Showing posts sorted by date for query computer power. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query computer power. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Sunday, May 3, 2026

Dawkins Again Settles For Trendslop In His Quest To Put The Final Nail In The Coffin Of God

 The reaction to ELIZA showed me more vividly than anything I had seen hitherto the enormously exaggerated attributions of an even well-educated audience is capable of making, even strives to make, to a technology it does not understand.

Joseph Weizenbaum

RMJ HAS ALERTED me to Richard Dawkins' latest attention getting exercise in announcing that he has interacted with an "artificial intelligence" program for three days and has declared it to be conscious.  Looking for where he has made that declaration, an outlet called, UnHerd, I found the beginning of his pay-wall blocked article.   

The Turing Test is shorthand for a 1950 thought experiment that the great mathematician, logician, computer-pioneer, and cryptographer Alan Turing (1912-1954) called the “Imitation Game”. He proposed it as an operational way in which the future might face up to the question: “Can machines think?”

The future has now arrived. And some people are finding it uncomfortable.

Modern commentators have tended to ignore the (incidental) details of Turing’s original game and rephrase his message in these terms: if you are communicating remotely with a machine and, after rigorous and lengthy interrogation, you think it’s human, then you can consider it to be conscious. Let’s graduate the definition as follows: the more prolonged, rigorous and searching your interrogation, the stronger should be your conviction that an entity that passes the test is conscious.

When Turing wrote — and for most of the years since — it was possible to accept the hypothetical conclusion that, if a machine ever passed his operational test, we might consider it to be conscious. We were comfortably secure in the confidence that this was a very big if, kicked into future touch. However, the advent of large language models (LLM) such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and others has provoked a hasty scramble to move the goalposts. It was one thing to grant consciousness to a hypothetical machine that — just imagine! — could one day succeed at the Imitation Game. But now that LLMs can actually pass the Turing Test? “Well, er, perhaps, um… Look here, I didn’t really mean it when, back then, I accepted Turing’s operational definition of a conscious being…”

I will not tell you how I very easily overcame the pay-wall to read the rest of his article,  I wasn't even expecting my attempt to cut and paste that bit of it to yield the result but it was similar to the way that some got past the Department of "justice's" masking in the Epstein material.   

Consider Dawkin's declaration that: 

the more prolonged, rigorous and searching your interrogation, the stronger should be your conviction that an entity that passes the test is conscious.

Having read his account of his interrogation, I am quite unimpressed with its rigor and searching not to mention its shortness.   I won't go into the, um, literary aspect of it  though I'd love to know what Marylinne Robinson (" In his new book, The God Delusion, he has turned the full force of his intellect against religion, and all his verbal skills as well, and his humane learning, too, which is capacious enough to include some deeply minor poetry.") would make of what the article says about his use of lit in his evaluation.

Given the widely noted factoid that Turing came up with the idea of his test from a gender-bender parlor game, the entire thing is based on intentional deception and credulity.   You can read the paper he said that in here.   For a popular description of it with a bit of more current observations on the idea and Turing's context, you can read this. 

Turing starts with a parlor game with a dash of gender fuckery: “It is played with three people, a man (A), a woman (B), and an interrogator (C). The interrogator stays in a room apart from the other two. The object of the game for the interrogator is to determine which of the two is the man and which is the woman.”

In this game, deception is the rule. Turing says that the woman is supposed to be honest. Her best strategy is to be herself, he explained. But the trick is for the man to perform as a woman: “It is A’s [the man’s] object in the game to try and cause C [the interrogator] to make the wrong identification.”

Then, Turing takes his gender-confusing game and adds an extra twist: “What will happen when a machine takes the part of A [the man] in the game? Will the interrogator decide wrongly as often when the game is played like this as he does when the game is played between a man and a woman? These questions replace our original, ‘Can machines think?’ ”

I don't know if the UnHerd people were being amusing when in the longer posted article they reference another bit of columnage by Dawkins, 

 Suggested reading

Why men are different from women

By Richard Dawkins

but his citation of Turing's test,  based on a gender-bending game, is kind of funny.  I mean, Dawkins lost his "Humanist of the Year" award for some comments interpreted as being anti-transexual.  And, as noted in the article just linked to,  Dawkins has some real issues when it comes to not only Transwomen, but Women, too. 

Interesting as that is to consider, I'm going to say that I think Dawkins' will to believe that an "AI" program is conscious is related to his career as Britain's current most famous atheist.  

I hadn't known that Dawkins was going to publish this as I noted the other day that consciousness has not been defined, even as it is the one thing that we can empirically know since our own consciousness is that through which we experience and believe and know anything at all.  I also noted that, despite that, not a few hard-core materialist-atheists of the most scientistic kind have, staring into the face of the "hard-problem" that consciousness is for materialism, scientism and the atheist ideology that is based in those, have declared consciousness to be an illusion.   As I (and others) have pointed out,  they seek to discredit the reality of consciousness by declaring it has the status of a state of consciousness.   I don't think Dawkins is that far gone, if not for the reason that he either is unappreciative of the problem for his ideology through his general philosophical insouciance or if he just doesn't think it's important.   Though I do think he might have a notion that, as previous contenders for his status as the most famous atheist in Britain have, that his ideology cannot be secure as long as a conclusive materialist answer to that problem is pending. 

As for even a rather sophisticated college-credentialed celebrity thinking that machines can think, that's a conclusion that many have been jumping to for more than a half a century.   The early computer scientist Joseph Weizenbaum famously was horrified to find that many such, including another materialist-atheist celebrity, Carl Sagan, mistook his unsophisticated chat bot ELIZA as such.   From his still relevant and highly readable Computer Power And Human Reason. 

Another widespread, and to me surprising reaction to the ELIZA program was the spread of a belief that it demonstrated a general solution to the problem of a computer understanding of natural language.  In my paper, I had tried to say that no general solution to the problem was possible, i.e., that language is understood on in contextual frameworks, that even these can be shared by people to only a limited extent, and that consequently even people are not embodiments of any such general solution.  But these conclusions were often ignored.  In any case, ELIZA was such a small and simple step.  Its contribution was, if any at all, only to vividly underline what many others had long ago discovered, namely, the importance of context in language understanding.  The subsequent, much more elegant, and surely more important work of Winograd in computer comprehension of English is currently being misinterpreted just as ELIZA was.  The reaction to ELIZA showed me more vividly than anything I had seen hitherto the enormously exaggerated attributions of an even well-educated audience is capable of making, even strives to make, to a technology it does not understand.  Surely, I thought, decisions made by the general public about emergent technologies depend much more on what that public attributes to such technologies than on what they actually are or an or cannot do.  If, as appeared to be the case, the public's attributions are wildly misconceived, then public decisions are bound to be misguided and often wrong.  Difficult questions arise out of these observations; what, for example, are the scientist's responsibilities with respect to making his work public?  And to whom (or what) is the scientist responsible? 

My interaction with "AI," much of it involuntary and unwilling,  leads me to the conclusion that it's just a souped up search engine that copies and regurgitates content that is posted online.  Some have noted it is an automated stealer of content that is then automated to repackage it, seemingly on the basis of its currency based on how often it is clicked on in web searches - so it probably is also stealing the results of automated searches of the past instead of evaluating the quality of what it steals.  It has the same relationship with original thought that Temu has with original design in that regard.  

A far, far more sophisticated analysis done by humans as to what "AI" of the kind that Dawkin's notes is based on "Large language models"  does, can be found in a recent article from Harvard Business Review.  

Leaders might assume that LLMs are able to offer a kind of unbiased, outside perspective. But new research found that leading LLMs have clear biases when it comes to strategy and consistently recommend strategies that align with modern managerial buzzwords and trends rather than context-specific strategic logic. This propensity for AI to opt for buzzy ideas over reasoned solutions is called “trendslop,” and leaders should beware of it warping their strategic planning. When using AI in strategic planning, leaders should: use it to expand options, not make choices; counteract known and potential biases; remain alert to changing biases; watch out for the hybrid trap; and not rely on context alone.

Perhaps being what academia takes as truly important, the amassing of money, they have put more thought into it than an ideological atheist would get away with in general culture. 

What the "AI" fed back to the person asking the questions changed, drastically, when a few of the assumptions fed into it changed and what it fed back was consistently influenced, not by logic, but by what it was scooping up from wherever.

In our recent research, we found that leading LLMs have clear biases when it comes to strategy. They consistently recommend strategies that align with modern managerial buzzwords and trends rather than context-specific strategic logic. Across thousands of simulations, we saw LLMs almost uniformly select the same trendy strategies, regardless of context. We call the propensity for AI to opt for buzzy ideas over reasoned solutions “trendslop.” In the context of strategic analysis, we call this phenomenon, “strategy trendslop.”

Which, by the way, is what I think Dawkins did in lots of both his scientific writing and in his "God Delusion" (a review of that from which the Robinson quote above comes)  which, notably, had more citations of Douglas Adams than it much did the subject matter that he purported to be refuting.   And Carl Sagan was known to do a bit of that, too.  Though I do think that Sagan's work in his own field was probably far more founded in scientific observation than Dawkins' has been. 

I don't think ideological atheists have a very good track record when it comes to judging machine intelligence.  

Monday, April 27, 2026

Before Going Back To Politics - More Hate Mail On Recent Topics

LETS DO AN EXPERIMENT,  a thought experiment to test the claim that those unresolvable, assumed to be fossilized blue-green algal mats that are estimated to be from a half a billion years after the first theorized organism formed and began reproducing, setting off the evolution of all current life on Earth, can tell us anything about that original organism.   Lets assume something wildly in favor of your claim but which I think may be absurdly optimistic,  that such an organism divided an average of once a modern day of 24 hours,  with about 365.25 of those comprising "a year."   That is, by the way, already built into the conventional assertions of the speculative estimates of conventional claims about the timing of all of this even though it's most improbable that the speeds of the early Earth's rotation and its travel around the sun were exactly as now. 

I think its probably a wild underestimate but under this scheme if you multiply 500,000,000 by 365.25 you would get 182,500,000,000 generations of life from the theorized first organism till the era of those algal mats, which, by the way, cannot be resolved as to reveal much of anything about their physiology never mind their actual lives in and over time.   

To give you something to help you imagine how much evolution can happen in that period of time, half a billion (500,000,000) years ago would get you into the Cambrian explosion when there was a "sudden" effusion of diverse and complex multicellular organisms flourished in the ancient oceans.   From Berkeley Ed's website 

Around 530 million years ago, a wide variety of animals burst onto the evolutionary scene in an event known as the Cambrian explosion. In perhaps as few as 10 million years, marine animals evolved most of the basic body forms that we observe in modern groups. Among the organisms preserved in fossils from this time are relatives of crustaceans and starfish, sponges, mollusks, worms, chordates, and algae, exemplified by these taxa from the Burgess Shale.

I can tell you that after I'd read Stephen Jay Gould's Wonderful Life about life in the Cambrian as found in the Burgess Shale,  there was a lot of inter-profession sniping as to whether or not he had drawn a lot of the creatures right because the very detailed fossils could be interpreted many different ways.   You can't see much if any detail of the organisms in the period we're talking about here.  The issue of the visual resolution of fossils and their complete absence is one of the main issues in this argument and the fact that the oldest evidence of life is not resolvable is entirely relevant. 

That inability to really say anything in any detail about, not the theorized first organism that, unlike every subsequent organism, had the unique life history of arising not from a living organism but from non-living matter, . . . not addressing the insurmountable problem of that but the theorized last common universal ancestor (LUCA) of all subsequent living lines of life before those diverged into the kingdoms that survive, is too briefly touched on in this article from Astrobiology at NASA. 

It must be noted that LUCA is not the origin of life. [N.B. IS NOT THE ORIGIN OF LIFE!] The earliest evidence of life dates to 3.7 billion years ago in the form of stromatolites, which are layers of sediment laid down by microbes. Presumably, life may have existed even before that. Yet, LUCA’s arrival and its evolution into archaea and bacteria could have occurred at any point between 2 to 4 billion years ago.

Phylogenetics help narrow this down, but Martin Embley isn’t sure our analytical tools are yet capable of such a feat. “The problem with phylogenetics is that the tools commonly used to do phylogenetic analysis are not really sophisticated enough to deal with the complexities of molecular evolution over such vast spans of evolutionary time,” he says. 

I'll repeat the relevant passage, phylogenetic analysis are not really sophisticated enough to deal with the complexities of molecular evolution over such vast spans of evolutionary time,  and, in case you didn't notice I'll point out again, "LUCA is not the origin of life,"  it is a theorized descendant of the earliest theorized unique organism mentioned above after who knows how many millions and billions and maybe trillions of intervening individuals were evolving.   And note how this article, which doesn't deal with that first of all organisms, starts out:

If we trace the tree of life far enough back in time, we come to find that we’re all related to LUCA. If the war cry for our exploration of Mars is ‘follow the water’, then in the search for LUCA it’s ‘follow the genes’. The study of the genetic tree of life, which reveals the genetic relationships and evolutionary history of organisms, is called phylogenetics. Over the last 20 years our technological ability to fully sequence genomes and build up vast genetic libraries has enabled phylogenetics to truly come of age and has taught us some profound lessons about life’s early history.

I've argued, over and over again and at length that the idea that that original organism [NOT LUCA] had genes as science identifies those today makes its conceived organization by random chance in the conditions of no genes available for it to randomly organize from and pass on to its immediate descendants then that makes a miraculous assembly of it through intelligent design one of the most rational of hypotheses about it.  Intelligence can do what random chance cannot be known to do do in far less time.  

I would deny that even if it is the most persuasive, the most rational, the explanation with the most explanatory power that the hypothesis of intelligent design can be science but that would also render the far less convincing always ideological or professionally ambitious attempts at purely material, chance-random explanations, if anything, even less persuasive as science.   

Abiogenesis is not science, it started out as ideological questing by blatantly materialist-atheist ideological scientists such as Alexander Oparin and J.B.S. Haldane to "explain the origin of life without God" and later generations starting out with those in Harold Urey's generation but it has also become, as it became, an academic specialization,  that most powerful of all things, something riddled with professional motives, politics, and seeking professional and so economic advancement.   Along with that was the certain knowledge that they must never, ever violate the prime objective of ideological academia, never imply an argument in favor of God. 

Without that original organism's remnants being found, securely identified as being that ultimate pin in the biggest haystack ever assembled,  found in resolvable detail, in enough resolvable detail to come to some accurate description of how it formed, how it did that most unprecedented and certainly enormously complex act of reproduction, successfully the first time,  internally multiplying and passing on the structures - including the containing membrane that certainly must have had to contain it, split and divide itself and reseal itself, at least twice,  and many other things  EVERYTHING SAID ABOUT THAT ORIGINAL ORGANISM IS NOT SCIENCE BUT IDEOLOGICAL LORE.    That such a thing could become a specialty of science is a sign of the decadence of academic science, the crowning glory of modern universities and academic life.   And it is far from the only example of that. 

Update:   And here I was being so generous to you by agreeing to stipulate there was an average of a generation a day during that half a billion years.   In my arguments at Laden's blog I speculated that it might have been an average of a generation every twenty minutes.    Three an hour times 24 hours in a day times 365.25 a year times 500,000,000

In plugging numbers into an online calculator - assuming I didn't make any errors this early before I've had coffee - that would give you about 13,149,000,000 generations.   Don't let your eyes glaze over, do the exercise of naming that number so you might get the idea of how much evolution could have happened between the theorized first, unique organism and those presumed to be fossilized algal mats.  THIRTEEN TRILLION, ONE HUNDRED FORTY-NINE  BILLION,  generations.   I haven't done the calculation or even tried to come up with something pretending to be an average of how long a "generation" in such a problem would be but I will venture the guess that is more generations back in the entire history of life on Earth than that for which we have resolvable fossils of generations of multicellular life.  If I'm wrong about that,  state your speculations and present the math.   Even if I might quibble about the speculations,  if your argument holds up I will have to admit that your argument is coherent. 

Update 2:

The "RNA world" hypothesis is full of problems,  and hardly a uniformly accepted creation myth.   One of the biggest problems with it is contained in this paper:

RNA therefore has all the properties required of a molecule that could catalyze its own synthesis (Figure 6-92). Although self-replicating systems of RNA molecules have not been found in nature, scientists are hopeful that they can be constructed in the laboratory. While this demonstration would not prove that self-replicating RNA molecules were essential in the origin of life on Earth, it would certainly suggest that such a scenario is possible.

Here's just the first problem found in this passage buried deep in the paper.

ALTHOUGH SELF-REPLICATING SYSTEMS OF RNA MOLECULES HAVE NOT BEEN FOUND IN NATURE, 

There is no, NO, evidence that there were "self-replicating systems of RNA molecules in nature.  Certainly not in a world in which life has not ever been present as is imagined to be the world in question.  That would be in the place where random-chance events would have had to be acting on those absent molecules in order for "RNA world" to have even existed in the first place and for massive improbability to work on them to assemble into a massively more complex entity, a living, metabolizing, replicating organism. 

Which gets us to a second and insurmountable problem for any of this to support a scientistic materialist-atheist scenario of the origin of life. 

SCIENTISTS ARE HOPEFUL THAT THEY CAN BE CONSTRUCTED IN THE LABORATORY. 

What they can artificially do in a laboratory, WITH VERY INTELLIGENT AND HIGH DEGREES OF DESIGN, can't tell you what would have happened in nature without that intelligence or those high degrees of design.  

It's exactly why the Miller-Urey experiment can tell you nothing of the sort nor can any other lab experiment done on these questions.   You cannot tease out the essential components of intelligence and design from such experiments anymore than you can the molecules, the containing vessels, the heat or UV or electricity or other energy put into them. 

Compared to the dishonesty, the mental elisions and gymnastics and lies necessary to pretend that this materialist-atheist-ideological quest to put the last nail in the coffin of God the Creator an admittedly non-scientific belief in intelligent design is far more intellectually respectable, especially if there is acceptance of what science can reliably tell us about geology, cosmology (and never forget I specified "reliably" tell us),  evolution, etc.   I have pointed out before here that the scientific grand-dad (through Richard Lewontin) of the materialist-atheist attack dog Jerry Coyne, the eminent geneticist Theodosius Dobzhansky said: 

"I am a creationist and an evolutionist. Evolution is God's, or Nature's method of creation."

Which is a lot more respectable than the junk that abiogenicists put out for all the reasons I've stated above.   I think he'll probably be remembered well after Jerry Coyne is not much more than a footnote and ever rarer and more obscure citations in papers few people read.

Last Update:

The absurdity of the refusal to admit any of this is ubiquitious within the pseudo-science of abiogenesis and academically oriented declaration.  I'll go through this relatively recent bit of bullshit from "Human Frontier Science Program" pointing out the problems with its claims in regard to the actual beginning of life on the early Earth. 

RNA can both store information and catalyze its own replication, making it a strong candidate for the first self-reproducing molecule of life. By combining statistical physics and AI-guided design, HFSP Research Grant Awardees showed that an astronomical diversity of self-reproducing RNAs likely exists, making an RNA-based origin of life more plausible.

Note that even this absurd claim doesn't claim to produce actual physical evidence BECAUSE SUCH EVIDENCE DOESN'T EXIST EVEN ON EARTH WHERE SUCH RNA, IN THE UBIQUITOUS PRESENCE OF BIOLOGICAL MOLECULES WOULD MAKE THE PRESENCE OF SUCH MORE LIKELY THAN ANY OTHER KNOWN PLACE THEY CAN'T FIND IT IN NATURE.   What it claims is that their "AI" manipulation of what I would bet are highly speculative bits of mathematical physics lore merely makes their stories "MORE PLAUSIBLE."   I was honest enough to admit that such will to believe on the basis of preferred plausibility was not science, these, no doubt, highly placed academic scientists oversell their preferred ideological position as science. 

I will note something that doesn't seem to occur to them, their speculative and unidentified and unfound RNA can only be their hoped for " first self-reproducing molecule of life" on Earth IF THAT IS, IN FACT, THE WAY IT HAPPENED.   Nothing about this gets us any closer to knowing the one and only way in which it happened, that information would require what I said it did above.  And their Just-so story is hardly an explanation of that first theorized organism, how it formed, how it metabolized, how it fed and replicated and turned into two, then more and eventually countless trillions, maybe quadrillions of organisms. 

According to the RNA world hypothesis, RNA has been a major player in the origin of life, supporting both roles of information carrier and catalyst. Central to this idea are RNAs capable of self-reproduction, where certain RNA sequences have the property to fold and accelerate reactions that assemble more copies of themselves from smaller pieces. This process is called autocatalysis and supports rudimentary forms of self-reproduction.

In looking to fact check these claims,  I can find no place where they have observed RNA, in fact, folding by itself in the absence of cellular chemistry or the artificial chemistry provided to it by scientists in a lab.   Unless they have observed that happening, in the absence of cellular or artificial chemistry, it can't be known to happen in the absence of those.   My guess is that RNA, like DNA as known to act in cellular chemistry was a product of biological evolution, though I can't find anything about that in my too brief search for that online.  I will read any papers anyone can put my way on that but I'll warn you I'll be on the look out for weasel words and the typical abiogenetic bullshitting that is ubiquitous in this literature. 

The HSFP Research Grant Team, composed of researchers from Ecole Supérieure de Physique et Chimie Industrielles (Paris, France), Max Planck (Leipzig, Germany), Boise State University (USA), the National Center for Biological Sciences Bangalore (India), and Sorbonne University (Paris), aimed to investigate whether many RNA sequences are capable of self-reproduction, knowing this is important in several regards. First, the more RNA sequences can self-reproduce, the more likely they are to appear in a primitive soup made of essentially random sequences. Second, for evolution to start, it is necessary that certain self-reproducer help the formation of others, which is only possible if there exists a variety of them. However, at the moment, only a few such RNAs are known, as they have been rationally engineered in the laboratory.

Note this, the science teams "aimed to investigate whether many RNA sequences are capable of self-reproduction, knowing this is important in several regards."  Such a sentence implies that what they're doing is looking for that in nature, in the absence of cellular or artificial chemistry that would aid RNA sequences "self-reproduction."  But I doubt they are actually watching RNA sequences in the absence of both to see it doing that themselves.   If they are even bothering to find actual molecules doing that instead of just plugging in numbers in equations or, worse, depending on "AI" programs (of human conception, construction and of chosen and limited and directed character) to do it,  I'd be very surprised.  My skepticism that they're doing anything of the sort is intensified by the last paragraph in the piece of tripe. 

To address the question of the diversity of self-reproducing RNA, we took inspiration from RNAs found in known organisms, namely ‘group I intron’, which cleave themselves from messenger RNAs, the carriers of genetic information. Indeed, group I introns are catalysts for reactions between RNAs, and it had already been demonstrated that this activity is sufficient for their self-reproduction from smaller pieces.By training statistical models that learn the patterns of sequence variations of group I introns across organisms, and combining this information with structure prediction from physics, the researchers were able to design and test experimentally tens of thousands of highly diversified RNAs of length 200, which are not found in nature, but mimic the function of natural ones.. 

I will note, overall, that their use of "AI" only intensifies my critique of this effort that nothing they are doing is done in the absence of intelligent design.   In this case the pseudo-intelligence of computer number crunching WHICH ONLY MULTIPLIES THE DESIGN AND INTELLIGENCE IN PUT INTO THE EXERCISE. 

But even then note this about their entirely make believe "science." 

To address the question of the diversity of self-reproducing RNA, we took inspiration from RNAs found in known organisms,

Their modeling depends on what happens within living cells, all of their modeling depends on life actually being what produces the "self-replicating" RNA of their imagining.  It cannot produce any knowledge of what happens in the absence of cellular action WHICH IS WHAT, IN FACT, REPLICATES RNA JUST AS IT REPLICATES DNA.  

That point is made clear in the end of this nonsense.

the researchers were able to design and test experimentally tens of thousands of highly diversified RNAs of length 200, which are not found in nature, but mimic the function of natural ones.

"THEY WERE NOT FOUND IN NATURE, BUT MIMIC THE FUNCTION OF NATURAL ONES." 

None of this tells us anything reliable about what happens outside of already living cells in nature.   It is all ideologically and, maybe more powerfully,  professionally interested bullshit.  

Thursday, December 11, 2025

Almost Mid Advent - St. Francis Bergoglio Changed A Lot More About Christmas Than People Realized And Women Have Led The Way

Lighting The Way To Christmas With Laudato Si  from last year when Good Pope Francis was still with us. 


----------------------------------------------


Elizabeth Davis rsm explores with us the meaning of the Cosmic Advent Wreath, grounded in “deep incarnation” and the way to create our own to mark the passage of the four weeks of Advent:
The Vimeo is a little sluggish on my computer but that could just be my underpowered computer.  

------------------
I don't think it's any accident that it's Women who seem to be leading the way to this new dimension of Advent and Christmas.   A lot of the Cosmic Christ Christology in my experience comes from the theology of Elizabeth A. Johnson.  And I really like how the order of Roman Catholic Womenpriests don't reject what is good in the official RC Church even as they are excommunicated by the guys.   Why should they acknowledge that?    Here's what got me started on this.

Based on the Encyclical Letter, Laudato Si’, The Sisters of Mercy of Newfoundland partnered with other Sisters of Mercy around the world in re-imagining our Advent journey.  They then offered us the Cosmic Advent Wreath, an adaptation of the traditional Advent Wreath which is used in many homes and churches. 

Rooted in “deep incarnation” the Cosmic Advent Wreath invites us into a radically different relationship with the world, a relationship where everything and everyone matters.  It brings Pope Francis’s encyclical letter Laudato Si’ to life in a new way.

Greens, fabric, or sand are options on which to set the wreath.  Candles  may be arranged in a circle, a spiral, or arc, and a variety of objects may be used between and among the candles: greens, rocks, shells, berries, whatever stirs your imagination and creativity. Diverse colours for the candles (blue, amber, red, green, white) invite us to embrace a new level of shared consciousness born of science and religion.  You may choose to tie coloured ribbons around white candles to reflect and celebrate the four major births of the cosmos that have brought us to this moment in history, and the final coming together of all in divine love.


Week 1:  Birth of the Universe. We pray with God’s incarnation in the creation of the cosmos (blue candle). 

“God’s first 'idea' was to become manifest – to pour out divine, infinite visible forms.  The 'First Flaring Forth' (Big Bang) is now our scientific name for the first idea; and 'Christ' is our theological name.  Both are about LOVE and BEAUTY exploding outward in all directions.” (Richard Rohr)

“God said, ‘Let there be light’; and there was light.  And God saw that the light was good.” (Genesis 1:3-4)

“When I look at your heavens, the work of your fingers, the moon and the stars that you have established… (Psalm 8:3)


Week 2:  Birth of the Solar system.  We pray with God’s incarnation in the creation of the Solar System (amber candle). 

“This vast ocean of our solar system is like a womb, that has unfolded over some five billion years to become galaxies and stars, palms and pelicans, the music of Bach and each of us alive today.” (Brian Swimme)

“O God, you established the luminaries and the sun; you have fixed the bounds of earth; you have made summer and winter.” (Psalm 74:16-17)

“ I have set my bow in the clouds, and it shall be a sign of the covenant between me and Earth.” Genesis 9:13)


Week 3:  Birth of Jesus, the Christ.  We pray with the incarnation in the person of Jesus the Christ (red candle).

Christ and Jesus are not exactly the same. In Jesus, God’s presence became more obvious and believable in the world. “By his incarnation (the Christ) inserted himself not just into our humanity, but into the Universe which supports humanity. The presence of the incarnate Word … shines at the heart of all things.” (Teilhard de Chardin)
 
“In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God… And the Word became flesh and lived among us.” (John 1:1,14)

“Christ is the image of the invisible God, the first born of all creation; for in him all things in heaven and on Earth were created.” (Col. 1:15-16)


Week 4:  My Birth into the whole Cosmic Body of the Universe.  We pray with God’s incarnation in each being – human and other that human (green candle). 

“We have the power to create a new world, and we have the power to destroy this one. How we choose depends on how we grasp this moment as the kiss of God, impelling us to stand up and speak.” (Illia Delio, OSF)

“For it was you who formed my inward parts; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you for I am fearfully and wonderfully made.” (Psalm 139:13-14)

 “Ask the animals and they will teach you; the birds of the air and they will tell you; asked the plants of earth and they will teach you; and the fish of the sea will declare to you.” (Job 12:7-8)


Christmas Eve:  All is One.  We pray with the coming together of all as One in Divine Love (white). 

“In union with all creatures, we journey through this land seeking God, for ‘if the world has a beginning and if it has been created, we must inquire who gave it this beginning, and who was its Creator.’ Let us sing as we go. May our struggles and our concerns for this planet never take away the joy of our hope.” (Laudato Si’, 244)

“That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our own eyes, which we have gazed upon and touched with our own hands—this is the Word of life.”  (1 John 1:1)

Jesus is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation.
In him all things were created, in heaven and on earth, things visible and invisible.
All things were created through him; all were created for him. 
He is before all else that is. In him all things hold together.
In him all the fullness of God was pleased to dwell,
and through him, to reconcile everything to himself,
whether on earth or in heaven,
making peace by the blood of his cross. (Colossians 1:15-20)




Saturday, November 8, 2025

It Occurs To Me

that in my challenged health when I don't feel up to writing new stuff that I could offer you parts of what I type out from others. 

One of the things I started doing when I learned to use a computer was to type out long passages or even entire books as a means of studying their content more closely.  I've typed out a lot of books over the years, many which I kept a copy of in some now antiquated format (floppy discs) or lost some other way.   Keeping a typed out copy wasn't the point of it.   

While typing out this passage from Luke Timothy Johnson's great but too little known book Living Jesus I thought of all the parallels of the problem of needing authority but that reliance comes WITH THE GUARANTEE THAT NO AUTHORITY, EVEN THE BEST OF IT IS ENTIRELY RELIABLE.   Of course I thought of all the other areas in life aside from organized Christianity that that is true of AS WELL AS THE OBVIOUS TRUTH OF JOHNSON'S CONFESSION ABOUT THE ENTIRELY FALLIBLE AND TOO OFTEN CORRUPT AUTHORITY OF THE CHURCHES.    

Academia, and I don't even consider the one and only one that most academics seem to care about,  actual and alleged and often quite dubiously attributed plagiarism.    The replicability crisis scandal in science,  the amazing record of outright fraud,  misfeasance, nonfeasance such as is regularly recorded by that great and too little known reporter of it,  Retraction Watch.  

The legal profession, which is saturated with lies, corruption, the institutional creation of lawyerly deception, dishonesty, greed, graft, grift in which only the paying clients interest is the measure of professional practice and ethics and the higher and higher consequences of that as lawyers are elevated - often by corruptly motivated politicians, executive and senatorial - into the judiciary and on to that most corrupt branch of the U.S. government,  the Supreme Court. 

The "non-profit" groups which are,  I suppose, something that is supposed to act as a secular replacement for all of the (sometimes all to human and fallible) religious charities.    There are so many examples of the various defects of those groups,  from the incredibly dubious identification of some of the most grotesquely wealthy and endowed legal entities in the world,  Harvard, Yale, Princeton, other private universities,   incredibly wealthy museums holding vast and often artistically or intellectully dubious collections of enormous and fungible value.   There are interest groups that serve the most corrupt and evil of governments - the ADL these days is a signal example of that - and the interests of millionaires and billionaires - so many obscenely endowed think tanks and public interest group.   Evil industry advocacy groups,  the gun industry, pollution generators,  etc.   And so many daffy, hypocritical groups on the alleged progressive to liberal to lefty identity.    All given tax exempt status as they serve the most corrupt interests and, through their having been granted the "non-profit" label, treated with an absurd and dishonest reverence by the media.

And don't get me started on the "free press" as the more often than not oligarchic knocking shop that it is. 

Here is what Luke Timothy Johnson wrote about the vicissitudes of the necessity of Christian teaching authority within The Church (the entire Church) at the end of Chapter 2 Learning Jesus Through Tradition

The Teaching Authority of the Church

The commitment to learn the living Jesus within the context of the church's tradition means coming to grips also with the leaders who from the beginning have been entrusted in a special way with maintaining the tradition.  It is this aspect of tradition - namely, its explicitly institutional character - that both the scholarly questions after the historical Jesus and the televagelistic marketers of Jesus most despise.  Academics resist authority in the name of intellectual freedom and integrity  freelance preachers reject ecclesial authority in the name of charismatic freedom and power. 

Those who commit themselves to tradition can scarcely miss the same inadequacies of human leadership that have been so brilliantly and consistently displayed in the history of Christianity.  They know that ministers of the gospel are often not as holy as they should be, are seldom as intelligent as we would like them to be,  and all too often identify the tradition with their own self-interest.  No matter how egalitarian the leadership of a community, or how hierarchical, the same human frailty and pettiness appear.  

Yet there can scarcely be tradition without institutional leadership.  Christianity is not simply a loose assemblage of those who at any time prefer to associate with each other;  it is a people with a history and a mission that must be articulated in specific social arrangements and dynamics.  The witness of leaders in the community, furthermore is at the heart of this tradition itself.  Those commissioned by the risen Lord as apostles were the first in a long line of shepherds for this flock  If every pope and bishop and presbyter and pastor and preacher has been unequal to the task,  that inadequacy has not made their role in maintaining the living thread of tradition any less essential.

The teaching authority remains essential today,  however difficult it is to reconcile with the egalitarian and anit-establishment urges of our age.  No more than the canon or the creed can the leadership of the church arrogate to itself the loyalty that is owed only to the living Lord;  no more than the canon or the creed does this leadership adequately express the meaning of the tradition, much less the Lord in whose name the tradition exists.   The teaching authority of the community functions best when it is not isolated.  The teaching office of the church requires the voice of prophecy to be alive if it is not to grow distended;  through prophets the living Jesus can speak in new ways.  And the preservers of tradition need also to hear the voices of theologians whose task is not so much to preserve as it is to extend the boundaries of our understanding of the mystery of Christ.  The tradition is impoverished if the voice of prophecy is stilled and if th teaching of theologians is, for whatever reason, made an enemy rather than an enricher of the tradition.

Like the canon and the creed,  the teaching authority of leaders helps provide a framework for learning Jesus in the community.  From generation to generation from the beginning hands have reached out to select,  hands have been laid on heads,  words of commission have been whispered in the ears of those whose mission is defined by the task of preserving and protecting the tradition within which Jesus can continue to be learned.  

I doubt that there has ever been a more honest assessment of the necessity and danger of maintaining authority within human institutions and human life than that.   People are always going on about his book The Real Jesus, his take down of the quest for the historical Jesus, but I think this book in which he explores the real consequence for Christians believing in the Living Lord Jesus and the continued experience of the Living Jesus in our lives is far, far more valuable.  

Saturday, October 25, 2025

Science As Permission To Do Evil

I HADN'T BEEN reading or paying that much attention to the interviews with Virginia Roberts Giuffre's ghost-writer Amy Wallace until I happened to hear some of the interview she did with Katie Couric.*  Among the horrific recounting of what Epstein and Ghizz Maxwell did to her and the other girls they trafficked this passage jumped out at me.

But because of his bizarre pseudo-scientific justifications for his behavior that he could explain, you know, he had to have sex three times a day, it was a biological necessity. And he was, he validated the reasons that he had sex with young girls that as as long as they had started menstruating, they were capable of having a baby, so they were a woman even if they were 12 years old. He had all these bizarre sort of justifications . . . 

So I listened to the full interview when I got back to my computer. 

I would agree that the theories referred to are pseudo-science except for three facts about what science is.  The idealistic definition of science as what can withstand the rigors of testing by scientific methods of careful observation, reporting measuring, analysis, peer-review and replication of either an experiment or observation,  that's not what science really is,   What science is in the real world is what gets accepted to be called science by those in the profession, in the publishing in recognized journal deputed to be scientific journals, those who pass it in peer review (an uneven if not extremely dodgy thing in itself) and gets the approval of science departments in industry, universities, colleges, etc.   In the case of the kind of junk science that Jeffrey Epstein clearly relied on to approve of his sexual degeneracy, sadism, rape and abuse of young girls - though perhaps not his taking advantage of it in his trafficking, no doubt, blackmailing and courting power through peddling or giving his blackmail on the rich, probably largely white, straight and powerful to governments and, I'll bet you anything billionaires and their financial interests.   He was just using "science" exploiting the "natural" inclinations of the straight male gender as science led him to believe was "natural" and so, OK.

So, 

1. Scientific method is not what science is in the real world because

2. Science at any given time is whatever those in the scientific establishment call "science" and 

3. A lot of that is based entirely on what universities, colleges, the publishing industry and "journalism" allows them to get away with calling "science."   

Based on that,  I think it's inaccurate to call those self-serving declarations of science that Epstein felt entitled to practice as "pseudo-science."   I agree with what Marilynne Robinson said,  if religion is answerable for bad religion then science has to be answerable for bad science - especially as so much of it exists quite contentedly within what is called science.  

There was nothing in that list from Amy Wallace that I didn't hear university faculty,  peer-reviewed, published scientists, whether biologists or those in the pseudo-social sciences say in some fashion.  Presenting what they said as falling within the expansively enfolding blanket of what science is at any given time.   I remember lots of stuff like that being said in the 1960s, 70s and 80s and have read it going back and onward from there.    Even after I very early concluded that psychology, sociology and anthropology** were pseudo-science in the later 1960s,  I paid attention to what the hucksters and snake-oil peddlers of those university and publishing ordained sciences said because their suckers were everywhere in the university and college credentialed influencers (we called them "journalists" back then, I was skeptical of that profession, as well, by then) and politicians and especially lawyers, judges and "justices" were suckers for it, especially when, just as with Epstein,  their bullshit science supported what they liked and wanted the law to mean.   

Amy Wallace talked about how even when the victims of Epstein and Maxwell went to the FBI the largely male, straight, white, affluent cops ignored what they were told.   Maybe that's because such science had seeped into the professional and institutional culture of policing too deeply for them to take such crimes seriously.   Maybe as, I have little doubt Epstein would claim, that his victims had participated in what they were doing on the basis of scientifically identified predilections on their parts - that is if anyone had ever bothered to grill the bastard on what he was doing.   I recall that kind of talk as a way to dismiss the idea that women or girls can be raped.  I remember hearing that from college credentialed males who had certainly taken the soc-sci requisites (they've got to keep their faculty doing something so they have to force students to take those bullshit courses).   I've heard of from lefty bloggers especially in the form of arguing for the reduction of the age of consent which would have, by the way, made much of the rape of Epstein and Maxwell the responsibility o the young girls they raped.  

We've paid an enormous price for the choice in the late 19th century of universities, their faculties and others in the academic racket allowing psych, soc, anthropology and,  God help us, even econ into the category of science.   I have no doubt that Epstein and Maxwell would have been as prone to rape and abuse and traffic young girls without the blessings of science but, even as they financed science, scientists, and such cultural entities as the "Scienceblogs" they used science to justify it to themselves, the naive girls they preyed on and, no doubt, others as having that blessing.  

* I'm impressed with how many who made a lot of money in the TV "news" business are doing better work on their own online.  

** I don't know how they're getting on in the profession, but I do know there are some in anthropology who started admitting what they do in no way fulfills the requirements of scientific method, though I think they're probably a small minority of those in the profession.   I strongly doubt that honest admission is going to survive because there's such a vested interest in keeping up that pretense.  

Post Script:  Re-reading this you may think that my indictment of the social sciences in permission of men to rape children is inaccurate.   A figure I've mentioned any number of times, one of the main academic figures in and supporters of Paidka, a sort of journal of those who were trying to get governments to lower or abolish ages of consent, the better to enable such men was the American sexologist, Vern Bullough.  The Wikipedia page on him, no doubt written and maintained by those who want him to be remembered well, starts:

Vern Leroy Bullough (July 24, 1928 – June 21, 2006) was an American historian and sexologist.[1][2]

He was a distinguished professor emeritus at the State University of New York (SUNY) at Buffalo, Faculty President at California State University, Northridge,[3] a past president of the Society for the Scientific Study of Sexuality, past Dean of natural and social sciences at the Buffalo State College in Buffalo, New York, one of the founders of the American Association for the History of Nursing, and a member of the editorial board of Paidika: The Journal of Paedophilia.[4]

And he was hardly the only figure in the social science establishment involved with that effort.   I've never made a list of those I've read about who promote that kind of science while working as acknowledged scientists but it's wouldn't be a short one if I did. 

Saturday, September 6, 2025

"It first glance such fears seem virtually unfounded, but there is an erie modernity to these antifederalist concerns"

THE MAN WHO MAY BE our finest living historian on these topics,  the Constitutional scholar and historian Paul Finkelman,  in his 1984 review of "The Complete Antifederalist" listed some of the things the antifederalists predicted would be possible under the proposed Constitution which, in fact, turned out to be very true.  I'm going to give you a good part of that passage asking you to see what is glaringly obvious,  most of what he noted had already happened under the Constitution WITHOUT THE SUPREME COURT OR ANYONE ELSE STOPPING IT has been repeated under Trump.  BUT NOW WITH SUPREME COURT APPROVAL.   The Roberts Court has made what would have seemed a few years ago to be a wild warning by that hot-headed revolutionary   Patrick Henry the law of the land through their six-three amending of the Constitution.   

I will note that I have copied this with the computer and that's asking for problems of line justification.  I'll try to fix that but I can't promise to catch all of it. 

How might the Constitution "totally destroy the liberties" of America? Some antifederalists feared the presidency, a position that combined the responsibilities of the nation's civil executive with those of commander-in-chief of the Army, while allowing for unlimited terms in office. Patrick Henry looked at the Constitution and did not see the "beautiful features"  that James Madison saw. Henry told the Virginia ratifying convention, "when I come to examine these features, Sir, they appear to me horridly frightful: Among other deformities, it has an awful squinting; it squints towards monarchy .. . Your President may easily become King .... "

Others worried about the Senate whose members would serve long terms without any check on them by the people. Many antifederalists predicted that the Senate would become an aristocracy. Because the Senate possessed executive and judicial, as well as legislative, roles, that body seemed especially dangerous. Henry warned, "Your Senate is so imperfectly constructed that your dearest rights may be sacrificed by what may be a small minority; and a very small minority may continue forever unchangeably this Government, athough horridly defective." 

Even the House of Representatives was too remote for some antifederalists. In their view, that body consisted of too few members for it to be truly representative of the people. 

It first glance such fears seem virtually unfounded, but there is an erie modernity to these antifederalist concerns. Is the modern imperial presidency any different from the one the antifederalists feared? Even the War Powers Act  has not prevented an American president from sending troops to Lebanon and Grenada. Without such a law, a secret war in Cambodia and Laos was fought for many years. And the imperial presidency has not been confined to foreign affairs. With a single order, Franklin Roosevelt incarcerated nearly 100,000 American citizens for three and a half years.  As the antifederalists might have predicted,even the Supreme Court lacked both the moral authority and the moral sensitivity to object.  The use of federal troops to suppress strikes in the nineteenth century and veterans protesting the depression during the 1932 Bonus March are yet other examples of what the antifederalists feared. If there are few such instances of this type of behavior in our nation's early history, it may be because the fears of the antifederalists remained alive until the Civil War. If there are more instances in recent years, it may be because a less well-read and less historically aware America has forgotten the warnings of antifederalists.

If you don't get an eerie feeling noticing the repeating, beyond rhyming, of history with the past eight months under Trump,  you are as stupid as the majority of the Roberts Court and the Republican-fascist majority in the Senate.    The same review by the same reviewer 41 years later could fill paragraphs, with little doubt including the crimes of Bush II and the Rehnquist Court's Bush v Gore decision.   Such things are coming far more often and in far more extreme forms as we go on in the Constitutional order. 

Anyone who has read much of what I've written might notice that I have always stressed the importance of equality as THE absolute foundation of legitimate democratic government,  leaving the far more widely noted matter of liberty in the background.   That's not because I don't value that thing which the antifederalists as well as the federalists were always harping on,  "liberty" but because, as the Constution has allowed all of those evils listed in that very partial list made by Paul Finkelman,  it has given "liberty" out in the most grotesquely unequal way,  over-complete liberty to rich, white men over the most basic rights of Black People, other People of Color, Women, Children,  WORKERS.  Note that what Trump is doing with federal troops now was done UNDER THE CONSTITUTIONAL ORDER to keep workers from organizing in the past, most of whom were poor, white men and women.    That was among the greatest evils of the Constitution, that it was founded and continues to promote inequality favoring the very same small minority which the framers favored.   Any time in our history when  partial progress towards equality and against the original reading of the Constitution was made,  in abolishing slavery through the civil war,  the Supreme Court can be counted on to knock it back if not down entirely as the Roberts Court is doing in nullifying the Voting Rights and  Civil Rights Acts.    That is the role that the Court has played AGAINST LAWS DULY ADOPTED BY THOSE SUBJECT TO THE VOTE, over and over again in our history.    That is why I have noted that the Supreme Court has been, since at least 1803 when it gave itself the Marbury power to do that,  MAKING THE PREDICTIONS OF "BRUTUS" THE LAW OF THE LAND.   

Now that the Roberts Court is outdoing the Taney Court, the Court of Plessey v Ferguson, the Courts that totally distorted the 14th Amendment out of any sense of its original meaning,  it's time to face the fact that no hard won progress towards equality or even rational government is going to be safe while the Supreme Court as it stands now retains its ability to do what was warned about in Brutus 15.

I will point out that the extreme rightists in the Roberts Court majority know that they cannot depend on what they want being had and secured through democracy,  maybe not even through the gerrrymandered, rigged-election Congress holding up through the various financial crises, recessions and depressions that have brought Democrats into the majority there, so they want the presidency to have the very powers of a king which the antifederalists warned it would always have a tendency to be.  It is one of the things that has been noted that third-world countries which followed a presidential system instead of a parliamentary system had a greater chance of becoming dictatorships.  I think it is worth considering that it was the antifederalists who predicted such a tendency,  not the federalists who won through the most dubious of means*. 

I'll call your attention to this part of Brutus 15 that I'll focus on more later. 

The power of this court is in many cases superior to that of the legislature. I have showed, in a former paper, that this court will be authorized to decide upon the meaning of the constitution, and that, not only according to the natural and obvious meaning of the words, but also according to the spirit and intention of it. In the exercise of this power they will not be subordinate to, but above the legislature. For all the departments of this government will receive their powers, so far as they are expressed in the constitution, from the people immediately, who are the source of power. The legislature can only exercise such powers as are given them by the constitution, they cannot assume any of the rights annexed to the judicial, for this plain reason, that the same authority which vested the legislature with their powers, vested the judicial with theirs — both are derived from the same source, both therefore are equally valid, and the judicial hold their powers independently of the legislature, as the legislature do of the judicial. — The supreme court then have a right, independent of the legislature, to give a construction to the constitution and every part of it, and there is no power provided in this system to correct their construction or do it away. If, therefore, the legislature pass any laws, inconsistent with the sense the judges put upon the constitution, they will declare it void; and therefore in this respect their power is superior to that of the legislature. In England the judges are not only subject to have their decisions set aside by the house of lords, for error, but in cases where they give an explanation to the laws or constitution of the country, contrary to the sense of the parliament, though the parliament will not set aside the judgment of the court, yet, they have authority, by a new law, to explain a former one, and by this means to prevent a reception of such decisions. But no such power is in the legislature. The judges are supreme — and no law, explanatory of the constitution, will be binding on them.

*  Read the review by Finkelman for only some of the examples of the rigging of the ratification process by the federalists.   Here's one that should remind you of recent events by the Republican-fascists in that most emblematic of "liberty loving" states,  Texas.

The third procedural issue, like the first, centered on the legality of the process. Storing asserts that the argument that the Convention lacked legal power to write a new Constitution "became less pertinent every day simply because the Constitution was in fact before the people."'  The process of ratification emerged as an even more dangerous factor, however. In Pennsylvania, for example, the state assembly voted to call a ratification convention before the Congress (meeting in New York at the time) had even transmitted the Constitution to the states.

On the penultimate day of the session, the pro-Constitution "Republicans, enjoying a temporary majority in the Assembly, pressed for immediate action.''50 Those opposed to the Constitution argued that a decision on when and how to choose delegates to a ratifying convention should be postponed until after the election of the new legislature set for the following month. The antifederalists advocated delay on the grounds that the Constitution was not officially before the assembly, and that the people of the state deserved the opportunity to read the proposed Constitution and vote for or against assembly members on the basis of that document. When the temporary federalist majority rejected these arguments, the antifederalist members of the assembly boycotted the last session in order to prevent a quorum. The next day, a mob forced two of the assemblymen back to the chamber in order to establish a quorum, and the call for a convention was approved. 

If this behavior on the part of the federalists reflected the tenor of politics to be expected under the new Constitution, it is understandable that many people feared an impending end to liberty.

The process of ratification of the Constitution was hardly less crooked in many of the other states,  Massachusetts - of which my state was then a part - was very much in line with the kind of vote rigging that Trump and the Republican-fascists want to make the law of the land right now. 



Wednesday, December 18, 2024

Military And Governmental Superstition About AI Is Killing Innocent People Right Now

OVER THE PAST year I've noticed an increasing number of those making pseudo-historical videos are obviously depending on AI to produce content.   My response to those is to click on those that look like they might be that kind of crap less and less but I still do on occasion.  One I clicked on a couple of days back was supposedly about Empress Elizabeth of Russia but which had many images entirely irrelevant to her and 18th century Russia, some of them images of Elizabeth I of England and clearly having something to do with England in her time.  Other  videos are even worse, mangling the chat-bot voice-over mixing all kinds of stuff together, using clearly inappropriate words as AI is quite likely to do and other stuff.  Maybe they've turned the production of this crap entirely over to AI, not even bothering to watch them before they're posted to get that monitization money from Youtube.   

I've noticed the same is sometimes true of those really annoying and unasked for AI "summaries" that now appear at the top of Google searches.   I hope Google soon either drops those or they give an opt-out feature.  Though I think it's very likely to twist the already twisted minds of a dangerously large number of the mid-brow who make up most of our so-called educated population.   The "information age" has produced an even lower percentage of informed People. 

But that's only relatively annoying and mostly innocuous. My doubts about so-called artificial intelligence increased about fifteen years ago when I first read about officials in the Pentagon anticipating using it for things like choosing targets to bomb and places to attack.   Well, that's part of what the Israeli government and its military are doing in Gaza, right now, wiping out entire neighborhoods because their computer conjectures that a Hamas militant might be in the general vicinity.  Which should be a war crime and, if it is, no one's doing much of anything to stop it.  

Human Rights Watch assessed four tools that the Israeli military has used in its ongoing offensive in Gaza related to military planning and targeting. One is based on mobile phone tracking to monitor the evacuation of Palestinians from parts of northern Gaza. Another, which the military calls “The Gospel,” generates lists of buildings or other structural targets to be attacked. Another, which the military calls “Lavender” assigns ratings to people in Gaza related to their suspected affiliation with Palestinian armed groups for purposes of labeling them as military targets. “Where’s Daddy?” purports to determine when a target is in a particular location so they can be attacked there.

Am I the only one who thinks the Israeli establishment is unusually cynical and callous as demonstrated in the names they give their engines of murder? 

Israel has a huge business in exporting its spying and repression technology to some of the worst regimes in the world,  that's something that its been doing since well back into the apartheid era of South Africa, the dictatorships in Latin America and Asia so I have no doubt that they would be even more willing to sell it to the American government, in fact they have been making a lot of money out of teaching military and control tactics to local American police agencies - remember that as you watch the Trump II era military-police tactics used against demonstrators and, who knows, even those who don't demonstrate against Trumpian fascism.   I doubt them using "artificial intelligence" would make them any less apt to kill and maim and terrorize people who are guilty of nothing more than demanding equality and democracy.  

The more general point is that if the Israeli regime is doing this you can imagine that other regimes in other countries are doing it - there are none so superstitious about the value of "AI" as those who don't have a clue about it but are sold it as being of benefit to them.  This is the new superstition, superstition with science and technology which is certainly going to be more dangerous because it magnifies and multiplies the power of those who choose to use it without much human intelligence or a shred of moral restraint.   Secularism is every bit as capable of producing superstition as the worst of any other aspect of human culture and ideology.   And, I'd argue, it's far worse because like science, secularism is divorced form any consideration of morality by common agreement. 

Sunday, May 5, 2024

this particular denial is the strangest thing that has happened in the whole history of human thought, not just the whole history of philosophy - A response

RUPERT SHELDRAKE, unlike many of his critics, is a working scientist who does some of the most ingeniously inexpensive and simple experiments that rigorously fulfill the requirements of scientific methods and some of his experiments actually do get that rare replication that seems to have become a non-requirement in late stage science.   He is regularly published going into his ninth decade, he continues to do groundwork in asking questions and gathering evidence from the public.  Just last week he made such an appeal to the public for information in regard to the possibility of inherited traits in animals.    He has been a fellow at Cambridge University, until 2010 he as a director of a project at Cambridge University, he was a research fellow of the Royal Society,   He did groundbreaking research in biology and agricultural science in India and Malaya, some of his work there has probably been more important in the lives of more People than that done by just about any of his critics, some of his basic work in studying auxin and related topics is among the most important science of the 20th century.  So there's no doubt about it, he has every right to be considered a scientist.  That he is unafraid to do what I said the "skeptics" obviously don't,  trust scientific methods to discern the truth even when they show things that are controversial is obvious.  

Unlike most of his critics, as well, Rupert Sheldrake has done serious graduate work and continuing reading and study of philosophy.  If there's one thing that is remarkable about those educated in science, it is how many of them are less than novices in that area of thought.  That used to not be a rarity among scientists, especially those from Europe and Britain but it has been among scientists, especially in the English speaking People for quite some time, now.  I think it's one of the reasons that he thinks and writes with a clarity and consistency that is unusual.  He clearly does what even some of his critics renowned for their writing ability, such as Richard Dawkins, fails to do, he is a critic of his own ideas as well as theirs.  Which is one of the reasons that I have every confidence that Dawkins' evolutionary psychology and its associated ideas will go onto that scrap-heap of discarded science where you can find Freudianism and Behaviorism, both credentialed science of their time and, Lord help us, still having rump communities that believe in them.  Some of them allowed to keep shop as practitioners.  

It's planting season and I don't have the time to write what I'd like to have so I'm going to type out some more from Rupert Sheldrake's book Science Set Free.  Right before a section titled Minds that deny their own reality, he says:

The strongest argument in favor of materialism is the failure of dualism to explain how immaterial minds work and how they interact with brains.  Te strongest argument in favor of dualism is the implausibility and self-contradictory nature of materialism.  

The dualist-materialist dialect has lasted for centuries.  The soul-body or mind-brain problem has refused to go away.  But before we can move forward, we need to understand in more detail what materialists cliam, since their belief system dominates institutional science and medicine, and every one is influenced by it.


I have pointed out that an immaterial mind - one which is not composed matter of or the consequence of material causation, could be expected to have qualities and abilities that aren't covered by the properties of matter and material causation.  An immaterial mind could not be subjected to scientific discovery because of that, science is structured only to discover things about things that exist within the properties of matter and material causation.  It is irrational to think that science could do more than notice discrepancies between physical systems and such minds, they couldn't even go far in explaining much about those discrepancies.  Materialists, rigidly holding with a rigidly monistic ideology that insists everything that exists must be restricted to the properties of material existence and the human made "laws of nature," insist that their promise that all will be explained even as they have failed to explain it for centuries, now.  Someone who believes minds surpass the qualities and limits of such a conception of matter and existence should realize that science can't handle the idea of such a mind, though they have certainly been trying to answer the question of how minds influence or control brains or our bodies in the same way instead of admitting that their idea can never have a scientific explanation.  They shouldn't feel bad about that because the materialists have never fulfilled that major promissory note they keep issuing, generation after generation, century after century, I'd argue for millennia, now, only they've structured things so their creditors are suckered into never calling for payment.  

Going on to his discussion of the materialists' irrational and decadent declarations that minds are, to one extent or other, illusory, he says.

Most neuroscientists do not spend much time thinking about the logical problems that materialist beliefs entail.  They just get on with the job of trying to understand how brains work,  in the faith that more hard facts will eventually provide answers.  They leave professional philosophers to defend the materialist or physicalist faith.

Physicalism means much the same as materialism, but rather tan asserting that all reality is material, it asserts that it is physical, explicable in terms of physics, and therefore including energy and fields as well as matter.  In practice, this is what materialists believe too.  In the following discussion I use the more familiar word "materialism" to mean "materialism or physicalism."


I'd add to that that recently some materialists have used the dodge of declaring themselves "naturalists" (which previously meant nudists, as I recall) which is just a ruse as it means pretty much the same thing as the other labels.  I interpret that to mean that even some of the slightly more philosophically astute materialists feel if not realize that there are deep problems with their ideology but they don't want to admit that or give it up.  Covering up their naked materialism, sort of.

Among materialist philosophers there are several schools of thought.  The most extreme position is called "eliminative materialism."  The philosopher Paul Curchland, for example, claims that there is nothing more to the mind than what occurs in the brain.  Those who believe in the existence of thoughts, beliefs, desires, motives and other mental states are victims of "folk psychology," an unscientific attitude that will in due course be replaced by explanations in terms of the activities of nerves.  Folk psychology is a kind of superstition, like belief in demons, and it will be left behind by the onward march of scientific understanding.  Consciousness is just an "aspect" of the activity of the brain.   Thoughts or sensations are just another way of talking about activity in particular regions of the cerebral cortex;  they are the same things talked about in different ways.  

Of course such eliminative materialists exempt their language about their own unevidence talk about these things from the rigid model they have created when, by their own claims, what they believe about all of it, from their academically snobbish and insulting labels for the ideas of those who disagree with him to their declared faith in the not yet reached triumph of science, to the very science they ask us to put our faith into, must all fall within the same countentless, purposeless chemical and material causation which cannot be anything but a huge crap shot at a hugely improbable picture of what is really true.  Such academic scribbleage and babblage gives away its own disbelief in that by even making the attempt to convince other People that their favorite line of belief is what they should believe because such a materialist faith would hold that none of it is meaningful, including their desire to be believed.  It cannot have more legitimacy than any other aspect of "folk psychology" only they insist that while most of humanity swims in that self-deceiving ignorance, they and their allies, alone, can, somehow, escape from it.  Many of those who hold university professorships and chairs in departments of philosophy aren't especially rigorous in their own criticism of their own ideas, especially those who hanker after the repute and status that is given to scientists.  That last thing is ubiquitous among those with college credentials in the humanities, in my experience.  It reached absurd lengths even among some of the more astute composers of the 19th and 20th centuries who should have known better.  

I think any university or college or school which hires and pays someone who denies the reality of or significance of consciousness, teaching students that what the university is in the business of providing them is, in effect, meaningless, is guilty of consumer fraud.  They, despite their desire to appear properly sciency, are promoting the ultimate act of intellectual decadence.  There's a lot of that in this late state of eutrophic modernism.  That is what materialism can be counted on to produce because it is, ultimately, a self-refuting and undermining ideology.  

Sheldrake continues:

Other materialists are "epiphenomenalists": they accept rather tahn deny the existence of consciousness, but see it as a functionless by-product of the activity of the brain, an "epipenomenon," like a shadow.  T. H. Huxley was n early advocate of this point of view, and in 1874 he famously compared consciousness to "the steam whistle that accompanies the work of a locomotive engine. . . without influence upon its machinery."  He concluded, "We are conscious automatons."  People might just as well be zombies, with no subjective experience, because all their behavior is a result of brain activity alone.  Conscious experience does nothing and makes no difference to the physical world.

Again, you have to wonder why someone who believes that would not only make an attempt to discern anything, never mind spend a lifetime in science, but to issue polemical statements, declarations, books, to convince other such minds of anything because, in the end, none of it makes any difference to anything and has an absurdly remote possibility of coming to an accurate description of reality.  Everything they come up with and believe would have as much of a chance as any other of finding reality on the basis of chemicals and physical structures which were a product of random chance in their particular situation.  You have to wonder how such a person accounts for the possibility that any two such organisms would contain the physical basis of that they could agree on anything.  How any two brains could make precisely the same structure to give rise to the same epiphenomenon - how brains would know how to do that is a question I've been posing, off and on, to materialists for a number of years now and I have never had any response that wasn't an expression of atheist materialist faith lacking any real explanation of how it is supposed to work.  

A recent form of materialism is "cognitive psychology," which dominated academic psychology in the English-speaking world in the late twentieth century.  It treats the brain as a computer and mental activity as information processing.  Subjective experiences, like seeing green, or feeling pain, or enjoying music, are computational processes inside the brain which are themselves unconscious.  

I've discussed that before, how computers are a deliberate creation made to mimic BY ANALOGY modeling of human mind, of humans thought, they have a relationship to minds as an anatomical statue made of sculptures of human organs, bones and other structures have to human bodies. To claim that human bodies function like anatomical models is about as astute as claiming that computers can serve as a means of understanding human minds.  Circular reasoning and inapt analogies flourish when science and philosophy are governed by materialists ideology.

Some philosphers, like John Searle, think that minds can emerge from matter by analogy with the way that physical properties can emerge at different levels of complexity, like the wetness of water emerging from the interactions of large numbers of water molecules.  In nature, there are indeed many different levels of organization (Figure 1.1)*, each of which has new properties that are not present in their parts alone.  Atoms have properties over and above nuclear particles and electrons.  Molecules have properties over and above atoms; the molecules of water, H2O, are fundamentally different from uncombined hydrogen and oxygen atoms.  Then the wetness of liquid water is not explained by water molecules in isolation, but through their organization together in liquid water.  New physical properties "emerge" at every level.  In the same way, consciousness is an emergent physical property of brains.  It is different from other physical processes, but is is physical nonetheless.  Many non-materialists would agree with Searle that consciousness is in some sense "emergent" but would argue that while mind and conscious agency originate in physical nature, they are qualitatively different from purely material or physical being.

Apart from the extremely fuzzy and, it seems to me, diffuse idea that so many different dissimilarities there are between larger physical entities and the properties of their component physical entities on lower levels of organization can be reified into the same kind of thing, this idea doesn't seem to explain much about minds.  Does water have wetness except as a product of perception, an action of minds?  And it would depend on what you define "wetness" as being, which is another action of minds.  Often a scientific definition of some phenomenon is created to limit what aspects of it will be under scientific discussion but I'd be surprised if science can come up with a definition of something like "wetness" or the perception of a color that will really encompass everything that's meant by the word when we use it.  I would question how anyone could really determine that all of the various such experiences which are called "physical properties" are connected except as they are experienced by living beings' minds.  Given the recent biology of such scientists as James Shapiro and Denis Noble, I think it makes at least as much and more sense to think that bodies are epiphenomena of minds.  

This last one was one of the things that those who tried to answer me with on those questions of how brains could make the physical structure(s) to give rise to an idea could be physically present in that brain, structures that would be entirely novel to that brain, structures that would need to be extremely precise and complex enough to give rise to a new idea in any particular brain, before the materialists' model of "brain only" minds would have any possibility of even knowing the brain needed to make a new structure - not to mention the problem of how it would know how to make that structure in that case.  Only the answer "natural selection" was no answer at all.

Finally, some materialists hope that evolution can provide an answer.  They propose that consciousness emerged as a result of natural selection through mindless processes from unconscious matter.  Because minds evolved, they must have been favored by natural selection and hence they must actually do something;  they must make a difference.  Many non-materialists would agree.  But materialists want to have ti both ways; emergent consciousness must do something if it has evolved as an evolutionary adaptation favored by natural selection;  but it cannot do anything if it is just an epiphenomeon of brain activity, or another way of talking about brain mechanisms.  In 2011, the psychologist Nicholas Humphrey tried to overcome this problem by suggesting that consciousness evolved because it helps humans survive and reproduce by making us fee "special and transcendent."  But as a materialist Humphrey does not agree that our minds have any agency;  that is to say, they cannot affect our actions.  Instead our consciousness is illusory;  he describes it as "a magical mystery show that we stage for ourselves inside our own heads."  But to say that consciousness is an illusion does not explain consciousness;  it presupposes it.  Illusion is a mode of consciousness.  

My guess would be that the psychologist Nichols Humphrey would take enormous offense of some skeptic of psychology and materialism such as myself would brush off his entire professional and academic work in the very terms that it must, itself, brush off every product of every conscious mind, only I'd do it on the basis of the central and basic logical disconnect that is baked into the entire field of academic dismissal of minds and consciousness in favor of atheist-materialist ideology, that it's clear that those academics pushing it don't really believe it when it comes to their own minds, their own consciousness and what they choose to believe and insist that others believe.    A point Sheldrake made earlier in the chapter about the published declarations dismissing consciousness by the pudding-headed Daniel Dennett.  I call him "pudding-headed,"  Rupert Sheldrake has much better manners than I do.   It's entirely legitimate to critique the behavior of the eliminative materalists of academia because everything about their actions proves they don't really believe it when it comes to them and their own meaningless burps and noises coming from those random molecular actions in their brains.   I'd bet if someone cribbed them for sale they'd assert in court that they were more than meaningless and not really attributable to their creativity. 

If all of these theories sound unconvincing, that is because they are.  They do not even convince other materialists, which is why there are so many rival theories.  Searle has described the debate over the past fifty years as follows:  

"A philosopher advances a materialist theory of the mind . . . He encounters difficulties . . . Criticisms of the materialist theory usually take a more or less technical form, but, in fact, underlying the technical objections is a much deeper objection; the theory in question has left out some essential features of the mind. . . and this leads to ever more frenzied attempts to stick with the materialist thesis.


The philosopher Galen Strawson, himself a materialist, is amazed by the willingness of so many of his fellow philosophers to deny the reality of their own experience;
 
"I think we should feel very sober, and a little afraid at the power of human credulity, the capacity of human minds to be gripped by theory, by faith.  For this particular denial is the strangest thing that has happened in the whole history of human thought, not just the whole history of philosophy."  


I am unaware of any materialist whose primary motivation is anything but their attachment to atheism, though some may have been led to atheism through a naive conception of materialism, the two seem to be linked pretty firmly in most minds that hold those ideologies.  Though  that would be those who consider the matter at any higher level of thought.  Materialism can be held even by non-atheists on the basis of conformity to the ambient requisite thoughts of secular culture, as a default, respectable, reputable and profitable mode of going along with that to get along.  I don't think most atheists or materialists really think about it very deeply at all, no more than those who maintain a naive, primitive, even quite mistaken notion of Darwinism, natural selection or, as many even college-credentialed folks abbreviate that "evolution."   I don't think most materialists, atheists or true-believes in scientism hold those on a particularly deep or sound basis, I think most of it is a product of wanting to fit in with the kind of People taken to have higher status in a secular, materialist, atheist, scientistic milieu.  I doubt most of the media figures, including some of those "public scientists" I ridiculed to such objection the other day are especially intellectually engaged with their own adopted ideology.  As I mentioned, even those as fully engaged as the eliminative materialists don't engage with the logical consequences of their own claims for the intellectual legitimacy of those very claims.   Materialism is one of the most philosophically inastute conceptions ever held and it is ubiquitous in our decadent stage of materialism as vulgar materialism has almost always ruled in those who gain power.  

Francis Crick admitted that the "astonishing hypothesis" was not proved.  he conceded that a dualist view might become more plausible.  But he added.

"There is always a third possibility;  that the facts support a new alternative way of looking at the mind-brain problem that is significantly different from the rather crude materialistic view that many neuroscientists hold today and also from the religious point of view.  Only time and much further scientific work, will  enable us to decide."


Yeah, there could be a third possibility or it could be that minds are non-material and, so, will never be able to be directly discerned by analogies to the properties of material causation.  It may be just a hard fact that we, in our thinking which is so tied to the experience and analysis of material objects and experiences, will never be able to articulate more than a vague sense of minds and consciousness.  It could be similar to the speculation by A. S. Eddington that there are laws of nature which our minds are not capable of discerning and will never know because of that.  If other species on some other planet, somewhere, may be able to conceive of those, it would be interesting to think about how we'd deal with that.  I'd imagine that materialist scientists on Earth would deny that those properties of matter which their minds could not comprehend could possibly exist.  But that's just speculative imagining on my part.  Maybe they'd learn the kind of humility and acceptance they figure non-sci-guys should practice in regard to their incomprehensible claims.

Before going on in the next section to discuss the latest fashion (or desperate resort) in panpsychism, the idea that matter has consciousness as an intrinsic property and our minds emerge out of that subatomic, atomic . . . consciousness, Rupert Sheldrake says, "There is indeed a third way."  

How panpsychism isn't just another from of the very fuzzy and vague notion of emergentism, I'd need to have explained to me.

I would point out to the panpsychists that there is religious precedent for their materialistic last resort, in fact it's in Scripture.  Jesus told the religious high and mighty of his day that God could raise up children of Abraham from rocks (Matthew 3:9} and, during his dramatic entry into Jerusalem that if the crowds didn't proclaim him the stones would do it (Luke 19:40).  Not to mention the scriptures tell us we are made of Earth (Genesis 2:7). The dualism of matter and spirit in some of Christian philosophy and theology was an artifact of Greek pagan philosophy, not the Hebrew tradition, certainly not as that was extended so drastically through the Gospel of Jesus and the theological explanations of the Glorified Jesus after his death by Paul and the Catholic Epistles.  The mind-body dilemma that has given rise to the ultimate decadence of brain sci-guys and their philosopher groupies in consciously denying the existence of significance of consciousness may well be attributable to pagan proto-science, perhaps as filtered through atheist materialism, of the classical period atomists (as popularized by a deeply flawed book by Stephen Greenblatt that was all the rage a while back) and was never much more than a product of that ideological assertion irrationally retained in the ideological basis of science.  

I am extremely skeptical of panpsychism, for a start the idea that any molecular, atomic, subatomic, "consciousness" any consciousness of rocks or crystals or other non-living entities could ever be conceived of in a way that connected them to the consciousness that we experience is as fraught with problems as the other materialist's ways of dealing with consciousness.  And it has the same problem as my rejection of ethology, the supposed science of animal behavior) as anything but lore passed off in the guise of science - and with a particularly nasty association with Darwinist eugenics.  The hard fact is that we have no way to consult even animals who are living as to what their experience of consciousness is, what any explanation of their own behavior is, we can't even know if human reports of that are accurate or honest.  How are we supposed to verify that for rocks and atoms?  How are we to even define what that would be?   I think it's just the latest or perhaps last straw of old-line materialism among those who have thought honestly enough about all of those other schemes of it to realize they are bunk but not being willing to admit that minds, consciousness, must well surpass the limits of material causation, to give that property to atoms does nothing to change that, to give it to subatomic particles does no more to remedy that problem.

I will say that there are ways to scientifically study some animal behavior as Rupert Sheldrake rather ingeniously does in his study of animal behavior to study such phenomena as animals who seem to know when their human companions are going to come home, but even that has its limits because no animal can tell us that's what they're doing and what motivates them to do it.  Sheldrake is one of the great living shoe-string practitioners of basic science research.  He said he learned a lot about how to do that kind of science among the scientists in India where there wasn't money to do fancier science.  His books are some of my favorite science reading as his talks, lectures, dialogues and conversations are in online listening.  His work is an example of the possibilities of using scientific method and intellectual searching  when it's freed of ideological straight-jacketing and the requirements to conform to the dominant materialist-atheist-scientistic hegemony in decaying modernism.

*  I don't have the book with me as I'm editing this, but I think it was an image that looked like this one I found online diagramming such a hierarchy. 

A nested hierarchy or holar- | Download Scientific Diagram