the churches can maintain their power. National Socialism, on the other hand, rests on scientific foundations. Christianity has certain unalterable principles, established nearly two thousand years ago, which have petrified into a system of dogma that is even further removed from reality. National Socialism, on the other hand, if it is to fulfill its purpose, must forever be brought in harmony with the latest results of scientific inquiry.
The Christian churches have always recognized the dangers that threaten their existence from the exact discoveries of science. They have therefore tried to suppress or falsify scientific research using fraudulent science, i.e., theology, and dogma. Our National Socialist concept of the world is on a far higher plane than than are the ideas of Christianity, whose essential points have been taken over from the Jews. For that reason, too, we have no need for Christianity. [...]
When we National Socialists speak of a belief in God, we do not mean the same thing as naive Christians and their clerical exploiters have in mind -- some anthropoid creature sitting around somewhere in the spheres. Instead, our intent is to open people's eyes to the fact that, aside from this small planet earth, which is relatively insignificant with relation to the vast universe, there is an unimaginably great number of other celestial bodies in the universe, an infinite number of bodies surrounded as is the sun by planets and, like these planets, in turn, similarly surrounded by smaller bodies, moons. The power of nature's law that propels these infinite bodies through the universe is what we call the omnipotent force, or God. The claim that this universal force could somehow care for the fate of each individual, of each bacillus here on earth, that it might be influenced by so-called prayers or other astounding things, rests to a great degree on the naivete or on profit-minded impertinence.
We National Socialists, on the other hand, demand of ourselves that we live as naturally as possible -- that is to say, in accord with the natural laws of life. The more precisely we understand and observe the laws of nature and of life and the more closely we adhere to them, the more we correspond to the will of that omnipotent force. The more we understand that will, the greater our successes shall be.
The logical conclusion that flows from this basic incompatibility between National Socialist and Christian views is that we must reject any increase in existing support for and any sponsorship of emerging Christian denominations. For this reason, we have definitively abandoned the idea of establishing an Evangelical Lutheran Reich Church formed from a conglomeration of the various denominations of the Evangelical Lutheran Church because the Protestant Church is as hostile to us as the Catholic Church. offering any form of support to the Protestant Church would ultimately work against us. [...]
For the first time in German history, the leadership of the nation rests consciously and completely in the hands of the Fuhrer himself. In creating the party, its organizations, and subsidiaries, the Fuhrer has devised an instrument for himself and thus for the whole of the German national leadership that renders him independent of the church. All influences that might impair or even harm the leadership exercised by the Fuhrer and the aid of the National Socialist Party must be eliminated. More and more, the people must be wrested from the clutches of the churches and their ministries. It is obvious from their point of view that the churches shall and must resist this loss of power. But never again are the churches to receive any measure of influence over the leadership of the nation. That influence must be broken, completely and forever.
Only the nation's government -- and by its order, the party, its organizations and subsidiaries -- exercises the right of governance over the people and the nation. Just as the harmful influences of astrologers, fortune-tellers, and other swindlers are being systematically eliminated and suppressed by the state, so too must the possibility of ecclesiastical influence be removed. Only when that has occurred will the nation's leadership be able to exert complete control over the individual citizen. Only then will Volk and Reich be secure in their existence for all future times.
Update: Here's the original, in German, beginning on page 9.
I am tempted to find statements by atheist heroes today for comparison, though I would imagine most people who had read a lot of them and, even more, their anonymous fans online, would find what Hitler's second in command said sounds very familiar.
Here, as quoted in The Third Reich Source Book by Anson Rainbach, Sander L. Gilman University of California Press 2013 pg. 440-441, (any typos are mine).
Confidential memorandum circulated on 6 June 1941. First published in The Trial of the Major War Criminals Before the International Military Tribunal, Nuremberg, 14 November 1954 - 1 October 1946, document 075-D, XXXV (Nuremberg, 1947-49), 7-13.
National Socialist and Christian concepts are irreconcilable. The Christian churches build upon man's ignorance and endeavor to keep the greatest possible number of people in a state of ignorance. For it is only in this fashion that the churches can maintain their power. National Socialism, on the other hand, rests on scientific foundations. Christianity has certain unalterable principles, established nearly two thousand years ago, which have petrified into a system of dogma that is even further removed from reality. National Socialism, on the other hand, if it is to fulfill its purpose, must forever be brought in harmony with the latest results of scientific inquiry.
The Christian churches have always recognized the dangers that threaten their existence from the exact discoveries of science. They have therefore tried to suppress or falsify scientific research using fraudulent science, i.e., theology, and dogma. Our National Socialist concept of the world is on a far higher plane than than are the ideas of Christianity, whose essential points have been taken over from the Jews. For that reason, too, we have no need for Christianity. [...]
When we National Socialists speak of a belief in God, we do not mean the same thing as naive Christians and their clerical exploiters have in mind -- some anthropoid creature sitting around somewhere in the spheres. Instead, our intent is to open people's eyes to the fact that, aside from this small planet earth, which is relatively insignificant with relation to the vast universe, there is an unimaginably great number of other celestial bodies in the universe, an infinite number of bodies surrounded as is the sun by planets and, like these planets, in turn, similarly surrounded by smaller bodies, moons. The power of nature's law that propels these infinite bodies through the universe is what we call the omnipotent force, or God. The claim that this universal force could somehow care for the fate of each individual, of each bacillus here on earth, that it might be influenced by so-called prayers or other astounding things, rests to a great degree on the naivete or on profit-minded impertinence.
We National Socialists, on the other hand, demand of ourselves that we live as naturally as possible -- that is to say, in accord with the natural laws of life. The more precisely we understand and observe the laws of nature and of life and the more closely we adhere to them, the more we correspond to the will of that omnipotent force. The more we understand that will, the greater our successes shall be.
The logical conclusion that flows from this basic incompatibility between National Socialist and Christian views is that we must reject any increase in existing support for and any sponsorship of emerging Christian denominations. For this reason, we have definitively abandoned the idea of establishing an Evangelical Lutheran Reich Church formed from a conglomeration of the various denominations of the Evangelical Lutheran Church because the Protestant Church is as hostile to us as the Catholic Church. offering any form of support to the Protestant Church would ultimately work against us. [...]
For the first time in German history, the leadership of the nation rests consciously and completely in the hands of the Fuhrer himself. In creating the party, its organizations, and subsidiaries, the Fuhrer has devised an instrument for himself and thus for the whole of the German national leadership that renders him independent of the church. All influences that might impair or even harm the leadership exercised by the Fuhrer and the aid of the National Socialist Party must be eliminated. More and more, the people must be wrested from the clutches of the churches and their ministries. It is obvious from their point of view that the churches shall and must resist this loss of power. But never again are the churches to receive any measure of influence over the leadership of the nation. That influence must be broken, completely and forever.
Only the nation's government -- and by its order, the party, its organizations and subsidiaries -- exercises the right of governance over the people and the nation. Just as the harmful influences of astrologers, fortune-tellers, and other swindlers are being systematically eliminated and suppressed by the state, so too must the possibility of ecclesiastical influence be removed. Only when that has occurred will the nation's leadership be able to exert complete control over the individual citizen. Only then will Volk and Reich be secure in their existence for all future times.
Update: Here's the original, in German, beginning on page 9.
I am tempted to find statements by atheist heroes today for comparison, though I would imagine most people who had read a lot of them and, even more, their anonymous fans online, would find what Hitler's second in command said sounds very familiar.
Wednesday, April 16, 2014
Heinrich Schütz Matthäus-Passion
Score
I might be wrong but I think Schutz's settings of the passions might contain the longest passages of sacred monophony since Dufay was commissioned to write an extensive body of chant about two hundred years earlier. Off hand, I can't think of another example in between them or, in fact, afterward. Its place was taken by recitative with an instrumental accompaniment in later settings.
Finland Puts Gay Porn Artist Who Eroticized Nazism and Rape On Stamps
When I heard about the Finnish Postal Service's decision to put Tom of Finland's images on stamps I thought it must be some straight people stupidly thinking they were doing something deliciously bold and transgressive. And apparently that's how it is being presented. Here's how the Guardian puts it.
The Finnish postal service's decision to use the artist's bold images on a new set of stamps will make philatelic history, but he's not the first gay hero to grace an envelope.
Make no mistake about this, an artist who presented thinly veiled images of Nazis and fascists as erotic heroes, of gay rape as an erotic image is not a "gay hero". Tom of Finland and his drawings are an emblem of internalized hatred by the victims of that hatred. For country with Finland's recent history to put him on stamps could only mean that the generation for which the Nazi period, the period of Stalin and Hitler and Mussolini, has ceased to have any formative influence on its public life. How quickly those hardest of hard lessons are forgotten by the class with enough education and professional attainment to be making the decision of what to put on stamps is extremely disturbing. Or maybe it's just straight people in the artsy crowd wanting to do something that will impress others in their crowd as being kewl.
Well, I'm not impressed at its kewlness, I'm disgusted. I don't want those images to be how straight people think of gay men, I certainly don't want gay men to think of ourselves in those term. Fascism, Nazism, rape, bondage are not what we deserve, we deserve entirely more than that. We deserve more than being sex objects to each other and certainly more than objects to abuse and discard. We deserve love and love is incompatible with what Tom of Finland presented as what gay men were all about. Putting Tom of Finland on stamps is a perpetuation of the hatred of gay men, only by other means that are far more insidious than legal discrimination and oppression. Once they have gotten gay men to oppress themselves, they've perfected a mechanism of oppression that will be far, far harder to defeat. When we do it to ourselves and each other, they can say that it's our choice.
The Finnish postal service's decision to use the artist's bold images on a new set of stamps will make philatelic history, but he's not the first gay hero to grace an envelope.
Make no mistake about this, an artist who presented thinly veiled images of Nazis and fascists as erotic heroes, of gay rape as an erotic image is not a "gay hero". Tom of Finland and his drawings are an emblem of internalized hatred by the victims of that hatred. For country with Finland's recent history to put him on stamps could only mean that the generation for which the Nazi period, the period of Stalin and Hitler and Mussolini, has ceased to have any formative influence on its public life. How quickly those hardest of hard lessons are forgotten by the class with enough education and professional attainment to be making the decision of what to put on stamps is extremely disturbing. Or maybe it's just straight people in the artsy crowd wanting to do something that will impress others in their crowd as being kewl.
Well, I'm not impressed at its kewlness, I'm disgusted. I don't want those images to be how straight people think of gay men, I certainly don't want gay men to think of ourselves in those term. Fascism, Nazism, rape, bondage are not what we deserve, we deserve entirely more than that. We deserve more than being sex objects to each other and certainly more than objects to abuse and discard. We deserve love and love is incompatible with what Tom of Finland presented as what gay men were all about. Putting Tom of Finland on stamps is a perpetuation of the hatred of gay men, only by other means that are far more insidious than legal discrimination and oppression. Once they have gotten gay men to oppress themselves, they've perfected a mechanism of oppression that will be far, far harder to defeat. When we do it to ourselves and each other, they can say that it's our choice.
Tuesday, April 15, 2014
Why Religion Is Essential For The Left: Reading Scripture Deeply Instead of Just Watching the Movie
It was my intention to post before Passover about this discussion between Krista Tippett and Avivah Zornberg about Zornberg's fascinating reading of the story of the Jews in Egypt and their liberation from the book of Exodus. I began going over all the interesting points Zornberg made about small details of the text that I'd just passed over to get to the action parts of the story. That's the typical, superficial, way that scriptures are read. Which is responsible for both the kind of superficial Biblical fundamentalism that so frequently misses the point entirely, the moral meaning of the text, the more profound implications of the relationship of people, each other and God. Which increasingly unsurprisingly ALSO leads to the atheist fundamentalist conception of the scriptures and religion. Those two fundamentalisms are joined at the .... well, "hip" by their superficial and naive conceptions of religion. Here's a passage that points that out perfectly.
Ms. Tippett: I wonder when you see a movie version of the sea parting. The Israelites coming out triumphant. And maybe you’ve just answered this question too but what is missing for you in that great climactic moment which does result in the freedom of the Israelites. What is missing for you in a kind of simple portrayal of that?
Dr. Zornberg: Well, I think, again, it's the question of The Particulars of Rapture. In other words, I'm always looking for the particulars.
Ms. Tippett: Yeah. "The Particulars of Rapture" is the title that you gave to your book about Exodus, so I wanted to ask you what you meant by that title. So, good.
Dr. Zornberg: All right, so we'll try to touch on both. It seems to me that it's a kind of storybook story, that Cecil B. DeMille story, in which there are the bad guys and the good guys, and the bad guys get it. You know, they get their comeuppance, and the good guys rejoice. And, somehow, it doesn't seem to me to be, that’s not a story for adults. What you find in the midrashic versions, many multiple narratives, is an emphasis on the complexity of the Israelite experience and the fact that, immediately they land on the other side, they begin to complain and sin, essentially to doubt the whole story of redemption. In other words, nothing is absolute. And the fact that the Israelites are witnessing the deaths of the Egyptians, that is something, according to a very famous and beautiful midrash, that means that the angels in heaven are not allowed to sing a song of praise. God stops them singing, because 'the creatures of My hand, the work of My hands, are dying in the sea. How can you be singing a song of praise?'
Ms. Tippett: And God is speaking of the Egyptians.
Dr. Zornberg: He's speaking of the Egyptians, at least in certain versions of the midrash. In other versions, He's speaking of the Israelites, who are also on the edge. So there is a sense here of the pathos of the human condition. And the Israelites are very aware of that. Their song and their dance — the women play a special role, again, in this story; they sing separately — has to do with the kind of faith that is required to live in a condition in which rapture doesn't usually come unalloyed. It comes with a sadness and a tension involved in it. So "The Particulars of Rapture," that wonderful line from a poem by Wallace Stevens, I had in mind the subtleties and the complexities of all the many stories, like the stories that are hidden within the apparent grand narrative.
There is the grand narrative which can be told very simply, and you could say it's a kind of children's story, and then there are all the details, which really make the experience, even the details that one isn't totally aware of oneself and which emerge sometimes only on retelling.
Since I have little time today and I really would like you to listen to the podcast or read the transcript, here's something relevant to yesterday's post, pointing out the importance of exactly this story of God liberating an enslaved People, how God did that in human terms, through imperfect, difficult and unwilling human agency with all of the messy complications involved. In short, it is a story that gives the real why and how of abolitionism and why this story has been so important, not to free people living in American style middle-class comfort, self-satisfied and contented, but to people living in slavery more crushing and oppressive than the typical readers of Alternet or going to a mega-church can conceive of. I will go so far as to say that I'm skeptical of any struggle against slavery and oppression that doesn't learn the same things that this story tells.
Ms. Tippett: The great theme of the Exodus — and this story has been used by other people in other situations also. African-Americans, slaves were very inspired, and in the civil rights movement, were very inspired by this Exodus story. There's liberation theology. It's been empowering for all kinds of people in all kinds of bondage. But tell me, when you think about the theme of human freedom, human liberation. I mean, what are the layers of the message that this narrative tells about that experience?
Dr. Zornberg: Well, I think one of the important issues is one we've touched on, and that is the need for those who have to be liberated to achieve in themselves some sense of the possibility of change. I think there comes a situation in totalitarian regimes of all kinds in which there is what Vaclav Havel, the Czech leader, calls in one of his books a kind of automatism, in which everyone somewhere becomes the system. People don't just accept their role, they almost become that role. There are no choices involved anymore. Nadezhda Mandelstam writes about the Russian situation under communism also as one in which no one believed that there could possibly be any change, nothing would ever change again. And this is not only those who are imposing the regime, but also those who suffered under it. So it seems to me that the story of the Exodus is one in which, in a quieter way, but I think in a very real way, one of the most important themes for liberation is the need for a process of growth within the persecuted if they are to have a history.
Notice how Zornberg finds in the hardships of the story during and after the escape from bondage how, in order to truly be free, to be a free People, there had to be the most profound transformation of The People, merely being dis-enslaved wasn't enough to become free, that was what the decades of wandering were about. I think that we in the American left could learn a lot about why our own choices as much as the backlash of our opponents have kept us from coalescing into a governing coalition. This program provides a lot to think about as to why religion can't be divorced from public discourse and the political struggle for justice. We got the very concepts we struggle for from the Jewish scriptures and tradition, they present an enormous range of human experience with those ideas and the difficulty of making them manifest and real in human history. To pretend that the history of the abolition movement, the civil rights movement, the labor movement and, yes, the feminist movement, is to abandon what has worked for what has not worked. If there is something that is obvious, the alternatives, the show biz spectacles and ego feeding spectacles of fundamentalism and the vapid and nihilistic materialism of the intellectual variety have never worked.
Ms. Tippett: I wonder when you see a movie version of the sea parting. The Israelites coming out triumphant. And maybe you’ve just answered this question too but what is missing for you in that great climactic moment which does result in the freedom of the Israelites. What is missing for you in a kind of simple portrayal of that?
Dr. Zornberg: Well, I think, again, it's the question of The Particulars of Rapture. In other words, I'm always looking for the particulars.
Ms. Tippett: Yeah. "The Particulars of Rapture" is the title that you gave to your book about Exodus, so I wanted to ask you what you meant by that title. So, good.
Dr. Zornberg: All right, so we'll try to touch on both. It seems to me that it's a kind of storybook story, that Cecil B. DeMille story, in which there are the bad guys and the good guys, and the bad guys get it. You know, they get their comeuppance, and the good guys rejoice. And, somehow, it doesn't seem to me to be, that’s not a story for adults. What you find in the midrashic versions, many multiple narratives, is an emphasis on the complexity of the Israelite experience and the fact that, immediately they land on the other side, they begin to complain and sin, essentially to doubt the whole story of redemption. In other words, nothing is absolute. And the fact that the Israelites are witnessing the deaths of the Egyptians, that is something, according to a very famous and beautiful midrash, that means that the angels in heaven are not allowed to sing a song of praise. God stops them singing, because 'the creatures of My hand, the work of My hands, are dying in the sea. How can you be singing a song of praise?'
Ms. Tippett: And God is speaking of the Egyptians.
Dr. Zornberg: He's speaking of the Egyptians, at least in certain versions of the midrash. In other versions, He's speaking of the Israelites, who are also on the edge. So there is a sense here of the pathos of the human condition. And the Israelites are very aware of that. Their song and their dance — the women play a special role, again, in this story; they sing separately — has to do with the kind of faith that is required to live in a condition in which rapture doesn't usually come unalloyed. It comes with a sadness and a tension involved in it. So "The Particulars of Rapture," that wonderful line from a poem by Wallace Stevens, I had in mind the subtleties and the complexities of all the many stories, like the stories that are hidden within the apparent grand narrative.
There is the grand narrative which can be told very simply, and you could say it's a kind of children's story, and then there are all the details, which really make the experience, even the details that one isn't totally aware of oneself and which emerge sometimes only on retelling.
Since I have little time today and I really would like you to listen to the podcast or read the transcript, here's something relevant to yesterday's post, pointing out the importance of exactly this story of God liberating an enslaved People, how God did that in human terms, through imperfect, difficult and unwilling human agency with all of the messy complications involved. In short, it is a story that gives the real why and how of abolitionism and why this story has been so important, not to free people living in American style middle-class comfort, self-satisfied and contented, but to people living in slavery more crushing and oppressive than the typical readers of Alternet or going to a mega-church can conceive of. I will go so far as to say that I'm skeptical of any struggle against slavery and oppression that doesn't learn the same things that this story tells.
Ms. Tippett: The great theme of the Exodus — and this story has been used by other people in other situations also. African-Americans, slaves were very inspired, and in the civil rights movement, were very inspired by this Exodus story. There's liberation theology. It's been empowering for all kinds of people in all kinds of bondage. But tell me, when you think about the theme of human freedom, human liberation. I mean, what are the layers of the message that this narrative tells about that experience?
Dr. Zornberg: Well, I think one of the important issues is one we've touched on, and that is the need for those who have to be liberated to achieve in themselves some sense of the possibility of change. I think there comes a situation in totalitarian regimes of all kinds in which there is what Vaclav Havel, the Czech leader, calls in one of his books a kind of automatism, in which everyone somewhere becomes the system. People don't just accept their role, they almost become that role. There are no choices involved anymore. Nadezhda Mandelstam writes about the Russian situation under communism also as one in which no one believed that there could possibly be any change, nothing would ever change again. And this is not only those who are imposing the regime, but also those who suffered under it. So it seems to me that the story of the Exodus is one in which, in a quieter way, but I think in a very real way, one of the most important themes for liberation is the need for a process of growth within the persecuted if they are to have a history.
Notice how Zornberg finds in the hardships of the story during and after the escape from bondage how, in order to truly be free, to be a free People, there had to be the most profound transformation of The People, merely being dis-enslaved wasn't enough to become free, that was what the decades of wandering were about. I think that we in the American left could learn a lot about why our own choices as much as the backlash of our opponents have kept us from coalescing into a governing coalition. This program provides a lot to think about as to why religion can't be divorced from public discourse and the political struggle for justice. We got the very concepts we struggle for from the Jewish scriptures and tradition, they present an enormous range of human experience with those ideas and the difficulty of making them manifest and real in human history. To pretend that the history of the abolition movement, the civil rights movement, the labor movement and, yes, the feminist movement, is to abandon what has worked for what has not worked. If there is something that is obvious, the alternatives, the show biz spectacles and ego feeding spectacles of fundamentalism and the vapid and nihilistic materialism of the intellectual variety have never worked.
Monday, April 14, 2014
Jacques Pellen & Gildas.Boclé Maen Kuzh
Maen Kuzh
Jacques Pellen, guitar
Gildas Boclé, bass
Gildas Boclé has become one of my favorite bass players, few bow the instrument as well as he does. Looking for his recordings has led to finding out about a lot of other fine musicians he plays with. His exploration of the large range of Celtic music, from continental Celtic cultures to Ireland is miles above most of the stuff that is passed off for that genre.
Jacques Pellen, guitar
Gildas Boclé, bass
Gildas Boclé has become one of my favorite bass players, few bow the instrument as well as he does. Looking for his recordings has led to finding out about a lot of other fine musicians he plays with. His exploration of the large range of Celtic music, from continental Celtic cultures to Ireland is miles above most of the stuff that is passed off for that genre.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)