Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Just As The Problem Of Evil Is An Insoluble Problem For Monotheistic Faith

the problem of perhaps irremediable stupidity is a problem for democratic faith.   Only the experience of every other  form of government as well as for the absence of the source of moral absolutes, proves that the alternatives are inevitably worse.  You can do that with an honest addressing of history, you can't do it with legal logic or science. 

In the United States a combination of things have led to us having a very dangerously high percentage of Americans being both dangerously ignorant (effectively stupid) and mean-spirited (moral stupidity), a combination of both of those problems is what got us here.   

Even with those who pealed off of the anti-democratic selfish party, the Republican-fascists, starting with Trump winning the nomination over either the stupidity of him being the presidential nominee or that he was too evil and corrupt for even those for whom Bush II and Dick Cheney weren't bad enough or incompetent enough, those who pealed off over the January 6th insurrection, the outrageous combination of corruption, criminality, war-criminality, and epic incompetence has not been enough to crater the support for Republican-fascist enabler of Trump and his goons in the recent election,  despite what the blue-landslide has led many to believe. 

Blaming "religion" for that is rather stupid in the way that we are encouraged to be stupid by the categorization of unlike entities called by the same name.   I went through the exercise of looking at the Pew research figures that the rump of the atheist fad of the 00's were citing to blame "religion" for Trump, to point out that even in the denominations with the highest support for Trump, there were significant percentages who voted for Hillary Clinton.  And the numbers of those in those denominations who voted against Trump were larger than the combination of all of those included in the "nones."  Blaming "religion" It's as stupid as blaming Black People for the polling figures that claimed that California's Proposition 8 banning marriage equality for Lesbians and gay men as so many blatherers on the blogs were doing eighteen years ago.  If I'd been blogging then, I'm sure I'd have called that out in a post.  I seem to recall saying in on a number of blog comment threads at the time.  

Groups don't vote, not even Republicans all voted for Republicans in this election or voted for Trump.  Individuals vote. 

The problem of ignorance in the United States, both the kind that simply doesn't know much and, worse, the FOX Lies, CNN, etc. produced those who know stuff that's wrong, is a matter of the mass media.  That's been a problem for American democracy since the start when it was ink on paper and bigots in mass meetings and social gatherings that were spreading it.   

Since a lot of that is based on something which religion is supposed to discourage, lying,  it's more a feature of America's laissiez-faire libertarian freedom, the privileges given to the media without extracting responsible service to equality and democracy than it does either religion or the public good of public education which was never as robustly supported as it needed to be and once TV entered into American homes, it had no chance to compete with it for the time and so minds of American children.   It's funny, I don't recall many of those who blame religion or "White Women" or any other named group slamming the things that really bring us corrupt, evil government, money, wealth, greed, cynicism, etc.   And if you point out the part that the media plays in that, especially the most powerful part of it, by a large measure, "entertainment" the libertarian lefty will go into a swivet.  

That the movies, TV, "comedy" etc. have encouraged mean-spirited, selfish, hateful suspicion on the one hand and conceited asshattery on the other, has only made the situation worse.   Trump is a product of all of that, a product of "reality" TV and shock-jockery and cynicism and brainless celebrity and wealth worship all from the media, just as Reagan was a product of the fakest of Hollywood ol' wayest horse operas and show-biz flag waving BS in an earlier mass media environment. 

Freedom of the "press" without requiring them to accurately inform The People, the basis of the American government may have been the stupidest thing the framers ever did, leaving that up to them to do on a voluntary basis.   And, yes, for the 18,739th time, the Warren court made one of the milestone blunders in that when it turned lying in the media into a "right."  One which allowed them to make money equal "speech" twelve years later,  the die was cast that would bring us to Trumpian fascism with that.   That we will have to abandon the old slogans of First Amendment idolatry to overcome those might be hard but the hard truth is without doing that American democracy is doomed. 

After watching American democracy implode over the past forty or fifty years, I don't think it's possible for us to continue as even the guaranteed to fail unequal liberal democracy we were without addressing that hardest fact.   And we won't do that if no one starts the discussion.  

If you don't like the consequences of Americans being too stupid to vote the way they do and, at the same time absolve the media that makes them that stupid, you're stupider than they are.   And we are told we must be that stupid by Jemey Madison et al because they were too stupid to take the time to write the First Amendment intelligently.   And we've been too stupid to amend it to correct their irresponsibility despite centuries of living with those consequences.  That includes your best and brightest, and biggest snobs. 


No comments:

Post a Comment