I HAVE NO IDEA why Google and Youtube are flooding my feeds with videos and other things about teaching reading. I can't think of anything I've searched for or written or posted that would lead to it. But it is something I've thought about quite a bit over my lifetime.
I've always been a good reader from the time I was a little kid starting school. Which is kind of odd because I've always been a "poor" to indifferent speller and my handwriting has been illegible my entire life.
That last one was the easiest to solve and the thing I think all children should be taught, ALWAYS HAND PRINT THINGS IN BLOCK CAPITAL LETTERS IF YOU CANNOT MAKE CURSIVE LEGIBLE. Children in school who have trouble making cursive or even printing in a mix of upper and lower case legibly should be allowed to do that. The very large number of us who have never been able to do that should have always been allowed to write things in block capitals and if they taught writing for comprehension instead of, well, I guess I have to call it "calligraphy" that would have always been the rule.
In my lifetime I've had several jobs that required me to read the handwriting of a lot of People of many different levels of intelligence and wisdom and some of the most brilliant and wise People I've known had handwriting that was far worse than even mine. It has nothing to do with intelligence or diligence. My brilliant sister-in-law, who is a very respected scientist with a number of graduate degrees has about the worst handwriting I've ever seen in my experience.
And some of the most modestly intellectually accomplished People of my experience have had beautiful cursive writing, though none of them reaching the legendary copper-plate level as once was typical of those taught by nuns in the past. I have an example of that which is a thing of beauty, or would be if the corner of it wasn't rodent nibbled, what appears to be a chain letter written in the late 19th century, in Canadian French recommending a novena to Saint Joseph, "which has never failed."
Along with that, allowing students to do their math on lined paper instead of the unlined paper they always gave us, teaching students to set things up in an orderly way would probably be about as big a help in teaching arithmetic. I don't hold with letting kids use calculators when there are old fashioned ways to do adding and long division and multiplication that are fast and work better than the ways they taught us in school (I would recommend the book How To Calculate Quickly by Henry Sticker). You don't get any sense of how numbers work using a calculator.
I've always thought the way they taught reading was bizarre, by using stories that had no information in them that contributed to an education, and which were generally rather boring. They should have taught children to read using short non-fiction passages that contained information that was part of their other subject matter. How much time to waste on make believe did they figure they had in school? And they could have them write about the short things they read as a way of teaching writing. If they taught them to read something with substantial content they would give them the skills to read stories and novels and make believe stuff if they wanted to.
I wish more of my teachers had concentrated on the grammar and mechanics of writing instead of discussing the plots of stories and novels and the literary devices that I have never had the slightest use for in my life. And neither do those with college-credentials for whom the explicit plot is as much of such stuff as they ever take in. If you want to promote an idea or theme, using fiction to do that is about as stupid a way of doing that as exists. And as hap-hazard a way of getting one across. About the only worse ways to do that are through movies or operas.
I've said before that one of the greatest contributions to my education was that we had two different pretty good encyclopedias in our house as well as a number of dictionaries and other reference books. One of my siblings and I read the entire World Book encyclopedia when were were in grade school. We weren't allowed to turn on the TV during the day. I've been thinking of asking the local libraries around here if they have a set they're getting rid of to make a bid for one, recapitulating in my senile years a useful thing I did in my juvenile years.
Anyway, if you want my advice on such a thing. Liberate kids from the tyranny of the penmanship fetish which has probably been more of a discouragement for kids than just about anything, convincing them that they're stupid before they can discover otherwise. That is along with standardized English spelling. Which, by the way, is nothing like phonetic and never has been since the advent of printing when they imported Dutch printers who didn't know English to do the type setting in England. Many of the worst absurdities in standard English spelling were put there by Dutch printers who didn't know the language. That is those that didn't change when pronunciation did. And a few put there by 18th century idiots of influence. Ask me about that if you haven't read my rants about it.
No comments:
Post a Comment